Heart Rate Variability and Neurological Disorders

 

Control n = 20

De novo PD without OH n = 20

P value

BRSII (ms/mmHg)

3.6 ± 2.2

2.7 ± 1.9

ns

BRSIV (ms/mmHg)

6.1 ± 4.0

4.0 ± 3.6

ns

PhaseII_E (mmHg)

20.5 ± 16.8

21.2 ± 13.6

ns

PhaseII_L (mmHg)

14.9 ± 12.7

9.5 ± 8.6

ns

PhaseIV

22.7 ± 9.5

11.6 ± 9.5

0.001

PRT

2.1 ± 1.1

4.6 ± 4.4

0.008

RR-LF (ms2)

25.7 ± 21.8

12.7 ± 11.2

0.037

RR-HF (ms2)

20.7 ± 17.4

22.0 ± 19.8

ns

LF/HF

1.55 ± 1.17

0.61 ± 0.29

0.003

SBP-LF (mmHg2)

0.48 ± 0.35

0.30 ± 0.30

0.040


PD Parkinson’s disease, OH orthostatic hypotension, BRS II baroreceptor reflex sensitivity in phase II, BRS IV baroreceptor reflex sensitivity in phase IV, Phase II_E systolic blood pressure (SBP) decrease in early phase II, Phase II_L SBP increase in late phase II, Phase IV the overshoot of blood pressure in phase IV, PRT blood pressure recovery time (time interval from the end of phase III to the complete return of SBP to the baseline value), RR-LF low-frequency component of RR interval, RR-HF high-frequency component of RR interval, LF/HF ratio of LF to HF, SBP-LF low-frequency component of systolic blood pressure



Sorensen et al. [31] documented cardiovascular autonomic dysfunction during wakefulness and sleep in patients with idiopathic rapid eye movement (REM) sleep behavior disorder (iRBD) and PD in whom HRV was evaluated. They reported that patients with iRBD had attenuated sympathetic nervous system activity as compared with controls, and this finding was more pronounced in patients with PD. As mentioned above in Oka’s report [30], the cardiac parasympathetic nervous system may be relatively well preserved in patients with PD as well as iRBD, and sympathetic nervous dysfunction may progress in line with the postganglionic sympathetic nervous dysfunction seen in early PD.

Previous studies have reported that the autonomic dysfunction in PD is associated with disease characteristics such as progression and duration during wakefulness [32, 33]. Several studies have demonstrated a relation between autonomic dysfunction and PD severity by evaluating the circadian fluctuations of HRV in PD patients [34, 35]. Covassin et al. reported that PD severity was significantly related to nocturnal HRV indices, and such associations were restricted to REM [36]. HRV has also been used to assess therapy in PD. Liu et al. have examined whether subthalamic nucleus deep brain stimulation (STN-DBS) affects functions of the autonomic nervous system as assessed by spectral analysis of HRV. They reported that the power of LF and HF components was significantly activated in the stimulation “on” groups by STN-DBS [37].

An association between non-motor symptoms and cardiovascular dysfunction as evaluated by HRV was recently reported in PD. The relations of olfactory function (odor stick identification test Japan, OSIT-J) to cardiovascular function as evaluated by HRV assessed on the basis of the coefficient of variation of RR intervals, cardiac 123I-MIBG uptake of the heart, orthostatic hypotension, and other clinical variables were studied. The OSIT-J score was related to the cardiac 123I-MIBG uptake, the fall in orthostatic blood pressure, and HRV, after adjustment for other clinical variables (Fig. 11.1) [38]. Kang et al. also reported that olfactory dysfunction in PD positively correlated with reduced HF bands on spectral analysis of RR intervals and suggested that olfactory involvement is associated with parasympathetic dysautonomia in cardiovascular systems [39].

A332405_1_En_11_Fig1_HTML.gif


Fig. 11.1
Correlations between the OSIT-J score and HRV. A significant correlation between the OSIT-J score and HRV was found. HRV was assessed by the coefficient of variation for RR intervals. OSIT-J odor stick identification test Japan, HRV heart rate variability



11.2.2 Parkinson’s Disease-Related Disorders



11.2.2.1 Multiple System Atrophy


It is well known that signs of dysautonomia such as orthostatic hypotension, abnormalities in bladder and bowel control, and temperature dysregulation are distinctive features in multiple system atrophy (MSA) [40]. A 24-h analysis of HRV was effective for characterizing cardiac autonomic status in MSA. Moreover, HRV variables negatively correlated with disease duration and severity [10]. Our previous study demonstrated reduced low RR-LF and HF components on spectral analysis of RR intervals (Table 11.2) [41].


Table 11.2
Comparison of spectral analysis of RR intervals between control and MSA























 
Control (n = 40)

MSA (n = 10)

P value

RR-LF

280 ± 197

125 ± 99

0.015

RR-HF

213 ± 200

48 ± 37

0.001

Brisinda et al. [42] evaluated autonomic nervous system dysfunction in PD and MSA using the Cardiac Autonomic Nervous System Evaluation protocol (CANSEp), which consisted of Ewing’s protocol and the analysis of HRV (HRVa). Ewing’s protocol scores were higher in MSA than in PD and controls. HRVa revealed abnormal autonomic function in PD and MSA, as compared with controls. Markedly decreased LF and HF powers were found in PD and MSA, during both daily activity and sleep. In PD, depressed vagal tone was predominant during sleep, whereas in MSA, depressed sympathetic tone prevailed during daily activity.


11.2.3 Progressive Supranuclear Palsy


Autonomic dysfunction in progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP) remains controversial. Some studies found no significant autonomic dysfunction in PSP patients [4346], whereas others reported autonomic cardiovascular abnormalities in PSP patients [14, 4750]. Holmberg et al. [51] evaluated autonomic function in PD, PSP, and MSA by means of laboratory autonomic tests, which included analysis of HRV at rest and during deep respiration, as well as blood pressure changes during 75° head-up tilt. Decreased HRV and severe hypotensive responses were seen in MSA patients regardless of age and disease duration, whereas this combination of findings was seen only in PD patients who were very elderly and had a prolonged disease duration. In PSP, only a few patients showed decreased HRV, and hypotensive responses were limited (Fig. 11.2).

A332405_1_En_11_Fig2_HTML.gif


Fig. 11.2
Relative heart rate variability (HRV) during controlled deep breathing in the patient groups and healthy controls. Mean levels and S.E.M. are shown. HRV was significantly reduced in the multiple system atrophy (MSA) group (**P < 0.01), whereas no significant difference (not significant, n.s.) was found in the Parkinson’s disease (PD) or progressive suparanuclear palsy (PSP) groups as compared with the controls



11.3 Dementias


Resting HRV and heart rate changes to deep breathing (HRDB) and to standing (30:15 ratio), which indicate cardiac vagal denervation, are reduced in DLB. Cardiac vagal dysfunction is also found in dementia with PD (PDD) [52, 53]. Differences among dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB), PDD, and PD without dementia with respect to the involvement of the autonomic nervous system have been demonstrated in a study investigating cutaneous and cardiovascular autonomic functions in patients with Lewy body disease [53]. That study used the coefficient of variation of RR intervals (CVRR) to estimate cardiovascular function. Abnormally low values of CVRR were observed in half of the patients with DLB, as compared with 25 % of the patients with PDD and PD. The mean CVRR value was significantly lower in the patients with DLB (Fig. 11.3). It was also reported that sudomotor function may be severely affected in Lewy body disorders, while skin vasomotor function and the cardiovascular system may be more severely affected in DLB and PDD than in PD.

A332405_1_En_11_Fig3_HTML.gif


Fig. 11.3
Comparison of CV-RR according to the type of dementia. The mean CVRR value was significantly lower in the patients with DLB. CV-RR coefficient of variation of RR intervals

Allan et al. [52] used spectral analysis of HRV to assess cardiovascular autonomic function in patients with Alzheimer disease (AD), vascular dementia (VaD), DLB, and PDD. They reported that the severity of cardiovascular autonomic dysfunction differed significantly among these four types of dementia. These four groups of patients also showed significant differences in total spectral power as well as LF and HF components (Table 11.3). Mean RR interval, very LF component, and LF/HF ratio did not differ significantly among the four groups, while LF and HF components were lower in patients with PDD than in healthy controls. The LF and HF components were also reduced as compared with the AD patient group. The LF components in patients with DLB were significantly lower than those in the healthy controls. Allan et al. [52] also evaluated cardiac autonomic dysfunction using Ewing’s protocol to perform autonomic function tests in patients with dementia. Ewing’s protocol consisted of five tests, consisting of three predominantly parasympathetic tests and two predominantly sympathetic tests, to assess autonomic dysfunction at bedside [54]. The test results were used to classify autonomic dysfunction into five groups according to severity [55, 56]


Table 11.3
Spectral analysis of HRV in patients with AD, VaD, DLB, and PDD









































































Heart rate variability

Diagnosis (n)

Control (31/38)

AD (32/39)

VaD (27/30)

DLB (23/30)

PDD (38/40)
 

Total power (ms2)

1003 (575–1431)

820 (483–1158)

922 (332–1512)

617 (300–934)

628 (301–714)

AD vs DLB: 0.24 (0.18)

ANOVA: p = 0.04

0.49 (0.55)

0.27 (0.19)

0.08 (0.05)

0.003 (0.003)

AD vs PDD: 0.02 (0.02)

DLB vs PDD: 0.38 (0.42)

Low-frequency power (ms2)

2323 (169–477)

1324 (158–490)

389 (91.5–687)

261 (85.6–438)

171 (94.0–247)

AD vs DLB: 0.25 (0.13)

ANOVA: p = 0.04

0.41 (0.43)

0.32 (0.29)

0.059 (0.02)

0.007 (0.002)

AD vs PDD: 0.06 (0.03)

DLB vs PDD: 0.61 (0.47)

High-frequency power (ms2)

293 (81・3–504)

165 (99・1–232)

231 (54.4–407)

129 (46.5–212)

105 (44.0–166)

AD vs DLB: 0.13 (0.20)

ANOVA: p = 0.003

0.89 (0.83)

0.59 (0.39)

0.10 (0.23)

0.001 (0.01)

AD vs PDD: 0.001 (0.01)

DLB vs PDD: 0.17 (0.25)


LF and HF components were reduced in patients with PDD as compared with healthy controls. LF and HF components were also reduced as compared with the AD patient group. LF components in patients with DLB were significantly reduced as compared with controls

P values in the left-hand column give the result of the univariate ANOVA across all groups

Columns 3–6 show the mean (95 % confidence intervals for the mean) for each heart rate variability test by diagnosis, with p values for that patient group in comparison with the control group in univariate ANOVA and in multivariate analyses in brackets

The results of other predefined contrasts are given in the right hand column

All significant results are shown in bold typeface

AD Alzheimer disease, DLB dementia with Lewy bodies, PDD Parkinson’s disease dementia, VaD vascular dementia, HRV heart rate variability, LF low frequency, HF high frequency
.

According to Ewing’s protocol, PDD was consistently associated with impairment of both parasympathetic and sympathetic function as compared with controls and AD. DLB showed impairment of parasympathetic function. PDD showed significantly higher impairment than DLB in terms of the Valsalva ratio, considered an indicator of parasympathetic function. Patients with VaD showed impairment based on the Valsalva ratio. Autonomic dysfunction occurs in all common dementias but is especially prominent in PDD and has important treatment implications [52]. Several studies have also described partial impairment of the sympathovagal balance and abnormal postural heart modulation in AD [57, 58], while recent reports indicate that cardiovagal dysfunction in AD correlates with cognitive decline [59], although resting HRV can be normal [60].


11.4 Cerebrovascular Disease


Autonomic dysfunction is frequently seen in patients with ischemic stroke [61, 62]. Patients with ischemic stroke have depressed parasympathetic activity in the acute or chronic stages, while the impairment of sympathetic activity remains controversial [63]. Acute cerebrovascular diseases are thought to significantly decrease HRV as a result of cardiovascular autonomic dysregulation. Decreased HRV has been demonstrated in stroke by cardiovascular reflex tests [64], as well as by spectral analysis of HRV based on 24-h ECG recordings [65, 66]. The HF and LF spectral components of HRV seem to be persistently reduced in hemispheric lesions [67, 68]. It is also known that decreased HRV is an independent predictor of mortality in patients with acute ischemic stroke [69]. The underlying mechanisms of these findings in patients with ischemic stroke remain to be elucidated. Increased sympathetic activity has been reported in acute stroke in some studies [61], although Korpelainen et al. found no impairment of sympathetic activity in patients with acute ischemic stroke [63]. The increased blood pressure variability in patients with acute stroke has been attributed to impaired baroreceptor reflex sensitivity (BRS) associated with the central parasympathetic and sympathetic nervous systems [62, 69]. Impaired BRS has also been linked to increased long-term mortality after acute stroke.

Xiong et al. [70] have studied whether autonomic function is impaired during different phases in ischemic stroke, using Ewing’s protocol of autonomic function tests as well as spectral analysis of HRV. Stroke patients in both the acute and chronic phases had significantly lower LF than did controls. On autonomic function testing by Ewing’s protocol [5355], patients with acute ischemic stroke showed impairment in two parasympathetic tests (Valsalva ratio, heart rate response to deep breathing), while those in the chronic stage showed impairment in all parasympathetic tests as compared with controls. They concluded that autonomic dysfunction in ischemic stroke persisted in the chronic stage (up to 6 months) after stroke and that parasympathetic dysfunction rather than sympathetic dysfunction predominates after ischemic stroke. The mechanism underlying the autonomic impairment in patients with stroke remains unclear. A few studies have assessed cardiovascular autonomic function in subtypes of ischemic stroke [71, 72], but the results were conflicting. One study reported that there was no significant association between impaired autonomic function and subtypes of acute ischemic stroke [73], whereas another study demonstrated that patients with acute atherosclerotic infarction of large arteries had lower parasympathetic activity and higher sympathetic activity than those with acute lacunar infarction [71]. Xiong et al. [73] evaluated cardiovascular autonomic function in ischemic stroke patients with large-artery atherosclerosis (LAA) and patients with small-vessel occlusion (SCO) by performing autonomic function tests by Ewing’s protocol and spectral analysis of HRV. The results demonstrated that cardiovascular autonomic dysfunction was influenced by the subtype of ischemia and that patients with LAA had more severely impaired parasympathetic and sympathetic functions than those with SCO (Table 11.4).


Table 11.4
Comparisons of HRV among subtypes of stroke and control
































































Heart rate variability

Diagnosis

Controls

Patients with LAA

Patients with SVO

p*

Time domain

Resting R-R interval (ms)

856.3 (816.3–896.3)a

865.2 (830.8–899.7)a

812.9 (762.7–863.1)a

0.189

Breathing frequency (cpm)

13 [12–15]

14 [12–16]

14 [13–16]

0.899

Frequency domain

Very low-frequency power (ms2)

94.9 (52.8–204.5)

65.4 (30.4–176.2)

56.0 (17.1–231.3)

0.249

Low-frequency power (ms2)

141.7 (52.9–231.9)

54.8 (28.5–118.6)

57.8 (18.5–187.2)

0.019

High-frequency power (ms2)

85.4 (35.1–167.9)

50.6 (27.5–165.7)

30.4 (15.5–171.4)

0.429

Total power (ms2)

387.4 (175.6–532.2)

231.9 (95.5–526.8)

129.6 (42.4–636.8)

0.211

LF/HF

1.7 (0.8–2.9)

1.1 (0.4–2.0)

1.1 (0.4–2.4)

0.103


LF power was significantly reduced in the LAA and SVO patient groups as compared with the controls. There were no differences in mean RRI, respiratory frequencies, very LF power, HF power, or LF/HF ratio between the patients and controls

Data expressed as median (interquartile range) except for awhere mean (95 % CI)

LF low frequency, HF high frequency

*Represents P values for comparison across all groups

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Aug 25, 2017 | Posted by in NEUROLOGY | Comments Off on Heart Rate Variability and Neurological Disorders

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access