Healthy Sleep Practices (Sleep Hygiene) in Children With ADHD

section epub:type=”chapter”>



Healthy Sleep Practices (Sleep Hygiene) in Children With ADHD



Penny Corkum1, Gabrielle Rigney2, Melissa Howlett3 and Shelly Weiss4,    1Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS, Canada,    2Central Queensland University, Adelaide, SA, Australia,    3Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS, Canada,    4University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada


Abstract


Sleep hygiene behaviors (or more appropriately termed “healthy sleep practices”) are commonly cited in health professionals’ recommendations for sleep difficulties among children, yet research evidence for such practices are lacking. This chapter defines and outlines healthy sleep practices, as well as differentiates between healthy sleep practices and specific behavioral sleep interventions in the treatment of sleep difficulties, specifically behavioral insomnia among children. The ABCs of SLEEPING mnemonic, a framework for many commonly made recommendations around healthy sleep practices, will be introduced and used to organize and highlight current evidence in each area among populations of typically developing children and children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), focusing on children ages 1–12 years of age. This chapter also includes a review of the literature examining the evidence of healthy sleep practices specifically among children with ADHD as compared to typically developing peers. The barriers to assessing, treating, and accessing evidence-based interventions targeting healthy sleep practices for children with behavioral insomnia will be discussed. Finally, a new tool, the ABCs of SLEEPING, will be described. This tool holds promise for bridging the gap in provision of evidence-based recommendations for healthy sleep practices interventions. After completing this chapter, the reader will be able to describe many healthy sleep practices recommendations commonly made by health professionals, as well as understand the evidence behind such recommendations for children with ADHD, and the treatment options currently available.


Keywords


Healthy sleep practices; sleep hygiene; behavioral insomnia; ADHD; treatment


5.1 Historical Overview and Terminology


Health professionals have historically provided recommendations regarding the behaviors and environmental factors that facilitate sleep (i.e., sleep hygiene). Recently, Gigli and Valente (2013) conducted a historical analysis of the term “sleep hygiene” and noted that this term dates back to 1864, when Italian Neurologist, Dr. Paolo Mantegazza (1831–1910), Professor of Hygiene at Pavia University, first referenced this concept in his book entitled Elementi de Igiene [Elements of Hygiene]. In this book, he espoused the importance of exercise, diet, as well as sleep schedules, timing, and duration, to optimize sleep. Gigli and Valente (2013) state that Mantegazza should be considered the “father of sleep hygiene.” Peter Hauri also deserves recognition for his contributions as he is frequently recognized as the person who coined the term sleep hygiene, although he himself did not like this term. Hauri (1939–2013) was a psychologist and a previous Director of the Mayo Sleep Disorders Clinic. During his career, he published two books (Hauri, 1977, 1991), which included strategies for helping people to manage their insomnia better without the use of medication. These sleep hygiene strategies included some of the same strategies put forth by Mantegazza, but within the context of modern sleep medicine. Hauri’s list of recommendations forms the basis for the current definition of sleep hygiene.


Today, inadequate sleep hygiene is classified as a subtype of chronic insomnia in the current International Classification of Sleep Disorders, third edition (ICSD-3; American Academy of Sleep Medicine, 2014), and is also discussed within the insomnia section of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, fifth edition (DSM-5; American Psychiatric Association, 2013). Inadequate sleep hygiene, as defined in the ICSD-3, relates to the following five categories: improper sleep scheduling, engaging in arousing activities close to bedtime, using sleep-disturbing products, using the bed for activities other than sleep, and maintaining an uncomfortable sleeping environment (American Academy of Sleep Medicine, 2014).


There is currently debate about the use of the term “sleep hygiene” amongst sleep clinicians and researchers. The term “hygiene” is a historical term which is associated with the social hygiene movement in late 19th and early 20th centuries. During this time, there was an attempt to control undesirable behaviors (e.g., prostitution and other vices) through scientific research methods. Many of the leaders of this movement were also proponents of eugenics. As such, the term “sleep hygiene,” which was popularized during this time, brings forth negative connotations for many and thus there is a desire to change this term. Many pediatric clinicians and researchers prefer the term “healthy sleep practices” rather than sleep hygiene. We will therefore use healthy sleep practices throughout this chapter and anticipate that others will also consider changing to this term both when communicating with patients/clients, families, as well as when educating other health professionals or the public about sleep practices.


5.2 What Are Healthy Sleep Practices?


While healthy sleep practices have a long history of being recommended for sleep difficulties, specifically insomnia, the scientific evidence for these practices is hard to ascertain. One reason for this is there are a number of definitional issues as to what strategies are included in this umbrella term and where the boundary exists with other intervention strategies. In fact, recommendations for healthy sleep practices and systematic behavioral interventions are often conflated (Smith & Corkum, 2016), resulting in behavioral interventions sometimes being considered within the group of strategies under the healthy sleep practices umbrella term. To better understand what is included in the term Healthy Sleep Practices, it is important to think about sleep intervention more broadly. It is generally agreed that sleep intervention should be implemented as a progression of steps from strategies that pose the least to most risk, starting with psychoeducation, then healthy sleep practices, then behavioral sleep interventions, and the last step being sedative/hypnotic medication (see Fig. 5.1). This stepped approach to treatment should be followed for typically developing children, as well as for children who have neurodevelopmental disorders (NDDs), such as attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD; Corkum, Davidson, Tan-MacNeill, & Weiss, 2014). Each of these steps will be elaborated upon below, so that the reader is able to differentiate between healthy sleep practices and the other steps of sleep intervention for insomnia.



5.2.1 Psychoeducation


The first step of this model is Psychoeducation, the provision of education to people to provide them with information needed to help address a problem. This is also the key component of prevention programs for pediatric insomnia (Morgenthaler et al., 2006; Taylor & Roane, 2010). Information is given to parents (and to youth when developmentally appropriate) about the biology of sleep, consequences of poor sleep, and what may put an individual at risk for developing or continuing to experience sleep problems (e.g., shift in circadian timing that happens during puberty). This information may help to correct misperceptions, such as that snoring indicates a really good deep sleep or that it is not normal to have arousals while sleeping. Providing education may also help to motivate parents or youth to engage in the sleep intervention (e.g., understanding why consistent bedtimes are important may help an adolescent commit to this aspect of sleep intervention). Psychoeducation by itself has been shown to be effective in treating insomnia in some children (Bruni et al., 2017; Morgenthaler et al., 2006), although the impact is thought to be limited. There is no evidence that psychoeducation alone is an effective intervention for the majority of children with ADHD or any other mental health disorder.


5.2.2 Healthy Sleep Practices


The second step of the model, which is the primary focus of this chapter, includes Healthy Sleep Practices. As noted above, this refers to a group of behaviors and environmental changes that promote factors associated with better sleep and reduce factors related to poor sleep. We recently organized healthy sleep practices into a mnemonic, the ABCs of SLEEPING (Bessey, Coulombe, & Corkum, 2013), which stands for: Age-appropriate; Bedtimes, wake times and naps, with Consistency; Schedules and routines; Location; no Electronics in the bedroom or before bed; Exercise and diet; Positivity and relaxation; Independence when falling asleep; Needs met during the day…all of the above equals Great sleep! Later in the chapter, this mnemonic will be elaborated upon to discuss what we know about ADHD and these healthy sleep habits (see Fig. 5.2 for a description of the ABCs of SLEEPING mnemonic).



5.2.3 Specific Behavioral Sleep Interventions


The third step of the model, Specific Behavioral Sleep Interventions, includes psychological strategies that have been used to address a range of psychological problems. These intervention strategies can be categorized into first-, second-, and third-wave therapies. Most commonly, sleep problems such as insomnia are addressed using behavioral strategies, a first-wave therapy, based on the theory of behaviorism which purports that psychological problems are best addressed by altering behavioral patterns (with limited attention given to thought processes). Strategies such as stimulus control, extinction-based techniques (e.g., unmodified extinction, graduated extinction, and camping out), bedtime fading, and scheduled awakenings are all examples of behavioral strategies and are discussed in Chapter 9. For older children/adolescents (and adults), cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), a second-wave therapy, is often employed. In fact, a specific version of CBT to address insomnia (CBT-I) has been developed, and has strong efficacy with adult populations (Okajima, Komada, & Inoue, 2011). CBT-I is based on both behaviorism as well as cognitive psychology, and purports that both maladaptive thoughts and behaviors need to be addressed to treat psychological problems. There is strong evidence for the effectiveness of both behavioral and CBT-I in treating insomnia for typically developing children as well as a growing body of evidence for youth with NDDs such as ADHD (see Chapter 11). Third-wave therapies, such as mindfulness, have only recently been applied to insomnia, but show promise as a treatment in adults with insomnia (Kanen, Nazir, Sedky, & Pradhan, 2015). Currently, there is no evidence for the efficacy of these strategies in pediatric insomnia.



5.2.4 Medication


The fourth and last step in the stepped approach to treating insomnia is Medication (see also Chapter 9). There are no prescription medications for the treatment of pediatric sleep problems that have been approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Moreover, there is very little research on the safety and effectiveness of medications used for insomnia (e.g., clonidine, trazadone, zopiclone, and benzodiazepines) for pediatric populations (Kratochvil & Owens, 2009). Therefore, pharmacological treatment should be reserved for use only after other strategies have been deemed ineffective and/or in special situations (e.g., during acute illness). Unfortunately, children with NDDs, including ADHD, are more likely to be prescribed these prescription medications prior to trying the other intervention strategies (Owens, Rosen, & Mindell, 2003), even though there is no evidence for their effectiveness and safety in children with NDDs (Bruni et al., 2017).


There are a number of over-the-counter (OTC) medications that have been used for the treatment of pediatric insomnia. Most of these OTC medications (e.g., antihistamines, tryptophan, vitamin D) have limited research evidence supporting their effectiveness in both typically developing children and children with NDD (Bruni et al., 2017). The one OTC hormonal supplement with some research evidence is melatonin, which is a synthetic form of the naturally occurring hormone. This supplement helps with adjusting our sleep–wake cycle (“chronobiotic”) and can also make one feel tired (“hypnotic”). There are a number of randomized controlled trials that have found this supplement to be effective in treating insomnia in children with NDDs more generally, and ADHD more specifically (Bruni et al., 2017; Cortese et al., 2013). For more information about using melatonin as a treatment for sleep problems in children with ADHD, please see Chapter 9.


5.3 Evidence for Healthy Sleep Practices


The above information highlights how healthy sleep practices fit into the treatment of insomnia, as well as how they differ from psychoeducation and specific behavioral sleep interventions. In this chapter, psychoeducation, psychological interventions, and pharmacological therapy will not be included in the definition of healthy sleep practices; rather, the focus will be limited to those strategies as described through the mnemonic ABCs of SLEEPING. In Fig. 5.2, each of the healthy sleep practices included in the ABCs of SLEEPING mnemonic are described. Our research team conducted a systematic review (Allen, Howlett, Coulombe, & Corkum, 2016) of studies examining evidence for each of the constructs described in the ABCs of SLEEPING mnemonic. Four databases (PubMed, PsycINFO, CINAHL, and EMBASE) were searched using key terms (e.g., children AND sleep, AND/OR insomnia, AND/OR bedtime) and 12,099 articles were identified. After removing duplicates (3822 articles were excluded) and reviewing for inclusions/exclusion based on preset criteria (e.g., ages 1–12 years, peer-reviewed, English, healthy typically developing children) at the title and abstract level (7976 were excluded) and at the full-text review level (218 were excluded), 77 studies remained for inclusion in this systematic review. Each of the constructs were examined for the empirical evidence that supports current recommendations and the level of empirical support was determined (i.e., Strong, Moderate, Limited, Equivocal, Insufficient, Nonsupportive). See Table 5.1 for definitions of each level of empirical support.



Table 5.1


























Level of empirical support
Level of evidence Definition
Strong >3 studies supporting recommendation (at least 1 well-designed trial) or well-designed systematic review in which the majority of findings support the recommendation, and none contradict the recommendation
Moderate >3 studies supporting recommendation (no trials) in which the majority of findings support the recommendation, and noncontradict the recommendation
Limited <3 studies in which none contradict the recommendation
Equivocal Study findings (regardless of the number of studies) are too mixed or contradicting to support the recommendation
Insufficient No studies directly address the recommendation
Nonsupportive Findings across studies (regardless of the number of studies) provide contradictory results or the results are inconsistent with the recommendation

Below, we present the evidence for each of these constructs as found in our systematic review with typically developing children (Allen et al., 2016), and then present what is known about ADHD for each of these constructs.



5.3.1 Age-Appropriate Bedtimes, Wake Times, and Naps With Consistency


Generally, it is recommended that children obtain age-appropriate sleep duration through appropriately set bedtimes, wake times and nap times, and that these sleep schedules are consistent across days including weekdays and weekends. The U.S. National Sleep Foundation recommends that toddlers (1–2 years of age) obtain 11–14 hours of sleep, preschoolers (3–5 years of age) obtain 10–13 hours of sleep, and school-aged children (6–13 years old) obtain 9–11 hours of sleep (Hirshkowitz et al., 2015). Generally, toddlers nap once or twice a day for approximately 2 hours total time. Approximately, half of preschoolers do not nap, and the ones that do nap typically have one nap per day for 1–2 hours. Very few school-aged children nap (Mindell, 2005). Furthermore, it has been recommended that children go to sleep before 9:00 p.m. and that there is no more than 30–60 minutes difference between bedtimes and wake times throughout the week. While these recommendations are thought to be among the most important recommendations, there is only a small body of research that evaluates the impact of these recommendations on sleep outcomes. Based on the systematic review by Allen et al. (2016), there was strong evidence for the importance of an age-appropriate sleep duration, moderate evidence for the timing of sleep (e.g., before 9:00 p.m. bedtimes and consistent schedules), and only limited support for the recommendation of no more than 30–60 minutes differences in bedtimes and wake times across the week.


For children with ADHD, there is mixed evidence regarding whether they obtain age-appropriate sleep duration. Some studies have found that they receive less sleep than their typically developing peers and less sleep than recommended, while other studies have found that they sleep longer than their peers and within the recommended amounts (Corkum & Coulombe, 2013). These mixed findings may in part be related to other factors such as comorbidities (e.g., whether the child has another disorder such as anxiety or depression, both of which have been associated with increased sleep difficulties) or treatment with stimulant medication (e.g., although there are mixed results, the most consistent finding is that stimulant medications delay sleep onset and as such shorten sleep duration). Children with ADHD have been reported to have an evening chronotype (otherwise known as being “night owls”) and consequently have later bedtimes than their typically developing peers (Durmuş, Arman, & Ayaz, 2017). This evening chronotype has been associated with increased sleep problems such as resistance to bedtime (Durmuş et al., 2017). Very little research has been conducted examining napping in children with ADHD, in part because this disorder is usually diagnosed in school-aged children at which age most children are no longer napping. However, one study found that children with ADHD (the Inattentive and Combined presentations) were more likely to have inadvertent naps than the typically developing group (Chiang et al., 2010). In fact, they found that inadvertent napping was one of the most highly correlated sleep problems associated with ADHD symptoms, particularly inattention symptoms. Some research has found that the regularity of sleep schedules for children with ADHD is less consistent than their typically developing peers. For example, Gruber, Sadeh, and Raviv (2000) found that relative to typically developing peers, children with ADHD demonstrated more instability across five consecutive nights of sleep in terms of sleep onset, sleep duration, and amount of true sleep. However, a study by Poirier and Corkum (2015) did not find differences in sleep stability across four nights between children with ADHD and a control group. While there are mixed findings about the duration, regularity, and consistency of sleep in children with ADHD, it does appear that these children may experience difficulties with these key healthy sleep practices, at least in some situations and for some children with ADHD.


5.3.2 Schedules and Routines


As noted above, age-appropriate and consistent sleep times are associated with better sleep outcomes. Not only are schedules important in terms of setting bedtimes, nap times, and wake times, but they also are important throughout the day. Schedules and routines are activities that are completed in a specific order during the day and night (e.g., bedtime routine, wake time routine, meal routine, homework routine). Schedules/routines provide structure, consistency, and stability, and if these schedules are consistent they can also provide cues to regulate a child’s arousal level. For example, breakfast is an important zeitgeber, or time cue, which sends a signal to the body’s biologic clock or circadian rhythm to “gear up for the day.” One of the key ways to help children fall asleep at predetermined scheduled times is by incorporating a bedtime routine. Bedtime routines should be relatively brief (30–60 minutes), help the child to relax (e.g., not include stimulating or frustrating activities), and should limit exposure to bright light. Nap time routines should be similar to bedtime routines, but shorter in duration. Morning routines should be energetic, fun, and the environment should include exposure to bright light. All routines should be consistently implemented across all days. The review by Allen et al. (2016) found strong support for establishing bedtime routines, but insufficient support for wake time routines and consistency in daytime routines. Insufficient support does not mean these are not important, but rather there was no evidence to judge their contribution to better sleep outcomes.


The core symptoms of ADHD (i.e., inattention, impulsivity, restlessness) makes the implementation of routines challenging for parents, and also makes following routines difficult for these children (Corcoran, Schildt, Hochbrueckner, & Abell, 2017). Therefore, ADHD parenting programs, which are considered one of the evidence-based interventions for ADHD, often focus on teaching parents to develop consistent routines to improve child behavior (Lee, Niew, Yang, Chen, & Lin, 2012). A study by Harris et al. (2014) found that in homes of children with ADHD, an increase in the daily routines (e.g., homework and household duties such as chores and cleaning up after oneself) was related to fewer externalizing and internalizing behavior challenges, even after adjusting for confounding variables such as the child’s age, sex, and parental adjustment. Similar to daily routines, sleep routines may also be problematic for children with ADHD. The authors’ early research found that child–parent interactions during bedtime routines were more challenging for the ADHD group than the typically developing group (Corkum, Tannock, Moldofsky, Hogg-Johnson, & Humphries, 2001). More recently, Noble, O’Laughlin, and Brubaker (2012) found that greater bedtime resistance was associated with a lack of bedtime routines in children with ADHD. They noted that this may result in increased child–parent conflict and poorer sleep overall; however, given the correlational nature of these data, causation cannot be inferred. Rather, it could also be that greater bedtime resistance may lead to lack of bedtime routines. While there is limited research on morning routines for children with ADHD, recent research has found that mornings are a source of stress for parents of children with ADHD, particularly for children who are treated with stimulant medication (Sallee, 2015). To our knowledge, there is no research examining napping routines in this population, given that the age of diagnosis is typically in the early school-age years at which time naps have ceased. While research indicates that routines may not be as commonly implemented with children with ADHD, it is not known whether the routines are qualitatively different for this population.



5.3.3 Location


Clinicians providing recommendations about healthy sleep practices often include changes to the sleep environment. Typical recommendations include sleeping in a dark, quiet, cool room on a comfortable bed, which is used exclusively for sleep. Based on Allen et al.’s (2016) review of the literature, these recommendations have limited empirical support and additional research needs to be conducted. The rationale behind the recommendation for a dark room is related to the fact that melatonin, a hormone that promotes sleep, is released in the dark (hence, it is often called the hormone of darkness). When given as a supplement, melatonin can both increase sleepiness (i.e., hypnotic effect), as well as regulate the circadian rhythm.


No research could be found specifically on the ideal sleep location characteristics for children with ADHD. However, there is some evidence that there may be subtle differences in melatonin profiles in children with ADHD compared to their typically developing peers (Nováková et al., 2011). This is more apparent in children with ADHD who also have sleep onset problems, who demonstrate delays in the release of melatonin (van der Heijden, Smits, Van Someren, & Gunning, 2005). Treatment with melatonin supplements for children with ADHD and delayed sleep onset has been shown to be effective in improving sleep onset and sleep duration but does not result in improvements in daytime behaviors (van der Heijden, Smits, Van Someren, Ridderinkhof, & Gunning, 2007).


5.3.4 No Electronics in the Bedroom or Before Bed


Not allowing electronics (including TVs, computers, videogame devices, and phones) in the bedroom and limiting their use for the hour before bedtime are commonly made recommendations by health professionals. There are two potential reasons for these recommendations. Electronics emit blue light which can potentially suppress the release of melatonin. Secondly, electronics can increase arousal levels, which is in contrast to the goal of using calming activities before bedtime. Allen et al. (2016) found strong support for removing all electronics from the bedroom, but there was insufficient support for recommending no use of electronics for 1 hour before bedtime (as there was no research on this topic included in the articles reviewed by Allen et al., 2016). The mechanism by which electronics use impacts sleep has not been determined, but multiple impacts are likely, such as taking up time that should be dedicated to sleep, increased physiological arousal, and exposure to bright light that may impact the timing of the sleep–wake cycle (Cain & Gradisar, 2010).



Children with ADHD are likely to spend more time watching television and engaging with other electronics and less time reading compared to their typically developing peers (Acevedo-Polakovich, Lorch, & Milich, 2007). There is also some evidence that they may be more likely to experience problems with electronics use, such as dependency (Bioulac, Arfi, & Bouvard, 2008) and that increased use is related to increased ADHD symptomatology (Nikkelen, Valkenburg, Huizinga, & Bushman, 2014). One study (which has not been replicated) found that access to electronics at bedtime was not associated with sleep problems in children with ADHD (van der Heijden, Stoffelsen, Popma, & Swaab, 2017). Despite these findings, the majority of the research literature suggests children with ADHD are likely to be adversely impacted by electronics use during bedtime routines, even more so than their typically developing peers.


5.3.5 Exercise and Diet


Daytime behaviors generally thought of as healthy behaviors can impact sleep in both positive and negative ways. For example, exercise can increase the duration of slow wave (restorative) sleep, but exercise too late in the day in some children can potentially cause sleep onset insomnia. A healthy diet and eating at correct times can improve sleep but eating too close to bedtime, trying to fall asleep when hungry, or consuming caffeinated foods/drinks, can all interfere with being able to fall asleep. While these recommendations make intuitive sense, again there is limited research on the impact of these factors on sleep (Allen et al., 2016). Interestingly, in the systematic review there was lack of support for the notion that exercising too close to bedtime can result in sleep problems (Allen et al., 2016).


Recent research has found that children with ADHD (especially as adolescents and adults) are more likely to be overweight and to engage in less physical activity than their peers (Kim et al., 2014), thus potentially setting the stage for poor sleep. Moreover, a recent study examined the relationship between diet and sleep in children with ADHD and found that children with more sleep problems also ate a diet higher in carbohydrates, fats, and sugars (Blunden, Milte, & Sinn, 2011). In Monastra’s (2008) chapter on ADHD, nutrition, and exercise, the research is clearly outlined that supports the impact diet and exercise can have on daytime functioning, while also recognizing that ADHD is not caused by these factors. Monastra stresses the importance of these as targets in treatment of ADHD. While no research is available about children with ADHD and caffeine consumption, there is evidence for increased consumption of coffee in adolescents with ADHD compared to their typically developing peers (Marmorstein, 2016).


5.3.6 Positivity and Relaxation


Falling asleep and sleeping restfully through the night requires a child to feel safe and relaxed. This requires that the home environment, throughout the day and particularly before bedtime, is a positive environment. Allen et al. (2016) found moderate support for this recommendation. Moreover, limited empirical evidence was found for the importance of parents to have a positive attitude toward sleep.


Compared to typically developing children, it has been shown that families of children with ADHD have higher rates of dysfunction (e.g., more conflict; Cunningham & Boyle, 2002), as well as increased daily struggles at home and school (Altepeter & Breen, 1992). Conflict and struggles are inherently negative and contradictory to a calm relaxed state. These conflicts and struggles are also more frequent in the evening than morning (e.g., Corkum, Andreou, Schachar, Tannock, & Cunningham, 2007), which would likely impact sleep in children with ADHD. Moreover, parents of children with ADHD have been found to hold beliefs that their children’s sleep problems are more intrinsic, less modifiable, and less responsive to treatment than parents of typically developing children (Goodday, Corkum, & Smith, 2014). These beliefs may make parents less likely to seek out and implement behavioral strategies to help improve their child’s sleep, although there is no empirical evidence that tests this assumption.


5.3.7 Independence When Falling Asleep


Allen et al.’s (2016) review of the literature found strong support for the association between independence in falling asleep and good sleep outcomes. Children who required a parent present to fall asleep or co-slept (in a reactive manner) were found to have more sleep problems, including later bedtimes, shorter sleep duration, and more night awakenings. Teaching children to fall asleep independently is a key component of many sleep interventions (Vriend et al., 2012).


There is no research available that specifically examines co-sleeping in children with ADHD. Perhaps, this is because at the time of diagnosis (which usually happens during early school years), co-sleeping is less common (less than 5% of typically developing, nonanxious school-aged children co-sleep on a regular basis; Palmer, Clementi, Meers, & Alfano, 2018). However, one study (Pressman & Imber, 2011) found an association with bed-sharing or lacking a consistent bedtime and what was labeled faux-ADHD (i.e., transient ADHD behaviors).


5.3.8 Needs Met During the Day


Having a child’s emotional and physiological needs met during the day have been considered to lay the foundation for good sleep at night. Previously, we discussed the importance of physical needs such as a healthy diet and exercise. Of interest, the first evidence-based 24-hour guidelines for time spent in physical activity, sedentary behavior (such as playing videogames and watching TV), and sleep were recently published in Canada (Tremblay et al., 2016), underscoring the importance of daytime behaviors for sleep. Having one’s emotional needs met is also important. Emotional well-being is often operationalized as having a secure attachment with one’s parents, not having internalizing symptoms such as anxiety, not feeling lonely, and having good self-esteem. Allen et al. (2016) found moderate support for the association of emotional well-being and good sleep.


Approximately two-thirds of children with ADHD have at least one comorbid disorder, with anxiety being a frequently occurring comorbidity (Reale et al., 2017). Anxiety has been found to be associated with increased sleep problems (Becker, Pfiffner, Stein, Burns, & McBurnett, 2016). A recent meta-analysis (Harpin, Mazzone, Raynaud, Kahle, & Hodgkins, 2016) found that over the long-term, children with ADHD, especially untreated ADHD, have lower self-esteem and poorer social outcomes (e.g., poorer peer relationships). While the research is limited on attachment in children with ADHD, a review of this literature found a relationship between insecure attachment and ADHD (Storebø, Rasmussen, & Simonsen, 2016). Attachment relationships are complex with bidirectional influences. Research is pointing to the role of emotional dysregulation, both in the child with ADHD and the parent (who may also have ADHD), as a mediator of insecure attachments. The above findings would indicate that some children with ADHD may not be having their emotional needs met during the day, which could negatively impact sleep.



5.3.9 All of the Above Equals Great Sleep!


As described above, there are many healthy sleep behaviors that lay the foundation for good sleep quality and quantity. While more research needs to be conducted to better understand which of these behaviors are most important to sleep, there is at least some evidence for many of these recommendations. As described above, children with ADHD seem to have challenges with many of the behaviors associated with healthy sleep practices. Therefore, one would expect that healthy sleep practices would be associated with poorer sleep in this population.


5.4 How ADHD Could Impact Healthy Sleep Practices


As noted above, children with ADHD may display poorer healthy sleep practices than their typically developing peers. There are many aspects of ADHD that could impact healthy sleep practices, including the child’s core ADHD symptoms, associated ADHD characteristics (e.g., social dysfunction), comorbidities, and treatment with stimulant medication (see Fig. 5.3). These factors could be conceptualized using Bronfenbrenner’s Ecological Systems Theory (Bronfenbrenner, 1989), in which the child’s qualities and treatment (i.e., core symptoms, associated characteristics, comorbidities, stimulant medication treatment) are embedded in the context of multiple interacting environmental factors, which gives rise to challenges and successes in development (in this case, sleep). The following sections explore how each factor might impact the child’s ability to develop and maintain healthy sleep practices.


Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jun 13, 2021 | Posted by in PSYCHOLOGY | Comments Off on Healthy Sleep Practices (Sleep Hygiene) in Children With ADHD

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access