23 Medial Parapharyngeal Approach



10.1055/b-0039-172585

23 Medial Parapharyngeal Approach

Alberto Schreiber, Marco Ferrari, Marco Ravanelli, Vittorio Rampinelli, Davide Lancini

The parapharyngeal space is a suprahyoid infracranial fascial space of the neck, whose shape is typically described as an inverted pyramid. 1 The superior boundary (i.e., the base of the pyramid) corresponds to the inferior surface of the petrous portion of the temporal bone, whereas the apex lies on the posterior end of the greater horn of the hyoid. The parapharyngeal space is enclosed between the prevertebral space, posteriorly, infratemporal fossa (or deep masticatory space) and submandibular fossa, anterolaterally, the parotid space and nodal levels IB and IIA, posterolaterally, and the nasopharynx and oropharynx medially. 2 The parapharyngeal space is further divided into prestyloid and retrostyloid compartments (also called real parapharyngeal space and carotid space, respectively) with respect to the styloid process and related muscles and ligaments. 1 Moreover, the parapharyngeal space can be divided into upper, middle, and lower portions based on the two horizontal planes passing through the inferior border of the lateral pterygoid muscles and mandibular angles. 2 , 3


Only the upper parapharyngeal space can be properly exposed via the transnasal pathway, namely, through the lower transpterygoid approach. 2 From a surgical viewpoint, the transnasal parapharyngeal space approach can be divided into a medial and lateral corridor with respect to the lateral pterygoid plate. The medial corridor targets the eustachian tube and related muscles, while the lateral corridor leads to the area of the external carotid foramen, jugular foramen, and related neurovascular structures. This chapter focuses on the endoscopic transnasal approach to the medial portion of the upper parapharyngeal space.


Given the strict relationship with the nasopharynx, the medial portion of the upper parapharyngeal space is particularly prone to be invaded by nasopharyngeal tumors. Moreover, lateral extension of tumors arising into the nasopharynx is favored by the presence of a defect within the pharyngobasilar fascia (called sinus of Morgagni), corresponding to the area where the eustachian tube and levator veli palatini muscle pass from the parapharyngeal space to the nasopharynx forming the torus tubarius. On the other hand, tumors primarily arising from the parapharyngeal space and invading the upper compartment usually extend in the lateral portion (or in both medial and lateral portions), which is composed of smooth structures that are easier to be displaced and compressed by the tumor compared to the eustachian tube and the pterygoid process.


In recent years, the transnasal endoscopic approach to the upper parapharyngeal space has progressively acquired a role in the resection of selected lesions of this area, especially when nonamenable for radical nonsurgical treatment. 4 , 5 The endoscopic surgical excision of the nasopharynx has been defined as the “nasopharyngeal endoscopic resection” (NER) and classified into three types depending on the extent of resection: 6 , 7 Type 1 resection is limited to the posterior nasopharyngeal wall; type 2 resection also includes the removal of the nasopharyngeal vault and sphenoidal floor; type 3 resection further requires the resection of the medial portion of the upper parapharyngeal space. The surgical technique is currently employed for recurrent/persistent nasopharyngeal carcinomas originally treated with primary (chemo)radiation, as well as for minor salivary gland tumors, papillary adenocarcinomas, plasmacytomas, sarcomas, mucosal melanomas, and other tumors or tumorlike lesions. 7 11


The main concern of the surgeon when approaching the medial upper parapharyngeal space is avoiding injury to the parapharyngeal tract of the internal carotid artery. In fact, the combination of a narrow surgical corridor, two-dimensional view, and need to manipulate irradiated tissues makes bleeding from the internal carotid artery a dramatic event. To minimize the chance of damaging this vessel, some concepts should be kept in mind: (1) Knowledge of bony anatomical landmarks (including the lateral pterygoid plate, foramen ovale, foramen spinosum, musculotubal canal) 6 , 7 , 12 , 13 and fascial anatomical planes (such as the plane guiding to the internal carotid artery between the medial pterygoid muscle and the tensor veli palatini muscle) 14 is of utmost importance to identify the position of the internal carotid artery in the surgical field. (2) The endoscopic perspective adopted during the critical phases of dissection should be carefully chosen to avoid disorientation and favor safe directions for surgical instruments; in particular, the ipsilateral perspective provides the best combination in terms of reliability of anatomical landmarks and safety of dissection trajectories. 15 (3) An in-depth analysis of the course of the internal carotid artery at preoperative imaging and use of a Doppler probe and navigation system are extremely helpful to identify unfavorable anatomic situations (e.g., medial kinking of the internal carotid artery) and localize the vessel at surgery, respectively.

Fig. 23.1 Axial view of the upper parapharyngeal space. This axial cadaver cut shows with a cranial-to-caudal perspective the left upper parapharyngeal space. V3, mandibular nerve; VII, facial nerve (extracranial segment); IX, glossopharyngeal nerve; X, vagus nerve; XII, hypoglossal nerve; APA, ascending pharyngeal artery; iIMA, infratemporal tract of the internal carotid artery; IJV, internal jugular vein; LoCM, longus capitis muscle; LPM, lateral pterygoid muscle; LVPM, levator veli palatini muscle; MP, mastoid process; MPM, medial pterygoid muscle; PG, parotid gland; phICA, parapharyngeal tract of the internal carotid artery; PhPl, pharyngeal plexus; PtPl, pterygoid plexus; StyP, styloid process; TVPM, tensor veli palatini muscle.
Fig. 23.2 Sagittal lateral-to-medial view of the upper parapharyngeal space. This sagittal cadaver picture shows with a lateral-to-medial perspective the upper parapharyngeal space. V2, maxillary nerve; V3, mandibular nerve; bET, bony portion of the eustachian tube; cET, cartilaginous portion of the eustachian tube; h, horizontal portion of the petrous internal carotid artery; IJV, internal jugular vein; ION, infraorbital nerve; JuB, jugular bulb; Lab, labyrinth; LVPM, levator veli palatini muscle; MMA, middle meningeal artery; MS, maxillary sinus; Na, nasopharynx; phICA, parapharyngeal tract of the internal carotid artery; SiS, sigmoid sinus; SpS, sphenoid sinus; TTM, tensor tympani muscle; v, vertical portion of the petrous internal carotid artery; VN, vidian nerve.

The endoscopic transnasal approach to the upper parapharyngeal space requires the harvesting of a transmaxillary corridor to laterally displace the content of the pterygopalatine fossa and expose the pterygoid process. Up to this step, the dissection can be performed taking advantage of the avascular subperiosteal planes to maintain a clean surgical field. The lower transpterygoid route (i.e., the route through pterygoid plates, sparing the base of the pterygoid process) is then employed to gain access to the pterygoid fossa and subsequently reach the parapharyngeal space. During this part of the dissection, several venous plexuses, vessels, and muscles are encountered, which are a considerable source of bleeding.


Given the impossibility to reach the entire parapharyngeal space via a transnasal route, the approach presented in this chapter fits particularly well with the concept of multiportal surgery. In lesions of the parapharyngeal space also invading the related skull base, surgery should be accurately planned, considering the possibility to combine nondisruptive surgical corridors (i.e., transnasal, transoral, transorbital, transcervical, transpetrosal) to manage advanced lesions. Likewise, the endoscopic parapharyngeal space approach can be combined with transnasal corridors targeting adjacent areas (i.e., infrapetrous, suprapetrous, transcondylar–transjugular tuberculum, medial petrous apex, infratemporal) when addressing extended skull base lesions.


As a final remark, it is worth mentioning that, especially in irradiated patients, wide resections of the upper parapharyngeal space with exposure of the overlying skull base and internal carotid artery frequently require reconstruction to avoid severe complications such as skull base osteitis/osteomyelitis or vessel blowout. Therefore, the surgical team performing the resection should also plan to resurface the defect with one of the many available local/regional reconstructive options (i.e., nasoseptal flap, lateral nasal wall flap, temporoparietal fascia flap).


The reader is asked to perform dissection of the upper parapharyngeal space both focusing on the numerous anatomical details of this anatomical area and keeping in mind the surgical aspects that have been emphasized in the present introduction.

Fig. 23.3 CT and MRI anatomy of the upper parapharyngeal space and related skull base. The panel includes two axial CT scans passing through the upper parapharyngeal space (upper left image) and related skull base (upper right image) and two columns of coronal MRI (A and B), whose position is depicted by white dotted lines. The upper parapharyngeal space is enclosed by the nasopharynx medially, pterygoid fossa (PtF) anteriorly, infratemporal fossa anterolaterally, prevertebral fascia posteriorly, skull base cranially, and axial plane passing through the inferior border of the lateral pterygoid muscle (LPM) caudally. The medial portion of the upper parapharyngeal space lies medially to the plane (white dashed line) joining the lateral pterygoid plate (LPP) and spina sphenoidalis (SSp). This space includes the cartilaginous eustachian tube (cET), tensor veli palatini muscle (TVPM), and levator veli palatini muscle (LVPM). V2, maxillary nerve; V3, mandibular nerve; AsPA, ascending palatine artery; BaP, basipterygoid; bET, bony eustachian tube; FA, facial artery; FL, foramen lacerum; FoPl, foraminal plexus; FOv, foramen ovale; FSp, foramen spinosum; iIMA, infratemporal tract of the internal maxillary artery; LoC, lower clivus; LPP, lateral pterygoid plate; MC, midclivus; MCM, middle constrictor muscle; MMA, middle meningeal artery; MPM, medial pterygoid muscle; MPP, medial pterygoid plate; NaP, nasopharyngeal posterior wall; NaV, nasopharyngeal vault; nJuF, nervous compartment of the jugular foramen; peICA, petrous tract of the internal carotid artery; PtPl, pterygoid plexus; RoF, Rosenmüller’s fossa; ScF, scaphoid fossa; SCM, superior constrictor muscle; SGM, styloglossus muscle; SoP, soft palate; ToT, torus tubarius; TTM, tensor tympani muscle; TuL, tubal lumen; VC, vidian canal.
Fig. 23.4 (a, b) Coronal T1-weighted MRI scan of the pterygoid process. As seen from a coronal perspective, the upper parapharyngeal space lies behind the pterygoid process and related muscles. Six white dotted lines (A–F) depict the position of images making up ▶Fig. 23.5 and ▶Fig. 23.6. V2, maxillary nerve; ET, eustachian tube; LPM, lateral pterygoid muscle; LPP, lateral pterygoid plate; LVPM, levator veli palatini muscle; MPM, medial pterygoid muscle; MPP, medial pterygoid plate; ON, optic nerve; SOF, superior orbital fissure; SoP, soft palate; TVPM, tensor veli palatini muscle; VN, vidian nerve.
Fig. 23.5 Axial CT and MRI of the upper parapharyngeal space and adjacent structures (part 1). The panel shows three rows of axial CT (left images), contrast-enhanced T1-weighted (middle images), and T2-weighted MRI (right images). From anterior to posterior, the upper parapharyngeal space can be reached passing through a multilayer anatomical area, including the posterior wall of the maxillary sinus (PWMS), pterygopalatine fossa (PPF), medial (MPP) and lateral pterygoid plates (LPP), scaphoid fossa (ScF), and pterygoid fossa (PtF). The lateral pterygoid plate is aligned with the foramen ovale (FOv), spina sphenoidalis (SSp), foramen spinosum (FSp), and related structures, including the mandibular nerve (V3), foraminal plexus (FoPl), and middle meningeal artery (MMA). The cartilaginous portion of the eustachian tube (cET) lies immediately posterior to the mandibular nerve. The vertical segment (v) of the petrous tract of the internal carotid artery (peICA) runs just behind the junction between the bony (bET) and cartilaginous eustachian tube. BaP, basipterygoid; FCB, fibrocartilago basalis; FL, foramen lacerum; h, horizontal segment of the petrous tract of the internal carotid artery; iIMA, infratemporal tract of the internal maxillary artery; LPM, lateral pterygoid muscle; MC, midclivus; PBF, pharyngobasilar fascia; PtPl, pterygoid plexus; PVC, palatovaginal canal; SPF, sphenopalatine foramen; ToT, torus tubarius; TuL, tubal lumen; VC, vidian canal; Vo, vomer.
Fig. 23.6 Axial CT and MRI of the upper parapharyngeal space and adjacent structures (part 2). Both the tensor veli palatini muscle (TVPM) and the levator veli palatini muscle (LVPM) follow the direction of the eustachian tube (ET) to reach the soft palate. The tensor veli palatini muscle passes outside from the pharyngobasilar fascia (PBF) and reaches the soft palate after turning around the pterygoid hamulus. The levator veli palatini muscle runs through the pharyngobasilar fascia together with the eustachian tube via a defect called the sinus of Morgagni. The anatomical boundary between the infratemporal fossa (also called deep masticatory space) and the upper parapharyngeal space is the interpterygoid fascia (white lines with arrowheads in the lower right image), which joins the mandible and tensor veli palatini muscle and forms the cranial portion of the superficial layer of the deep cervical fascia. The stylopharyngeal diaphragm, or fascia, joins the styloid process (StyP) with the levator veli palatini muscle and serves as separation between the prestyloid and retrostyloid compartments of the upper parapharyngeal space. Therefore, transnasal parapharyngeal approaches that cross both these muscles unavoidably transgress the medial portion of the infratemporal fossa. V3, mandibular nerve; HyC, hypoglossal canal; IJV, internal jugular vein; JuB, jugular bulb; LoC, lower clivus; LoCM, longus capitis muscle; LPM, lateral pterygoid muscle; LPP, lateral pterygoid plate; MPM, medial pterygoid muscle; MPP, medial pterygoid plate; NaP, nasopharyngeal posterior wall; nJuF, nervous compartment of the jugular foramen; PCV, petroclival vein; PG, parotid gland; phICA, parapharyngeal tract of the internal carotid artery; PhPl, pharyngeal plexus; PtPl, pterygoid plexus; RoF, Rosenmüller’s fossa; ShS, sheath of the styloid process; ToT, torus tubarius; vJuF, vascular compartment of the jugular foramen.
Fig. 23.7 MRI para-axial scan parallel to the path of the eustachian tube depicting the “parapharyngeal carrefour.” The understanding of the three-dimensional relationship between the mandibular nerve (V3), eustachian tube (ET), and internal carotid artery is of utmost importance. Both the mandibular nerve and the parapharyngeal and vertical petrous tracts of the internal carotid artery (peICA) run with a vertical trajectory and are separated by the eustachian tube, which can be seen along its entire course due to enhancement of the mucosa of the tubal lumen (TuL; white arrowheads). MPP, medial pterygoid plate; LPP, lateral pterygoid plate.
Fig. 23.8 (a–f) Contrast-enhanced CT axial anatomy of the parapharyngeal space and adjacent areas. The panel includes six axial contrast-enhanced CT scan, from cranial (a) to caudal (f). The upper parapharyngeal space is adjacent to the infratemporal fossa anterolaterally, which includes the temporal muscle (TM), masseteric muscle (MM), lateral pterygoid muscle (LPM), and medial pterygoid muscle, which are surrounded and intersected by the pterygoid plexus (PtPl), infratemporal tract of the internal maxillary artery (iIMA), and branches of the mandibular nerve (V3). The retrostyloid compartment of the upper parapharyngeal space continues posteriorly into the area of the jugular foramen, which houses the internal jugular vein (IJV), petroclival vein (PCV), and the group of lower cranial nerves (X*). BaP, basipterygoid; ET, eustachian tube; HyC, hypoglossal canal; IPS, inferior petrosal sinus; LPP, lateral pterygoid plate; MMA, middle meningeal artery; MPP, medial pterygoid plate; peICA, petrous tract of the internal carotid artery; phICA, parapharyngeal tract of the internal carotid artery; PhPl, pharyngeal plexus; ScF, scaphoid fossa; ShS, sheath of the styloid process; SiS, sigmoid sinus; SSp, spinal sphenoidalis; StyP, styloid process.


Endoscopic Dissection


Nasal Phase




  • Anterior and posterior ethmoidectomy.



  • Transethmoidal sphenoidotomy.



  • Removal of the sphenoid sinus floor.



  • Type D endoscopic medial maxillectomy.


Skull Base Phase




  • Step 1: Exposure of the descending palatine canal and removal of the posterior wall of the maxillary sinus medial to the infraorbital canal.



  • Step 2: Lateralization of the content of the pterygopalatine fossa.



  • Step 3: Removal of the perpendicular plate of the palatine bone.



  • Step 4: Removal of the medial pterygoid plate.



  • Step 5: Partial removal of the base of the pterygoid process.



  • Step 6: Removal of the tensor veli palatini muscle.



  • Step 7: Removal of the levator veli palatini muscle.



  • Step 8: Removal of the eustachian tube.



  • Step 9: Opening of the carotid sheath.



  • Step 10: Removal of the prevertebral fascia.



  • Step 11: Medial paracarotid dissection.



  • Step 12: Lateral paracarotid dissection.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

May 10, 2020 | Posted by in NEUROSURGERY | Comments Off on 23 Medial Parapharyngeal Approach

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access