DYSTONIA
Dystonia is a syndrome characterized by sustained muscle contractions that produce twisting and repetitive movements or abnormal postures (
37). The movements seen in
dystonia tend to be
directional. This stands in contrast to
chorea, which can also appear as writhing and twisting but tends to be more random and dancelike. The twisting or torsional nature of the contractions may force the body into abnormal positions that may be intermittent or sustained. These positions are consistent and reproducible on examination.
Dystonia is usually worse with action, and sometimes may be present only with particular actions, such as equinovarus posturing of the foot when walking forward but not backward, or abduction of the arm when writing. This very characteristic action specificity of
dystonia sometimes tempts clinicians to misdiagnose these movements as psychogenic.
When
dystonia results in
tremor (
dystonic tremor), a so-called
null point may be identified on examination. The affected limb or neck shows little or no
tremor in this position. In contrast, spasticity and
rigidity do not vary depending on the action. Also, many children and young adults discover one or more “sensory tricks” (
geste antagoniste) that help control their
dystonia, such as lightly touching one’s chin with a finger to straighten the neck when cervical
dystonia is present. Even thinking of doing the sensory trick is often enough to improve the
dystonia, highlighting the higher-order processing involved in modulating this movement disorder (
38). The pathophysiology of
dystonia is complex and involves abnormalities of both globus pallidal firing and intracortical inhibition (
39,
40).
Although the term
dystonia was initially coined to describe a particular form of childhood onset, primary torsion
dystonia (
dystonia musculorum deformans, or Oppenheim disease) (
41), physicians should consider
dystonia a sign rather than a single disease entity.
Dystonia can be classified by age at onset, anatomical distribution, and etiology. A strong relation exists between age at onset and distribution, with onset before age 23 years being more associated with lower-limb
dystonia that often spreads to involve the trunk and arms. Adult-onset
dystonia typically starts in the neck, face, or vocal cords and remains localized (
4,
42). Etiologically,
dystonia can be classified as primary or secondary (
43), as shown in
Table 3.1. The
primary dystonias encompass all dystonias for which no degenerative brain pathology can be identified. They are also characterized by the following (
43): (a)
dystonia as the sole abnormality (except
tremor), (b) absence of laboratory or imaging data to suggest acquired or degenerative cause, (c) absence of a response to levodopa, and (d) absence of known history implicating an environmental, structural, or pharmacological cause such as neuroleptic exposure or stroke.
The archetypal genetic form of
primary dystonia in children, DYT-1, is inherited as an autosomal dominant trait with incomplete penetrance. With only approximately 30% of gene carriers ever developing symptoms, the etiology of the incomplete penetrance is unclear, but it likely involves environmental or genetic modifiers (
44). Onset is in childhood, usually in the leg or arm initially. It may generalize to involve both legs and trunk, remain in one arm, or become bibrachial. Although it may present in adulthood, DYT-1 usually does not appear in individuals older than 24 years (
45). DYT-1
dystonia is due to a three-base
pair (GAG) deletion in the gene coding for the
torsin A protein (
46). No structural abnormalities are visible on MRI, although abnormal
basal ganglia metabolism is noted on functional imaging such as fluorodeoxyglucose-positron emission tomography (FDG-PET) (
47). Early recurrent major depression has been found to be associated with the GAG deletion in DYT-1, independent of the presence of physical disability, suggesting that the depression may itself be an expression of the abnormal gene (
48).
Secondary dystonias include genetic disorders in which
dystonia is one of several manifestations of the disease and those due to environmental or acquired causes.
Dystonia related to metabolic disorders, heredodegenerative diseases, mitochondrial disorders, and toxic environmental exposures often show abnormalities of the
basal ganglia on
neuroimaging. However, some patients with
secondary dystonias have normal findings on
neuroimaging. In this category with normal imaging are several rare disorders termed “
dystonia-plus” syndromes, which are caused by genetic defects that result in
dystonia in association with another movement disorder. These include dopa-responsive
dystonia (DRD), myoclonus-
dystonia (MD), and rapid-onset
dystonia parkinsonism (RDP). All three of these rare genetic disorders have psychiatric manifestations and comorbidities that are only just beginning to be described, deepening questions about the role of the
basal ganglia in mood disorders (
49,
50). Higher rates of depression and obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) have been identified both in patients with these syndromes and in nonmanifesting mutation carriers, compared with the general public.
Dopa-responsive
dystonia classically has its onset in childhood, although relatives may have adult-onset
parkinsonism. Onset is usually characterized by bilateral leg
dystonia, often with toe walking and spasticity. It is often associated with a diurnal variation (i.e., symptoms are better in the morning than in the evening) (
51). This variability has
sometimes led to the incorrect diagnosis of psychogenicity, although it should be noted that during any examination point, the signs will be consistently reproduced.
Parkinsonism and postural instability may also be present in children, and the disorder may be confused with
cerebral palsy (
52,
53).
A dominantly inherited deficiency in the guanosine triphosphate (GTP) cyclohydrolase enzyme (GCH-1) is usually the cause of DRD (
51). GCH-1 is involved in the synthetic pathway for tetrahydrobiopterin (BH
4). BH
4 is a cofactor for tyrosine hydroxylase, the ratelimiting step in the synthesis of dopamine. BH
4 is also a coenzyme in the synthesis of tyrosine and serotonin. Cerebrospinal fluid measurements reflect low biopterin and low dopamine metabolites. Mutation sequencing does not identify all individuals with DRD (
54). The diagnosis can be most reliably made by the dramatic and sustained reversal of symptoms with low-dose levodopa (
55). Carriers of this enzyme defect have been found to have higher rates of major depressive disorder and OCD than the general population (
49).
Myoclonus-
dystonia, which is a distinct genetic disorder associated with mutations of the epsilon sarcoglycan gene (
56) (
DYT11), usually presents in childhood or adolescence with proximal myoclonic jerking and
dystonia. Although these are usually seen together, some individuals may demonstrate only myoclonus, and others, only isolated
dystonia. Symptoms are responsive to alcohol, and the higher rate of alcohol dependence is thought to be secondary to self-palliation. M-D is also associated with obsessive-compulsive disorder (
49).
The treatment of
dystonia in childhood depends in part on etiology. Atypical features on examination or history—drug exposures,
dystonia at rest rather than action, hemidystonia, early speech abnormalities, cranial
dystonia in a child, abnormal neurological examination, or any imaging or laboratory abnormalities—suggest a secondary rather than a
primary dystonia. If physicians identify a secondary cause, the underlying disorder is the primary therapeutic target if a treatment is available. In particular, a levodopa trial should be instituted in every child with
dystonia who has normal brain imaging to rule out that the
dystonia is DRD. When
dystonia is primary, or when the underlying disorder is untreatable, symptomatic treatment of
dystonia includes anticholinergic medications, benzodiazepines, and muscle relaxants. The anticholinergic medication trihexyphenidyl may be used alone (
57) or in combination with baclofen or clonazepam or both to treat primary generalized
dystonia. Although it may be associated with memory impairment in adults, trihexyphenidyl may be tolerated in children in doses exceeding 40 mg daily. The peripheral anticholinergic side effects of trihexyphenidyl, such as dry eyes, constipation, and stomach pain, can be countered with low doses of pyridostigmine, an acetylcholinesterase inhibitor. Anticonvulsants such as topiramate and levetiracetam have also shown some benefit as adjunctive therapies (
58,
59). Botulinum toxin may be used for prominent limb
dystonia (
60).
Deep-brain stimulation (DBS) involves the implantation of electrodes into subcortical structures in the brain, through which continuous electrical stimulation may be applied to the targeted brain structure. This therapy has shown promise in the alleviation of such diverse neurological problems as
dystonia,
tremor, and cluster headache. DBS targeting the subthalamic nucleus has been Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved since 1996 for the treatment of adults with idiopathic Parkinson disease. However, it was not until 2005 that the efficacy of stimulating the globus pallidus internal segment was clearly established in children with DYT-1
primary dystonia (
61). In this controlled trial, patients with
primary dystonia ranging in age from 14 to 54 years old experienced a 30% to 50% improvement in their
dystonia symptoms. Risk of a significant intra- or perioperative event such as stroke, hemorrhage, and death may be 1% to 2%, depending on the implanting center. Therefore DBS is still reserved for medically refractory cases of generalized
dystonia. Reports also are emerging of the efficacy of DBS
in some forms of symptomatic
dystonia in children, such as
dystonia related to pantothenate kinase-associated neurodegeneration (
62).