Adding a Face and the Story to the Data: Acupuncture for PTSD in the Military




Courtesy of Anita Hickey, MD


Acupuncture is a holistic approach, which has been used since ancient times to treat physical, emotional, psychological, and spiritual disorders at a fundamental systemic level. This is in accordance with the current system’s view of living systems, organizations and ecosystems, which recognize that the whole is greater than the sum of its parts due to the parts being in relationship [1].

Acupuncture has long been used for physical, emotional, psychological, and spiritual disorders in China, Korea, Japan, and other countries in the Far East. It utilizes thin, filament-like needles to treat more than 2000 points, which connect with 12 main and 8 secondary pathways called meridians. According to ancient texts, these channels conduct “qi” between the surface of the body and internal organs.

Qi is the circulating life force that regulates spiritual, emotional, and physical balance. The opposing forces of yin and yang influence qi. Imbalances of the flow of qi may be caused by illness, trauma, stress, and poor lifestyle choices. Acupuncture is believed to balance yin and yang, which keeps the normal flow of energy unblocked and restores harmony and health to the body and mind [2].

An acupuncture diagnosis is made after listening to the patient and performing an examination to determine the patient’s mental, emotional, and physical condition. A treatment is then designed to treat both symptoms and the underlying imbalance. Just as in conventional Western medicine, varying amount of skill in diagnosis and treatment can result in differing outcomes.


12.1 Acupuncture for PTSD


Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a complex syndrome , which affects mental, emotional, behavioral, and physical aspects of health. According to Otis and colleagues in a 2010 study, PTSD has been found to coexist in 34–50 % of veterans referred for treatment of chronic pain [3]. Persistent hyper arousal and activation of the fight or flight response in these patients results in dysregulation of the autonomic nervous system and other related neurophysiologic functions [4, 5]. Disruption of these systems in patients with PTSD has been shown to be associated with the multiple poor health outcomes including: metabolic disease, cardiovascular disease, asthma, cancer, back pain, peripheral vascular disease, gastrointestinal problems, and thyroid disorders. Polypharmacy and the risks associated with taking multiple medications are common in these patients because of their multiple comorbidities and symptoms, such as hypertension, headaches, sleep disorders, and nightmares [6].

James Reston, a New York Times reporter who accompanied President Nixon to China in 1971, introduced acupuncture to the public at large in the USA. Since then, awareness and use of acupuncture has increased throughout the US populace in general and among members of the military. In 2007, Smith et al. reported that active duty military members and veterans reported seeking treatment for acupuncture and other complementary and alternative therapies in order to avoid side effects from medications and to learn health strategies to prevent and treat the underlying cause of disease rather than focus on management of the symptoms of disease [7].

The growing use of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) modalities was reflected in a 2013 article published in The Journal of Complementary and Alternative Medicine, which reported that the overall use of CAM, including acupuncture by active duty military members is higher (44.5 %) than in comparable civilian surveys (38.3 %), with the vast majority of treatments sought outside of the military health care system [8]. Simultaneously, research as to the mechanisms and effectiveness of acupuncture has grown both in quantity and quality [9].

A recent meta-analysis and systematic review on acupuncture for trauma spectrum response (a common symptomatic and functional spectrum of physical, cognitive, psychological, and behavioral effects seen in combat veterans who have experienced psychological and/or physical trauma), found acupuncture to be effective for headaches, and promising for chronic pain , sleep disturbances, anxiety and depression [10]. More specific to PTSD, a recent systematic review of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and prospective clinical trials for PTSD, found that, based on one high-quality RCT and a meta-analysis, the effectiveness of acupuncture was statistically superior to waitlist control. No statistical difference was found between the effectiveness of acupuncture and cognitive behavioral therapy . Acupuncture plus moxibustion was shown to be superior to oral selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRI) therapy for PTSD in the meta-analysis [11].

Although high-quality controlled studies, meta-analysis and systematic reviews, are important in determining the effectiveness of a therapy, case reports help us to see the faces and stories of those who seek and benefit from the availability of acupuncture and other holistic therapies, which have been used since ancient time to treat wounds and disorders of the spirit as well as those of the body and mind.

Together with other military medical acupuncturists I have found that active duty military patients and veterans are very accepting of acupuncture [12]. Indeed, many of my patients have reported paying out of pocket for acupuncture prior to finding out that it was available in our pain management clinic.

It is well known that mental health disorders such as depression and anxiety are present in approximately 60 % of patients presenting for treatment of chronic pain [13]. Advanced imaging studies have revealed many commonalities in the neural processing of chronic pain and areas of the brain where emotional “suffering” is processed [14]. Because many of our pain patients present with a history of trauma and a diagnosis of PTSD, it is common to address this disorder in our pain patients (in addition to their chronic pain complaint) within the holistic approach afforded by acupuncture.

Although some patients request referral for acupuncture treatment to avoid medications, procedures, and surgery, the majority of our patients are referred for acupuncture after all the available and applicable conventional therapies have failed to significantly improve their condition(s). The latter is true for the patients in the following case reports.


12.2 Case 1: In-Patient with Severe Low Back Pain


A 21-year-old active duty female US Marine was referred to the pain clinic from orthopedics on a Friday afternoon with a complaint of severe low back pain and difficulty walking. Due to the severity of her complaints, she was admitted to the orthopedic service to rule out cauda equina syndrome. An urgent MRI showed no evidence of central spinal stenosis. Lumbar degenerative disc disease at the L4–5 and L5-S1 levels was mild with minimal neuroforaminal narrowing.

The patient had been brought to the pain clinic on a gurney. Pain medication consisted of intravenous (IV) morphine via a patient controlled analgesic device. Her history of present illness was significant for chronic remitting and relapsing low back pain since boot camp with no known trauma or initiating event. She had been seen in the pain clinic the previous year for an epidural steroid injection for right lower extremity leg pain and numbness in the L5-S1 distribution. Her leg pain had improved following the epidural steroid injection.

On physical exam, vital signs were within normal limits. Her pain was 9–10/10. The patient was 5 ft 4 in., and 120 lbs. She was able to move all of her extremities, but grimaced and moaned when asked to move her legs. Her back pain increased with any movement. Leg strength was 4/5 throughout all muscle groups both left and right with no asymmetry. Straight leg raises were negative for radicular pain but produced severe increase in her low back pain at 10–20 ° of elevation. Deep tendon reflexes were symmetrical. She had no sensory deficits.

The patient was unable to sit in the gurney or to roll to her side or abdomen. Three corpsmen were needed to assist in log rolling the patient to her side as any flexion or extension of her back resulted in cries of pain. No focal tenderness was found.

Initial conventional pain management treatment consisted of converting her IV morphine to oral long acting opioid equivalents, with short acting opioid for break through pain. A low dose of amitriptyline was started and given at bedtime both as a pain adjunct and to assist with sleep hygiene.

On the following Monday, a multidisciplinary meeting was convened to discuss the patient. Attendees included a pain management physician, an orthopedic surgeon, a psychiatrist, the health psychologist, a chaplain, a case manager, and a physical therapist. The psychiatrist proceeded to summarize the patient’s social history, which included sexual molestation as a child, and gang rape as a teenager, with the latter resulting in pregnancy. She had kept the child, who was being reared by relatives. She had subsequently joined the US Marine Corps.


12.2.1 Subsequent Treatment


In addition to medication management, physical therapy, mental health counseling, and chaplain services and counseling, acupuncture was offered to the patient and she agreed to this. She was transported to the pain clinic Monday afternoon via gurney.

Due to her history of anxiety , insomnia, and general irritability the first treatment chosen was a “four gates” treatment consisting of LI 4 and LR 3 bilaterally. Although initially anxious, she tolerated the treatment well. After the 20 min treatment she was significantly calmer.

I then performed an “internal 7 dragon” treatment, which has been used since ancient times for patients with a history of severe emotional and/or physical trauma: CV 15, ST 25 bilaterally, ST 32 bilaterally, and ST 41 bilaterally placed top to bottom, right to left. After obtaining de qi sensation, the needles were dispersed and left in place for 15 min. The needles were then removed. The patient was then repositioned prone. A “7 external dragons” treatment was then performed: GV20, BL 11 bilaterally, BL 23 bilaterally, and BL 61 bilaterally. The needles were again placed from right to left, top to bottom, obtaining “de qi” sensation and dispersing (180 degrees counterclockwise) and left in place for 15 min. The needles were then removed. The patient appeared much more engaged and less anxious and fearful after the treatment.

The patient was seen the next afternoon for a second treatment. She was brought to the pain clinic by wheelchair, and was able to assist herself up onto the treatment table. Her pain was 4–5/10. She was able to lay prone and an NN + 1 treatment was performed using the shao yin, tai yang meridians: KI 3, SP 6, HT 3, SI 3, and BL 60. A “mega mu shu” treatment was used: GB 25 (−) to BL 23X BL 52 ( + ) bilaterally at 4 Hz electrical stimulation. This was left in place for 30 min.

On Wednesday, the patient walked to the pain clinic in uniform for her third treatment. The same points as the day prior (shao yin, tai yang command points and “mega mu shu” treatment) with the addition of a percutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (PENS) treatment of the painful area of the lower back using inner and outer bladder lines from L3-S1 with crossed handles at each level in a daisy chain pattern (−), ( + ), (−), ( + ). The treatment was again left in place for 30 min. Her pain was 2–3/10 at discharge.

The patient was discharged to the barracks adjacent to the hospital the following day and by the end of the week had returned to her unit. Follow-up from the chaplain revealed that she had been able to return to working out at the gym and to remain on active duty status. He conveyed to us that she had experienced a profound benefit from the acupuncture.

The patient reported that in addition to helping her physical pain, the acupuncture helped her to feel that it was possible for her to recover emotionally and go on with living her life instead of reliving her past.

The chaplain requested to be treated with acupuncture using the “the same treatment which you used for her.” When asked about history pertaining to PTSD, he said simply, “I was a chaplain in Vietnam and Korea.” I treated him using the “7 internal dragons and 7 external dragon’s” five-element acupuncture treatment. He returned to his work as a hospital chaplain. My follow-up consisted of a nod and a smile or a “thumbs up” when I later saw him on his rounds in the wards or walking the hospital passageways.


12.3 Case 2: Patient with Low Back Pain, Flat Affect with Pictures in Her Pocket


A 29-year-old female first class Petty Officer with chronic low back pain, refractory to other therapies, was referred to the pain management acupuncture clinic. Her low back pain of approximately 3 years began after she was injured in the bombing of the USS Cole in October of 2000.

Her lumbar spine MRI was significant for L4–5 and L5-S1 degenerative disease with no central or neuroforaminal stenosis. Her constant low back pain averaged 5–7/10 and limited her ability to run. It was worsened by bending, twisting, and lifting anything over 15 pounds. She denied radicular symptoms, leg weakness, and bowel or bladder incontinence. She had undergone chiropractic treatments, physical therapy, and other conservative treatment, including nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory medications, muscle relaxants and opioids which did not significantly alleviate her pain and caused intolerable side effects. She had also undergone trigger point injections and diagnostic medial branch blocks to rule out facet mediated low back pain without benefit.

She had been evaluated by neurosurgery and was not felt to be a surgical candidate. She gave a history of having suffered significant burns of the face and hands at the time of the blast. Although scarring from the burns was not visible, the patient produced pictures which had been taken of her at the time of her treatment for the burns at Landstuhl Regional Medical Center in Germany. The patient was also followed for chronic PTSD related to the blast.

On physical exam, vital signs were within normal limits. Her pain VAS 6–7/10. Her affect and speech were flat, but responses were appropriate and no cognitive deficits were appreciated. She was observed to have a normal gait and stance. She had tenderness to palpation over her lumbar paraspinous region bilaterally and pain was increased with flexion of the lumbar spine to 45° and lumbar spine extension to 25°. No sensory, motor, or deep tendon reflex abnormalities were observed and exam of all other systems was within normal limits.


12.3.1 Treatment Course


As no other treatment had been effective to date, the patient was eager to try any therapy which might offer her some relief of her physical and emotional symptoms. Her first treatment consisted of the “7 internal and external dragons” five-element acupuncture treatment (see detailed treatment description in text of first case history above). She did not note significant improvement in pain following the treatment, but did note significant improvement in mood. Due to complaint of lack of pleasure and depression together with low back pain, her second treatment consisted of a shao yin, tai yang N N + 1 French energetic treatment in the prone position for 30 min with points: KI 10, SP 6, HT 3, SI 3, BL 60 together with a “mega mu shu” treatment: GV 4 and bilateral BL 23, BL 52, and GB 25 with electrical stimulation (e-stim) at 4 Hz. She noted a significant decrease in her pain from 6/10 to 2–3/10.

The following week, she returned with baseline low back pain lowered to 4/10. Her third treatment consisted of repeating the “7 internal and external dragons” five-element acupuncture treatment. Both her pain and her mood were significantly improved following her third treatment. The clinic staff noted that she now smiled and joked with them, displaying a much broader range of emotion and speech.

Her fourth treatment focused on her chronic low back pain and consisted of an NN + 1 treatment using command points (−) KI 10 to ( + ) HT 3 and (−) SI 3 to ( + ) BL 40 together with a PENS treatment of the inner and outer bladder line points at the L4-S1 levels using a daisy chain pattern of e-stim at 30 Hz.

The patient returned approximately every 5–8 weeks for treatments to maintain improvement of her low back pain. Shao yin, tai yang meridian treatments were alternated with tai yin, yang ming meridian treatment using LU 7, LI4, LI11, ST 36 (xiaqihai, meaning lower sea of qi), and SP 6 together with CV 6 (The upper sea of qi, qihai) and ST 25 bilaterally to help irritable bowel symptoms, occasional headaches, and lack of energy.

Approximately 1 year after she began treatment, the patient’s severe PTSD symptoms recurred, after she returned from testifying in the trial of the terrorists’ accused of planning the bombing of the USS Cole. She again improved after repeating the “7 internal and external dragons” five-element treatment, on two occasions approximately 3 weeks apart. She continued to have improvement in her mood and returned approximately monthly for treatment of her low back pain.

After another 6 months, she again had a relapse in her PTSD symptoms when asked to tour the ship to which she was being transferred to for sea duty. The ship was of the same class as the USS Cole. The patient was again treated with the seven internal and external dragon treatments and on her second visit with LU7, LI4, LI 11, ST 36, SP 6, CV 6, and ST 25. After she once again improved in regard to mood, irritable bowel syndrome (IBS), sleep, back pain, and headaches, she decided to separate from the military in order to minimize the risk for reactivation of her PTSD. She indicated that she would continue to seek acupuncture treatment for both her emotional and physical well being.


12.4 Case 3: Combat Scarred Service Member Medevac’d from Theater


The patient is a 51-year-old officer. He reported last being well prior to his 2007–2008 Iraq deployment . During that deployment, the patient suffered a mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) when a mortar barrage hit his base with about 10–15 rounds impacting near him. Diving for cover, the patient sustained shrapnel to his left knee but denied experiencing loss of consciousness (LOC) or posttraumatic amnesia. He did not seek immediate treatment.

Several other traumatic experiences occurred during that deployment, wherein the patient witnessed “death up close.” Perhaps the most traumatic experience the patient described was losing his friend to an improvised explosive device (IED). The patient was supposed to be on the convoy which took the life of his good friend and subordinate. “That should have been me,” the patient reported, noting that he asked his subordinate to attend the convoy so that he could go to lunch with a governmental organization.

Following his return home, the patient continued to experience marked guilt and recriminations. During the time when he was not at home, he worked nonstop, throwing himself into his work. To keep from thinking about things that he had seen during his deployment, the patient started drinking regularly, two or more drinks per night. He started to become depressed.

Symptoms of PTSD, chiefly, emotional numbing with memory loss, flashbacks, depersonalization and derealization, sleep disturbance, and hypervigilance, accompanied increasing guilt. He did not seek treatment and thought that by redeploying he might be able to make amends, particularly if he was killed in an act saving someone else. When the opportunity arose for another combat tour, this time to Afghanistan in 2012, the patient leaped at the chance.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jun 3, 2017 | Posted by in NEUROLOGY | Comments Off on Adding a Face and the Story to the Data: Acupuncture for PTSD in the Military

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access