Mood Disorders and Suicide in Children and Adolescents
45.1 Depressive Disorders and Suicide in Children and Adolescents
Depressive disorders occur in children of all ages but are much more prevalent with increasing age. Children and adolescents with depressive disorders often display irritability, withdrawal from family and peers, and deterioration in academic investment, leading to devastating social isolation. The core features of major depressive disorder have striking similarities in children, adolescents, and adults, although developmental factors influence its clinical presentation.
Although suicidal thoughts and behaviors can occur in the context of a depressive disorder, most youth who contemplate, attempt, or complete suicide are not in the midst of a major depression. Most children and adolescents with depressive disorders do not exhibit suicidal behaviors. Thus, it is not clear that optimal treatments for depression mitigate the risks of suicidality among youth in general.
Mood disorders among children and adolescents have been increasingly recognized over the last three decades, and evidence suggests that combined treatment modalities, including medication and cognitive-behavioral strategies, may have the greatest efficacy. Although clinicians and parents have readily acknowledged transient sadness and despair among youth, it has become clear that the full criteria of persistent disorders of mood can occur even in prepubertal children. Two criteria for mood disorders in childhood and adolescence are a disturbance of mood, such as depression or elation, and irritability.
Although diagnostic criteria for mood disorders in the text revision of the fourth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV-TR) are almost identical across all age groups, the expression of disturbed mood varies in children according to their age. Young, depressed children commonly show symptoms that appear less often as they grow older, including mood-congruent auditory hallucinations, somatic complaints, withdrawn and sad appearance, and poor self-esteem. Symptoms that are more common among depressed youngsters in late adolescence than in young childhood are pervasive anhedonia, severe psychomotor retardation, delusions, and a sense of hopelessness. Symptoms that appear with the same frequency regardless of age and developmental status include suicidal ideation, depressed or irritable mood, insomnia, and diminished ability to concentrate.
EPIDEMIOLOGY
Depressive disorders increase in frequency with increasing age in the general population. Mood disorders among preschool-age children are extremely rare; the rate of major depressive disorder in preschoolers is estimated to be about 0.3 percent in the community and 0.9 percent in a clinic setting. Among prepubertal school-age children in the community, the point prevalence is approximately 1 percent. Depression in referred samples of school-age children is about the same in boys as in girls, with some surveys indicating a slightly increased rate among boys. Among adolescents, reported rates of major depression range from 1 to about 6 percent in community samples, and the rate of depression among adolescent females is double the rate in adolescent males. Estimates of cumulative prevalence of depression among older adolescents range between 14 and 25 percent. Reported rates of dysthymic disorder are generally lower than those of major depressive disorder, with rates of 5 of 100,000 in prepubertal children compared with 1 percent for major depressive disorder. School-age children with dysthymic disorder have a high likelihood of developing major depressive disorder at some point after 1 year of the dysthymic disorder. In adolescents, as in adults, dysthymic disorder is reported to occur in about 5 of 1,000 adolescents compared with about 5 percent for major depressive disorder.
Among hospitalized children and adolescents, the rates of major depressive disorder are much higher than in the general community; of these, as many as 20 percent of children and 40 percent of adolescents are depressed.
ETIOLOGY
Considerable evidence indicates that the mood disorders in childhood are the same fundamental diseases experienced by adults.
Molecular Genetic Studies
Two genes have been identified as incurring vulnerability for depressive disorder. The first one, the MAOA gene, is responsible for the functioning of monoamine oxidase, and the second is the serotonin transporter gene (5-HTT). The serotonin transporter gene, which is involved in the process of making serotonin available, is present in homozygous long alleles, a heterozygous one long and one short allele pair, and homozygous short alleles. A large longitudinal study in New Zealand found a relationship of early environmental stress and subsequent depression in children with one or two short alleles, but not in those children in the sample with
two long alleles. Because the short alleles are less efficient in transcription, this finding suggests that the availability of the transporter gene may provide a marker for vulnerability to depression. Thus, a stress-diathesis model for the emergence of depression may best fit with these data.
two long alleles. Because the short alleles are less efficient in transcription, this finding suggests that the availability of the transporter gene may provide a marker for vulnerability to depression. Thus, a stress-diathesis model for the emergence of depression may best fit with these data.
Familiality.
Mood disorders in children, adolescents, and adult patients tend to cluster in the same families. An increased incidence of mood disorders is generally found among children of parents with mood disorders and relatives of children with mood disorders; having one depressed parent probably doubles the risk for offspring. Having two depressed parents probably quadruples the risk of a child having a mood disorder before age 18 years compared with the risk for children with two unaffected parents. Some evidence indicates that the number of recurrences of parental depression increases the likelihood that the children will be affected, but this increase may be only partly related to the affective loading of the parent’s own family tree. Similarly, children with the largest number of severe episodes have shown much evidence of dense and deep familial aggregation for major depressive disorder.
Biological Factors.
Studies of prepubertal major depressive disorder and adolescent mood disorder have revealed a variety of biological abnormalities. For example, prepubertal children in an episode of depressive disorder secrete significantly more growth hormone during sleep than do normal children and those with nondepressed mental disorders. These children also secrete significantly less growth hormone in response to insulin-induced hypoglycemia than do nondepressed patients. Both abnormalities persist for at least 4 months of full, sustained clinical response, with the last month in a drug-free state. In contrast, the data conflict regarding cortisol hypersecretion during major depressive disorder; some workers report hypersecretion, and others report normal secretion.
Sleep studies are inconclusive in depressed children and adolescents. Polysomnography shows either no change or changes characteristic of adults with major depressive disorder: reduced rapid eye movement (REM) latency and an increased number of REM periods.
Magnetic Resonance Imaging.
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans in more than 100 psychiatrically hospitalized children with mood disturbances show a low frontal lobe volume and a high ventricular volume. These results are consistent with MRI findings in adults with major depression insofar as postmortem studies of depressed adults have demonstrated selective loss of frontal lobe cells and frontal lobe serotonin. Damage to the frontal lobes has also been associated with depressive symptoms in patients after stroke. The frontal lobes seem to have multiple connections with the basal ganglia and the limbic system and are also believed to be involved in the neuropathology of depressive symptomatology.
Endocrine Studies.
Thyroid hormone studies have found lower free total thyroxine (FT4) levels in depressed adolescents than in a matched control group. These values were associated with normal thyroid-stimulating hormone. This finding suggests that, although values of thyroid function remain in the normative range, FT4 levels have been shifted downward. These downward shifts in thyroid hormone possibly contribute to the clinical manifestations of depression. Some data suggest that the addition of exogenous thyroid hormone can potentiate the effects of antidepressant medication in adults with depression. Impairment in mood and cognitive function in adults with subclinical hypothyroidism has been found to be corrected with exogenous thyroid hormone.
Social Factors
The finding that identical twins do not have 100 percent concordance suggests a role for nongenetic factors in the emergence of major depressive disorder. Despite a lack of definitive evidence, given the stress-diathesis hypotheses of depression, genetic vulnerability in combination with a variety of social factors, including level of family conflict, abuse or neglect, conflict, family socioeconomic status, and parental separation or divorce, may play a significant role in the emergence of depressive disorders in children. Evidence indicates that boys whose fathers died before they were 13 years of age are at greater risk than controls to develop depression.
The psychosocial impairment that characterizes depressed children lingers far after recovery from the index episode of depression. These deficits can be compounded by the relatively long duration of at least 1 year for a dysthymic episode and an average of 9 months to 1 year for a depressive episode in a child or adolescent. For an adolescent, a major depressive episode significantly interferes with social and academic skills, which are poorly accomplished or unaccomplished during the episode. Among preschoolers with depressive clinical presentations, the role of environmental influences is likely to have a significant impact on the course and recovery of the young child.
DIAGNOSIS AND CLINICAL FEATURES
Major Depressive Disorder
Major depressive disorder in children is diagnosed most easily when it is acute and occurs in a child without previous psychiatric symptoms. Often, however, the onset is insidious, and the disorder occurs in a child who has had several years of difficulties with hyperactivity, separation anxiety disorder, or intermittent depressive symptoms.
According to the DSM-IV-TR diagnostic criteria for major depressive episode, at least five symptoms must be present for a period of 2 weeks, and there must be a change from previous functioning. Among the necessary symptoms is either a depressed or irritable mood or a loss of interest or pleasure. Other symptoms from which the other four diagnostic criteria are drawn include a child’s failure to make expected weight gains, daily insomnia or hypersomnia, psychomotor agitation or retardation, daily fatigue or loss of energy, feelings of worthlessness or inappropriate guilt, diminished ability to think or concentrate, and recurrent thoughts of death. These symptoms must produce social or academic impairment. To meet the diagnostic criteria for major depressive disorder, the symptoms cannot be the direct effects of a substance (e.g., alcohol) or a general medical condition. A diagnosis of major depressive disorder is not made within 2 months of the loss of a loved one, except when marked functional impairment, morbid preoccupation with worthlessness, suicidal ideation, psychotic symptoms, or psychomotor retardation is present.
A major depressive episode in a prepubertal child is likely to be manifest by somatic complaints, psychomotor agitation, and mood-congruent hallucinations. Anhedonia is also frequent, but anhedonia, as well as hopelessness, psychomotor retardation, and delusions, are more common in adolescent and adult major depressive episodes than in those of young children. Adults have more problems with sleep and appetite than depressed children and adolescents. In adolescence, negativistic or frankly antisocial behavior and the use of alcohol or illicit substances can occur and may justify the additional diagnoses of oppositional defiant disorder, conduct disorder, and substance abuse or dependence. Feelings of restlessness, grouchiness, aggression, sulkiness,
reluctance to cooperate in family ventures, withdrawal from social activities, and a desire to leave home are all common in adolescent depression. School difficulties are likely. Adolescents may be inattentive to personal appearance and show increased emotionality, with particular sensitivity to rejection in love relationships.
reluctance to cooperate in family ventures, withdrawal from social activities, and a desire to leave home are all common in adolescent depression. School difficulties are likely. Adolescents may be inattentive to personal appearance and show increased emotionality, with particular sensitivity to rejection in love relationships.
Children can be reliable reporters about their own behavior, emotions, relationships, and difficulties in psychosocial functions. They may, however, refer to their feelings by many names. Clinicians, therefore, must ask children about feeling sad, empty, low, down, blue, or very unhappy and about feeling like crying or about having a bad feeling that is present most of the time. Depressed children usually identify one or more of these terms as their persistent feeling. Clinicians should assess the duration and periodicity of the depressive mood to differentiate relatively universal, short-lived, and sometimes frequent periods of sadness, usually after a frustrating event, from a true, persistent depressive mood. The younger the child, the more imprecise his or her time estimates are likely to be.
Mood disorders tend to be chronic if they begin early. Childhood onset may be the most severe form of mood disorder and tends to appear in families with a high incidence of mood disorders and alcohol abuse. The children are likely to have such secondary complications as conduct disorder, alcohol and other substance abuse, and antisocial behavior. Functional impairment associated with a depressive disorder in childhood extends to practically all areas of a child’s psychosocial world; school performance and behavior, peer relationships, and family relationships all suffer. Only highly intelligent and academically oriented children with no more than a moderate depression can compensate for their difficulties in learning by substantially increasing their time and effort. Otherwise, school performance is invariably affected by a combination of difficulty concentrating, slowed thinking, lack of interest and motivation, fatigue, sleepiness, depressive ruminations, and preoccupations. Depression in a child may be misdiagnosed as a learning disorder. Learning problems secondary to depression, even when long-standing, are corrected rapidly after a child’s recovery from the depressive episode.
Children and adolescents with major depressive disorder may have hallucinations and delusions. Usually, these psychotic symptoms are thematically consistent with the depressed mood, occur with the depressive episode (usually at its worst), and do not include certain types of hallucinations (such as conversing voices and a commenting voice, which are specific to schizophrenia). Depressive hallucinations usually consist of a single voice speaking to the person from outside of his or her head, with derogatory or suicidal content. Depressive delusions center on themes of guilt, physical disease, death, nihilism, deserved punishment, personal inadequacy, and (sometimes) persecution. These delusions are rare in prepuberty, probably because of cognitive immaturity, but are present in about one half of psychotically depressed adolescents.
Adolescent onset of a mood disorder can be difficult to diagnose when first seen if the adolescent has attempted self-medication with alcohol or other illicit substances. In a recent study, 17 percent of young persons with a mood disorder first received medical attention because of substance abuse. Only after detoxification could the psychiatric symptoms be assessed properly and the mood disorder diagnosed correctly.
Dysthymic Disorder
Dysthymic disorder in children and adolescents consists in a depressed or irritable mood for most of the day, for more days than not, over a period of at least 1 year. DSM-IV-TR notes that in children and adolescents, irritable mood can replace the depressed mood criterion for adults and that the duration criterion is not 2 years but 1 year. According to the DSM-IV-TR diagnostic criteria, at least three of the following symptoms must accompany the depressed or irritable mood: poor self-esteem, pessimism or hopelessness, loss of interest, social withdrawal, chronic fatigue, feelings of guilt or brooding about the past, irritability or excessive anger, decreased activity or productivity, and poor concentration or memory. During the year of the disturbance, these symptoms do not resolve for more than 2 months at a time. In addition, the diagnostic criteria for dysthymic disorder specify that during the first year, no major depressive episode emerges. To meet the DSM-IV-TR diagnostic criteria for dysthymic disorder, a child must not have a history of a manic or hypomanic episode. Dysthymic disorder is also not diagnosed if the symptoms occur exclusively during a chronic psychotic disorder or if they are the direct effects of a substance or a general medical condition. DSM-IV-TR provides for specification of early onset (before 21 years of age) or late onset (after 21 years of age).
A child or adolescent with dysthymic disorder may have had a major depressive episode before developing a dysthymic disorder, but it is much more common for a child with dysthymic disorder for more than 1 year to have major depressive episode. In this case, both depressive diagnoses are given (double depression). Dysthymic disorder in children is known to have an average age of onset that is several years earlier than the age of onset of major depressive disorder. Controversy exists among clinicians and researchers about whether dysthymic disorder is best categorized as a chronic, insidious version of major depressive disorder or represents a separate disorder. Occasionally, young persons fulfill the criteria for dysthymic disorder, except that their episodes last only 2 weeks to several months, with symptom-free intervals lasting for 2 to 3 months. These minor mood presentations in children are likely to indicate severe mood disorder episodes in the future. Knowledge suggests that the longer, the more recurrent, the more frequent, and perhaps the less related to social stress these episodes are, the greater is the likelihood of a severe mood disorder in the future. When minor depressive episodes follow a significant stressful life event by less than 3 months, it is often part of an adjustment disorder.

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

