Doctor–Patient Communication


Transferring patient-centered interview

Let the patient finish talking

Use open-ended questions

Pause

Encourage the patient to continue talking

Paraphrase

Summarize the contents

Reflect the patient’s emotions




Let the Patient Finish Talking, Give Him Space


Studies show that doctors already interrupt patients for the first time after 15–20 s. Usually an open-ended first question (like: “What brings you here today?”) signals to the patient that he has space to speak. If the doctor lets the patient finish what he is saying, then it has been found that patients are more cooperative, keep their comments short, and only talk about relevant things. The average patient speaking time at the beginning of an interview is 92 s, and 78 % of patients stop within 2 min (Langewitz et al. 2002).


Open-Ended Questions


Open-ended questions are those that cannot be answered with a simple yes or no. By using open-ended questions, the doctor allows the patient space and signals that he is interested in the patient’s point of view. If, however, the patient cannot find the right words, it can be meaningful to help him with closed questions. No additional questions or explanations should be added after an open question has been asked, since the question will then curtain its supportive, patient-centered function.


Pause


A short pause of about 3 s has been found to be effective. In short pauses of silence, ideas occur to the patient that they may have forgotten. The pause permits the patient to continue speaking if there is something to add. The patient may express thoughts he/she had hesitated to address. The pause lowers the inhibition threshold for speaking about psychosocial matters. During the pause, the doctor emphasizes by listener signals (“hmm,” “yes”) and by his posture that he is listening to the patient and wants to give him the opportunity to continue speaking. Contrary to the fear that pauses might be interpreted as incompetence, pauses act as relief. It is pleasant to be able to think about something briefly. The doctor appears interested, calm, and sure.


Case Study

“Pause”

Doctor: You mentioned briefly stress at work; can you tell me more about that?

Patient: Hmm, yes. The problem is that the company is not in a very solid position. And now there was a large recall action that had to be dealt with quickly to prevent further damage. That meant we all had to work overtime; that takes a lot out of you.

Doctor: Hmm… (3 s pause)

Patient: …to be honest, I just can’t go on. I have trouble dragging myself out of bed in the morning and trouble falling asleep at night. And there are often arguments with my wife. And I can’t blame her. When I come home at night, I’m often irritable and haven’t energy to do much of anything. Actually, I could do with a week’s vacation, but that’s impossible at the moment.


Encourage the Patient to Continue Talking


Nonverbal signs like nodding when the patient hesitates encourage him indirectly to continue speaking. Eye contact signals attention and interest, and also encourages patients to continue speaking. Posture facing the patient emphasizes the doctor’s presence. Verbal possibilities to encourage the patient to speak are short expressions like “mhm” or “ah yes.”


Paraphrase


Paraphrasing means repeating what has been said by the patient in one’s own words. The doctor takes on the patient’s viewpoint and focuses on that part of what the patient said that has the greatest relevant content. Using paraphrases is a good way to support the patient in emotional or personal topics. Questions tend more to disrupt. Paraphrasing often brings new perspectives for the patient that lead to what can be astounding solutions.


Case Study

“Paraphrase”

Patient: Couldn’t we postpone the next chemotherapy cycle?

Doctor: You would like to have a longer pause?

Patient: Yes. You see, it’s like this: My sister lives in the USA and is coming for a visit in 2 weeks. I can’t visit her at the moment, and the medications make me so tired. Well, it would be really dumb while she is here.

Doctor: Ah yes, you don’t want to be hampered while your sister is here?

Patient: Yes, that’s it. Actually, I don’t want her to realize so much that I’m sick. I mean, she knows it, of course, but she shouldn’t have to be confronted with it.

Doctor: Mhm, you don’t want your sister to see you as sick.

Patient: Yes, I don’t want pity or so from her. You see, I’m the older one and I was always there when she needed me.

Doctor: OK, I understand. You don’t want pity and help from your little sister.

Patient: Well, if she helps a little that’s OK, but no pity.

While the first paraphrase focuses on the treatment, the doctor addresses the stress and the patient’s personal background in the later ones. This reflects the background of the patient’s rejection for her. Often, the patients themselves will then arrive at a new solution. If this is not the case, the doctor can help.

Doctor: Could you imagine telling her that you don’t want pity?

Patient: Actually, it’s silly. I’m still strong enough to deal with my sister’s sympathy and I can tell her that I don’t want her to pity me.


Summarize the Contents


With paraphrasing, the doctor only picks up on the most important parts of the message, whereas summarizing covers a larger segment of the discussion. The doctor says in his own words what he has understood. The patient can then add information he had forgotten. This leads to agreement between the doctor and the patient. The doctor checks whether he has understood what the patient said. Summaries are also a suitable means of transition to a new discussion or to announce the end by summarizing the most important contents. In this way, it is also a doctor-centered communication technique.


Reflect the Patient’s Emotions


Reflecting emotions is very similar to paraphrasing. However, the reflection refers primarily to emotional contents. Sometimes, these emotions are addressed directly. Sometimes, the response to emotions is based on an observation of body reaction or refers to what is said between the lines.


Case Study

“Reflecting emotions”

Patient: I’m afraid it could be a malignant tumor.

Doctor: You are anxious and worried about what the examination will reveal.

Patient: My mother had a fatal accident 3 weeks ago. (Cries)

Doctor: You become very sad when you think of that event.

The doctor then waits to see whether the patient permits the doctor to pick up on his emotion. In the pause, he can collect his own feelings. Once the doctor has described the feeling, the patient has the possibility of talking further or changing the subject.

After an intensive emotional statement, it is especially important that the doctor pauses and does not immediately soothe or change the subject. For the patient, it is important that he does not feel dismissed but rather gains the doctor’s interest and sympathy. He experiences that emotions are acceptable.


Pitfalls






  • A common mistake is to give too much advice. In terms of partner relationships, advice is reasonable when it comes to medical expertise, but less appropriate the more psychosocial concerns are associated with the advice.



Doctor-centered interview


A doctor-centered interview includes many structuring techniques (Table 6.2). They help to focus and streamline the interview. Thus, they complement the already-discussed patient-centered interviewing techniques .




Table 6.2
Doctor-centered interview






















Taking over the doctor-centered interview

Transparency

Of contents

Of the environment

Of the interview phases

Doctor-centered question types

Interrupting

Metacommunicative comments


Transparency


The basic instrument for keeping within time limits is the transparency of the interview contents, the timeframe, and the transitions between various interview phases. The transition to a new interview phase should be clearly emphasized. Table 6.3 lists important techniques for providing transparency.




Table 6.3
Transparency

















Transparency of content

Provide information about the treatment steps that you have planned for this appointment

Provide the necessary technical information

Inform the patient why you do, what you do

Transparency of the environment

Point out potential trouble

Provide information about the timing of the interview

Transparency of the interview phases

Make it clear if you expect from your patient longer explanations or short answers

Indicate transitions between patient-centered and doctor-centered interview

Announce the conclusion of the interview well in advance


Questions in a Doctor-Centered Interview


Table 6.4 lists the question types that serve to structure a doctor-centered interview .




Table 6.4
Question types to structure a doctor-centered interview
























Closed-ended questions

Questions that can be answered with yes, no, or a short statement

Allow to query specific information

“Are you vaccinated against tetanus?”

Alternative questions

Already provide different answers

“Is the discharge green, brown, or yellowish?”

Knowledge questions

A doctor can provide more targeted information when he queries the knowledge of the patient in advance

“Have you yourself looked for information about how one can cure your pain?”

Opinion questions

Target value systems

Problems can be anticipated, priorities regarding the course may be set

“How do you feel about taking medication?”

Counter questions

In case of patient questions with unclear intention

More information before answer

Often particularly useful in case of aggressive, difficult patients

Leading questions

The interviewee is given a specific answer

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jun 17, 2017 | Posted by in PSYCHOLOGY | Comments Off on Doctor–Patient Communication

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access