Additional Conditions That May Be a Focus of Clinical Attention
Certain conditions may be the focus of clinical attention leading to contact with the mental health care system but lack sufficient evidence for a diagnosis. Sometimes these conditions may be noted during the course of a psychiatric evaluation even though no mental disorder has been found. Other times there is a need to note the primary reasons for contact with the mental health care system even though diagnostic evaluation reveals no mental disorder. A mental disorder may eventually be found, but the focus of attention is on a condition that is not caused by a mental disorder. For example, a patient with an anxiety disorder may receive treatment for a marital problem that is unrelated to the anxiety disorder itself.
Thirteen conditions make up the category of additional conditions that may be a focus of clinical attention: malingering, bereavement, occupational problems, adult antisocial behavior, religious or spiritual problem, acculturation problem, phase-of-life problem, noncompliance with treatment for a mental disorder, academic problem, identity problem, age-related cognitive decline, borderline intellectual functioning, and child or adolescent antisocial behavior.
Malingering is the intentional production of false or overly exaggerated physical or psychological symptoms motivated by external gains. Clinically, it is often crucial to distinguish malingering from true mental illnesses such as factitious, somatoform, or dissociative disorders. Malingering may be associated with child, adolescent, or adult antisocial behavior, which is characterized by engaging in illegal or immoral activities. However, the antisocial behavior in these conditions never reaches the level necessary to diagnose an antisocial personality disorder.
Bereavement is a condition that can become the focus of clinical attention even if it does not progress to the outright acute mental disorder of depression. Clinicians must be aware of the difference between normal bereavement and depression and be alert for the development of more serious symptoms.
Examples of an occupational problem include job dissatisfaction and uncertainty about career choices. A phase-of-life problem might be associated with such major life-cycle changes as starting college, getting married, or having children. Stress during times of cultural transitions, such as moving to a new country or entering the military, can lead to an acculturation problem. Young people who join cults might provide examples of religious or spiritual problems. Age-related cognitive decline must be distinguished from dementia, and borderline intellectual functioning must be distinguished from diagnosable developmental delays or specific learning disorders. Academic problems, identity problems, and noncompliance with treatment are the remaining conditions addressed in this chapter, and students should be able to describe and recognize their characteristics.
Students should study the questions and answers below for a useful review of these conditions.
Helpful Hints
Students should know the following terms.
acculturation problem
adoption studies
age-associated memory decline
antisocial behavior
brainwashing
coping mechanisms
cults
cultural transition
culture shock
kleptomania
malingering
marital problems
mature defense mechanisms
medicolegal context of presentation
noncustodial parent
normal grief
occupational problem
patient–doctor match
phase-of-life problem
religious or spiritual problem
sociopathic
stress
superego lacunae
white collar crime
Questions
Directions
Each of the questions or incomplete statements below is followed by five suggested responses or completions. Select the one that is best in each case.
32.1 White collar crime
A. is a term coined by Robert Merton
B. occurs mainly by people who deem themselves to be decent
C. is not influenced by technological advances
D. does not include violations of environmental and health laws
E. costs society less than robbery, burglary, car theft, and larceny
View Answer
32.1 The answer is B
Most individuals who commit white collar crime think of themselves as basically decent, and most of the time, they probably are. The term white collar crime was coined by Edwin Sutherland (not Robert Merton) at a 1939 meeting of the American Sociological Society. He defined white collar crime in his 1949 book White Collar Crime as “a crime committed by a person of respectability and high social status in the course of his occupation.” For statistical purposes, the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) has defined white collar crime as illegal acts characterized by deceit, concealment, or violation of trust that are not dependent on the application or threat of physical force or violence. Individuals and organizations commit these acts to obtain money, property, or services; to avoid the payment or loss of money or services; or to secure personal or business advantages.
During the final decade of the twentieth century, as violent crime rates diminished, government and private lawsuits for fraud and other financial violations greatly increased. Scholars and law enforcement personnel have speculated that the surge in high-stakes white collar crime is a result, at least in part, of technological advances (e.g., the Internet, automated teller machines) that facilitate certain kinds of offenses (e.g., identity theft, embezzlement) and provide opportunities for new kinds of white collar crime (e.g., hacking into computer databases; disseminating computer viruses). The scope of white collar crime is ever widening. It has come to include criminal acts in violation of environmental and health laws. Financially, white collar crime costs society approximately 37.5 times as much (not less than) as robbery, burglary, car theft, and larceny put together.
32.2 Borderline intellectual functioning
A. is present in approximately 14 percent of the general population
B. is usually diagnosed after completion of school
C. is essentially the same as mental retardation
D. is defined as an IQ below 70
E. none of the above
View Answer
32.2 The answer is A
Borderline intellectual functioning is defined by an IQ in the 71 to 84 range (not an IQ below 70). Approximately 14 percent of the general population has an IQ within this range. Because individuals within this IQ range tend to have little impairment outside of educational settings, the diagnosis is often overlooked after completion of school. The condition may continue to be a focus of clinical attention if it compromises social functioning, vocational adjustment, or compliance with medical management.
The 1959 edition of Classification in Mental Retardation defined anyone with an IQ less than one standard deviation below the mean (IQ below 85) as mentally retarded. This definition was applied without regard to functional impairment, and many individuals who fell within this range had no discernible adaptive difficulties. The 1973 edition of Classification in Mental Retardation redefined mental retardation as an IQ less than two standard deviations below the mean (70 or below) with associated impairments in adaptive functioning.
32.3 Academic problems
A. can be diagnosed only if they are the result of factors external to the student, such as family difficulties or social stressors.
B. are evidenced by a pattern of academic underachievement or a decline from a previous level of functioning.
C. are rarely diagnosed with the use of intelligence tests.
D. cannot be diagnosed if attributable to a mental disorder.
E. none of the above
View Answer
32.3 The answer is B
The diagnosis of an academic problem is when the focus of clinical attention is on an academic problem that is not due to a mental disorder, or if it is due to a mental disorder, the problem must be sufficiently severe enough to warrant independent clinical focus. Academic problems can result from factors intrinsic as well as external to the student.