Complicated grief
Prolonged grief disorder
Persistent complex bereavement disorder
1. Yearning/longing for the deceased
✓
✓
✓
2. Intense feelings of sorrow/emotional pain
✓
3. Thoughts/images of deceased
✓
4. Being lost in thoughts/daydreaming about deceased
5. Thought/worry about how/why deceased died
✓
✓
6. Trouble accepting the death
✓
✓
✓
7. Feeling shocked/stunned since the death
✓
✓
✓
8. Emotional numbness since the death
✓
✓
✓
9. Difficulty to have positive memories about deceased
✓
10. Bitterness or anger about death
✓
✓
✓
11. Guilt/self-blame about death
✓
✓
12. Worry about not managing without deceased
✓
13. Avoidance of reminders
✓
✓
✓
14. Avoidance of getting rid of deceased’s possessions
✓
15. Intense emotional reactions to reminders
✓
16. Physical reactions to reminders
✓
17. Visiting cemetery/time with ashes to feel close to deceased
✓
18. Spending time with deceased belongings
✓
19. Experiencing pain or physical symptoms deceased had
✓
20. Hearing her/his voice, seeing him/her
✓
21. Wish to die to join deceased
✓
✓
22. Wish to die because life not worth living
✓
23. Difficulty trusting others without similar loss
✓
✓
✓
24. Difficulty feeling close to others
✓
✓
25. Loneliness, feeling all alone in world since death
✓
✓
26. Feeling envious of others who did not experience loss
✓
27. Feeling life empty without purpose, without deceased
✓
✓
✓
28. Difficulty experiencing joy/satisfaction without deceased
29. Concern/uncertainty about role in the world/identity
✓
30. Difficulty to pursue plans for future
✓
✓
31. Interference with ability to work/socialize/function
✓
✓
✓
Duration of symptoms
6 months
6 months
12 months (6 months in children)
In the validation study of the SCI-CG conducted among treatment-seeking grievers who lost a loved one at least 6 months prior, yearning and longing for the deceased was found to be the most frequently endorsed symptom (88% of the sample), which is in line with its inclusion in all proposed diagnostic criteria sets. However, interestingly, the second most frequently endorsed symptom was intense feelings sorrow and emotional pain (endorsed by 86.1% of the sample). In fact, early conceptualizations of grief had emphasized the central role of emotional pain [13], and consistent with this, a recent network analysis study identified it as the most central symptom of PCBD [14]. It was thus surprising that it was not included as a core symptom of CG nor PGD.
Since these two reactions are core elements of CG/PGD/PCBD, their persistence may contribute to obstructing the evolution from acute grief towards integrated grief. Specifically, yearning for the deceased and emotional pain can be reinforced through two feedback loops (see Fig. 5.1) [14]: (1) yearning for the deceased may trigger approach behaviors (e.g., spending time looking at pictures), that subsequently trigger thoughts related to the deceased, that in turn reinforce yearning; while (2) loss-related emotional pain (pain when thinking about the death of the loved one) may trigger avoidance behaviors, that in turn produce the opposite effect [15], increasing thoughts related to the deceased. Importantly, these two feedback loops could also reinforce each other, thus both contributing to maintaining the whole syndrome of CG/PGD/PCBD.
Figure 5.1
A Cognitive and Behavioral Model Explaining the Maintenance of Grief Reactions
Other Pathological Reactions to Bereavement
In addition to the bereavement-specific maladaptive set of reactions to loss that is CG/PGD/PCBD, other psychiatric disorders might develop or be precipitated in the aftermath of losing a loved one. Table 5.2 reports the common psychiatric disorders that can develop in the aftermath of the death of a loved one, and their main features.
Table 5.2
Common psychiatric disorders that can develop in the aftermath of the death of a loved one, and their main features
Main affects | Main preoccupations | Diagnostic timeframe | |
---|---|---|---|
CG/PGD/PCBD | Yearning, emotional pain | Deceased/death | ≥12 months (≥6 months for children) |
ASD | Fear | Life threat | ≥3 days and <1 month |
PTSD | Fear | Life threat | ≥1 month |
MDD | Sadness, anhedonia | Worthlessness/guilt | ≥2 weeks |
Acute Stress Disorder and Posttraumatic Stress Disorder
Acute Stress Disorder (ASD) and Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) both occur in response to exposure to a traumatic event. DSM-5 defines traumatic events as events involving direct exposure to a life-threatening event (i.e., being a direct victim of or witnessing the trauma), as well as learning that it occurred to someone close. Learning about the death of a loved one thus qualifies as a traumatic event, and ASD and PTSD can both unsurprisingly occur after bereavement.