, Julia Doss2, Sigita Plioplys3 and Jana E. Jones4
(1)
Department of Psychiatry, UCLA, Los Angeles, CA, USA
(2)
Department of Psychology, Minnesota Epilepsy Group, St. Paul, MN, USA
(3)
Department of Psychiatry, Northwestern University, Chicago, IL, USA
(4)
Department of Neurology, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, Madison, WI, USA
Keywords
Cognitive behavior therapy (CBT)AnxietyDepressionCognitive restructuringExposureNegative thoughtsBehavioral activationParental coachHow Common Are Anxiety and Depression in PNES?
Anxiety is one of the most common mental health problems in childhood and adolescence with prevalence rates ranging from 6 to 20% [1]. The anxiety disorders include agoraphobia, panic disorder, specific phobia, separation anxiety, social anxiety (including selective mutism), and generalized anxiety disorder. These disorders are frequently unrecognized and untreated in childhood [2, 3]. Anxiety disorders are common in children with PNES, but there is very little data to indicate how commonly they occur. In a recent multi-center study, 83.6% of children with PNES also met criteria for an anxiety disorder [4].
Major depressive disorder (MDD) is also a frequent mental health problem especially in adolescence [3]. It is estimated that 2% of children and 4–8% adolescents have experienced an MDD with males and females having similar rates in childhood and females having higher rates in adolescence [5, 6]. Studies have demonstrated that approximately 5–10% of children and adolescents experience subsyndromal symptoms of MDD [6]. Rates of MDD in PNES are not known, but the recent study by Plioplys et al. [4] also reported that 43.6% of the 8–18-year-old PNES sample had depressive disorders. Similar to the general child and adolescent population, older age and female gender increased the risk of having both depression and PNES [4].
In many children and adolescents, anxiety disorders and depression occur before the onset of PNES and often remain after the NES symptoms are treated [7, 8]. As a result, it is important to recognize anxiety and depression as commonly occurring problems in children and adolescents with PNES.
Among the different types of psychotherapeutic or psychosocial interventions, exposure-based CBT has the most empirical support for treating children and adolescents with anxiety disorders. But, it is of utmost importance that you identify if and when is the most appropriate time to address these PNES comorbid conditions with CBT. This will depend on the child’s response to the interventions to reduce PNES episodes, level of resistance, learning style, and rapport with you. It may be appropriate to try to incorporate CBT elements only after the child clearly understands and accepts the relationship among negative emotions, stress, and NES symptoms. As mentioned in the tips to treating PNES in Fig. 5.1 of Chap. 5, children with PNES, particularly those with learning difficulties, are often resistant to what might appear to them as “homework.” Therefore, it is imperative that you introduce CBT at a much slower pace than would be typically utilized in a 10–12-week anxiety or depression CBT intervention protocol. If the child demonstrates nonverbal or verbal cues of discomfort or resistance, back off until you feel the child will benefit from CBT. Evidence-based protocols can be helpful to you, but you will need to carefully modify the timeline, order, and manner in which you introduce the CBT skills (see Appendix M for CBT resources).
Evidence-Based CBT in the Treatment of Anxiety Disorders and Depression
In CBT, the clinician or therapist helps to teach the child adaptive coping skills and introduces practice opportunities (exposures) to develop coping techniques or skills to overcome the anxiety symptoms or situations that increase stress and impaired functioning. There is compelling evidence that children with anxiety disorders have a better treatment responses compared to adolescents. There appear to be neurodevelopmental changes in the brain that facilitate learning in childhood and disrupt the acquisition of new learning in adolescents [9]. There is also evidence that children with anxiety disorder have even better outcomes if a multimodal approach is utilized, and CBT is introduced in combination with a selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI). Combined CBT and sertraline, an SSRI, has the highest response rates (80.7%), whereas CBT alone produced response rates (59.7%) similar to those of medication alone (54.9%) [10].
CBT is also recommended for depressive disorders in children and adolescents although its efficacy is not as strong as has been demonstrated in anxiety disorders [6]. Therefore, in children and adolescents with severe depression, antidepressants are indicated as soon as possible [6]. Psychotherapy can be introduced at the same time as medications are started or at some point afterwards. In adolescents, the response rate for combined CBT and SSRI treatment was 67% compared to 38.6% for usual care [11]. In children with depression, however, the evidence for CBT is less compelling as few clinical trials have been conducted in this age group (See review in [11]).
Treating Anxiety Disorders in Children and Adolescents
This section briefly describes the essential elements or key factors that have been deemed to be the most important when treating anxiety disorders in children and adolescents. It also explains how CBT works and what CBT components work better than others.
Eisen and Silverman [12] reported that cognitive restructuring and relaxation training produced similar reductions in anxiety. Silverman et al. [13] also found that skills training and contingency training reduced anxiety symptoms. More recently, Nakamura et al. [14] found that exposure tasks were important for achieving treatment gains. Peris et al. [15] recently attempted to determine the essential components of CBT in the treatment of anxiety disorders using data from a large-scale treatment trial (Child/Adolescent Anxiety Multimodal Study; [10]). The authors hypothesized that relaxation training, cognitive restructuring, and exposure would be imperative to reach treatment goals. Two techniques clearly contributed to treatment outcomes, and these included exposure and cognitive restructuring. These techniques reduced symptoms of anxiety and were linked to improved functioning. Relaxation training did not appear to significantly contribute to the reduction in symptoms of anxiety or change the course of treatment.
Cognitive Restructuring
This CBT element is comprised of multiple building blocks which ultimately teach the child or adolescent to identify and begin to conquer the thoughts that facilitate the production of anxiety responses or feelings of anxiety.
Thoughts and Feelings
First, it is important to teach the child and adolescent about the relationship between thoughts and feelings. There are a number of examples that have been used to introduce this relationship. Wagner [16] suggests using the example of “noise at the window.” If there is a noise at the window at night, a child’s emotional response depends on what the child thinks caused the noise at the window. This, in turn, will determine how the child feels about the noise. If the child believes it is a robber or thief, the child will be terrified and likely fear for his/her safety. If the child thinks that the noise is only a branch rustling outside, the child may briefly notice the noise and fall quickly to sleep.
Identifying thoughts and feelings seems like a simple task. But it is often a difficult concept for many children and adolescents with anxiety disorders to understand and learn. In the context of PNES, this is particularly difficult because these children typically have problems identifying negative feelings. In addition to the suggestions how to probe for emotions in Chap. 5, several simple exercises can help the child with PNES identify thoughts and feelings related to positive or negative feelings. See the following examples.
What would you think if the teacher called you to the front of the room? What are some thoughts that would run through your mind?
Am I in trouble?
What did I do wrong?
Maybe I made a good grade, and the teacher wants to use my paper as an example?
What are some feelings that might be connected to those thoughts?
Sad
Mad or frustrated
Very happy to finally have my work noticed by the teacher!
Once the child begins to recognize the relationship between thoughts and feelings, it is important to have the child monitor and identify the thoughts associated with anxiety or negative feelings. This is also a difficult task because many children and adolescents have never considered that their thoughts are associated with their feelings of anxiety, fear, and worry. It is helpful to begin to teach the child how to stop and catch the thoughts that appear before the feelings of anxiety. This can be a game that is played in the session and at home by asking, “What were you thinking just before you became upset?” and “What is the most distressing thought that you have?” Also, anxiety thoughts often occur quickly, almost automatically, so a child might need to make a play-by-play, moment-by-moment notation of all possible thoughts that may or may not be associated with anxiety. Suggest that the child use these questions in the context of keeping a daily thought diary, cutting out pictures of faces and scenes from a magazine to practice identifying possible thoughts and feelings, or even drawing simple figures using “thought bubbles” to identify potential thoughts.
Once the child begins to identify thoughts, it is important to teach the child a number of different techniques in order to help replace, restructure, reframe, and challenge the child’s anxious and distressing thoughts. These techniques include, but are not limited to, Socratic questioning, social skills training, and problem-solving.
Socratic Questioning: It is difficult and unproductive to tell someone to stop having anxious thoughts. Socratic questioning allows the therapist or parent to address the anxiety directly without avoiding the distressing thoughts associated with the anxiety. Children with anxiety often do not challenge their thoughts or conduct reality testing to see if there is indeed a real possibility that something catastrophic will happen. Socratic question can often facilitate the process of examining anxiety from a different perspective and to determine if the information the thought provides is valid.
Examples of Socratic questions:
What is the worst thing that could happen?
What else could happen?
What is the likelihood that this outcome would happen?
What is the evidence that this is something that everyone will notice?
What if it really happens?
What could you do to change it?
How beneficial is it for you to have that thought?
Is that thought helpful?
Does anxiety tell the truth?
Problem-Solving Skill Development: We often assume that children and adolescents implicitly learn to become problem-solvers with little explicit instruction. The truth is that many of them struggle with problem-solving skills. To restructure and change thoughts and perceptions that are anxiety laden, it is necessary to identify possible solutions. Just thinking that things will be better or that they are not a cause for worry does not always make it so. Problem-solving allows the child or adolescent to deconstruct the thought or scenario and identify the core factors that the child can change or modify. Consider applying these techniques to your work on Child Long-Term Treatment Goal 5 (see Chap. 9 and Appendix L).
Problem-solving (adapted from [17])
What is the problem? State the problem.
What would make the problem better? Write down all ideas no matter what they are.
What can you do to fix it?
What else could you try?
What else can you do? What else can be done?
Who can help you with this problem?
What would make this problem go away?
Rank order your possible solutions to the problem!
Keep trying each solution until the problem is solved!
Social Skills Development: Children with anxiety (and those with PNES) might lack social skills. Anxiety might also present in social contexts—asking questions in class, meeting new kids, finding a place to sit in the cafeteria, ordering at a restaurant, talking on the phone—just to name a few. A child needs to develop social skills in order to address fears related to social interactions via exposure tasks. Provide the child with opportunities to practice social skills in different situations to help the child acquire a key skill set.
Social skills
Describe feared social situation.
Identify the core fear or belief.
Review possible scenarios or outcomes.
List possible ways to cope with feared social situation.
Practice before implementing—write-out or talk-out scenarios, rehearse with family, and rehearse in session.
Discuss what to do if it all goes bad—one cannot promise that someone will not be rude.
Provide scenarios that are small steps to the real-life situation that is feared.
Dismantling the Anxiety System—False Alarms and Avoidance: Anxiety is hardwired in each of us as part of our “fight or flight” fear system. When an anxiety disorder is present, this fear response system goes haywire. It acts like a car in a parking lot with the alarm sounding off when no one is nearby or like the smoke detector going off in the middle of the night because the battery is dying. There is no actual danger. When the anxiety alarm goes off, anxious negative thoughts occur almost simultaneously, and often there is a physical response that occurs. The heart rate may increase, breathing becomes shallow, sweating occurs, and even stomach upset might set in. These responses are similar to the physical symptoms described in Goal 4 of the child long-term treatment (see Chap. 8 and Appendix H). This system functions to move us out of dangerous situations. But in anxiety disorders, the system overresponds and provides false information.

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Full access? Get Clinical Tree


