Diagnosis of Pediatric PNES

, Julia Doss2, Sigita Plioplys3 and Jana E. Jones4



(1)
Department of Psychiatry, UCLA, Los Angeles, CA, USA

(2)
Department of Psychology, Minnesota Epilepsy Group, St. Paul, MN, USA

(3)
Department of Psychiatry, Northwestern University, Chicago, IL, USA

(4)
Department of Neurology, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health, Madison, WI, USA

 



Keywords
Risk factorsDiagnostic obstaclesPNES gold standard diagnosisComprehensive psychiatric/psychological assessmentComorbid anxietyComorbid depression



The Underlying Psychopathology, Triggers, and Risk Factors


As briefly mentioned in the overview to this treatment guide, the underlying psychopathology of children with PNES, conversion disorder, involves displacement of the tension associated with negative emotions, such as anxiety, anger, fear, frustration, and demoralization onto physical symptoms. Why certain children develop conversion disorder with epilepsy-like symptoms rather than other physical symptoms remains unclear [1, 2]. However, current psychodynamic theories on pediatric PNES and evidence for triggers (see review in [3]) and risk factors [4]) shed light on ways the disorder might develop.

From the research perspective, triggers for pediatric PNES include learning difficulties; social problems; parent marital discord; family dysfunction; unrealistic expectations by the child or the parents for the child to excel at school, sports, or extracurricular activities; bullying and other forms of psychological abuse; and rarely physical or sexual abuse [59]. But not every child who experiences these trigger factors develops PNES. Two independent risk factors differentiate children with PNES from their siblings, a somatopsychiatric factor and an adversity factor [10]. In other words, children with medical problems, excessive use of medical services, fearful response to physical sensations, and psychiatric diagnoses—the somatopsychiatric factors—are at risk for PNES. Bullying associated with emotional problems, psychiatric diagnoses, and treatment with psychiatric drugs—the adversity factors—also increase the vulnerability for PNES.

From the psychodynamic perspective, children who develop PNES and other conversion disorders [11] appear to use avoidance when faced with situations that trigger negative emotions (fear, anger, frustration, anxiety, or sadness). In addition to not confronting and/or problem-solving the situation that triggers these negative feelings, these children are often unaware of or deny experiencing negative emotions. Thus, they are avoidant on both the functional and emotional levels. In some cases, the children have language difficulties with impaired use and/or retrieval of words to describe their emotions (alexithymia) (see review in Reilly et al. [3]) and/or difficulty using sentences to formulate [12] their feelings and thoughts, particularly those involving abstract concepts. As a result, and given their use of avoidance, they do not tune into their negative emotions and/or verbally express or talk about their problems and the associated emotions.

In other cases, the children have intact language skills. However, when they verbalize and express their difficulties or problems to their parents and ask for their help, the parents pay no or little attention to the children’s complaints. In some cases, parents misinterpret, scold, criticize, or verbally abuse the children for their difficulties and avoidant behavior. These responses cause the children to back off, not share their difficulties with their parents, and continue to avoid dealing with the problems at hand.

The children’s unexpressed negative emotions accumulate when the problem situation(s) does(do) not go away and/or gets(get) worse due to the children’s avoidance. Repeat exposure to the problem situation(s) and the lack of problem-solving triggers(s) the children’s anxiety, as well as negative responses by others, which, in turn, make the children more fearful. Mounting of their unexpressed negative feelings on the one hand and the practical results of not problem-solving on the other hand result in these children feeling there is no way out. Taylor [13] used the term predicament to describe this situation, which leads to displacement of the growing tension and mounting unresolved problems into physical symptoms.

Because of the attention these children get due to the seizure-like episodes, they are excused from meeting demands in the school, home, and social environment and/or from dealing with other potential stressors or triggers of their condition. Increased attention by parents and others to the child’s “seizures,” together with continued avoidance of dealing with ongoing problems, difficulties, and/or challenges, is called secondary attention. This inevitable phenomenon reinforces recurrence of the episodes which then take on a life of their own. The more they recur, the more attention the child gets and the more difficult it is for the child to cope with the ongoing problems. Antiseizure medications, also known as antiepileptic drugs (AEDs), can have adverse effects, including fatigue and irritability that further impair the children’s ability to problem-solve and reinforce this vicious cycle. In terms of family functioning, the child’s symptoms might overwhelm the parents in their efforts to deal with the child’s illness and their own ongoing life stressors, such as family discord.

From the behavioral perspective, how parents respond when their child reports physical symptoms acts as positive or negative emotional reinforcers. As such, they can influence how much their child complains about aches, pains, and not feeling well. The wide range of parental responses includes a lack of response, a neutral concerned response, or an excessive anxious response for the child to receive immediate medical attention. In some families, parents only pay attention to their children when they are sick or have physical complaints. Children whose parents are overly anxious when their children have somatic complaints and children of parents who pay attention to them only when they are ill are at high risk for somatization and conversion disorder [14, 15].


The Gold Standard Diagnosis


Confirmation of PNES is based on two essential components. The first component is a prolonged video-EEG (vEEG) in which the child has seizure-like episodes without EEG evidence for ongoing epileptic activity. The second component is that the child meets criteria for a conversion disorder or, more rarely, a dissociation disorder, based on a comprehensive psychiatric evaluation. This treatment guide focuses on treatment of children with PNES who have a conversion disorder. Table 2.1 lists the DSM-5 diagnostic criteria for this disorder [16].


Table 2.1
DSM-5 diagnostic criteria for conversion disorder
















Conversion disorder

One or more symptoms of altered voluntary motor or sensory function

Physical findings provide evidence of incompatibility between the symptom and recognized neurological or medical conditions

The symptom or deficit is not better explained by another medical or mental disorder

The symptom or deficit causes clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning or warrants medical evaluation


Why Is It Difficult to Diagnose PNES in Children?



Medical Reasons



PNES Mimics Epilepsy


In most cases, physicians confirm a diagnosis of seizures due to epilepsy based mainly on reports by parents, family members, or other observers of the seizure manifestations. An EEG finding of epileptic activity helps confirm the diagnosis. However, EEG electrodes on the scalp do not pick up epileptic activity from deeper regions in the brain. Therefore, the lack of epileptic activity during a routine EEG when a patient is not experiencing a seizure does not rule out a diagnosis of epilepsy. Most epilepsy patients usually do not have a seizure in the doctor’s office. So, when a child first has a non-epileptic seizure, even if a routine EEG is normal, physicians do not usually consider the possibility of a non-epileptic seizure.


PNES Occurs in About One-Third of Children with Epilepsy


In children with epilepsy whose seizures were controlled, the parents and physicians assume that the child has had a breakthrough of seizures when NES symptoms occur. In children with new-onset seizures, when seizures continue despite a trial of at least two AEDs, physicians assume they are dealing with intractable or treatment-resistant epilepsy. They, therefore, increase the AED dose, add an AED, or change to another AED in their effort to control seizures.


AED Adverse Effects


Since these drugs do not control seizure-like symptoms unrelated to epilepsy, the child’s episodes continue. High doses of multiple AEDs can cause adverse behavioral and cognitive effects (see review in Caplan [16]). Parents might interpret medication side effects, such as inattention, spacing out due to tiredness, and irritability, as ongoing seizures. This, in turn, can lead physicians to further increase AED doses and/or number of drugs to control the “seizures.”


Parental Behavior


As previously described above in “The Underlying Psychopathology, Triggers, and Risk Factors”, parents’ behavior when their children let them know about problems they are experiencing influences if and how the children share their difficulties with the parents and do or do not problem-solve. Features of parent behavior, described below, can make it difficult for physicians to reach a PNES diagnosis.


Denial of Psychological Problems


Some parents of children with PNES have difficulty recognizing or accepting that their children have learning, social, or psychological difficulties. These parents typically deny that their children have any problems other than seizures when physicians ask about problems.


Misinterpretation of Children’s Behavior


As mentioned in section “The Underlying Psychopathology, Triggers, and Risk Factors”, parents might unwittingly misinterpret their children’s call for help as evidence for laziness, attention seeking, shyness, and/or lack of assertiveness, depending on the nature of the domain in which the child is having a problem. So, when physicians ask these parents if their children have any problems, they might respond with one of the above features, which are typically regarded as normal behavior.


Attention to Physical Symptoms


Parents are unaware that the attention, they do or do not give to their children’s episodes, can perpetuate these symptoms.


Child Behavior


Many children with PNES deny that they have problems other than seizures. Others might acknowledge feeling sad or mad but not about the stress, difficulties, and problems they actually face.


Red Flags for Pediatric PNES



Child’s Medical History


The following information in the child’s history should alert you to the possibility of PNES:

Oct 20, 2017 | Posted by in PSYCHIATRY | Comments Off on Diagnosis of Pediatric PNES

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access