Dual Diagnosis
Essential Concepts
“Dual diagnosis” patients, as discussed in this chapter, are patients with schizophrenia who also suffer from a drug or alcohol use disorder. Half of patients with schizophrenia have a current or past problem with drugs or alcohol.
Alcohol and cannabis use disorders are the most common comorbidities after nicotine.
Given the scope of the problem, screen all patients with schizophrenia for substance use, including for “low-grade” use that is nevertheless impairing.
Treatment is most successful if concurrent and integrated, that is, the patient receives treatment in one system.
“Bacchus hath drowned more men than Neptune.”
—Thomas Fuller, British physician and adage collector, 1654-1734
“Dual diagnosis” denotes the co-occurrence of a psychiatric condition, in our case schizophrenia, and a drug or alcohol use disorder. The term is neither precise (other dual diagnoses exist, for example, mental illness with developmental disorders) nor does it delineate a homogeneous class of patients (different mental disorders ranging from anxiety disorders to psychosis combined with any use to dependence), but the term has stuck. It came into being when, in the 1980s, a new cohort of “young adult chronic patients” who had never been institutionalized overwhelmed a treatment system that was ill-prepared to treat poorly compliant, drug-misusing patients with schizophrenia in the community, leading to the phenomenon of revolving-door psychiatric admissions.

Although the term “dual diagnosis” captures the problem of rather significant comorbidity, the term is not a diagnosis with specific interventions. Each of the disorders present in “dual” contributes to the outcome independently, and needs to be diagnosed and treated optimally and specifically in its own right.
In this chapter, I am discussing substance use in patients with diagnosed schizophrenia; the diagnostic difficulties that arise regarding drug-induced psychosis versus schizophrenia are dealt with in a separate chapter (Chapter 4). Smoking is so common and its consequences so devastating that I devote the whole next chapter to nicotine dependence. Caffeine, another common comorbidity, deserves a brief mention. In moderation, caffeine can be useful to counteract drug-induced sedation. However, excessive caffeine use can cause caffeine intoxication (“caffeinism”). Consider caffeinism in your restless patient with sleep problems.
SCOPE OF THE PROBLEM
Already in their first episode of schizophrenia, 30% of patients have a substance use disorder (the exact percentage will vary with region and definition of substance use) (Larsen et al., 2006). Substance-misusing first-episode patients are typically young men, and they often have better premorbid social, but poorer academic, adjustment compared to their nonabusing counterparts. In the Clinical Antipsychotic Trials of Intervention Effectiveness (CATIE) cohort, which is more representative of chronic patients, almost 4 in 10 patients had a current substance use problem (Swartz et al., 2006). Lifetime rates of any substance use problem are even higher.
