Author
Year
Conditions being studied
Study type
Cell transplantation procedures
Stroke type
Timing of delivery after stroke
Phase category
Location
Cell type
Cell source
Delivery route
Kondziolka et al.
2000
Ischemic
7–55 months
Phase1, NR/SB
USA
Predifferentiated neuronal cells, LBS neurons®
Allogeneic
NT2/D1 human precursor cell line
IC
Kondziolka et al.
2005
Ischemic
1–6 years
Phase 2, R/SB
USA
Predifferentiated neuronal cells, LBS neurons®
Allogeneic
NT2/D1 human precursor cell line
IC
Bang et al.
2005
Ischemic
5–9 and 7–11 weeks
Phase1/2, R
Korea
MSC
Autologous
Bone marrow
IV
Savitz et al.
2005
Ischemic
1.5–10 years
Phase 1, NR/OL
USA
Fetal lateral ganglionic eminence cells, LGE cells ®
Xenogeneic
Primordial porcine striatum
IC
Rabinovich et al.
2005
Ischemic or hemorrhagic
4–24 months
NR/OL
Russia
Nerve and hematopoietic hepatic cells
Allogeneic
Human fetus immature nervous and hematopoietic tissues
IT
Suárez-Monteagudo et al.
2009
Ischemic or hemorrhagic
3–8 years
Phase 1, NR/OL
Cuba
MNC
Autologous
Bone marrow
IC
Lee et al.
2010
Ischemic
Approximately within 7 and 9 weeks
Phase 2, R/SB
Korea
MSC
Autologous
Bone marrow
IV
Barbosa da Fonseca et al.
2010
Ischemic
62–82 days
Phase 1, NR/OL
Brazil
MNC
Autologous
Bone marrow
IA
Savitz et al.
2011
Ischemic
24–72 h
Phase 1, NR/OL
USA
MNC
Autologous
Bone marrow
IV
Honmou et al.
2011
Ischemic
36–133 days
Phase 1, NR/OL
Japan
MSC
Autologous
Bone marrow
IV
Battistella et al.
2011
Ischemic
59–82 days
Phase 1, NR/SB
Brazil
MNC
Autologous
Bone marrow
IA
Bhasin et al.
2011
Stroke
3 months to 1 year
NR
India
MSC
Autologous
Bone marrow
IV
Friedrich et al.
2012
Ischemic
3–10 days
Phase 1, NR/OL
Brazil
MNC
Autologous
Bone marrow
IA
Moniche et al.
2012
Ischemic
5–9 days
Phase1/2, NR/SB
Spain
MNC
Autologous
Bone marrow
IA
Prasad et al.
2012
Ischemic
8–29 days
Phase 1, NR/OL
India
MNC
Autologous
Bone marrow
IV
Rosado-de-Castro et al.
2013
Ischemic
19–89 days
Phase 1, NR/OL
Brazil
MNC
Autologous
Bone marrow
IA or IV
Bhasin et al.
2013
Ischemic or hemorrhagic
3 months to 2 years
Phase 1/2, NR/OL
India
MNC
Autologous
Bone marrow
IV
MSC
Jiang et al.
2013
Ischemic or hemorrhagic
11–50 days
Phase 1, NR/OL
China
MSC
Allogeneic
Umbilical cord
IA
Li et al.
2013
Hemorrhagic
5–7 days
Phase 1/2, NR/SB
China
MNC
Autologous
Bone marrow
IC
Wang et al.
2013
Ischemic
1–7 years
Phase 1, NR/OL
China
CD34+ positive cells
Autologous
Peripheral blood
IT
Prasad et al.
2014
Ischemic
18.5 days, median
Phase 2, R/SB
India
MNC
Autologous
Bone marrow
IV
Banerjee et al.
2014
Ischemic
Within 9 days
Phase 1/2, NR/OL
UK
CD34+ positive cells
Autologous
Bone marrow
IA
Chen et al.
2014
Ischemic
6 months to 5 years
Phase 2, R/SB
Taiwan
CD34+ positive cells
Autologous
Peripheral blood
IC
Sharma et al.
2014
Ischemic or hemorrhagic
4–144 months
Phase 1/2, NR/OL
India
MNC
Autologous
Bone marrow
IT
Taguchi et al.
2015
Ischemic
Within 10 days
Phase 1/2, NR/OL
Japan
MNC
Autologous
Bone marrow
IV
As shown in Table 5.2, there are 22 ongoing clinical trials regarding cell therapy against ischemic cerebral stroke being conducted all over the world, including the UK, France, Malaysia, China, Korea, the USA, Hong Kong, Spain, India, and Japan. Of these, 15 trials are currently recruiting participants and three trials are ongoing, but the recruitment of new participants was closed by the end of October 2015. The other four trials are expected to begin recruitment in the near future. The study subjects are all adults, including both sexes. The timing of cell delivery after stroke varies among these ongoing trials from the acute to chronic stages. Cell type also varies widely, including allogeneic neural stem cells (NSCs); autologous BMSCs; allogeneic MSCs derived from the bone marrow, umbilical cord, or adipose tissue; and autologous BMMNCs. One study is employing multipotent adult progenitor cells derived from allogeneic bone marrow. Some studies involve randomized, double-blind controlled trials to compare the safety, feasibility, and effect between intravenous transplantation of BMSCs or BMMNCs (or endothelial progenitor cells) and a placebo against ischemic cerebral stroke in the acute or subacute stage. The clinical trial phase category also varies from phase 1 to 3. Taken together, there are a total of 47 clinical trials worldwide that have been completed or are ongoing regarding cell therapy against cerebral stroke. The materials regarding cell culture, including the basic medium and supplements used for cell preparation, mainly depend on the cell type and timing of cell delivery. The following subsection will address this issue according to cell type.
Table 5.2
Ongoing clinical trials regarding “Cell Therapy against Cerebral Stroke” at the end of October 2015
Clinical trial identifier | Conditions being studied | Study type | Cell transplantation procedures | ||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Stroke type | Timing of delivery after stroke | Phase category | Recruitment | Location | Start from | Last updated | Cell type | Cell source | Delivery route | Cell preparation | Published protocol | ||
Allogeneic NSC | |||||||||||||
NCT01151124 | Ischemic | 6–60 months | Phase 1, NR/OL | Ongoing but not recruiting | UK | 2010/Jun | 2015/May | NSC | Allogeneic | Human fetal brain cortical tissue | IC | Ex vivo derivation | Stem Cell Res Ther. 2014 Apr 11;5(2):49 |
NCT02117635 | Ischemic | 2–3 months | Phase 2, NR/OL | Recruiting | UK | 2014/Jun | 2015/Oct | NSC | Allogeneic | Human fetal brain cortical tissue | IC | n.d. | None |
Autologous MSC | |||||||||||||
NCT00875654 | Ischemic | Less than 6 weeks of onset | Phase 2, R/OL | Ongoing but not recruiting | France | 2010/Aug | 2015/Feb | MSC | Autologous | Bone marrow | IV | n.d. | None |
NCT01461720 | Ischemic | 2 weeks to 2 months | Phase 2, NR/SB | Recruiting | Malaysia | 2012/Mar | 2015/Mar | MSC | Autologous | Bone marrow | IV | Ex vivo expansion | None |
NCT01714167 | Ischemic or hemorrhagic | 3–60 months | Phase 1, NR/OL | Recruiting | China | 2012/Jun | 2015/Jun | MSC | Autologous | Bone marrow | IC | n.d. | None |
NCT01716481 | Ischemic | Within 90 days of onset | Phase 3, R/OL | Recruiting | Korea | 2012/Nov | 2014/May | MSC | Autologous | Bone marrow | IV | Ex. vivo expansion | Trials. 2013 Oct 1;14:317 |
NCT02564328 | Ischemic | 6–60 months | Phase 1, R/SB | Recruiting | China | 2014/Nov | 2015/Sep | MSC | Autologous | Bone marrow | IV | n.d. | None |
(Listed on clinical trials registry of Japan Medical Association as JMA-IIA00117) | Ischemic | Within 74 days | Phase 3, R/DB | Recruiting | Japan | 2013/Mar | 2015/Aug | MSC | Autologous | Bone marrow | IV | n.d. | Brain 134:1790–807, 2011 |
Allogeneic MSC | |||||||||||||
NCT01297413 | Ischemic | Over 6 months | Phase 1/2, NR/OL | Recruiting | USA | 2011/Feb | 2015/Sep | MSC | Allogeneic | Bone marrow | IV | n.d. | None |
NCT01673932 | Ischemic | 6–60 months | Phase 1, R/OL | Recruiting | Hong Kong | 2012/Oct | 2015/Jul | MSC | Allogeneic | Umbilical cord blood | IC | Ex vivo expansion | None |
NCT01678534 | Ischemic | Within 2 weeks of onset | Phase 1/2, R/DB | Recruiting | Spain | 2014/Sep | 2015/Jan | MSC | Allogeneic | Adipose tissue | IV | Ex vivo expansion | J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis. 2014 Nov-Dec;23(10):2694–700 |
NCT02378974 | Ischemic | Within 7 and 14 days | Phase1/2, R/DB | Recruiting | Korea | 2015/Feb | 2015/Mar | MSC | Allogeneic | Umbilical cord | IV | Ex vivo expansion | None |
NCT01922908 | Ischemic | 3–10 days | Phase 1/2, R/DB | Not yet recruiting | USA | 2015/Jul | 2015/May | MSC | Allogeneic | Bone marrow | IV | Ex vivo expansion | None |
NCT02448641 | Ischemic | 6–60 months | Phase 2, R/DB | Not yet recruiting | USA | 2015/Aug | 2015/May | MSC | Allogeneic | Modified human MSC line, SB623® | IC | Ex vivo expansion | Cell Therapy for Brain Injury. Springer International Publishing Switzerland; 2015. p.101 |
NCT01849887 | Ischemic | 24–72 h | Phase 1/2, R/DB | Not yet recruiting | USA | 2017/Jan | 2014/Dec | MSC | Allogeneic | Bone marrow | IV | Ex vivo expansion | None |
Autologous MNC | |||||||||||||
NCT02245698 | Ischemic | Subacute/chronic | Phase 1, NR/OL | Recruiting | India | 2008/Dec | 2014/Sep | MNC | Autologous | Bone marrow | IT | Ex vivo isolation | None |
NCT01832428 | Ischemic or hemorrhagic or other | N.D. | Phase1/2, NR/OL | Recruiting | India | 2014/Sep | 2014/Sep | MNC | Autologous | Bone marrow | IT | Ex vivo isolation | None |
NCT02290483 | Ischemic | 1–7 days | Phase 2, R/OL | Recruiting | Spain | 2015/Apr | 2015/Jul | MNC | Autologous | Bone marrow | IA | Ex vivo isolation | None |
NCT02178657 | Ischemic | 1–7 days | Phase 2, R/SB | Recruiting | Spain | 2015/Apr | 2015/Jul | MNC | Autologous | Bone marrow | IA | Ex vivo isolation | None |
Allogeneic bone marrow-derived multipotent adult progenitor cells | |||||||||||||
NCT01436487 | Ischemic | 1–2 days | Phase 2, R/DB | Ongoing but not recruiting | USA and UK | 2011/Oct | 2015/May | Multipotent adult progenitor cells | Allogeneic | Bone marrow-derived progenitor cell, MultiStem® | IV | Ex vivo expansion | Int J Stroke. 2014 Apr;9(3):381–6 |
Comparative study between autologous MSC and MNC or EPC | |||||||||||||
NCT01468064 | Ischemic | Approximately 5 and 6 weeks | Phase 1/2, R/DB | Recruiting | China | 2011/Aug | 2011/Aug | MSC or EPC | Autologous | Bone marrow | IV | Ex vivo expansion | None |
NCT00908856 | Ischemic | Approximately 4 days for MNC and 23 days for MSC | Phase 1, R/DB | Not yet recruiting | USA | 2016/Jan | 2014/Dec | MSC or MNC | Autologous | Bone marrow | IV | Ex vivo isolation or expansion | Transfusion. 2009 Jul;49(7):1471–81 |
5.2.1 Bone Marrow Stromal Cells
In the previous literature, “mesenchymal stromal cells,” “mesenchymal stem cells,” and “multipotent stem cells” are collectively abbreviated as “MSCs,” which are likely to lead some confusion. Similarly, “bone marrow stromal cells” and “bone marrow stem cells” are collectively abbreviated as “BMSCs.” In this subdivision, mesenchymal stromal cell is abbreviated as “MSC,” and bone marrow stromal cell is abbreviated as “BMSC” to avoid misunderstanding. According to a review article by Charbord, the historical emergence of the concept of “mesenchymal stem cell” emerged in the 1960s [34]. Besides hematopoietic stem/progenitor cells, the bone marrow contains cells that form colonies consisting of plastic-adherent, elongated cells of fibroblastic appearance when cultured at low density in liquid medium containing serum. In 1991, Caplan first introduced the term “mesenchymal stem cell.” To clarify the nomenclature for MSC, International Society for Cellular Therapy has proposed the term “multipotent mesenchymal stromal cell” in 2005. The accumulation of several years of solid and rigorous research indicates that MSCs are mesenchymal precursors with multipotency and self-renewal capacity that are present in the bone marrow of multiple species, including humans, as well as in other sources, including adipose tissue and the umbilical cord. MSCs can be extensively amplified ex vivo, which enables their use in cell therapy applications. Although the pluripotency of MSCs is somewhat controversial (criteria for differentiation need to be rigorously defined) [34, 35], MSCs, especially BMSCs, show several advantages (see Chap. 2) over other cell types as resources of cell therapy against cerebral stroke.
Regarding the cell culture of human BMSCs, previous basic research investigating human BMSC (hBMSC) therapy against cerebral stroke in animal models employed liquid culture media comprising a basic culture medium with supplements for cell growth [36–50]. Table 5.3 summarizes the basic culture medium and supplements used for ex vivo hBMSC expansion in these preclinical studies. Historically, animal serum (i.e., fetal bovine serum; FBS) or human serum was added to the basic medium, including Dulbecco’s modified Eagle medium (DMEM) or alpha-minimal essential medium (αMEM) for ex vivo cell expansion. These basic media contain inorganic salts, amino acids, vitamins, nucleotides, glucose, and buffers. In most cases, antibiotic agents were also added. As previously discussed elsewhere, the use of FBS raises several concerns for preparations of clinical-grade hBMSC, including the potential for an immunologic reaction to the xenogeneic antigen and/or the potential risk for viral and prion contamination [51]. Animal or human serum has also been shown to have inconsistent lot-to-lot performance, which may cause variability in the cell expansion effect. To overcome the inconsistent performance associated with serum, the development of serum-free hBMSC culture medium has been warranted. Toward this end, human platelet lysate (PL) was recently tested for use in hBMSC expansion instead of FBS or autologous human serum. As a result, some researchers reported that autologous human PL was an efficient substitute for FBS in expanding hBMSCs [52, 53]. More recently, there have been attempts to establish another serum-free expansion system for hBMSCs. Chase et al. reported a serum-free medium containing xenogeneic components as a containing medium as a potential substitute for serum-containing medium in hBMSC expansion [54]. Thus, hBMSCs isolated and expanded in serum-free medium supplemented with recombinant human platelet-derived growth factor-BB (PDGF-BB), basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF), and transforming growth factor-β1 (TGF-β1) were found to effectively retain their phenotypic, differentiation, and colony-forming potential. In addition, Yamauchi et al. reported that serum-free, allogeneic human PL-containing medium supplemented with granulocyte-colony stimulating factor (G-CSF) was safe and could accelerate the expansion of hBMSCs for cell therapy against cerebral infarct in rats [55]. Taken together, multiple culture media have been tested for hBMSC culture in basic research studies, including serum-containing media, serum-free and allogeneic human PL-containing media supplemented with or without G-CSF, and serum-free and xenogeneic recombinant human PDGF-BB-, bFGF-, and TGF-β-containing media.
Table 5.3

Past basic research regarding hBMSC therapy against cerebral stroke AND cell culture

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Full access? Get Clinical Tree


