Adaptogens


Herbal medicine

Dosage

Major/active constituents

Key evidence

PotentialAEs

Potentialclinical use

Clinical advice

Ashwagandha (Withania somnifera)

Total dose of 500–1000 mg/day dried extract standardised to withanolides, or 4–6 g/day root powder

Withaferin A and Withanolide D

Mainly positive RCTs and open-label studies demonstrating efficacy as an anxiolytic and stress reducer. One RCT showing no superiority over placebo with use of a high dose, and a systematic review concluding that evidence is poor quality

Only mild adverse events reported. No interaction found with SSRIs

General anxiety; Potential use in OCD alongside SSRIs; no data on other anxiety disorders

Generally safe and well-tolerated. Appears to be safe for co-use with SSRIs. Further research needed to determine acute effects

Roseroot (Rhodiola rosea)

170 mg SHR-5 extract standardised to salidroside and rhodioloside for acute or chronic use. 300–600 mg/day generally recommended for chronic daily use

Salidroside, rhodioloside and rosavins

Several RCTs demonstrating anxiolytic effects and efficacy for increased working capacity in fatigued individuals when administered chronically. One review concluding that R. rosea is the most effective adaptogen for acute use

May have side effects such as irritability or insomnia. No interactions with drugs reported, although inhibition of proteins involved in drug metabolism have been reported

GAD; stress and fatigue; no data on other disorders. May be useful for Social Anxiety given the demonstrated acute effects

Not recommended for patients with bipolar disorder or insomnia due to potential side effects, but otherwise safe and well-tolerated. Although no interactions with drugs have been reported, if co-used with other drugs this should be carefully monitored due to the potential for increased bioavailability of these drugs

Gotu Kola (Centella asiatica)

Crude herb 0.5–6 g/day; Triterpenoid fraction of Centella asiatica 60–120 mg/day standardised to asiaticoside, Asiatic acid and madecassic acid

Asiaticoside

Some evidence for anxiolytic effects as well as improving cognition and quality of life, although only preliminary data are available

Mild adverse reactions reported, including skin reactions and upset stomach. Hepatotoxicity has also been reported although the dose used in these cases is not known

Possible use for GAD, although only one small, open-label study supporting this. No other clinical disorders studied

Not recommended for use in pregnant or breastfeeding women, or for longer than 6 weeks due to potential adverse reactions. Regular liver function tests may be warranted. Further large, placebo-controlled studies are needed, particularly in clinical populations

Siberian Ginseng (Eleutherococcus senticosus)

Dried herb 300–800 mg/day standardised to eleutherosides

Eleutherosides, triterpenoidsaponins and glycans

Numerous clinical trials demonstrating efficacy over placebo in improving mental work capacity, reducing stress and fatigue. Some evidence for superior stress-reducing effects over Panax ginseng

No adverse reactions reported in studies. Further research required regarding potential interactions

Chronic fatigue; stress; no data on other clinical disorders

Maximal effects achieved around 4 weeks, therefore usually administered for around 6 weeks followed by a 1–2 week break. Further research needed in clinical populations

Schisandra (Schisandra chinensis)

Tincture 0.5–2.0 mL; seed powder 0.25–3 g; tablets 50–200 mg standardised to schisandrin and γ-schizandrin

Chemical composition not fully known, key constituents believed to be schisandrin and gomisin

Demonstrated efficacy for increased working capacity when used acutely. Some evidence that repeated administration up to 10 days is also beneficial. One RCT showing longer treatment may result in detrimental effects

Excitability, sleeplessness and depression reported in a minority of subjects when administered daily for 2 weeks or more

Efficacy in fatigued individuals, data from clinical populations lacking

Based on reports of excitability and sleeplessness following long-term administration, intermittent use is recommended. No herb–drug interactions reported and appears to be safe for co-use with cancer drugs

ADAPT-232 (R. rosea, S. chinensis and E. senticosus)

Acute dose: 270 mg tablet standardised to rhodioloside, rosavin, tyrosol, schizandrin, γ-schizandrin and eleutherosides B and E

Rhodioloside, rosavin, tyrosol, schizandrin, γ-schizandrin and eleutherosides B and E

Several RCTs showing improved cognition and working capacity in stressed and fatigued individuals following acute administration. Also some evidence for efficacy in improving quality of life and reducing length of illness in pneumonia patients

No adverse reactions reported

Long-term stress, no data from clinically anxious patients at this stage

May be effective if used acutely for patients presenting with fatigue or stress. Further research needed to determine chronic effects, and whether effective for clinically diagnosed disorders such as GAD



In an RCT in clinically anxious patients, a significantly greater proportion of patients receiving WS met the criteria for response than those in the placebo group following 6-week treatment [20]. Clinical response was defined as a reduction in Hamilton Anxiety Scale (HAM) score to below 12 and a Global Rating Scale (GRS, both patient and rater) of not more than one (ratings from 0 = no symptoms to 4 = very severe symptoms). However, the titration schedule for this study was left to the discretion of the treating physician, with doses increased up to a maximum of 2.5 g per day. For this reason it is difficult to ascertain the most effective dosage across participants using these data. However, a more recent study by Auddy and colleagues [21] addressed this issue by randomising 130 participants to receive WS 125 mg once daily, 125 mg twice daily, or 250 mg twice daily, versus placebo for 60 days. A dose-dependent improvement was observed for HAM score, suggesting that higher doses may be more effective for the treatment of anxiety.

In a third clinical study using WS, Cooley and colleagues [22] divided participants with moderate to severe anxiety of longer than 6 weeks’ duration into two groups who received either weekly counselling sessions from a naturopathic doctor as well as 600 mg/day WS, or cognitive-behavioural therapy (CBT) sessions and placebo. Anxiety was significantly reduced in the naturopathic care group compared with the psychotherapy group. Whilst this study was placebo-controlled, it was not double-blinded as the care providers could not be blinded to participant distribution. The inclusion of psychotherapy techniques for one group but not the other also meant that groups were exposed to different factors besides WS treatment alone.

Using 600 mg/day WS compared with placebo, Chandrasekhar and colleagues [23] reported significant improvements in scores on the Perceived Stress Scale (PSS-10) and the General Health Questionnaire (GHQ-28), as well as reductions in levels of serum cortisol using a non-clinical adult sample. Interestingly, a much higher dose of 12 g/day resulted in non-significant differences in HAM scores versus placebo [24]. Only scores for “anxious mood,” an item on the HAM, showed a significant difference between groups. When taken together with the other findings mentioned above, this suggests an inverted U-shaped dose response curve regarding the effects of WS on stress and anxiety, with clarification from future studies required.

In a recent double-blind RCT, 30 patients diagnosed with Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD) according to DSM-IV criteria received either adjunctive 120 mg/day WS or placebo for 6 weeks, in addition to stable treatment on selective serotonin re-uptake inhibitors (SSRIs). A significant treatment effect was found in favour of WS, as measured by symptom severity on the Yale-Brown Obsessive-Compulsive Scale (Y-BOCS). The authors concluded that WS may be an effective adjunct to SSRIs in the treatment of OCD [25].

In addition to the RCTs detailed above, open-label studies have also shown positive effects of WS, with 2 g/day WS root powder for 3 months resulting in lowered blood pressure in subjects with stress-oriented hypertension [26]. Although the decrease in diastolic blood pressure was significant when the supplement was given with either water or milk, the decrease in systolic blood pressure only reached significance for those who took the supplement with milk. It is therefore recommended on the basis of this study that for patients with stress-related hypertension WS root powder is taken with milk.



3.2.2.3 Safety


Although, the general daily dosage WS recommendation is 500–1000 mg of an extract standardised to 1–2 % withanolides [27], doses used in human clinical trials have generally been in the range of 4–6 g/day WS root [26]. Clinical trials have reported no significant differences in adverse events compared with placebo, with the only adverse events found being mild in severity, for example, gastrointestinal upset, overstimulation and “feeling warm” [20, 22, 23]. Even doses as high as 12 g/day have been reported to be well-tolerated with no adverse reactions [24]. When administered alongside SSRIs, no adverse events have been reported either, suggesting that WS does not interact negatively with these drugs [25].




3.3 Roseroot (Rhodiola rosea)



3.3.1 Overview


A member of the Crassulaceae family, Roseroot (Rhodiola rosea) has long been used as a medicinal plant in Europe. R. rosea is grown in dry ground in the Arctic and Alpine regions of Europe, Asia and America, and whilst the green aerial part of the plant is used as a food ingredient, the root-stock is used in medicine. The use of R. rosea in medicine also dates back to the ancient Greeks [28], and traditional uses in countries such as England, Germany and Tibet include treatment for headache, use as a “brain tonic” and treatment of lung diseases. Roseroot has also traditionally been used as an anti-stress agent to reduce symptoms such as irritability, cognitive dysfunction and fatigue [29]. However, it is in Russia that the use of R. rosea as a stimulant and anti-stress treatment has been most extensive.


3.3.1.1 Mechanism of Action


The main active substance regarding the adaptogenic effects of R. rosea has been identified as salidroside, a phenylpropanoide derived from phenylethane [5, 30]. However, other compounds are also considered to be active adaptogenic constituents, including the phenylpropane rosavins [29, 31]. The stimulant and anti-stress actions of R. rosea and the glycoside salidroside have been extensively studied in Russia since they were first discovered in the 1960s [3234]. The adaptogenic properties of R. rosea and salidroside have been well-documented [3537] with the stimulant effect of these substances reported to play an important role [5, 33]. The extract SHR-5, manufactured by Swedish Herbal Institute, was characterised by HPLC-fingerprint analysis and standardised on the p-tyrosol-glucoside salidroside [30]. Olsson and colleagues [38] reported that the SHR-5 extract is standardised for rhodioloside (4 mg per 144 mg tablet) and appears to be a 70 % ethanolic extract with a 4:1 drug:extract ratio.

Evidence suggests that R. rosea inhibits monoamine oxidase and catechol-O-methyltransferase activity, thus modulating brain levels of monoamines, including serotonin and dopamine [39, 40]. Brain levels of these neurotransmitters may also be enhanced through increased permeability of the blood–brain barrier to their precursors [5]. Additionally, there is some evidence that R. rosea may affect the opioid system [41], and effects on cortisol secretion and HPA axis regulation and mediation of kinase enzymes have also been reported in the literature [29].


3.3.1.2 Preclinical Studies


Much of the research on the adaptogenic effects of R. rosea is unavailable for review due to its publication in Russia; however, the available literature suggests that R. rosea increases resistance to a wide variety of stressors: with R. rosea extracts found to protect against the harmful effects of oxygen, cold, radiation and heavy physical exercise as well as increasing working capacity, decreasing fatigue, improving learning and long-term memory, and regulating brain function in rodents [35, 42]. The majority of these studies investigated the effects of single-dose administration with significant acute effects seen within 1–2 h post-dose; however, Petkov and colleagues [35] demonstrated improved memory using a maze model 24 h post-dose, as well as long-term memory of this maze after 10 days’ treatment.


3.3.1.3 Clinical Studies


In human studies a protective effect of R. rosea against the detrimental effects of stress and anxiety has similarly been demonstrated. In a review of the acute effects of adaptogens conducted by Panossian and Wagner [43] R. rosea was reported to be the most active of the adaptogens discussed, with evidence produced to demonstrate its stimulant effects.The standardised SHR-5 extract was used by Shevtsov and colleagues [30] in an RCT investigating the acute effects of R. rosea on capacity for mental work. Stressed and fatigued military cadets were administered either two (370 mg R. rosea) or three capsules (555 mg R. rosea), with both doses found to significantly reduce fatigue, as reflected in an anti-fatigue index based on performance of a variety of mental tasks. Beneficial effects on pulse pressure were also reported.

In a larger crossover RCT, Darbinyan and colleagues [5] investigated the effect of repeated low-dose R. rosea treatment on work-related fatigue. Fifty-six young, healthy physicians were assigned to receive 170 mg SHR-5 or placebo for 2 weeks in a crossover design, with an intermediate washout period of 2 weeks. The Fatigue Index was found to be significantly improved after 2 weeks’ R. rosea treatment compared with placebo, suggesting that R. rosea can be useful in reducing fatigue in stressful work situations. However, closer examination revealed that this effect was only significant when the night duty was shorter. When participants had longer night shifts, the dose administered was not sufficient to reduce fatigue. Future studies could aim to investigate the doses necessary for effects in situations of higher levels of fatigue and stress.

In addition to the anti-fatigue effects in non-clinical samples, chronic effects of R. rosea have also been demonstrated in patients with Generalised Anxiety Disorder (GAD). In a small open-label study, ten GAD patients received 170 mg R. rosea in the form of standardised SHR-5 tablets twice daily for 10 weeks [44]. A significant reduction in anxiety following this intervention was found on the Hamilton Anxiety Rating Scale (HARS) and the anxiety subscale of the Four Dimensional Anxiety and Depression Scale. Four participants were classed as achieving remission, defined as a score of ≤8 on the HARS and a score of 1 or 2 on Clinical Global Impressions of Improvement (CGI-I). Half the sample had ≥50 % reduction in scores on the HAM-A scale, suggesting clinical as well as statistical significance. However, the lack of placebo control in this study, as well as the small sample size, makes it difficult to draw firm conclusions about the efficacy of this extract in GAD.


3.3.1.4 Safety


The most common side effects of R. rosea involves irritability and insomnia [44], suggesting a possible stimulating effect. It has therefore been recommended that this extract not be used in patients with bipolar disorder [45]. In addition, there may be inhibitory effects on CYP3A4 and p-glycoprotein that should be considered [46]. Inhibition of these proteins affects drug metabolism and can lead to increased bioavailability of drugs; therefore, potential interactions should be examined prior to commencing R. rosea supplementation. On the other hand, general daily dose recommendations are in the range of 300–600 mg, with no known interactions with other drugs or herbs [27]. Repeated administration is thought to be safe, with no adverse events reported following 2 weeks’ treatment with 170 mg R. rosea [5].


3.4 Gotu Kola (Centella asiatica)



3.4.1 Overview


Gotu Kola (Centella asiatica) has been used traditionally in both Ayurvedic and Chinese medicine to treat anxiety and depression, and to assist meditation by producing a calming effect on the mind [4749]. The people of Java and other Indonesian islands have also used C. asiatica for the treatment of other medical conditions including leprosy, eczema, diarrhoea, amenorrhea and fever [50]. The plant belongs to the Umbellifere (Apiaceae) family and is found throughout India up to an altitude of 1800 m, as well as in swampy areas of many tropical and subtropical countries. The whole plant is used for medicinal purposes, usually administered in the form of capsules, teas or tinctures. It contains compounds such as triterpene acids, fatty oil, glycosides and flavonoids [50].


3.4.1.1 Mechanism of Action


The main biologically active components of C. asiatica are saponins (also called triterpenoids), which include asiaticosides amongst others [50]. A pharmacokinetic study of total triterpenoid fraction of Centella asiatica (TTFCA) suggests that the active compounds are well-absorbed in humans [51]. Peak plasma levels of Asiatic acid were reached 4.5 and 4.2 h following oral administration of 30 mg and 60 mg of extract, respectively. Plasma half-lives were 2.2 h in the 30 mg dose and 3.4 h in the 60 mg dose. Saponin levels were not detectable after 24 h post-dose. Repeated treatment over 7 days resulted in higher peak plasma concentrations, longer half-lives and greater area-under-the-curve absorption values [51].

With regard to anxiolytic effects, the main constituent of C. asiatica is the triterpineglycoside asiaticoside, as demonstrated in both in vitro and in vivo studies [49, 52]. Triterpines in C. asiatica increase serotonin, noradrenaline and dopamine in the brain, as well as reduce serum corticosterone levels [52]. It is thought that this is the mechanism through which C. asiatica has calming effects. It has also been postulated that C. asiatica may exert anxiolytic effects through increased GABA activity. An ethanolic extract was shown to increase GABA levels in mice [53], whilst an aqueous extract stimulated Glutamic Acid Decarboxylase (GAD) by over 40 % at a dose of 1 mg/mL in vitro [54]. Activity at the GABAA receptor has also been demonstrated [55]. In addition, the anxiolytic activity may be in part due to binding to cholecystokinin receptors [56].


3.4.1.2 Preclinical Studies


Anti-stress and anxiolytic effects of C. asiatica have been demonstrated using animal models. Long-term pretreatment resulted in enhanced elevated plus maze (EPM) performance and attenuated acoustic startle response (ASR), whilst gastric ulceration induced by cold and restraint stress was significantly inhibited [53]. The isolated compound asiaticoside has also been found to have anxiolytic effects at various doses [57]. However, it has been proposed that the method by which active compounds are extracted may affect the efficacy of this plant as an anxiolytic. In one study in rats only the methanol and ethyl acetate extracts, along with isolated asiaticoside, showed anxiolytic effects when using the EPM for 5 min [49]. Importantly, asiaticoside did not affect locomotor activity, suggesting that these compounds are without sedative effects in rodents. Using a rat model to determine whether the triterpenoid Asiatic Acid (AA) had anxiolytic effects, Ceremuga and colleagues [55] found that rats treated with AA spent more time in the open arms of the EPM, although the difference was non-significant. When administered with the benzodiazepine midazolam the effect reached statistical significance, which the authors attributed to a synergistic effect.


3.4.1.3 Clinical Studies


Evidence regarding anxiolytic effects of C. asiatica is somewhat scarce, although research interest has increased in recent years. In a systematic review, Ernst [58] found one study of C. asiatica that met search criteria. It was therefore stated that only preliminary data are available for this herb. Similarly, in a review including case reports, open-label and placebo-controlled trials, Baek and colleagues [45] reported that there is a scarcity of scientific evidence for the use of C. asiatica in the treatment of anxiety and insomnia. However, positive effects of C. asiatica on anxiety and general well-being have been demonstrated in a select number of human trials, providing a basis for further research.

In a small, double-blind RCT investigating acute effects on the acoustic startle response (ASR), 40 healthy participants were randomised to receive either 12 g C. asiatica or placebo. After 30 and 60 min, ASR amplitude was found to be significantly decreased for C. asiatica compared to placebo, although changes to self-rated anxiety were non-significant [48]. Considering that such a large dose of C. asiatica was administered, it is questionable as to whether this would be safe or effective long-term. Studies of the chronic effects of C. asiatica have used much lower doses, such as the 750 mg daily dose used by Wattanathorn and colleagues [59] who reported improved mood and cognitive function in an elderly population. However, in an RCT by Carlson and colleagues [60] which utilised only 68 mg C. asiatica in conjunction with Gingko biloba and fish oil, no treatment effect was reported in relation to overall Quality of Life (SF-36) scores in healthy older participants. It should be noted, however, that high baseline scores on the SF-36 were reported for participants in this study, suggesting that improvements may be range-limited.

With regard to clinical studies of C. asiatica, one open-label study was found with 33 participants diagnosed with Generalised Anxiety Disorder (GAD). C. asiatica leaf extract 500 mg BID was administered for 8 weeks. At the end of the study period, anxiety was significantly reduced, and stress and depression ratings were also reduced, as measured using the SF-36, Hamilton’s Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale (BPRS) and the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI) [61].


3.4.1.4 Safety


The recommended adult daily dose of total triterpenoid fraction of Centella asiatica extracts standardised for asiaticoside, Asiatic acid and madecassic acid is 60–120 mg, and for crude herb the recommended daily dose is 0.5–6 g [63]. C. asiatica has been shown to be safe when administered in combination with Gingko Biloba and Docosahexanoic Acid (DHA). Participants receiving this combination formula experienced no significant differences from placebo in platelet function or experience of adverse events, and adverse events reported were minor [60]. However, some mild side effects have been reported in other trials, including skin reactions and gastrointestinal upset [45]. In addition, three cases of jaundice with elevated liver enzymes were reported in Argentina following C. asiatica consumption for 20–60 days [62], although the dosage and standardisation of the consumed extract is unknown, and the patients recovered on discontinuation. As there is limited knowledge regarding long-term safety of C. asiatica consumption or the safety during breastfeeding, it is recommended that use of C. asiatica should not exceed 6 weeks and that nursing mothers should refrain from using this herb [50].


3.5 Siberian Ginseng (Eleutherococcus senticosus)


Siberian Ginseng (Eleutherococcus senticosus) belongs to the Araliaceae family, a family native to Asia, the Malay peninsula, Polynesia, Europe, North Africa and the Americas [64]. According to Chinese medical records, E. senticosus has been used for over two centuries to increase vitality and energy, and has also been used by Russian cosmonauts to aid with adaptation to life stressors in space [3]. Davydov and Krikorian [65] reported that E. senticosus was first introduced to Europe as an adaptogen and ergogen (referring to increased potential for work output) through encounters with Soviet trainers and athletes who had incorporated it into their training regimes.


3.5.1 Mechanism of Action


The adaptogenic effects of E. senticosus are thought to be due to the capacity of its secondary metabolites to exert protective and inhibitory actions against free radicals [65]. E. senticosus roots contain the active constituents eleutherosides, triterpenoidsaponins and glycans, while the leaves contain hyperoside, a flavanol glycoside which has been reported to be an effective sedative [66]. Eleutherosides have demonstrated ability to improve carbohydrate metabolism and energy provision and to increase synthesis of protein and nucleic acids [67]. It is thought that these factors may prevent the exhaustion stage of the stress response, although more evidence is needed [3]. In addition, E. senticosus may exert neuroprotective, hepatoprotective and cardioprotective activity [67]. In times of chronic stress, repeated E. senticosus administration has been found to engage the HPA axis, enabling the body to adapt to repeated stressors by balancing the switch-on and switch-off stress responses [67].

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Apr 12, 2018 | Posted by in PSYCHIATRY | Comments Off on Adaptogens

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access