11
Auxiliary Staff in Mental Health Care: Requirements, Functions and Supervision
Dain van der Reyden
Department of Occupational Therapy, School of Health Sciences, University of KwaZulu-Natal, Durban, South Africa
Introduction
Occupational therapy ‘auxiliaries’ are currently trained in several countries, notably the USA, Britain, Canada and South Africa. For the purposes of clarity, the term ‘auxiliary staff’ will be used as a collective term, to include occupational therapy assistants (OTAs), occupational therapy technicians (OTTs) and community rehabilitation workers (CRWs). These workers are often classified as support staff and mid-level health workers. The OTT, for example, is equivalent to that of some certified OT assistants (COTAs) as trained in the USA. The different states in the America provide training of different durations (one to three years), but it would seem that the scope of practice of the COTA, however, remains consistent and corresponds to that of the OTT.
An Internet search shows substantial numbers of references to COTAs (CA.Gov. 2013). It is obvious that training is widespread throughout the USA and that this category of staff is well regulated with an expected 30% growth in employment from 2008 to 2018. However, auxiliary staff are often not available nor trained to assist in occupational therapy interventions in many parts of the world, and volunteers may be used to fulfil many of the tasks usually allocated to auxiliary staff. South Africa has been proactive in the training of occupational therapy auxiliary staff to assist with the intervention programmes in mental health care and other areas where their services are considered to be vital.
During the 1960s to 1980s in South Africa, professional nurses were frequently allocated to organise and manage areas such as the industrial contract areas and recreational activities, in the absence of a qualified occupational therapist. For many years, mental health care facilities ran productive workshops and handcraft areas, producing high-quality products, without the aid of an occupational therapist. The staff allocated to these areas were usually called ‘therapy nurses’ or were qualified tradesmen, such as carpenters. They provided a variety of constructive and recreational activities with the main aim of occupying, training and stimulating patients. It must be acknowledged that many newly qualified occupational therapists benefited from the vast experience of these ‘therapy nurses’ and technicians.
As a result of the increase in the numbers of occupational therapists and the formalisation of training for auxiliary categories (support staff), occupational therapy departments are now better staffed. Staff numbers are, however, rarely adequate to provide the needed service, especially in medium- and long-term units.
The need for auxiliary staff also does not seem to have decreased with the increase in numbers of qualified occupational therapists, but seems to be the opposite, largely due to the extension of occupational therapy services into new areas of practice, the opening of new departments, specialisation within the profession and demand for occupational therapy services in the private sector and different levels of health care provision.
The role of the occupational therapist, particularly within mental health care facilities, is often that of manager, planner and organiser of programmes and services for entire populations of patients. They, therefore, make use of auxiliary staff to implement many aspects of direct service provision within the psychosocial field of practice. The primary health care approach, as now implemented in most countries, presents exciting challenges to the occupational therapist and auxiliary staff. It demands that comprehensive mental health and psychiatric services be provided at a community level.
There has been a substantive shift in attitude and approach towards auxiliary staff who are currently accepted as valued members of the profession, with a specific role and contribution which is certainly not inferior but rather complimentary to that of the graduate occupational therapist.
Current situation
The South African National Department of Health has approved, as part of the human resource plan, mid-level worker (MLW) categories of staff in the majority of health professions. Mid-level workers in occupational therapy include occupational therapy assistants, who have completed a one-year certificate course and are also required to register but are not consistently referred to as MLW due to the duration of their training, and the occupational therapy technician and the community rehabilitation worker, who have each completed two years of training. These acronyms will be used hereafter.
Occupational therapy auxiliaries were trained to function mainly within institutional settings, whilst CRWs were trained to practise within a community setting. In South Africa, the trend is for the professional to train only one category, that of the OTT, who has advanced occupational therapy auxiliary specific skills, as well as community development and community-based rehabilitation skills, and who is able to function effectively in both facility-based services (FBS) and community-based services (CBS). Training for OTAs, COTAs as trained in several states in America, and CRWs are no longer offered, but these workers may, with additional training, apply to do the Health Professionals Council of South Africa board examination to enable registration as an OTT.
As the situation in South Africa differs from that in other parts of the world, South African occupational therapists are directed to the reference list for relevant material.
Ethical and legal context
Auxiliary staff must comply with the professional requirements of the country in which they practice, such as scope of practice, registration, annual payment of fees, ethical rules and other professional conduct requirements.
Registration of occupational therapy auxiliaries
Occupational therapy auxiliaries need to register with a licensing body or similar health profession council in order to practise and need to comply with similar rules and regulations as the occupational therapist. Most countries determine that occupational therapy auxiliaries must practise under the supervision of an occupational therapist and may not establish a private practice or work independently of an occupational therapist.
The occupational therapist is obliged to provide an appropriate level of supervision and, importantly, retain professional responsibility and liability for treatment implemented by occupational therapy auxiliaries under his/her supervision (Dada & McQuoid-Mason 2001). A supervisor is a person who ensures that the assigned tasks are performed correctly and efficiently (American Occupational Therapy Association 1994).
The responsibilities of the occupational therapy auxiliary included the following:
- Conducting oneself in accordance with the ethical principles, rules and guidelines of the profession and statutory licensing body, and treating patients/clients and care providers without any bias with regard to nationality, socio-economic status, religious affiliation, politics, personal preferences or personal gain. This essentially means placing the interest of the patient above all else and demonstrating the highest level of professional integrity at all times.
- Accepting and practising within a supervisory relationship, which would include effectively and efficiently executing the prescription of the occupational therapist, implementing protocols as indicated and demonstrating loyalty to the profession and employing body.
- Maintaining professional registration and actively participating in continual professional development activities where they are required by the licensing authority and performing only those tasks which he/she has been trained to do or has gained sufficient experience to do. Additionally, it is expected that the auxiliary will exercise the degree of competence and care, which could reasonably be expected from an auxiliary with that level of training and experience.
Responsibility of the employing body
The appointment of a registered occupational therapist to provide and ensure ongoing supervision of OTTs remains the responsibility of the employing body. The author, however, believes that both the occupational therapist and the auxiliaries involved need to motivate for ongoing supervision.
Responsibilities of the supervising occupational therapist
The occupational therapist retains overall responsibility for services provided and is vicariously liable for actions of auxiliaries, as well as overall quality assurance. It is thus essential that the occupational therapist accepts the supervisory management function as an integral part of his/her role. The time spent on supervision should be offset by the time gained by auxiliary staff coping more efficiently with tasks delegated to them and the extension of the occupational therapy service offered.
The occupational therapist should provide adequate supervision and management of services provided by auxiliaries whilst providing appropriate referrals, prescriptions and protocols for implementation and delegating effectively. The occupational therapist should not expect the auxiliaries to perform any acts for which they have not been adequately trained, or do not have the experience and skills to do, and should furthermore facilitate continuing professional development and ongoing training.
In situations where the supervising occupational therapist is employed to supervise and is not onsite, the author believes that he/she must, of necessity, accept responsibility not only for supervision at certain times but also for organising, supervising and developing the service at that centre. These duties will therefore include an evaluation of the institution or centre, which could be of an extensive visit, possibly a survey, as well as discussions with all staff concerned in order to determine real needs and ascertain policy. This would be followed by planning and organising a service, which could realistically be offered, considering staff and facilities available.
It would be important to determine the role of the auxiliary staff in the provision of the service, to prevent exploitation, which means that the supervisor should obtain a job description for the particular staff member or, if not available, draw up such a job description. The supervisor should also ensure that management is well informed and in agreement with the role of the staff member.
Communication channels between auxiliary staff and other departments and between the occupational therapist, students and auxiliary staff should be established. Lines of authority must be established. Problems may arise if auxiliary staff take instructions from the supervising occupational therapist or are not supported by other staff, such as professional nurses on the ward. The occupational therapist should therefore anticipate possible difficulties and communicate regularly with wards and management to keep inevitable misunderstandings to a minimum. All changes, plans and special programmes should also be discussed with all involved.
Tasks and functions of auxiliary staff and practical considerations
The appointment of auxiliary staff enables the occupational therapist to spend a greater part of the day in direct service provision and, together with auxiliary staff, carry greater patient loads. It enables the occupational therapist to establish programmes for large numbers of patients, which can be implemented by auxiliary staff, and to develop and provide a variety of services within a variety of settings. Auxiliary staff can therefore assist the occupational therapist to establish a more effective and efficient service and will contribute to the overall development and maintenance of occupational therapy services at institutions, clinics or centres. This includes the development of community outreach programmes.
Guiding principles
The OTA (one year training) is trained to work according to the prescription of the occupational therapist. His/her main contribution therefore lies within the implementation phase of intervention.
The OTT, on the other hand, has either specialised activity skills, a trade qualification, advanced occupational therapy auxiliary skills and/or training in community rehabilitation and development. Such a person, therefore, is able to work within prescribed protocols of intervention, for example, for the treatment of a person with a stroke (cerebral vascular accident), and may implement these based on assessment findings.
Occupational therapy auxiliaries are trained to deal with the non-compliant, routine, repetitive and medium- to long-term ‘standard’ types of cases. Any clients with multiple handicaps or diagnoses that are treatment resistant or have an unusual client picture and are actively ill would generally not be seen without direct occupational therapy intervention. The occupational therapist retains the responsibility to plan, institute and terminate interventions and programmes. The auxiliary staff therefore assist the occupational therapist with those aspects of implementation and departmental organisation which do not require constant and/or direct intervention or all the theoretical knowledge, skill and expertise of the occupational therapist. This, however, does not imply that the occupational therapist makes all the decisions. Rather, planning is done collaboratively with auxiliary staff.
Tasks which may be undertaken by auxiliary staff
It should be noted that the scope of work and level of responsibility of auxiliary staff will vary from country to country. Content, training, experience and duration of practice will influence the nature and content of expectations. The occupational therapy auxiliary should, with supervision, be able to cope effectively with the following: