Methods for treating pain and painful syndromes in spinal cord injury: Medications, therapies, interventions, and neuromodulation





List of abbreviations


AB


able-bodied


CNS


central nervous system


DRGS


dorsal root ganglion stimulation


IL


interleukin


PAG


periaqueductal gray


PNS


peripheral nerve stimulation


PT


physical therapy


RVM


rostral ventromedial medulla


SNRI


serotonin-norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor


SCI


spinal cord injury


SCS


spinal cord stimulation


tDCS


transcranial direct current stimulation


TENS


transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation


Introduction


Pain frequently limits activities, decreases quality of life, and leads to significant psychological impairment independent of other functional deficits after SCI ( ; ; ). In general, SCI pain is not well understood from the cellular, molecular, and even spinal cord pathway levels ( ).


Sixty-five percent to eighty percent of individuals with SCI live with chronic pain, and nearly one third rate this pain as severe ( ; ; ). About half of all individuals with SCI suffer from pain so severe that it interferes with function and rehabilitation independent of deficits related to their SCI ( ). It is generally believed that level of injury does not have an influence on the degree of post-SCI chronic pain. Penetrating injuries may be more likely to result in chronic pain ( ), and there is some evidence that incomplete lesions lead to more chronic pain than complete lesions ( ; ).


Pain after SCI can generally be divided into nociceptive, visceral, at-level neuropathic, and below-level neuropathic ( ). It is theorized that SCI pain may be fairly unique and related to relative serotonin, norepinephrine, and dopamine deficits due to loss of supraspinal inhibition ( ; ; ). Additionally, there is a well-described inflammatory milieu that occurs after SCI and may contribute to an additional inflammatory basis of pain ( ). Furthermore, post-SCI changes are noted in synaptic dendrites in individuals who experience significant pain, suggesting a dynamic neuroplastic component to pain ( ). It is likely the unique combination central nervous system (CNS) changes after SCI creates a “pro-pain” state, and not surprisingly, SCI pain is often refractory to medical treatments ( ; ).


The treatment of SCI-related pain often comes down to using a multimodal approach with medications, physical interventions, treatment of underlying conditions like spasticity, treatment of acquired overuse syndromes, and potentially the use of neuromodulation interventions. The typical categories of SCI-related pain can be reviewed in Tables 1 and 2 .



Table 1

Classification of spinal cord injury-related pain.



















Classification Definition
Nociceptive somatic pain Pain from skin, subcutaneous tissues, bones, joints, connective tissue, muscle, and tendons. Often occurs from overuse, age-related breakdown, or acute injury
Nociceptive visceral pain Pain from organs and supporting structures. Often occurs with internal injury or infection
At-level neuropathic pain Pain within 2 levels of the segment of the spinal cord that is injured. Often central or peripheral (radicular) pain that has typical neuropathic qualities
Below-level neuropathic pain Pain below the level of the injured spinal cord segment related to disruption of the typical neural connections

Original table : These are the four generally agreed-upon classifications of pain as it related to the spinal cord-injured population.


Table 2

Characteristics of different pain types.




































Nociceptive pain Neuropathic pain
Somatic pain Visceral pain
Pain origin Skin, subcutaneous tissues, mucous membrane, joints, connective tissue, muscle, and bone Organs, organ capsule or covering, connecting and supporting structures Central or peripheral nerves
Location Localized Generalized or diffuse Radiating or specific
Quality Pinprick, stabbing, sharp, sore, aching Cramping, throbbing, squeezing, pressure, or sharp Burning, “pins and needles,” tingling, electrical, or lancinating
Mechanism of pain A-delta fiber activity
Located in the periphery
C Fiber activity
Involving deeper innervation
Nondermatomal (central), or dermatomal (periphery)
Clinical examples


  • Sickle cell crisis



  • Superficial burns and lacerations



  • Stomatitis



  • Intramuscular injections



  • Spasticity-mediated pain



  • Bone metastases




  • Colic spasm



  • Appendicitis



  • Kidney stone



  • Chronic pancreatitis



  • IBS



  • Angina



  • Menstrual cramps




  • Trigeminal neuralgia



  • Avulsion neuralgia



  • Posttraumatic neuralgia



  • Radiculopathy



  • Peripheral neuropathy



  • Phantom limb



  • Herpetic neuralgia


Original table : Differentiating pain generators is important in determining a treatment algorithm. These are the general characteristics of different types of pain.


Application to other areas of neuroscience


There is a growing emphasis on the connection between physical experiences and psychologic interpretation that goes beyond pain management. One particular area of interest has been the neural pathway between the amygdala, periaqueductal gray matter, and rostral ventromedial medulla (RVM). The amygdala stores emotional experiences. It is connected to the periaqueductal gray matter, which contains a high concentration of opioid, cannabinoid, and endorphin receptors ( ). The RVM is not involved in generating an initial pain response but does help regulate the maintenance of neuropathic pain ( ). The ventral posteromedial nucleus plays a major role in central sensitization, a condition of the nervous system that is associated with development and maintenance of chronic pain that is caused by increased excitability of cell membranes, synaptic efficiency, and reduced inhibition of nociceptive pathways ( ). The plasticity of neurons that undergo central sensitization has been the target of newer therapies, though significant mechanistic gaps in our understanding remain ( ).


These pathways significantly influence pain processing, decision-making, avoidant behavior, and personality expression ( ) and are thought to modulate opioid-induced analgesia ( ). Additionally, recent studies showed modulating this pathway impacts the extent of depression-associated pain in mice under chronic stress ( ). Physical activity, such as Tai Chi and cycling, has been shown to modulate this opioid pathway, thereby reducing overall pain levels and reducing levels of circulating inflammatory markers ( ). This concept is fundamental to the use of physical activity to combat pain in patients with depression.


Main narrative text


Physical therapy and exercise


In the AB population, the clinical treatment of pain generally progresses from noninterventional PT-based treatment to more aggressive interventional treatments such as injections and ultimately surgery if there continues to be minimal to no improvement and depending on the pain generator ( ; ). There are important similarities and differences in treating pain after SCI compared to the AB population. The most common subset of pain in the SCI population is neuropathic pain, either at or below the level of injury (E. ) and generally is not as responsive to PT ( ). However, many individuals have concomitant nociceptive pain ( ) that may be more receptive to traditional PT interventions.


Eighty percent of those with SCI pain found PT and exercise helpful to a large extent, second only to cannabis and alcohol in terms of treatment effect ( ). Other studies in the United States ( ) noted half of respondents who participated in PT reported “considerable” pain reduction and a study from Sweden ( ) noted very high satisfaction rates despite overall low levels of PT utilization. Telehealth PT using high-dose scapular stabilizing and rotator cuff strengthening program in SCI individuals with signs of impingement syndrome was effective in reducing shoulder pain by more than 50% after 24 weeks ( ).


Exercise has been used as an augmentative strategy for many chronic conditions including osteoarthritis, peripheral vascular disease, low back pain, and fibromyalgia ( ; ; ; ) and there is a linear relationship between frequency, duration, and intensity of exercise and chronic pain ( ). There are few high-quality studies assessing exercise and pain in the SCI population. noted significant improvement in pain scales and number of days per week with pain in nociceptive and neuropathic pain levels after training on a double-poling ergometer three times per week for 10 weeks at 70%–100% peak heart rate during intervals.


Recently, due to increased consensus on the benefits of exercise after SCI, an SCI exercise guideline was released ( ). The PAG, which has high concentrations of opioid and cannabinoid receptors sends projections to the RVM and both areas are activated by aerobic exercise ( ; ; ). Additionally, there is an antiinflammatory cascade involving downregulation of pro-inflammatory Interleukin (IL)-1B and Tumor necrosis factor-alpha and upregulation of antiinflammatory IL-6 and IL-10 ( ; ). Some of the potential improvement in pain as it relates to exercise may be a partial function of improved psychological well-being ( ).


Medications


Medications targeting neuropathic pain after SCI are the best studied. Pregabalin (Lyrica) and gabapentin (Neurontin) are antiepileptics and considered first-line medications in the treatment of neuropathic pain in patients with SCI injury ( ). In 2012, pregabalin (Lyrica) became the first and remains the only Federal Drug Administration approved medication for neuropathic pain in patients with SCI in the United States. Its approval was based on two double blind placebo controlled randomized trials ( ; ). In the study by , 70 patients showed improvement in pain and sleep when compared to the control arm of 67 patients. studied 220 patients and exhibited improvement in pain 1 week into treatment. published an updated systematic review from their 2010 publication ( ) and cited 13, level-1 randomized controlled trials supporting both the anticonvulsants pregabalin and gabapentin.


Antidepressants are also utilized in treating neuropathic pain in SCI. Like pregabalin (Lyrica) and gabapentin (Neurontin), the tricyclic antidepressants amitriptyline (Elavil), nortriptyline (Pamelor), imipramine (Tofranil), and desipramine (Norpramin) are first-line medications. These medications have only demonstrated efficacy in patients with concomitant depression ( ). More recently venlafaxine revealed similar effects to amitriptyline in subjects with pain and depression ( ). Other antidepressants, such as duloxetine, have not proven to be effective in patients with pain related to SCI ( ). Taken together, the serotonin-norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors (SNRIs) duloxetine (Cymbalta) and venlafaxine (Effexor) are considered second-line medications.


Despite common use in practice, opioids have inferior efficacy than previously mentioned medications. Tramadol, a synthetic opioid with SNRI properties, has some efficacy and is a third-line medication ( ; ). As a sole agent, tramadol should be employed before other opioids such as oxycodone. Oxycodone is considered a fourth-line medication and has only level 4 evidence supporting its use ( ; ).


The effects of cannabinoids are mediated via the CB 1 and CB 2 G-protein receptors, where CB 1 is widely expressed in the CNS ( ). Interestingly, CB 1 is upregulated following SCI ( ). The analgesic properties of cannabinoids are mediated through the PAG ( ; ). Indirect effects on opiate, serotonin, NMDA, and GABA receptors link endocannabinoids to other pain-related pathways ( ; ; ). A metaanalysis of five randomized control trials suggests that inhaled cannabis may provide short-term relief for about 20% of patients with neuropathic pain ( ). Future studies are needed to assess long-term effects of cannabinoids on neuropathic pain, specifically as it relates to SCI, as well as the optimal route of administration ( ). The mechanism of action for medications typically used for the treatment of SCI-related pain can be reviewed in Table 3 .



Table 3

Medication management of pain in spinal cord injury.
































































Class of medication Targeted category of pain Mechanism of action Monitoring
Anticonvulsant


  • Gabapentin



  • Pregabalin

Neuropathic GABA analog


  • Peripheral edema



  • Weight gain



  • Dose adjustment for renal impairment

Antidepressant, tricyclic


  • Amitriptyline



  • Nortriptyline

Neuropathic Inhibit reuptake of serotonin and/or norepinephrine at the presynaptic neuronal membrane pump


  • Behavior changes, suicidality



  • Anticholinergic effects (e.g., constipation, urinary retention)

Antidepressant, serotonin/norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor


  • Duloxetine



  • Venlafaxine

Neuropathic Inhibits neuronal serotonin and norepinephrine reuptake; weakly inhibits dopamine reuptake


  • Behavior changes, suicidality



  • Avoid use in those with hepatic impairment



  • Dose adjustment for renal impairment

Nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drug


  • Ibuprofen



  • Naproxen



  • Celecoxib*



  • Diclofenac



  • Indomethacin



  • Ketorolac



  • Meloxicam



  • Nabumetone

Nociceptive Inhibits cyclooxygenase-1 and 2 (COX-1 and 2) enzymes, resulting in decreased formation of prostaglandin precursors; decrease proinflammatory cytokine levels


  • Cardiovascular thrombotic events



  • Gastrointestinal bleeding, ulceration, and perforation



  • Avoid use in those with renal disease

Nonopioid analgesic


  • Acetaminophen



  • Paracetamol

Nociceptive Not fully known, analgesic effects likely due to activation of CNS descending serotonergic inhibitory pathways


  • Hepatotoxicity

Opioid


  • Buprenorphine



  • Codeine



  • Fentanyl



  • Hydrocodone



  • Hydromorphone



  • Methadone



  • Nalbuphine



  • Oxycodone



  • Tramadol

Nociceptive Binds to opiate receptors in the CNS, inhibiting ascending pain pathways


  • CNS depression



  • Respiratory depression



  • Hypotension



  • Constipation

Cannabis Nociceptive Activation of the endogenous endocannabinoid system through CB1 and CB2 receptors


  • Psychoactive properties



  • Dizziness



  • – Nausea, vomiting



  • Fatigue, drowsiness

Baclofen Spasticity GABA agonist at the GABA B receptor


  • Lowers seizure threshold



  • Consider dose adjustment for renal impairment



  • CNS depression



  • Urinary retention

Dantrolene Spasticity Inhibits the release of calcium from sarcoplasmic reticulum


  • Peripherally acting on skeletal muscle



  • Hepatotoxicity; monitor liver function closely

Alpha 2 adrenergic agonist


  • Clonidine



  • Tizanidine

Spasticity Increasing presynaptic inhibition; reduces facilitation of spinal motor neurons


  • Orthostatic hypotension



  • Drowsiness, dizziness



  • Bradycardia



  • Monitor liver function

Benzodiazepine


  • Diazepam

Spasticity Facilitates GABA effects on the GABA A receptor


  • Caution with concomitant use of opioids



  • CNS depression



  • Use with caution in those with renal and hepatic impairment and respiratory disease

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Nov 9, 2024 | Posted by in NEUROLOGY | Comments Off on Methods for treating pain and painful syndromes in spinal cord injury: Medications, therapies, interventions, and neuromodulation

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access