Abstract
Seizures represent the most distinctive and frequent manifestations of neurological disease in the neonatal period. Compared with seizures in older patients, neonatal seizures have different clinical appearances, electrographic characteristics, etiologies, and management approaches. Because most neonatal seizures are acute symptomatic seizures occurring because of a brain insult or brain dysfunction, neonatal seizures indicate the presence of underlying disorders that may require specific therapy. Problematically, neonatal seizure diagnosis is difficult because the clinical manifestations of seizures may be subtle and difficult to reliably identify. Furthermore, most neonatal seizures are EEG-only (subclinical, nonconvulsive) and have no clinically evident manifestations. Thus, EEG monitoring plays an increasingly important role in neonatal seizure identification and management. Treatment of neonatal seizures is generally considered necessary because experimental and human evidence suggest seizures may lead to secondary brain injury and are associated with less favorable outcomes. However, antiseizure medications may have associated risks, and there are few data to guide evidence-based management. This chapter reviews the pathophysiology and clinical aspects of neonatal seizures with emphasis on the influence of the developmental characteristics of the perinatal brain; viewed in this context, the manifestations, causes, and effects of neonatal seizures become more understandable.
Keywords
neonate, seizure, status epilepticus, electroencephalogram, antiseizure medications
Seizures in the newborn infant represent the most distinctive frequent manifestations of neurological disease in the neonatal period. The incidence of seizures varies with gestational age and birthweight and is most common in the very low birthweight (VLBW) infant. Estimated incidences are 58/100 live births in the VLBW infant and 1 to 3.5/100 live births in the term infant. Compared to seizures at later developmental stages, seizures in the newborn differ in their clinical appearances, electrographic characteristics, etiologies, management, and outcomes. Because most seizures during the newborn period are acute symptomatic seizures due to cerebral injury or dysfunction, they are an important manifestation to alert the clinician to underlying neurological disorders. However, recognition of seizures in the newborn period can be very difficult because of subtle or absent clinical manifestations. To assist in both the accurate identification of seizures in the newborn and the successful treatment with antiepileptic drug therapy, electrophysiological monitoring—either conventional or limited channel monitoring—now plays a critical role within the neonatal intensive care unit. Treatment of neonatal seizures is generally considered necessary because experimental and human evidence suggests seizures may lead to secondary brain injury and are associated with less favorable outcomes. However, antiseizure medications may have associated risks, and there are few data to guide evidence-based management. This chapter reviews the pathophysiology and clinical aspects of neonatal seizures with particular emphasis on the influence of the developmental characteristics of the immature brain.
Pathophysiology
Mechanisms
A seizure results from an excessive synchronous electrical discharge (i.e., depolarization) of neurons within the central nervous system (CNS). Neuronal depolarization is produced by the influx of sodium (Na + ), and repolarization is produced by the efflux of potassium (K + ). Maintenance of the potential across the membrane requires an energy (adenosine triphosphate [ATP])-dependent pump, which extrudes sodium and takes in potassium.
Although the fundamental mechanisms of neonatal seizures are not entirely understood, current data suggest that excessive depolarization may occur because of the imbalance of neural excitation over inhibition for the following reasons ( Table 12.1 ). First, one cause of excessive depolarization may relate to a failure of the ATP-dependent sodium-potassium pump thereby disabling the cell from maintaining a stable membrane potential. Hypoxemia-ischemia and hypoglycemia, key common processes for neuronal injury in the newborn, can lead to such decreases in cellular energy production. Second, an excess of excitatory neurotransmitters can result in excessive depolarization. This imbalance of excess excitatory neurotransmitters, particularly in relation to the principal excitatory neurotransmitter glutamate, may result from increased synaptic release and/or diminished reuptake in presynaptic nerve endings and glia. Cellular injury, from hypoxic-ischemic neuronal injury, can result in the release of excessive extracellular glutamate. Third, a relative deficiency of inhibitory versus excitatory neurotransmitters exists normally in the immature brain and may lead to an excessive rate of depolarization (see later). Developmentally, this enhanced excitation is important for activity-dependent synaptogenesis. However, in the setting of brain injury, this normal enhancement of excitation can be accentuated and lead to excessive depolarization. The brain concentration of gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA), the major inhibitory neurotransmitter, is lower in the newborn brain than in adulthood. Moreover, these GABA receptors in early life have been shown to be paradoxically excitatory and depolarizing because of a reversal of the chloride gradient in immature neurons compared to the adult. This age-specific difference in neurotransmitter receptor function may contribute to the refractoriness of neonatal seizures to conventional antiepileptic drugs mediated via GABA. Fourth, metabolic disturbances occurring in the newborn, such as pyridoxine deficiency, can also lead to seizures. Glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD), the synthetic enzyme for GABA, requires binding of the critical cofactor of the enzyme, pyridoxine, specifically the active form, pyridoxal-5-phosphate. A state of pyridoxine dependency, in fact, is accompanied by decreased brain and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) levels of pyridoxal-5-phosphate and GABA. The molecular abnormality in this disease involves a defect in lysine degradation leading to an intermediate that forms an adduct with pyridoxal-5 phosphate, thereby preventing its action (see later). Finally, other molecules can influence the membrane’s sensitivity to depolarizations such as calcium and magnesium that interact with the neuronal membrane to inhibit Na + movement. Thus, hypocalcemia or hypomagnesemia increase the Na + influx, resulting in depolarization.
PROBABLE MECHANISM | DISORDER |
---|---|
Failure of ATP-dependent sodium-potassium pump secondary to decreased adenosine triphosphate | Hypoxemia, ischemia, and hypoglycemia |
Excess of excitatory neurotransmitter (i.e., glutamate) | Hypoxemia, ischemia, and hypoglycemia |
Deficit of inhibitory neurotransmitter (i.e., GABA) | Pyridoxine dependency |
Membrane alteration: increased sodium permeability | Hypocalcemia and hypomagnesemia |
Neuroanatomical and Neurophysiological Substrates
Seizure phenomena in newborns differ considerably from those observed in older humans, and the phenomena in premature infants differ from those in full-term newborns. In the vast majority of neonatal seizures, electrical onset is focal or multifocal with the spread of the seizure occurring within one hemisphere and secondary generalization to the contralateral hemisphere only rarely. Thus, newborns rarely have well-organized, generalized tonic-clonic seizures, and premature infants have even less well-organized seizures than do term infants. The precise reasons for these differences relate to the status of neuroanatomical and neurophysiological development in the perinatal period.
Neuroanatomical Features
The most critical neuroanatomical developmental processes of relevance to the manifestation of seizure activity in the newborn period are the organizational events (see Chapter 7 ) ( Table 12.2 ). The relevant events include the attainment of proper cellular orientation, alignment, and layering (i.e., lamination of cortical neurons); the elaboration of axonal and dendritic ramifications; and the establishment of synaptic connections. Only the first of these processes (lamination) is fully developed by the term equivalent in the human newborn. The latter two events (neurite outgrowth and synaptogenesis) required to provide the cortical connectivity to propagate and sustain a generalized seizure is rudimentary in the term newborn infant. In contrast, in the newborn monkey, the spread of seizure discharges is relatively rapid, and well-organized, synchronous, generalized seizures are readily apparent clinically and electroencephalographically. Such propagation of seizures appears related to the more advanced cortical organization and myelination of cortical efferent systems and interhemispheric commissures present in the newborn monkey. The relatively advanced cortical development apparent in limbic structures in the human newborn infant and the connections of these structures to the diencephalon and brain stem may underlie the frequency and dominance of oral-buccal-lingual movements (e.g., sucking, chewing, or drooling), oculomotor movements, and apnea as clinical manifestations of neonatal seizures.
Anatomical |
|
|
|
Physiological |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Neurophysiological Features
The relation of excitatory to inhibitory synapses is important in determining the capacity of a focal discharge to both form and then to spread to contiguous and distant brain regions. Strong evidence indicates that the rates of development of the excitatory and inhibitory synaptic activities differ in the newborn cerebral cortex (see Table 12.2 ). Excitatory activity is mediated by glutamate through two key receptor types, N -methyl- d -aspartate (NMDA) and α-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazolepropionic acid (AMPA). These two excitatory receptors are the predominant neurotransmitter receptors found in the immature brain, with a relative paucity of the principal inhibitory receptors for GABA. Indeed, the neonatal period is characterized by levels of excitatory neurotransmitter expression and function that exceed those observed in adult cortical neurons, while inhibition is not yet at adult levels ( Fig. 12.1 ). Moreover, properties of these two glutamate receptors enhance their excitatory function. NMDA receptors in the neonatal period exhibit prolonged duration of the NMDA-mediated excitatory postsynaptic potential, reduced ability of magnesium to block NMDA receptor activity, diminished inhibitory polyamine binding sites, and a greater sensitivity to glycine enhancement. Similarly, AMPA receptors in the neonatal period are deficient in the GluR2 subunit responsible for rendering the AMPA channel impermeable to calcium. Thus, these immature AMPA receptors are permeable to calcium and, as a consequence, enhanced excitation. In addition, early in development, the principal inhibitory neurotransmitter, GABA, acts at the major postsynaptic GABA A receptor (GABA A ) to produce excitation rather than inhibition, as occurs later in development. Consistent with these developmental phenomena, it is easier to produce epileptic activity in the immature animal than in the adult ( Fig. 12.2 ).
Insights into the critical developmental relationship between neuronal chloride (Cl − ) levels and Cl − transport in the perinatal period have major implications for understanding the basis of GABA excitation, and thus key clinical and therapeutic aspects of neonatal seizures ( Table 12.3 ). GABA activation of the major postsynaptic GABA A receptor causes Cl − flux. In the mature neuron, there is Cl − influx down an electrochemical gradient. However, in developing brain, at maturational stages comparable to the human perinatal period, GABA activation causes Cl − efflux, and GABA activation is therefore excitatory. The basis for this paradoxical effect relates to a developmental mismatch between the two Cl − transporters that determine neuronal Cl − levels . Thus, in the perinatal period, in the human cerebral cortex the expression of the Na + -K + -Cl − cotransporter (NKCC1) responsible for Cl − influx reaches a developmental peak, whereas the expression of the K + -Cl − cotransporter (KCC2) responsible for Cl − efflux is relatively low (see Fig. 12.1 ). The result is a high internal neuronal level of Cl − , so when the GABA A receptor is activated there is efflux (rather than influx) of Cl − , resulting in depolarization and excitation. The later developmental upregulation of the KCC2 cotransporter extruding Cl − lowers the internal neuronal Cl − level. Thus, with GABA A receptor activation there is Cl − influx with hyperpolarization and inhibition.
GABA is excitatory rather inhibitory in perinatal neurons because of elevated neuronal Cl − |
GABA A receptor activation therefore causes Cl − efflux and depolarization (excitation) rather than influx and hyperpolarization (inhibition) |
Elevated neuronal Cl − levels result in the perinatal period because of exuberant development of NKCC1, which mediates Cl − influx , in the presence of developmentally low levels of KCC2, which mediates Cl − efflux |
With development, NKCC1 declines, KCC2 increases, and thus neuronal Cl − levels decrease; GABA A receptor activation then results in Cl − influx and hyperpolarization (inhibition) |
These developmental changes may explain the imperfect response of neonatal seizures to GABA-agonist antiseizure medications (i.e., phenobarbital, benzodiazepines) |
These findings may explain the therapeutic inconsistency of GABA agonists, such as phenobarbital and benzodiazepines, to be effective anticonvulsants in the newborn infant with seizures. This lack of anticonvulsant pharmacological efficacy is particularly apparent after neonatal hypoxic-ischemic insults, which, in an experimental model, are associated with the up-regulation of NKCC1. The NKCC1 inhibitor, bumetanide, has potent antiseizure properties by enhancing GABA-mediated inhibition through the blockage of Cl − uptake and the lowering of neuronal Cl − levels (see later). Moreover, because the maturation of the two cotransporters and neuronal Cl − levels occurs in a caudal-rostral direction, spinal cord and brain stem motor neurons would be expected to exhibit GABA-mediated inhibition before the cerebral cortical regions. This maturational process could explain the frequent occurrence of electroclinical uncoupling/dissociation in which antiseizure medications with GABA agonist mechanisms (i.e., phenobarbital and benzodiazepines) suppress motor manifestations of seizures (by spinal cord and brain stem inhibition) but not cortical electroencephalographic (EEG) manifestations (due to lack of cortex inhibition). The presence of a relative overexpression of NKCC1 versus KCC2 has been documented in postmortem human neonatal brain, and combined with the efficacy in rodent neonatal seizure models, a Phase 1 to 2 study has been initiated to examine the safety and pharmacokinetics of the use of bumetanide as a combination anticonvulsant in human infants suffering from acute neonatal seizures.
Energy Metabolism
The most prominent acute biochemical effects of seizures involve energy metabolism ( Fig. 12.3 ). Seizures are associated with a greatly increased rate of energy-dependent ion pumping, which is accompanied by a fall in the concentration of ATP and phosphocreatine, the storage form of high-energy phosphate in the brain. The resulting rise in adenosine diphosphate (ADP) has two major effects. First, the rise in ADP leads to the stimulation of glycolysis at the rate-limiting, phosphofructokinase step, which ultimately results in accelerated production of pyruvate (see Fig. 12.3 ). In the first minutes after the onset of seizure, there is a sharp increase in the rate of glucose utilization. In the absence of seizure, a major proportion of the pyruvate formed from glycolysis enters the mitochondrion, is oxidized to carbon dioxide, and is associated with the production of ATP. With seizure activity, however, a considerable proportion of pyruvate is converted in the cytoplasm to lactate in the presence of elevated levels of the reduced form of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH). Second, the rise in ADP leads to a shift of the redox state in the cytoplasm toward reduction (i.e., NADH; see Fig. 12.3 ). The excess of lactate, specifically the associated hydrogen ion, has the beneficial effect of causing local vasodilation and a consequent increase in local blood supply and substrate influx. In addition, seizures are associated with elevated blood pressure, which contributes to increased cerebral blood flow (CBF) and substrate influx. This pressor effect is presumed to be a central autonomic component of the seizure because it can be interrupted by a section of the spinal cord or by administration of sympathetic ganglion-blocking agents. An impairment of cerebrovascular autoregulation with seizure causes the pressor response to result in increased CBF.
Despite these important compensatory factors, in experimental animals neonatal seizures are accompanied by reductions in brain glucose concentrations . In the neonatal rat, rabbit, dog, and monkey, despite normal or slightly elevated blood glucose concentrations, brain glucose concentrations fall dramatically within 5 minutes of onset of seizure to nearly undetectable levels after 30 minutes ( Table 12.4 and Fig. 12.4 ). Concomitant with the fall in brain glucose is a rise in brain lactate, which is used readily as a metabolic fuel in the neonatal brain. This fall in brain glucose concentration and rise in brain lactate are directly reminiscent of a hypoxic-ischemic brain insult and presumably relate to the accelerated rate of glucose utilization in an attempt to preserve supplies of phosphocreatine and ATP. Glucose conversion to lactate, which is accelerated with neonatal seizures, results in only two molecules of ATP for each molecule of glucose, as opposed to the 38 molecules of ATP generated when pyruvate enters the mitochondrion and is oxidized to carbon dioxide. Consistently, in vivo studies by magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) of cerebral metabolites in newborn dogs subjected to convulsant-induced seizures demonstrated a prominent decrease in phosphocreatine (with which ATP is in equilibrium) and in intracellular pH. MRS studies by Younkin and colleagues in the human newborns demonstrate the relevance of these experimental data to the clinical situation ( Fig. 12.5 ). Four newborns had seizures during MRS imaging. The seizures resulted in substantial (~50%) decrease in the phosphocreatine to inorganic phosphate (PCr/Pi) ratio. One newborn’s seizures were successfully treated with intravenously administered phenobarbital, which caused an immediate increase in the PCr/Pi ratio. Furthermore, newborns had PCr/Pi ratios of less than 0.8 during seizures and developed long-term neurological sequelae, indicating that neonatal seizures may increase cerebral metabolic demands above energy supply, thereby causing or exacerbating injury. These observations indicate seizures may lead to secondary brain injury in an already injured neonatal brain and therefore have important implications for prognosis and therapy.
METABOLITE | CEREBRAL CORTEX (%) | THALAMUS (%) |
---|---|---|
Glucose utilization | 424–598 | 261–411 |
Glucose | 4 | 1 |
Lactate | 267–650 | 308 |
Phosphocreatine | 23–28 | 28 |
Adenosine triphosphate | 56–77 | 60 |
Mechanisms of Brain Injury With Seizures
The deleterious effects of seizures may be divided into those related to prolonged seizures (in which the most prominent feature is cell loss) and those related to briefer recurrent seizures (in which the most prominent feature is altered development). While minimal data are available in human newborns (see later discussion), experimental studies are abundant, primarily in developing rodent models. Importantly, although the threshold for seizure generation is lower in the developing brain than in the mature brain, developing neurons are less vulnerable to injury from single prolonged seizures than are mature neurons. This may be due to a lower density of active synapses, lower energy consumption, and immaturity of relevant biochemical cascades to cell death.
Prolonged Seizures
The best-documented mechanisms by which prolonged seizures may cause brain injury are depicted in Fig. 12.6 . Seizures may be accompanied by hypoventilation and apnea, which result in hypoxemia and hypercapnia. Hypoxemia may yield cardiovascular dysfunction and ischemic injury to brain, particularly in a newborn whose brain already has been compromised by an insult. Accentuation of the disturbance in cerebral energy metabolism when hypoxemia or hypoxemia-ischemia is combined with seizures has been shown in animal models.
Hypercapnia may combine with seizure-induced adaptive elevations in arterial blood pressure and increased lactate to cause an abrupt increase in CBF in animal models and humans. a
a References .
The importance of this increase in CBF is to maintain substrate supply to the brain and thereby to preserve energy supplies is consistent with the deleterious effect of hypotension when added to seizure, as shown in a neonatal dog model. Because cardiac dysfunction and diminished cardiac output are late complications of seizures, resulting hypotension, diminished CBF, impaired energy metabolism, and additional brain injury are major threats of repeated prolonged seizures (see Fig. 12.6 ). Because the impairment of cerebrovascular autoregulation persists into the postictal period, later decreases in blood pressure may also lead to potentially dangerous CBF reductions.Several lines of evidence indicate that elevations of arterial blood pressure and CBF also occur in the human newborn with seizures, as described in neonatal animal models. Studies using continuous monitoring of arterial blood pressure demonstrated sharp increases in mean arterial blood pressure during neonatal seizures, including subtle seizures, even in paralyzed patients ( Fig. 12.7 ). A study of Doppler ultrasound at the anterior fontanelle in 12 newborns demonstrated a sharp increase in CBF velocity during seizures, most of which were subtle in type. Moreover, the likelihood that this increase in CBF velocity is related to an increase in CBF was shown by the direct documentation of an increase in regional CBF by positron emission tomography during a subtle seizure in an infant. In a study of 12 newborns with seizures, ictal measurements of regional CBF by single photon emission computed tomography showed a 50% to 150% increase, and this increase occurred in newborns with subtle seizures and EEG-only seizures. Although the increase in CBF with seizure initially may be an adaptive response to increase substrate supply to the brain at a time of excessive metabolic demand, this response could become maladaptive in some newborns . For example, depending on such factors as the gestational age of the newborn or the neuropathological substrate for the seizures, some newborns may have highly vulnerable capillary beds, such as the germinal matrix in premature infants or the margins of ischemic lesions in premature infants or asphyxiated term newborns. Under these circumstances, an increase in CBF could rupture these capillary beds and cause intraventricular hemorrhage, hemorrhagic periventricular leukomalacia, or hemorrhagic infarction (see Fig. 12.6 ).
Repeated prolonged seizures may be deleterious for the brain, even in the absence of prominent disturbances of ventilation or perfusion (see Fig. 12.6 ). The deleterious effects of hypoventilation and apnea can be controlled by prompt and vigorous support of ventilation. However, studies of paralyzed and well-ventilated, primarily adult animals subjected to repeated seizures indicate that eventually adaptive compensatory increases in substrate supply to brain experiencing seizures can no longer adequately compensate for the increase in energy expenditure and the resulting fall in energy reserves. Thus, decreases in brain ATP and phosphocreatine concentrations become progressive and irreparable brain injury may result. a
a References .
Nevertheless, most studies indicate that the neonatal brain is more resistant to seizure-induced neuronal necrosis than is the adult brain . Prevention of the changes in high-energy phosphate levels that appear to be important in the causation of brain injury by pharmacological treatment of seizures was shown by MRS in the neonatal dog. As described previously, changes in high-energy phosphate compounds comparable to those observed in animal models were demonstrated by MRS during subtle seizures in human newborns. Four newborns had seizures during MRS imaging. The seizures resulted in a substantial decrease in the PCr/Pi ratio, and in one newborn whose seizures were successfully treated with intravenously administered phenobarbital, there was an immediate increase in the PCr/Pi ratio (see Figs. 12.5 and 12.8 ).Work with newborn animals indicates that glucose administration just before seizures prevents the fall in brain glucose level that occurs with status epilepticus and also markedly reduces mortality and brain cell loss. This protective effect of glucose was substantially greater in neonatal than in older animals ( Fig. 12.9 ). The precise beneficial effect of the glucose did not seem to relate to brain ATP and phosphocreatine concentrations because neither concentration in the whole brain was altered in these experiments. However, the glucose did appear to serve as a carbon source because DNA, RNA, protein, and cholesterol concentrations were relatively spared in the glucose-treated animals. In a study with potential clinical relevance, glucose administered early during seizures in neonatal rats subjected to hypoxia-ischemia led to decreased mortality but no change in the extent of ischemic brain injury. The potential for important interactions between glucose homeostasis and seizures is raised further by MRS studies of neonatal dogs, which showed that levels of hypoglycemia that do not result in alterations in levels of high-energy phosphates are accompanied by distinct decreases in such levels when seizures occur in addition to hypoglycemia. These data indicate the importance of careful attention to glucose homeostasis in the management of the newborns with seizures, and they raise the possibility that administration of glucose may be a useful adjunct to the therapy of some newborns with seizures.
An additional mechanism for the genesis of brain injury with severe seizures relates to excitatory amino acids . a
a References .
Injury to neuronal dendrites and cell bodies, the most prominent acute manifestations of injury from seizures, occurs particularly in limbic structures (e.g., hippocampus) and in distant sites intimately connected with limbic structures (e.g., selected areas of thalamus and cerebellum). The predilection of the limbic system of the newborn for seizure discharges discussed earlier is highly relevant in this regard. The experimental data suggest that the mechanism of neuronal injury in these structures involves excessive synaptic release of excitatory amino acids , particularly glutamate, the principal neurotransmitter for the regions that exhibit injury (see Fig. 12.6 ). When diminution of energy supplies is added, the energy-dependent reuptake systems for excitatory amino acids in presynaptic nerve endings and astrocytes are impaired, and the local accumulation of the neurotransmitters is accentuated (see Fig. 12.6 ). The result is postsynaptic damage at the axodendritic and axosomatic sites. The evidence that indicates a major role of excitatory amino acids as mediators of neuronal death with prolonged seizures is summarized in Table 12.5 . A particular vulnerability of the developing brain of the newborn may relate to the rich expression in the developing brain of glutamate receptors, which appear to play an important role in neuronal differentiation and plasticity. This rich expression of glutamate receptors, important for normal development, may become a source of overexcitation and neuronal death with repeated or prolonged seizures. Thus, the data suggest that severe seizures can induce a pathological extension of a normal synaptic event and that excitotoxic amino acids may thereby mediate cellular injury, not only at the site of the epileptic discharge but also at distant sites excited by the epileptic discharge.Prolonged seizures cause excessive release of glutamate and aspartate at excitatory amino acid synapses |
The topography of seizure-related neuronal damage corresponds to the topography of postsynaptic sites innervated by glutamate-aspartate transmitters |
Cytopathological features of seizure-related neuronal death are indistinguishable from those of glutamate-induced neuronal death |
Specific blockers of glutamate receptors prevent neuronal death with prolonged seizures in vivo, even without preventing seizure activity per se |
Recurrent Seizures
Although most evidence does not suggest serious structural or functional defects from a single neonatal seizure, recurrent seizures , even if not prolonged, are associated with long-term functional, morphological, and physiological deficits ( Table 12.6 ). The most consistent functional disturbance involves deficits in cognition . Visual-spatial memory and learning have been particularly involved, and these deficits are consistent with the locus of the principal structural deficits in the hippocampus. The morphological correlates of the functional disturbances involve neuronal developmental abnormalities rather than neuronal cell loss . The most severe disturbances occur in the hippocampus and include dendritic spine loss in CA3 pyramidal cells, and a distinctive pattern of synaptic reorganization of axons and terminals of the dentate granule cells (i.e., mossy fibers). The degree of this “sprouting” of mossy fibers correlates with the severity of the cognitive deficits. In addition, dentate granule cell neurogenesis, which, unlike in other cortical areas, persists in the neonatal period, is impaired after recurrent seizures.
No definite cell loss Impaired cognitive functions |
Synaptic reorganization of axons and terminals in hippocampus (sprouting of mossy fibers) |
Decreased neurogenesis in hippocampus |
Loss of dendritic spines in hippocampus |
Increased susceptibility to later epilepsy because of changes that all favor excitation including: increased NMDA and AMPA receptors and decreased GABA receptors, altered AMPA receptors (decreased GluR2), imbalance of excitatory and inhibitory systems, and altered intrinsic neuronal membrane properties |
Recurrent seizures also lead to physiological and molecular alterations that favor subsequent neuronal excitability and therefore epileptogenesis , as well as the occurrence of neuronal injury with subsequent insults. Alterations include increases in excitatory amino acid receptors (NMDA and AMPA/kainate), decreases in GABA receptors, posttranslational alterations in AMPA receptors (resulting in a decrease in the GluR2 subunit) that render them permeable to calcium, imbalanced excitatory and inhibitory systems, and altered intrinsic neuronal membrane properties—all of which favor excitation. Recent data from animal models show that brief episodes of neonatal seizure, produced in particular by hypoxia or hypoxia ischemia, can result in long-term alterations in AMPA receptor subunit composition that can predispose to subsequent spontaneous seizure activity. Importantly, in a rodent model, the alterations in AMPA receptor subunit composition, and later spontaneous seizures could be reversed by early posttreatment with the AMPA receptor antagonist NBQX. These data provide evidence that early postseizure treatment may have clinical potential to mitigate some of the deleterious long-term consequences of neonatal seizures, particularly the later development of epilepsy. Consistent with the deleterious effect of recurrent seizures, an observational study of neonatal electrophysiological monitoring of seizures in term infants with hypoxic-ischemic brain injury targeting anticonvulsants to reduce seizure burden was associated with a lower rate of postneonatal epilepsy.
In addition to the modifications of neurotransmitter expression and function, changes in ion channels and metabolic pathways have been suggested to contribute to permanent changes in excitability . KCNQ potassium channels play a very important role in controlling excitation in early-life. The human KCNQ2 and KCNQ3 channel loss-of-function phenotype, benign familial neonatal seizures, suggests these channels are present, active, and important during the neonatal period. A number of medications including flupirtine, a KCNQ channel opener, has been shown to be effective in preventing chemo-convulsant seizures in the neonatal rodent.
Recently, an important regulator of protein translation and synthesis, the mTOR (mammalian target of rapamycin) pathway, has been implicated in epileptogenesis in a number of adult seizure models, and overactivation of mTOR is the hallmark defect of the disease tuberous sclerosis (see Chapter 5 ), which has a high incidence of epilepsy. Similar to adult experimental models, it appears that mTOR upregulation occurs in models of neonatal seizures, and the mTOR inhibitor rapamycin has been shown to prevent acute hypoxia-induced neonatal and convulsant-induced seizures.
Taken together, emerging evidence from many experimental models suggests a series of changes that occur in the immature brain in response to early postnatal seizures. First, changes in immediate early genes and posttranslational modifications of existing proteins occur within minutes to hours, whereas transcriptional events and the onset of inflammatory signaling occur within hours to days. Cell death is minimal following seizures in the immature brain compared to the adult. Later changes include gliosis and axonal sprouting, which may contribute to overall network excitability and dysfunction. These changes are outlined in Fig. 12.10 , and each represents a separable opportunity to discover novel therapeutic targets that are unique and age-specific to the immature brain.
A critical question, of course, is the extent to which these changes occur in the human newborn who experiences recurrent seizures, and what seizure burden may produce such adverse neurobiological consequences. Although this question remains unanswered, there is mounting evidence that seizures are associated with less favorable neurobehavioral outcomes (see later).
Clinical Aspects
Historically, most neonatal seizures were identified by direct clinical observation. More recently, many neonatal intensive care units place increased emphasis on EEG monitoring to identify seizures. This monitoring can include principally, conventional EEG, or amplitude-integrated EEG (aEEG), or both. An expanded role for EEG monitoring has been advocated by recent guideline and consensus statements (see later discussion). However, because this shift toward the use of EEG monitoring is recent, many of the data related to neonatal seizure diagnosis, management, and outcome are based on studies that relied on clinical identification of seizures. Increasing use of EEG monitoring has raised two important possibilities about data derived from studies of clinically identified seizures. First, some clinically identified motor and behavioral phenomena characterized as seizures do not have a simultaneous EEG seizure correlate; this finding suggests that the occurrence of some neonatal seizures may have been overestimated in the past. Second, many electrographic seizures are not accompanied by clinically observable alterations in neonatal motor or behavioral function; this finding suggests that the occurrence of neonatal seizures may have been underestimated in the past. These observations underscore the importance of EEG data in the identification and management of newborns with seizures.
Seizure Classification
Seizure Types
A seizure is defined clinically as a paroxysmal alteration in neurological function (i.e., behavioral, motor, or autonomic function). Such a definition includes clinical phenomena that are associated temporally with seizure activity identifiable on an EEG and, therefore, are clearly epileptic (i.e., related to hypersynchronous electrical discharges that may spread and activate other brain structures). The clinical seizure definition also includes paroxysmal clinical phenomena that are not consistently associated temporally with EEG seizure activity; how many of these clinical phenomena without identifiable EEG correlates are epileptic and just not identifiable on surface-recorded EEG and how many are nonepileptic is not resolved (see later discussion). The classification of neonatal seizures presented here categorizes clinical seizures and designates those clinical seizures likely to be associated with EEG seizure activity.
The classification schemes for neonatal seizures have varied over time ( Table 12.7 ). A consensus statement on neonatal EEG terminology by the American Clinical Neurophysiology Society defined three types of neonatal seizures: (1) clinical-only seizures in which there is a sudden paroxysm of abnormal clinical change that does not correlate with a simultaneous EEG seizure, (2) electroclinical seizures in which there is a clinical seizure coupled with an associated EEG seizure, and (3) EEG-only seizures in which there is an EEG seizure that is not associated with any outwardly visible clinical signs. EEG-only seizures are also referred to as subclinical, nonconvulsive, or occult seizures ( Table 12.8 ). Neonatal EEG seizures are described as having (1) a sudden EEG change; (2) repetitive waveforms that evolve in morphology, frequency, and/or location; (3) an amplitude of at least 2 µV; and (4) a duration of at least 10 seconds ( Table 12.9 ).
CLINICAL SEIZURE | ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHIC SEIZURE CORRELATE | |
---|---|---|
COMMON | UNCOMMON | |
Subtle | + | |
Clonic | ||
Focal | + | |
Multifocal | + | |
Tonic | ||
Focal | + | |
Generalized | + | |
Myoclonic | ||
Focal, multifocal | + | |
Generalized | + |
|
|
Electrographic seizure definitions were provided earlier and are summarized in Table 12.9 . It is important to distinguish between electrographic seizures and other related EEG patterns. Although a seizure on EEG is composed of an evolving pattern of epileptiform discharges, not all epileptiform discharges are seizures. Epileptiform dischar ges are brief abnormalities that stand out from the EEG background, usually due to a peaked or sharp appearance. They are sometimes referred to as “sharp waves” or “spikes” because of this EEG appearance. It is normal for newborns to have some sharp waves, and many newborns with epileptiform discharges do not experience seizures. However, epileptiform discharges that occur in runs or are clustered in one brain region are associated with an increased risk of seizure occurrence. In particular, brief rhythmic discharges (BRDs) are EEG patterns that meet the criteria for neonatal seizures (sudden, abnormal, evolving) but are shorter in duration than 10 seconds. BRDs have also been referred to as brief intermittent/ictal/interictal rhythmic discharges (BIRDs) or brief electroencephalographic rhythmic discharges (BERDs). BRDs are associated with underlying brain pathology and are associated with the occurrence of seizures, as well as an increased risk of future developmental delay, cerebral palsy, and mortality. Further, some BRDs are associated with clinical signs, including focal clonic activity. Indicating that the exact separation between seizures and shorter rhythmic discharges may be less distinct. Clearly the 10-second rule is largely arbitrary, and electrographic events with a clinical correlate are generally considered electroclinical seizures even if they last less than 10 seconds.
For those seizures with a clinical correlate, the most recent International League Against Epilepsy seizure classification report classifies neonatal seizures according to the same descriptors as seizures at later ages, rather than as a separate entity as had occurred in prior seizure classification systems. However, the organization of this chapter will retain emphasis of the classification of clinical seizures noted in Table 12.7 .
Despite great efforts to carefully describe the appearance of neonatal seizures, inter-rater agreement in neonatal seizure identification by clinical observation is suboptimal . Malone and colleagues presented clinical data and video clips of abnormal neonatal movements from 20 newborns to 137 observers, including 91 physicians from seven neonatal intensive care units. Observers classified the movements as seizure or nonseizure. The average number of correctly classified events was only 50%, compared to the gold standard of EEG classification. Further, interobserver agreement was poor for both physicians and other health care professionals. Similarly, in a study of staff observing high-risk newborns, only 9% of 526 electrographic seizures were identified by clinical observation, indicating that an underdiagnosis of seizures occurred. In addition, 78% of 177 nonictal events were incorrectly identified as seizures, indicating that an overdiagnosis of seizures occurred. Problematically, the more difficult to diagnose seizure types tend to occur more often than the more readily diagnosed seizure types in newborns. A study of 61 seizures in 24 newborns classified seizures by their most prominent clinical features. Clonic and tonic seizures, which might be more readily identified, only occurred in 20% and 8%, respectively, while orolingual, ocular, and autonomic features, which might be more difficult to identify, were the main features in 55%.
Despite the limitations in clinical recognition of seizures discussed previously, attempts at clinical recognition and classification of neonatal seizures are critical to diagnose seizures and differentiate them from nonictal events. Four essential clinically evident seizure types can be recognized: subtle, clonic, tonic, and myoclonic (see Table 12.7 ). Subtle seizures do not have a clear position in the most recent International League Against Epilepsy seizure classification report, but they are very common in newborns and the term is used frequently throughout the literature. Thus, the term is retained as part of the categorization system in this chapter. As discussed further on, a critical fifth seizure type to consider in newborns is seizures with no observable clinical correlate, which have been referred to as EEG-only seizures, subclinical seizures, nonconvulsive seizures, and occult seizures . In the terminology used later, multifocal refers to clinical activity that involves more than one site, is asynchronous, and, usually, is migratory, whereas generalized refers to clinical activity that is diffusely bilateral, synchronous, and nonmigratory.
An important initial distinction in classifying a seizure is whether it has a generalized or focal mechanism of onset . Focal seizures have a defined region of onset, and electrical activity initially spreads through neural networks in that region, although the seizure may spread within the hemisphere or to the contralateral hemisphere with time. Generalized seizures may begin from a specific point, but almost immediately involve bilateral neural networks, such that electrical activity appears on both sides of the brain simultaneously on EEG. In the vast majority of neonatal seizures, onset is focal or multifocal . Spread of the seizure within one hemisphere and secondary generalization to the contralateral hemisphere are less common in newborns than in older children, presumably because the network connections in the newborn brain are not as fully developed (discussed earlier).
Subtle Seizures.
The clinical manifestations of certain neonatal seizures may be overlooked even by skilled observers, and these paroxysmal alterations in neonatal behavior and motor or autonomic function are defined as subtle seizures ( Table 12.10 ). Available information from studies using EEG recording simultaneously with video recording or direct observation suggests that (1) subtle seizures are more common in premature than in full-term infants; and (2) some subtle clinical phenomena in full-term infants are not consistently associated with EEG seizure activity (i.e., clinical-only seizures). Common ictal clinical manifestations, confirmed by simultaneous abnormal EEG discharges, in a group of premature infants of 26 to 32 weeks of gestation, included sustained opening of eyes, ocular movements, chewing, pedaling motions, and a variety of autonomic phenomena. Similar subtle clinical phenomena occur in association with EEG seizure activity in full-term newborns, although slightly less commonly than in preterm newborns. a
a References .
Thus, eye opening, ocular movements (often sustained eye opening with ocular fixation in premature infants and horizontal deviation in term newborns), peculiar extremity movements (e.g., resembling “boxing” or “hooking” movements), mouth movements, and apnea have been documented in association with EEG seizure activity (see Tables 12.10 and 12.11 ).Ocular phenomena |
Tonic horizontal deviation of eyes with or without jerking of eyes a |
Sustained eye opening with ocular fixation b |
Oral-buccal-lingual movements |
Chewing b |
Other manifestations |
Limb movements |
Autonomic phenomena c |
Apneic episodes a |
a Documented with simultaneous electroencephalographic seizure activity most commonly in term newborns.
b Documented with simultaneous electroencephalographic seizure activity most commonly in premature newborns.
c Documented with simultaneous electroencephalographic seizure activity as a prominent isolated seizure manifestation most commonly in the premature infants, but autonomic phenomena (e.g., increase in blood pressure) are also common accompaniments of seizures in term newborns.
SCHER AND CO-WORKERS a ( N = 12; MEAN BIRTH WEIGHT, 1358 g) | RADVANYI-BOUVET AND CO-WORKERS b ( N = 21; MEAN BIRTH WEIGHT, 1220 g) |
---|---|
Clonic movements (6)Myoclonic movements (2)Staring (2)Nystagmus (1)Apnea (1)Hiccough (1)Chewing (7)Ocular movements (4)Apnea (4)Tachypnea (3)Bradycardia (6)Tachycardia (1) | Sustained eye opening with fixed gaze (15) |
Tonic, often with facial “wincing” (8) | |
Myoclonic movements (7) | |
“Jerks” (1) | |
Pedaling movements (2) | |
Cry-grimace (3) |
a Data from Scher MS, Painter MJ, Bergman I, Barmada MA, et al. EEG diagnoses of neonatal seizures: clinical correlations and outcome. Pediatr Neurol . 1989;5:17–24.
b Data from Radvanyi-Bouvet MF, Vallecalle MH, Morel-Kahn F, Relier JP, et al. Seizures and electrical discharges in premature infants. Neuropediatrics. 1985;16:143–148.
The frequency with which subtle clinical seizure phenomena are associated with concomitant EEG seizure activity is uncertain. In one study, 22 newborns, approximately 85% of whom were of greater than 36 weeks of gestation, exhibited paroxysms of such ocular abnormalities as eye opening or blinking, oral-buccal-lingual movements, pedaling or stepping movements, or rotary arm movements with an “inconsistent association” with EEG seizure activity. Only tonic horizontal deviation of the eyes was consistently associated with EEG seizure activity. In another report of 44 newborns (28 premature), subtle clinical phenomena, defined as outlined in Table 12.10 , accounted for 70% to 75% of all clinical seizures with simultaneous EEG correlates. It is more common for subtle clinical events to have an electrographic correlate (i.e., electroclinical seizures) if the newborn has other types of seizures; these events are somewhat less likely to be seizures when they are the only behavior of clinical concern. However, it is important to recognize that not all epileptic events may be identified by conventional surface EEG recording (see later). Taken together, the data indicate that at least some caution should be used in attributing an epileptic origin to subtle clinical phenomena, particularly when these phenomena are the only seizure manifestation.
The issue of apnea as a seizure manifestation deserves special consideration. Although apnea has been demonstrated as a seizure manifestation in premature infants, most apneic episodes in the premature infants are not epileptic in origin. However, apnea has been documented with electrical seizure activity, more commonly in the full-term newborns. In 14 of the 21 newborns studied by Watanabe and colleagues, the newborns exhibited other subtle phenomena during the apneic seizure (e.g., eye opening, “staring,” deviation of the eyes, and mouth movements). Of additional value in clinical identification of apnea as a seizure is the observation that apnea accompanied by EEG seizure activity (i.e., convulsive apnea) is less likely to be associated with bradycardia than is nonconvulsive apnea. However, convulsive apnea that is prolonged may be complicated ultimately by bradycardia. Other rarer clinical phenomena observed in newborns with apneic seizures, and occasionally in isolation, include episodic vertical deviation of eyes (usually downward) with or without eye jerking, hyperpnea, vasomotor phenomena, and abnormal cardiac rhythm (usually with bradycardia). a
a References .
Clonic Seizures.
A clonic seizure is defined as a seizure characterized by “rhythmic movements of muscle groups in a focal distribution which consist of a rapid phase followed by a slow return movement.” Clonic seizures appear as repetitive and rhythmic jerking movements that can affect any part of the body including the face, extremities, and even diaphragmatic or pharyngeal muscles. Clonic seizures represent the clinical seizure type associated most consistently with EEG seizure activity.
Clonic seizures in the newborn are often classified as focal or multifocal (see Tables 12.7 and 12.12 ). Focal clonic seizures involve the face, upper or lower extremities on one side of the body, or axial structures (neck or trunk) on one side of the body. Newborns commonly are not clearly unconscious during or after a focal seizure. The neuropathological condition often is focal (e.g., cerebral infarction), although focal clonic seizures may occur with metabolic encephalopathies. Because focal clonic seizures occur with focal etiologies, it is likely that newborns with only focal clonic seizures have more favorable outcomes than those with other seizures types. Multifocal clonic seizures involve several body parts, often in a migrating fashion, although the migration most often “marches” in a non-Jacksonian manner (e.g., left arm jerking may be followed by right leg jerking). Generalized clonic seizures (i.e., diffusely bilateral, generally symmetrical, and synchronous movements) are rarely, if ever, observed in newborns. Clonic seizures are often reliably recognized by clinical observation, but they must be distinguished from other repetitive movements, such as jitteriness, tremulousness, and myoclonus (see later). Unlike those nonepileptic movements, the muscle twitches of a clonic seizure cannot be suppressed with gentle pressure and occur spontaneously (see later discussion).
Focal clonic seizures |
Localized clonic jerking |
Usually not unconscious |
Often associated with EEG seizure |
Multifocal clonic seizures |
Simultaneous or in sequence clonic jerking from multiple locations |
Nonordered (non-jacksonian) migration |
Often associated with EEG seizure |
Generalized clonic seizures |
Diffusely bilateral, generally symmetrical, and synchronous movements |
Rarely, if ever, observed in newborns |
Tonic Seizures.
Tonic seizures are defined as a “sustained flexion or extension of axial or appendicular muscle groups.” Two categories of tonic seizures should be distinguished: focal and generalized tonic seizures (see Tables 12.7 and 12.13 ). Focal tonic seizures consist of sustained posturing of a limb or asymmetrical posturing of trunk or neck. Mizrahi and Kellaway also classified horizontal eye deviation as a focal tonic seizure, although some classify those events as subtle seizures. Focal tonic seizures are associated consistently with EEG seizure discharges. Several nonepileptic conditions may mimic focal tonic seizures. Focal tonic episodes may occur as initial manifestation of alternating hemiplegia of childhood in which the EEG is normal, and after the first weeks of life the tonic episodes are followed by the characteristic prolonged periods of hemiparesis. Hemifacial spasm , a rare disorder in newborns with a posterior fossa lesion (e.g., cerebellar tumor, facial nerve trauma), is not accompanied by abnormal EEG features.
Focal tonic seizures |
Sustained posturing of a limb |
Asymmetrical posturing of trunk or neck |
Often associated with EEG seizure |
Generalized tonic seizures |
Tonic extension of upper and lower limbs |
Usually not associated with EEG change |
Generalized tonic seizures are characterized by tonic extension of both upper and lower extremities (mimicking “decerebrate” posturing) but also by the tonic flexion of upper extremities with the extension of lower extremities (mimicking “decorticate” posturing) (see Table 12.13 ). The possibility that such clinical seizures represent posturing and are not ictal has been raised because of the frequent association with severe intraventricular hemorrhage and the often poor response to antiseizure medication therapy. Approximately 85% of such clinical seizures were not accompanied by electrographic activity or by autonomic phenomena. The 15% of generalized tonic seizures that were accompanied by electrographic seizure activity were also accompanied by autonomic phenomena. Thus, these generalized tonic events may represent “brain stem release” phenomena and uninhibited extensor posturing that appears similar to tonic stiffening in patients with severe brain injury. As an additional mimic to generalized tonic seizures, episodes of generalized hypertonia provoked by minor tactile or other stimuli are characteristic of hyperekplexia , which is also known as startle disease or congenital stiff-man syndrome (see later).
Myoclonic Seizures.
Myoclonus is defined as a rapid, isolated jerk which can affect one or multiple muscle groups, can be ictal or nonictal in etiology, and can arise from injury to any level of the nervous system. Myoclonic seizures are clinical episodes that are usually not associated with EEG discharges ( Table 12.14 ). Myoclonic movements are distinguished from clonic movements by the faster speed of the myoclonic jerk and the predilection for flexor muscle groups. There are three categories of myoclonic seizures: focal, multifocal, and generalized myoclonic seizures (see Tables 12.7 and 12.15 ). Focal myoclonic seizures typically involve flexor muscles of an upper extremity. Of 41 focal myoclonic seizures studied by Mizrahi and Kellaway, only 3 were associated with EEG seizures (see Table 12.14 ). Multifocal myoclonic seizures are characterized by asynchronous twitching of several parts of the body. In five episodes studied by Mizrahi and Kellaway, none had associated EEG seizure discharges (see Table 12.14 ). Generalized myoclonic seizures are characterized by bilateral jerks of flexion of upper and occasionally of lower limbs. These seizures may appear identical to the infantile spasms observed in older infants. Generalized myoclonic seizures are more likely to be associated with EEG seizure discharges than are focal or multifocal myoclonic seizures. Of 58 generalized myoclonic seizures studied by Mizrahi and Kellaway, 35 had associated EEG seizure discharges (see Table 12.13 ). All three varieties of myoclonic seizures may occur as a feature of severe neonatal epileptic syndromes.
TYPE OF MYOCLONIC SEIZURE | CONSISTENT EEG SEIZURE | INCONSISTENT OR NO EEG SEIZURE |
---|---|---|
Generalized | 35 | 23 |
Focal | 3 | 38 |
Multifocal | 0 | 5 |
Focal and multifocal myoclonic seizures |
Well-localized, single or multiple, migrating jerks, usually of limbs |
Usually not accompanied by electroencephalographic seizure discharges |
Generalized myoclonic seizures |
Single or bilateral synchronous jerks of flexion, more in upper than in lower limbs |
May presage infantile spasms with suppression-burst electroencephalographic pattern and hypsarrhythmia |
Often associated with EEG seizure |
Myoclonic seizures must be distinguished from nonepileptic myoclonus, which can occur with injury to any level of the nervous system and from normal physiological myoclonus, which occurs in normal newborns. Unlike such other forms of myoclonus, myoclonic seizures are not induced by stimuli and cannot be suppressed by pressure to the affected body part. Furthermore, newborns with myoclonic seizures almost always have abnormal neurological exams, whereas newborns with benign myoclonus are otherwise normal.
Electroencephalographic-Only (Subclinical, Nonconvulsive, Occult) Seizures
A major issue with clinical diagnosis of seizures in newborns is the high incidence of EEG-only seizures in newborns. a
a References .
Numerous studies have indicated that about 80% to 90% of electrographic seizures do not have any associated clinical correlate and therefore would not be identified without continuous EEG monitoring even by the most expert and observant bedside caregivers. Clancy and colleagues evaluated 41 newborns with seizures happening frequently enough to occur during a routine EEG. Only 21% of 393 seizures identified on EEG were accompanied by clinically evident seizure activity (i.e., electroclinical seizures), while 79% of the seizures identified on EEG were EEG-only seizures. Electroclinical seizures and EEG-only seizures had similar durations, and there were no differences in the degree of encephalopathy. The authors concluded that “unaided visual inspection of infants seriously underestimates true seizure frequency,” and that “long-term EEG monitoring may be necessary in many infants to determine their real seizure frequency and to judge the adequacy of antiepileptic drug treatment.” In a related study, Murray and colleagues evaluated 51 term newborns with continuous video EEG. Nine newborns experienced a total of 526 electrographic seizures, and only 19% of the electrographic seizure time was accompanied by clinical manifestations ( Fig. 12.11 ). Further, only 9% of electrographic seizures were accompanied by clinical seizure activity that was identified by neonatal staff. These data indicate that the majority of neonatal seizures are EEG-only, that is, identifiable only with EEG monitoring.In newborns with clinically evident seizures, the administration of antiseizure medications may lead to termination of the clinically evident seizures while electrographic seizures persist, which is an occurrence referred to as electromechanical uncoupling or electromechanical dissociation. In the study by Clancy and colleagues, 79% of 393 electrical seizures recorded were not accompanied by clinical seizure activity monitored by direct observation; 88% of the total population of patients had been treated with one or more antiseizure medications. Thus, when clinically evident electroclinical seizures terminate following antiseizure medication administration, EEG monitoring may be needed to assess for ongoing EEG-only seizures.
The reasons for electroclinical dissociation/uncoupling are probably multiple, but data concerning the development of Cl − transporters in perinatal human brain provide a rational explanation . As discussed earlier, a developmental mismatch occurs between the transporter responsible for Cl − influx (NKCC1) and the transporter responsible for Cl − efflux (KCC2), so that, in the human perinatal brain, neuronal Cl − levels are likely to be high. Thus, GABA activation results in Cl − efflux with resulting depolarization, and thus excitation. Therefore, with treatment with common anticonvulsant medications, such as phenobarbital and benzodiazepines, which are principally GABA agonists, electrographic seizures are not consistently terminated. However, because the maturation of the transporters occurs in a caudal-to-rostral direction, neuronal Cl − levels in the brain stem and spinal cord motor systems would be expected to decrease to normal levels before cortical neuronal levels. Thus, GABA activation induced by antiseizure medications would eliminate the motor phenomena of the seizure, but not the cortical electrographic component, resulting in electroclinical dissociation/uncoupling.
The findings described earlier have led to an increased reliance on EEG monitoring with either conventional EEG or aEEG for three main reasons. First, many newborns experience only EEG-only seizures, and EEG-only seizures constitute the majority of neonatal seizures. Second, even in newborns with clinically evident electroclinical seizures, the administration of antiseizure medications may induce electromechanical dissociation/uncoupling with the termination of clinically evident seizures but persisting EEG-only seizures. Third, clinical events may be difficult to distinguish as seizure based on clinical observation, which potentially leads to unnecessary exposure of newborns to antiseizure medications for nonepileptic events. As a result, many neonatal intensive care units place increased importance on EEG monitoring, either using conventional EEG or aEEG, to identify neonatal seizures ; and, as noted earlier, an expanded role for EEG monitoring has been advocated by recent guidelines, consensus statements, and committee reports (see later discussion).
Nonepileptic Movements
Nonepileptic neonatal movements can be difficult to distinguish from seizures by appearance alone, and EEG assessment may be required. Some nonictal movements are benign events while others, although not seizures, are nonetheless abnormal and indicative of underlying brain injury or dysfunction.
Jitteriness.
Jitteriness is characterized by movements with qualities primarily of tremulousness but occasionally of clonus. The most consistently defined causes of jitteriness are hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy, hypocalcemia, hypoglycemia, and drug withdrawal. Five characteristics aid in distinguishing between jitteriness and seizure ( Table 12.16 ). First, jitteriness is not accompanied by ocular phenomena (i.e., eye fixation or deviation); seizures often are associated with ocular phenomena. Second, jitteriness is exquisitely stimulus sensitive; seizures generally are not stimulus sensitive. Third, the dominant movement in jitteriness is tremor (i.e., the alternating movements are rhythmic and of equal rate and amplitude); the dominant movement in seizure is clonic jerking (i.e., movements with a fast and slow component). Fourth, the rhythmic movements of limbs in jitteriness usually can be stopped by gentle passive flexion of the affected limb; seizures do not cease with this maneuver. Finally, jitteriness is not accompanied by autonomic changes (e.g., tachycardia, increase in blood pressure, apnea, cutaneous vasomotor phenomena, pupillary change, salivation, or drooling); seizures may be accompanied by one or more of these autonomic changes. These same distinguishing clinical features are useful in the clinical distinction of episodic movements other than jitteriness that may mimic a seizure.
CLINICAL FEATURE | JITTERINESS | SEIZURE |
---|---|---|
Abnormality of gaze or eye movement | 0 | + |
Movements stimulus sensitive | + | 0 |
Predominant movement | Tremor | Clonic jerking |
Movements cease with passive flexion | + | 0 |
Associated autonomic changes | 0 | + |
Tremors.
Tremors may be misidentified as clonic seizures because both are characterized by rhythmic oscillatory movements. In tremor, both phases of movement are of the same amplitude and speed, whereas with a clonic seizure there is a fast movement followed by a slower rebound movement. In addition, tremors are generally higher frequency (faster movement) and lower amplitude (smaller and finer movements) than clonic seizures, which are characterized by slower frequency and higher amplitude movements. Finally, tremors are suppressed by subtle pressure or repositioning of the affected body part while seizures persist with pressure or repositioning. Though often spontaneous, tremors may be elicited by stimuli, while seizures arise spontaneously.
Jitteriness and tremors are common and are reported in about half of healthy newborns. A benign tremor is hypothesized to be due to the immaturity of inhibitory neurons or elevated levels of catecholamines. Excessive, pathological tremors can occur with systemic disorders (hypoglycemia, hypocalcemia, infection, drug withdrawal, or thyroid disease) and primary neurological disorders (hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy or intraventricular hemorrhage). Fine tremors are more likely to be benign or related to electrolyte disturbances while higher-amplitude tremors are more likely to be secondary to brain disorders.
Nonepileptic Myoclonus.
Nonepileptic myoclonus may be benign or pathological. Healthy premature infants often demonstrate occasional spontaneous myoclonus. Benign neonatal myoclonus , alternately termed benign neonatal sleep myoclonus, can be pronounced, is typically most prominent in sleep, and can last up to several minutes. Benign neonatal myoclonus may be differentiated from pathological myoclonus in that benign myoclonus can be stopped by rousing the infant and typically does not involve the face. The episodes usually last for several minutes or more and occur only during sleep, particularly quiet (non-rapid eye movement) sleep. They can be provoked by gentle rocking of the crib mattress in a head-to-toe direction and cease abruptly with arousal. The EEG pattern during the episodes does not show an ictal correlate, and interictal EEG findings are either normal or show minor, nonspecific abnormalities. The episodes can be exacerbated or provoked by treatment with benzodiazepines and resolve within approximately 2 months. The neurological outcome is normal.
Pathological myoclonus is attributed to a brain stem release phenomenon from loss of cortical inhibition of lower circuits. It is frequently seen in infants with severe global brain injury from hypoxia-ischemia, severe intraventricular hemorrhage, and toxic-metabolic disturbances, including drug withdrawal and glycine encephalopathy. These newborns have abnormal neurological exams and abnormal background patterns on EEG.
Hyperekplexia.
Hyperekplexia is also known as startle disease or congenital stiff-man syndrome . It is characterized principally by two abnormal forms of response to unexpected auditory, visual, and somesthetic stimuli, which are an exaggerated startle response and sustained tonic spasms. Additional features are generalized hypertonia and prominent nocturnal myoclonus. The “minor” form of hyperekplexia only involves excessive startle, while the “major” form is associated with additional problems, including generalized stiffness while awake, nocturnal myoclonus, and an increased risk of sudden infant death syndrome from central and obstructive apnea.
The hypertonia and exaggerated startle are apparent from the first hours of life, and sudden jerky movements have been noted even in utero. The typical clinical picture is a hyperalert infant who responds to sudden external stimulus, auditory, visual, or somesthetic (simple handling, nose tap, air blow over face) with recurrent startles, increasing rigidity, jittery movements that become rhythmic and mimic seizure, and occasionally apnea. The stiffness may interfere with bathing and diaper changes. Feeding difficulties and spasms can prevent adequate nutrition. Indeed, the tonic spasms may mimic generalized tonic seizures and can be dangerous, because they may lead to apnea. The EEG does not show epileptic discharges associated with the clinical events.
Hyperekplexia may be caused by glycine receptor gene mutations, and clonazepam can be an effective treatment for excessive startle. The episodes usually cease spontaneously by the age of approximately 2 years. In some patients, the disorder is inherited in an autosomal dominant fashion, and the responsible gene is on chromosome 5, which is known to encode the α-1 subunit of the glycine receptor. Neurophysiological studies suggest that the primary physiological abnormality is related to increased excitability of reticular neurons in the brain stem. The α-1 subunit of the glycine receptor is critical for Cl − influx and thereby inhibitory interneuron function in spinal cord and brain stem.
Other Normal Motor Activities.
Newborns may exhibit additional normal motor activity that could be mistaken for seizures, and these are important to recognize to avoid unnecessarsy diagnostic testing and exposure to antiseizure medications ( Table 12.17 ). Certain unusual but benign paroxysmal neonatal motor phenomena (e.g., paroxysmal downward gaze or upward gaze) also must be distinguished from seizure (see Chapter 9 ).
Roving, sometimes dysconjugate eye movements, with occasional nonsustained nystagmoid jerks at the extremes of horizontal movement (contrast with fixed, tonic horizontal deviation of eyes with or without jerking, characteristic of subtle seizure) |
Sucking, puckering movements not accompanied by ocular fixation or deviation |
Asleep |
Fragmentary myoclonic jerks (may be multiple) |
Isolated, generalized myoclonic jerk as infant wakes from sleep |
Does Absence of Electroencephalographic Seizure Activity Indicate That a Clinical Event Is Nonepileptic?
Central to the concept that certain neonatal clinical events are nonepileptic (e.g., brain stem release phenomena) is the lack of a consistent EEG seizure accompaniment. Does the absence of EEG seizure activity rule out an epileptic origin for the clinical activity? Data from older children and adults, as well as in newborns, indicate that epileptic phenomena can occur in the absence of surface-recorded EEG discharges, and such phenomena can be generated at subcortical (i.e., deep limbic, diencephalic, brain stem) levels ( Table 12.18 ).
Many simple partial seizures in older children and adults have been accompanied by no ictal seizure discharges recorded from surface electrodes |
Complex partial seizures in older children and adults emanating from the temporal lobe, particularly the hippocampus, may be undetectable on surface-recorded EEG and even from subdural electrodes; depth electrodes may be required to detect the ictal hippocampal discharges. Many subtle seizure phenomena in the newborn suggest complex partial seizures; subtle seizures have been documented in congenital maldevelopment of the hippocampus; the hippocampus is a frequent site of neuronal disease in neonatal encephalopathies, especially hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy |
Clinical seizure phenomena can occur in infants with hydranencephaly in the absence of (surface-recorded) EEG discharges |
Bilateral, synchronous, and rhythmic myoclonic movements can occur in benign neonatal sleep myoclonus and in benign myoclonus of early infancy, always without seizure discharges from surface-recorded EEG |
Particularly strong support for the notion that neonatal seizures may originate from brain stem structures is provided by rodent studies. Investigators showed that stimulation of the inferior colliculus of the adult rat caused a persistent electrical discharge accompanied by wild running behavior. However, stimulation of this midbrain region in the neonatal rat produced less complex movement such as “forelimb paddling, hind limb treading, and rolling-curling movements of the torso.” These may be analogous to the “boxing,” “bicycling,” and similar movements of the human newborn. Moreover, the sensitivity of the inferior colliculus for the development of the electrical and clinical seizure activity was considerably greater in the newborn than in the older animal. In addition, it is noteworthy that the inferior colliculus of the newborn is particularly sensitive to hypoxic-ischemic brain injury, the most common cause of neonatal seizures.
Several studies of more than 100 newborns with EEG-confirmed seizures have helped to clarify the relationship between subtle seizures and electrographic seizures. First, the proportion of newborns who exhibited subtle clinical seizures was nearly identical among newborns who either did or did not exhibit simultaneous electrographic discharges. Thus, there was no overrepresentation of subtle seizures in the newborns who did not exhibit an EEG correlate. Second, the groups with and without EEG accompaniments to the subtle seizures were clinically similar and had similar neurological outcomes. Thus, there was no indication that the newborns without consistent EEG correlates to the subtle movements were more likely to have cerebral destruction with resulting “release” phenomena. Third, newborns with subtle seizures sometimes exhibited or did not exhibit concomitant EEG seizures. Finally, the clinical phenomena often began seconds before the electrographic discharges. Together, these data indicate that some subtle clinical seizures may originate from subcortical structures and only sometimes propagate to the cortex to produce surface-recorded EEG seizures. This mechanism would account for inconsistent electroclinical correlations and for the fact that the initial EEG change may occur after the initial clinical manifestation.
More data are needed regarding the pathophysiology of subtle seizures. Of particular importance is whether such “surface EEG-silent” seizures have the potential to result in brain injury, whether they can be eliminated by conventional antiseizure medication therapy, and whether elimination of the events is associated with more favorable neurobehavioral outcomes.
Seizure Etiology
The majority of neonatal seizures occur in the context of acute neurological disorders. Thus, most neonatal seizures may be considered acute symptomatic seizures, which have been defined as seizure occurring at the time of a systemic insult or in close temporal association (often 1 week) with a documented brain insult. The current International League Against Epilepsy classifies seizure causes as genetic, structural metabolic, and unknown . Within that classification scheme, the majority of neonatal seizures are structural metabolic in etiology.
Determination of the seizure etiology is critical because it affords the opportunity to provide specific treatment and important prognostic information. While there are many causes for neonatal seizures, a relatively limited group of etiologies accounts for the majority of affected newborns. The most common causes and their usual time of onset in premature or full-term infants are shown in Table 12.19 . The most common underlying etiologies are hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy, stroke, intracranial hemorrhage, intracranial infections, and cerebral dysgenesis. a
a References .
Less common but important etiologies include inborn errors of metabolism and neonatal epileptic syndromes, such as benign familial neonatal epilepsy (BFNE), benign nonfamilial neonatal seizures (“fifth-day fits”), early myoclonic epilepsy, early infantile epileptic encephalopathy (EIEE), and malignant migrating partial seizures of infancy (see later).CAUSE | TIME OF ONSET a | RELATIVE FREQUENCY b | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
0–3 DAYS | >3 DAYS | PREMATURE | FULL TERM | |
Hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy | + | +++ | +++ | |
Intracranial hemorrhage c | + | + | ++ | + |
Intracranial infection d | + | + | ++ | ++ |
Developmental defects | + | + | ++ | ++ |
Hypoglycemia | + | + | + | |
Hypocalcemia e | + | + | + | + |
Other metabolic f | + | + | ||
Epilepsy syndromes g | + | + | + |
a Postnatal age when seizures most commonly begin.
b Relative frequency of seizures: +++, most common; ++, less common; +, least common.
c Hemorrhages are principally germinal matrix intraventricular, often with periventricular hemorrhagic infarction, in the premature infant and subarachnoid or subdural in the term infant.
d Early seizures occur usually with intrauterine nonbacterial infections (e.g., toxoplasmosis, cytomegalovirus infection), and later seizures usually occur with herpes simplex encephalitis or bacterial meningitis.
e Two varieties of hypocalcemia (see text).
The Neonatal Seizure Registry consortium of seven tertiary care pediatric centers in the United States prospectively collected data related to etiology in a cohort of 426 newborns with seizures who underwent continuous EEG (cEEG). The most common seizure etiologies were hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy in 38%, ischemic stroke in 18%, neonatal onset epilepsy in 13%, intracranial hemorrhage in 11%, neonatal genetic epilepsy syndrome in 6%, congenital cerebral malformation in 4%, and BFNE in 3%. In addition, for all these etiologies, the seizure burden was high, with 59% of subjects having greater than 7 electrographic seizures, and 16% status epilepticus. There was no significant difference in seizure burden between preterm and full-term newborns or among the three most common causes of seizure (hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy, ischemic stroke, and intracerebral hemorrhage). These etiologies were similar to those reported in a study by Weeke and colleagues of 378 newborns obtained over a 14-year period with seizures confirmed by EEG or aEEG from a level 3 neonatal intensive care unit. The most common etiologies identified were hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (46%), intracranial hemorrhage (12.2%), and perinatal arterial ischemic stroke (10.6%). These etiologies are quite similar to those found in a study by Tekgul and colleagues in which 89 newborns underwent careful etiological evaluation. The most common etiologies were global hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy in 40%, focal ischemic injury in 38%, intracranial hemorrhage in 17%, cerebral dysgenesis in 5%, transient metabolic disturbance in 3%, infection in 3%, and an inborn error of metabolism in 1%. The etiology remained unknown in 12%. Thus, in summary three key conditions account for nearly 75% of neonatal seizures —hypoxic-ischemic brain injury (40% to 50%), arterial stroke (10% to 15%), and intracranial hemorrhage (10% to 20%). The next two most common etiologies are intracranial infection (5%) and cerebral dysgenesis (5%). The remaining less common conditions, accounting for 5% to 10% of all seizures, remain important because of potential therapeutic interventions in transient metabolic disorders and inborn errors of metabolism.
The following discussion briefly discusses common seizure etiologies with an emphasis on seizure characteristics. More detailed discussions of the specific clinical entities may be found in the appropriate chapters of this book.
Hypoxic-Ischemic Encephalopathy
Hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy is the most common cause of neonatal seizures in both full-term and premature infants accounting for close to one-half of the causes (see Chapters 16 and 18 ). a
a References .
The seizure burden is often high in the term newborn with hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy, and may result in electrographic status epilepticus in between 10% and 15% of cases. A multicenter observational study of 90 newborns treated with therapeutic hypothermia for hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy and who underwent conventional EEG monitoring identified electrographic seizures in 48%, including 10% with electrographic status epilepticus. Abnormal EEG background features (excessive discontinuity, depressed and undifferentiated patterns, burst suppression, or extremely low voltage) were associated with seizures, but no perinatal variables, including pH less than 6.8, base excess ≤−20, or 10-minute Apgar ≤3, predicted seizure occurrence. Similarly, an earlier single center of 26 consecutive newborns with hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy undergoing therapeutic hypothermia and continuous conventional EEG monitoring identified electrographic seizures in 65%, which were entirely nonconvulsive in 47% with seizures, and constituted electrographic status epilepticus in 23% with seizures. Regarding the timing of seizures in hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE), conventional teaching has been that seizures generally occur in the initial 24 hours of life and become more frequent from 12 to 24 hours after birth. Recent studies using EEG monitoring in consecutive newborns with hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy confirmed that seizures are most common in the initial 24 hours, but that they can initiate during hypothermia or rewarming, and rarely after a return to normothermia ( Fig. 12.12 ).There is some evidence that therapeutic hypothermia may reduce electrographic seizure exposure in newborns . However, comparing seizure incidence on studies conducted before and after therapeutic hypothermia utilization may not reflect a reduction in seizures because most studies performed initially relied on clinical observation for seizure identification while most studies performed later used EEG monitoring for seizure identification. Data obtained before the implementation of therapeutic hypothermia as a neuroprotective strategy reported EEG seizures in 22% to 64% of newborns. In newborns with moderate to severe hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy managed with therapeutic hypothermia, seizures were identified in 30% to 65%. A single-center study did note a significant reduction in EEG seizure burden in newborns with moderate (but not severe) hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy who underwent therapeutic hypothermia compared with those who did not receive this treatment, after controlling for degree of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)–assessed injury, suggesting that therapeutic hypothermia had anticonvulsant therapeutic impact. Similarly, a retrospective study of 107 newborns with hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy identified seizures in 37 with EEG monitoring. The EEG tracings could be analyzed in 31 newborns, including 15 who received therapeutic hypothermia and 16 who did not receive therapeutic hypothermia. EEG monitoring was initiated earlier in newborns who received therapeutic hypothermia, and despite that group having a longer opportunity for seizure identification with EEG monitoring, the recorded electrographic seizure burden in the cooled group was significantly lower than in the noncooled group (60 vs. 203 minutes). However, this difference was only apparent in those with moderate hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy.
As described earlier, multiple animal and human studies suggest that seizures exacerbate existing cerebral injury. Thus, most clinicians aim to identify and manage seizures in these newborns. A statement from the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends that centers performing therapeutic hypothermia in newborns with hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy have either aEEG or conventional EEG available for seizure identification .
Ischemic Stroke
Ischemic stroke is the second most common cause of neonatal seizures in full-term newborns, accounting for between 10% and 20% of cases (see Chapter 21 ). The incidence of perinatal arterial stroke is approximately 1 in 1600 to 5000. At least half of neonatal stroke cases are not recognized in the neonatal period, but for those that are diagnosed in the neonatal period, up to 97% present with seizures and 50% have seizures as the only recognized sign. Compared to newborns with more diffuse brain injury, such as hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy, those with neonatal stroke as a cause of seizures are more likely to appear active and alert between seizures. In addition, seizures due to arterial ischemic stroke tend to occur after the first 12 hours of life; that is, somewhat later than those due to hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (see Chapter 22 ). The risk of developing subsequent epilepsy ranges from approximately 10% to 50%, depending on time to follow-up and inclusion criteria.
Cerebral sinus venous thrombosis occurs less frequently than arterial stroke in newborns, affecting approximately 1 in 8 to 38,000 children per year; 42% to 78% of these newborns have experienced a venous infarct. Seizures are the presenting symptom or a complication of cerebral sinus venous thrombosis in 55% to 80% of the cases, but affected newborns usually also manifest diffuse and focal neurological deficits.
Intracranial Hemorrhage
Intracranial hemorrhage may be difficult to establish conclusively as a cause of seizures distinct from hypoxic-ischemic or traumatic injury because of the frequent association of one or both of these factors with the hemorrhage. Nevertheless, approximately 15% of term infants have intracranial hemorrhage as the primary cause of their seizure, and this incidence is higher in premature infants. In the contemporary multicenter neonatal seizure registry study described earlier, intracranial hemorrhage was the etiology in 12% of newborns with seizures, and in the large previously described single-center cohort, 12% had intracranial hemorrhage as the etiology.
Intracerebral hemorrhage often presents with seizures in newborns. In one prospective study of newborns and children with intracerebral hemorrhage, 60% of 20 newborns with intracerebral hemorrhage presented with seizures. In addition, 18 subjects underwent EEG during the acute period, including EEG monitoring in 13, and EEG-only seizures were identified in 25% of the 20 newborns.
Primary subarachnoid hemorrhage , although very common, is usually not of major clinical significance. Nevertheless, seizures can occur secondary to subarachnoid hemorrhage in the full-term infant, and in that context the spells most often have their onset on the second postnatal day. Newborns with subarachnoid hemorrhage in association with hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy usually exhibit seizures on the first postnatal day, probably as a result of the encephalopathy rather than the hemorrhage. In the interictal period, newborns with seizures secondary to uncomplicated subarachnoid hemorrhage often appear remarkably well.
Germinal matrix-intraventricular hemorrhage , emanating from small blood vessels in the subependymal germinal matrix, is principally a lesion of the premature infants, occurring in the first 3 days of life (see Chapter 24 ). Seizures in association with this type of hemorrhage usually occur with severe lesions or with accompanying parenchymal involvement or both. In one series of EEG-confirmed seizures, 28 of 62 (45%) of preterm newborns had severe intraventricular hemorrhage with or without periventricular hemorrhagic infarction. More recent studies have documented a high incidence of seizures in the preterm infant in the first 72 hours of life, and these were strongly associated with the presence of intraventricular hemorrhage (IVH). In one study, 95 very preterm infants (<30 weeks gestational age) underwent aEEG monitoring during the first 72 hours of life. The overall incidence of seizures in this sample was 48%. High seizure burden was associated with increased risk of IVH throughout each of the 3 days of monitoring. The seizures observed in this very preterm cohort demonstrated a similar evolution in time line to the seizures of a term infant suffering from HIE with the highest median seizure burden during the 0- to 24-hour period. These observations support the potential role of perinatal asphyxia in the pathway to IVH.
Subdural hemorrhage is often associated with a traumatic event, and it is probably the associated cerebral contusion that results in the convulsive phenomena (see Chapter 22 ). The most common variety of subdural hemorrhage is the convexity type, and the seizures in this setting are often focal. Historically, in one large series, convulsive phenomena occurred in 50% of newborns with subdural hemorrhage and appeared in the first 48 hours of life. However, in more recent series with less severe hemorrhages, the vast majority of subdural hemorrhages were asymptomatic. In most newborns with extra-axial hemorrhage, no neurosurgical intervention is required, and following resolution of the acute symptomatic seizures, the prognosis is excellent.
Intracranial Infection
Intracranial bacterial and nonbacterial infections are not uncommon causes of neonatal seizures (see Chapters 34 and 35 ). In the contemporary multicenter neonatal seizure registry study described earlier, infection was the etiology in 4% of newborns with seizures. There is an equal incidence in preterm and term infants. Infections can include congenital infections (such as TORCH [ T oxoplasmosis, O ther, R ubella, C ytomegalovirus, and H erpes infections] infection) or acute CNS infections. Of the bacterial infections, meningitides secondary to Group B streptococci and Escherichia coli are the most common pathogens. The onset of seizures in these instances is usually in the latter part of the first week and subsequent to that period. The relevant nonbacterial infections include the various neonatal encephalitides: toxoplasmosis, herpes simplex, coxsackievirus B infection, rubella, and cytomegalovirus infection. In intrauterine toxoplasmosis or cytomegalovirus infection that is severe enough to result in neonatal seizures, the episodes occur in the first 3 days of life. Seizures associated with herpes simplex encephalitis tend to occur after 7 days of life. Early-onset disseminated herpes simplex virus (HSV) disease does not usually present with seizures. Seizures are more common in term infants with localized CNS rather than disseminated disease. The infant with this variety of neonatal HSV infection usually has been discharged from the hospital before the illness begins. The usual signs are stupor and irritability, which evolve to seizures (often focal) and, perhaps, coma.
Developmental Defects
Many aberrations of brain development can result in seizures, which begin at any time during the neonatal period. In the contemporary multicenter neonatal seizure registry study described previously, brain malformations were the etiology in 4% of newborns with seizures. Similarly, in prior studies malformations of cortical development accounted for 5% to 9% of neonatal seizures. Common malformations include tuberous sclerosis, focal cortical dysplasia, hemimegalencephaly, lissencephaly, subcortical band heterotopia, periventricular nodular heterotopia, schizencephaly, and polymicrogyria (see Chapters 5 and 6 ). Though these disorders may be the cause of a substantial percent of neonatal seizures, most patients with these malformations do not have seizures in the neonatal period. In tuberous sclerosis, only 5% of children develop seizures in the neonatal period. Outcomes depend primarily on the type and severity of malformation.
Metabolic Disturbances
This category includes abnormalities in the levels of glucose, calcium, magnesium, electrolytes, amino acids, organic acids, blood ammonia, and other metabolites; certain intoxications, especially with local anesthetics; mitochondrial or peroxisomal disturbance; pyridoxine and folinic acid responsive seizures (FARS); and glucose transporter deficiency ( Table 12.20 ). The aberrations in levels of glucose and divalent cations are the most frequent. In the contemporary multicenter neonatal seizure registry study described earlier, the etiology was a transient metabolic disturbance in 4% and an inborn error of metabolism in 3% of newborns with seizures.
Hypoglycemia |
Hypocalcemia and hypomagnesemia |
Local anesthetic intoxication |
Hyponatremia |
Hypernatremia (especially during correction) |
Amino acidopathy (especially nonketotic hyperglycinemia) |
Organic acidopathy |
Hyperammonemia (often associated with acidopathies) |
Mitochondrial disturbance (pyruvate dehydrogenase, cytochrome- c oxidase) |
Peroxisomal disturbance (Zellweger syndrome, neonatal adrenoleukodystrophy) |
Pyridoxine dependency (also pyridoxal-5-phosphate deficiency) |
Folinic acid–responsive seizures |
Glucose transporter deficiency DEND HI/HA syndrome |
Hypoglycemia.
Hypoglycemia is most frequent in small newborns, most of whom are small for their gestational age, and in infants of mothers who are diabetic or prediabetic (see Chapter 25 ). Hypoglycemia is thought to be responsible for approximately 3% of neonatal seizures, although the incidence has been falling with improved neonatal care. The most critical determinants for the occurrence of neurological symptoms in neonatal hypoglycemia are the duration of the hypoglycemia and, as a corollary, the amount of time elapsed before treatment is begun . Neurological symptoms consist most commonly of jitteriness, stupor, hypotonia, apnea, and seizures. In a review of infants who were small for their gestational age and who had hypoglycemia, approximately 80% exhibited neurological symptoms; and more than 50% of symptomatic infants who were small for their gestational age experienced seizures. The onset is usually the second postnatal day. In these newborns, it is often particularly difficult to establish that hypoglycemia is the cause of the neurological syndrome, because perinatal asphyxia, hemorrhage, hypocalcemia, and infection are frequently associated. In an earlier series, although 9% of infants with seizures experienced hypoglycemia, in none was the metabolic defect the only potential etiological factor. In a more recent series, only 3% of neonatal seizures were related to hypoglycemia. In contrast to the situation with small infants, neurological symptoms, including seizures, are much less frequent in hypoglycemic infants of diabetic mothers (10% to 20%), possibly because the duration of hypoglycemia in the latter infants is relatively brief. Hypoglycemia significant enough to trigger seizures is often associated with adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes.
Hypocalcemia.
Hypocalcemia has two major peaks of incidence in the newborn . The first peak, which takes place in the first 2 to 3 days of life, occurs most often in low-birth-weight newborns, both of average and below-average weight for their gestational age, and in infants of diabetic mothers. In an earlier series, 13% of the infants with seizures exhibited hypocalcemia, but as with hypoglycemia, the metabolic defect was not the only major etiological possibility. In a later series, hypocalcemia was the cause of 3% of neonatal seizures. A therapeutic response to intravenous calcium is of major value in determining whether the low serum calcium is related etiologically to the seizures. Early hypocalcemia may be a condition associated with neonatal seizures rather than the cause.
When hypocalcemia appears later in the neonatal period , without the complicated associated factors of early-onset hypocalcemia, delineation of hypocalcemia as the major etiological factor in the convulsive phenomena is easier. Classically, these hypocalcemic newborns are large, full-term infants who avidly consume a milk preparation with a suboptimal ratio of phosphorus to calcium and phosphorus to magnesium (e.g., cow’s milk or a high-phosphorus synthetic formula). Hypomagnesemia is a frequent accompaniment, or, more rarely, may be present without hypocalcemia. The neurological syndrome is consistent and distinctive, involving primarily the following: hyperactive tendon reflexes; knee, ankle, and jaw clonus; jitteriness; and seizures. The convulsive phenomena are often focal, both clinically and electroencephalographically. Later-onset hypocalcemia of the nutritional type is unusual in the United States. Later-onset hypocalcemic seizures are associated more commonly with endocrinopathy (maternal hyperparathyroidism, neonatal hypoparathyroidism) or with congenital heart disease (with or without DiGeorge syndrome). Primary hypomagnesemia—a rare defect of magnesium absorption—may produce a syndrome similar to that just described for late-onset hypocalcemia. The onset of seizures is most commonly between 2 and 6 weeks of age. Because calcium levels also may be low, the mistaken diagnosis of primary hypocalcemia may be made. Parenteral administration of magnesium prevents the seizures and early infantile death.
Local Anesthetic Intoxication.
Seizures are a prominent feature of neonatal intoxication with local anesthetics, which are inadvertently injected, usually into the infant’s scalp, at the time of placement of paracervical, pudendal, or epidural block or local anesthesia for episiotomy. Although direct injection into the fetus is the usual mode of administration, transplacental transmission is possible. Paracervical and pudendal blocks have been the most common forms of maternal analgesia involved in the well-documented cases of fetal injection. Two distinguishing features of local anesthetic intoxication aid in the differential diagnosis : (1) pupils fixed to light and often dilated and (2) eye movements fixed to the oculocephalic (doll’s eyes) reflex. These latter signs are unusual in hypoxic-ischemic disease in the first 12 hours. The finding that infants with intoxication improve over the first 24 to 48 hours (if properly supported) further distinguishes the disorder from severe hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy. Clinical signs suggestive of local anesthetic intoxication should alert the physician to a particularly careful inquiry into the obstetrical history and to a search for needle marks on the infant’s scalp. Determination of local anesthetic levels in blood and CSF establishes the diagnosis. Management depends on prompt recognition. Vigorous support, especially of ventilation, is essential. The therapy required depends, in part, on the time of recognition of the intoxication; the half-life of the drug in blood is approximately 8 to 10 hours. Removal of the drug is accomplished more effectively by diuresis with acidification of the urine than by exchange transfusion. Antiseizure medications are of questionable value, and control of seizures is effected best by removal of the local anesthetic. The outcome is good if complications do not occur.
Other Metabolic Disturbances.
Metabolic disturbances other than hypoglycemia and deficiency of divalent cations are uncommon causes of seizures in the newborn (see Table 12.20 ). Worthy of note are hyponatremia and hypernatremia, hyperammonemia, other amino acid and organic acid abnormalities, mitochondrial disturbances, peroxisomal disorders, pyridoxine dependency, FARS, and glucose transporter deficiency. These metabolic disturbances are all discussed much more extensively in Chapter 27 , Chapter 28 , Chapter 29 .
Hyponatremia may result in seizures and often occurs with inappropriate antidiuretic hormone secretion in the context of bacterial meningitis, intracranial hemorrhage, hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy, or excessive intake of water. The latter may occur in a child with minor gastrointestinal difficulties with inappropriate dilution of formula or excess water (in place of formula) intake. Hypernatremia occurs primarily in severely dehydrated infants or as a complication of overly vigorous use of sodium bicarbonate for the correction of acidosis. Seizures often result during the correction of hypernatremia if markedly hypotonic solutions are used, perhaps secondary to the development of intracellular edema. Seizures are most likely to arise in the setting of overly rapid correction with hypotonic fluids.
Inborn errors of metabolism may also present with neonatal seizures, and these conditions are discussed in much more detail in Chapters 27 and 28 . Disturbances of amino acid or organic acid metabolism may result in neonatal seizures, virtually always in the context of other neurological features. The most common of these associated with neonatal seizures are nonketotic hyperglycinemia, sulfite oxidase deficiency, multiple carboxylase deficiency, multiple acyl-coenzyme A dehydrogenase deficiency (glutaric aciduria, type II), and urea cycle defect. Hyperammonemia or acidosis (or both) most commonly accompanies these disturbances. Transient disturbance of the glycine cleavage enzyme may cause neonatal seizures; the diagnosis can be missed if CSF glycine levels are not determined because plasma glycine levels may be normal. The process resolves spontaneously after approximately 6 weeks of age.
Additional unusual causes of neonatal seizures in this context include mitochondrial or peroxisomal disturbance (see Chapter 29 ). Of the former, pyruvate dehydrogenase deficiency and cytochrome c oxidase deficiency, with elevated lactate in blood and CSF, are the most common. Although not strictly a “metabolic” disturbance, peroxisomal disease, especially Zellweger syndrome or neonatal adrenoleukodystrophy, associated with elevations of blood levels of very-long-chain fatty acids and other biochemical changes, is associated with severe neonatal seizures, caused by associated cerebral neuronal migrational defects.
Pyridoxine dependency , a disturbance in pyridoxine metabolism, may produce severe seizures that are recalcitrant to usual therapy (see Chapter 29 ). Onset is usually in the first hours of life, but intrauterine seizures as well as onset after the neonatal period have been observed. Seizures are usually multifocal clonic and recalcitrant to all therapeutic modalities. There is an associated newborn encephalopathy, which may manifest as hyperalertness, tremulousness, or hypothermia. A prodrome of restlessness, irritability, and emesis preceding seizures has been described. A progressive encephalopathy and ultimately death ensue if treatment is not initiated.
Generalized tonic-clonic seizures, a rare form of neonatal seizure, have been described in newborns with pyridoxine dependency. However, the clinical presentation may be varied. Clinical studies also indicate that the disorder may begin after days or weeks; that the seizures may respond initially to anticonvulsant medications; and that doses of pyridoxine greater than 100 mg may be necessary to stop the seizures.
Any suspicion of the disorder should lead to a therapeutic trial of pyridoxine (see later). The diagnosis may be suspected from the EEG that usually shows an unusual paroxysmal pattern consisting of generalized bursts of bilaterally synchronous high-voltage 1- to 4-Hz activity with intermixed spikes or sharp waves ( Fig. 12.13 ). Diagnosis is supported by documentation of cessation of seizures and normalization of the EEG findings within minutes after intravenous injection of 50 to 100 mg of pyridoxine. The EEG findings may not normalize for several hours, even when a prompt seizure response is observed. Subsequently complete control of seizures on pyridoxine monotherapy and recurrence on withdrawal established the diagnosis.
Most infants have exhibited subsequent intellectual disability despite therapy from the first days of life. Nevertheless, early therapy may decrease the likelihood or severity, or both, of intellectual deficit; indeed, 8 of the 10 reported infants with normal intellect were identified and treated in the first month of life. However, many infants treated in the first month still exhibit cognitive deficits later. Intrauterine therapy by maternal pyridoxine supplementation may be necessary to prevent fetal brain injury.
The molecular defect involves the active form of pyridoxine, pyridoxal-5-phosphate, necessary for the action of GAD, which leads to the synthesis of the inhibitory neurotransmitter GABA. This formulation is supported by the finding of low GABA levels as well as elevated glutamate levels in CSF. The disturbance of pyridoxal-5 phosphate results because of its inactivation by alpha-amino adipic semialdehyde (AASA), an intermediate in the degradation of lysine. AASA accumulates because of a defect in its degradation by AASA dehydrogenase (antiquitin), the result of a mutation in the ALDH7A1 gene. Elevated urinary AASA is a reliable biomarker for the diagnosis of antiquitin deficiency and, hence, pyridoxine-dependent seizures. The major structural features in pyridoxine-dependent seizures include evidence for both neuronal and white matter injury, with diffuse cortical atrophy, callosal thinning, and impaired cerebral myelination. These findings may relate to the elevation in CSF and brain of glutamate, caused by the molecular defect. Glutamate may lead to neuronal injury by excitotoxic mechanisms and to oligodendroglial injury by free radical mechanisms. Intrauterine onset of anatomical disturbance is suggested by the fetal imaging finding of partial hypoplasia of the corpus callosum.
Pyridoxamine phosphate oxidase deficiency (PNPO) is a related neonatal epileptic disorder involving synthesis of pyridoxal-5-phosphate. The molecular defect involves PNPO, which is required for synthesis of pyridoxal-5-PO 4 . The clinical presentation often includes fetal seizures, and infants are often premature and exhibit an encephalopathy as well as seizures. The disorder requires treatment with pyridoxal-5 phosphate; pyridoxine, not unexpectedly, is not effective therapy. Folinic acid-responsive seizures refer to a clinical syndrome of neonatal seizures with onset as early as the first hours of life, responsiveness to oral administration of folinic acid, and the presence on CSF analysis for monoamine neurotransmitters of two unknown metabolic peaks (see Chapter 29 ). The disorder is accompanied by a discontinuous EEG pattern with multifocal sharp waves and progressive cerebral cortical and white matter atrophy. The seizures respond to oral folinic acid at doses ranging from 2 to 20 mg twice daily; the lowest doses have been used in the neonatal period. At least 50% of the infants have had subsequent cognitive deficits. Recent data indicate that FARS and pyridoxine-dependent seizures are syndromes caused by the same genetic defects (see Chapter 29 ).
A disorder of glucose transport from blood to brain is important to recognize because prompt treatment can lead to the cessation of seizures and to improved neurological development. This disorder is caused by an autosomal dominant, heterozygous mutation in the GLUT1 transporter (SLC2A1 gene) (see Chapter 29 ). Approximately 25% of cases have had onset of seizures in the first 2 months of life. The mean age of onset of seizures is 5 months. The striking metabolic findings are low glucose concentrations in CSF with normal blood glucose concentration. The mean ratio of CSF to blood glucose has been 37%. That the hypoglycorrhachia was not the result of increased glycolysis, but rather of impaired glucose transport, is shown by the consistent finding of a low (rather than high) lactate level in CSF. The impaired glucose transport is related to a defect of the glucose transporter (Glut1) responsible for the facilitative diffusion of glucose across the blood-brain endothelial barrier and across the neuronal plasma membrane. Treatment with a ketogenic diet, which supplies usable metabolic fuel for brain energy metabolism not transported by the glucose transporter, is generally effective in leading to seizure control and may blunt the impaired neurological development that is a consistent feature of the disease. However, in general, the beneficial effect of the ketogenic diet is most apparent for seizure control.
DEND refers to a syndrome characterized by developmental delay, epilepsy, and neonatal diabetes. Characteristic features are a severe neonatal-onset epileptic encephalopathy and diabetes mellitus, associated with a channelopathy involving the endocrine pancreas and the brain. The molecular defect involves an ATP-dependent potassium channel (KATP), responsive to the ratio of intracellular ATP/ADP concentrations. This channel normally closes when the ATP/ADP ratio rises; that is, in association with increased blood glucose. Thus, potassium remains intracellular, and the cell depolarizes. The depolarization leads to Ca 2+ influx and thereby to physiological insulin release. This mechanism serves to regulate insulin release moment-by-moment in response to blood glucose. In DEND, the channels are unable to close properly. Treatment with insulin is inadequate and does not ameliorate the neurological manifestations. However, sulfonylurea, an oral hypoglycemic agent, binds to the channel, promoting closure and physiological insulin release. Prompt recognition and treatment of this syndrome with oral hypoglycemic agents and not systemic insulin administration are essential for a good neurological outcome.
The HI/HA syndrome (hyperinsulinism/hyperammonemia syndrome) also involves regulation of insulin secretion and is associated with neonatal and infantile seizures. The median age of presentation is 4 to 5 months, although approximately 20% exhibit seizures in the first 72 hours of life in association with hypoglycemia. The hypoglycemia is caused by hyperinsulinism. The molecular defect involves glutamate dehydrogenase (GDH), which generates ATP through the oxidation of glutamate. The rise in ATP to ADP ratio results in closure of K ATP channel and insulin secretion, as discussed re: DEND syndrome. The mutation in the responsible gene ( GLUD1 ) impairs its normal inhibition by GTP. Leucine, an endogenous activator of GDH, then operates unopposed to activate GDH and leads to the molecular events described previously for insulin release. Management of the hyperinsulinism in this disorder is accomplished with diazoxide, which promotes the opening of the K ATP channel, thereby inhibiting insulin release. Protein restriction is also useful. The hyperammonemia is mild, is related primarily to upregulated GDH in kidney, and is unrelated to the neurological phenomena. On follow-up, affected infants later exhibit principally atypical absence seizures, learning disabilities, and behavioral problems.
Drug Withdrawal
A rare cause of seizures is passive addiction of the newborn and drug withdrawal. The drugs particularly involved are narcotic-analgesics (e.g., methadone), sedative-hypnotics (e.g., shorter-acting barbiturates), propoxyphene, tricyclic antidepressants, cocaine, and alcohol (see Chapter 38 ). The usual time of onset of seizures in this setting is the first several days of life.
Neonatal Epilepsy Syndromes
As described earlier, most neonatal seizures represent acute symptomatic (provoked) seizures, but there are rare newborns with epilepsy. Several neonatal syndromes are principally distinguished according to their clinical features (see Tables 12.19 and 12.21 ). The current International League Against Epilepsy classification system defines several electroclinical syndromes with onset in the neonatal and infantile periods. An epilepsy syndrome was defined as “a complex of clinical features, signs, and symptoms that together define a distinctive, recognizable clinical disorder.” These distinctive disorders are identifiable on the basis of a typical age of onset, specific EEG characteristics, seizure types, and other factors which, when taken together, permit a specific diagnosis. The classification and terminology used to describe these syndromes have evolved over time. The five major neonatal epilepsy syndromes are discussed next.
BFNE Benign nonfamilial neonatal convulsions (fifth-day fits) |
EME |
EIEE (Ohtahara syndrome) |
Malignant migrating partial seizures |
Benign Familial Neonatal Epilepsy.
This syndrome is an autosomal dominant condition manifesting with seizures in the first week of life. Seizure onset is usually on the second or third postnatal day, and in the interictal period the newborn appears well. The seizures most often are focal clonic, focal tonic, or apneic and may occur with a frequency of 10 to 20 per day or higher. The electroclinical characteristics are typical and consist of an initial brief period of EEG flattening, accompanied by apnea and motor activity, followed by a bilateral discharge of spikes and slow waves, accompanied by clonic activity. The disorder is usually self-limited, with cessation of seizures in 1 to 12 months. Neurological development is usually normal. However, about 10% to 15% of children develop epilepsy later in life. Family histories indicate autosomal dominant inheritance with incomplete penetrance. However, because of the benign course of the disorder, the history of previously affected family members may be overlooked unless specifically sought by direct questioning of parents and sometimes grandparents. Two separate chromosomal loci have been identified (i.e., chromosome 20q13.3 and chromosome 8q24). Both genes encode voltage-gated potassium channels (KCNQ2 on chromosome 20 and KCNQ3 on chromosome 8), which may function in the same heteromeric complex to regulate the threshold for neuronal excitability. BFNE has also been reported in patients with mutations in PRRT2 and genes coding for a sodium channel subunit (SCN2A). Mutations in these genes are associated with a spectrum of diseases, including neonatal epileptic encephalopathies. A study of 36 families, which included 33 families with BFNE, found 27 of these families had KCNQ2 mutations, one had a KCNQ3 mutation, and two had SCN2A mutations.
Benign Nonfamilial Neonatal Convulsions.
This syndrome is also referred to as “fifth-day fits” or benign idiopathic neonatal seizures. It was initially described in Australia and France, and subsequently elsewhere, and is characterized by the onset of seizures in the latter part of the first week of life in apparently healthy full-term infants. The peak time of onset is the fifth day, and approximately 80% to 90% have had their onset between the fourth and sixth days of life. The seizures are usually multifocal clonic, often with apnea. Status epilepticus has occurred in approximately 80% of cases. Despite the abrupt onset and frequent status epilepticus, in most patients seizures cease after 24 hours, and in all patients within 15 days. The patient is normal between seizures; diagnostic testing, including standard laboratory tests and neuroimaging, are normal; and the prognosis is consistently favorable. The interictal EEG is generally normal, although a nonspecific theta pattern referred to as “theta pointu alternant” has been described in some patients. Anticonvulsant medications are often administered acutely in view of status epilepticus, but long-term therapy is generally not needed in view of the self-resolution of seizures in these patients. The demonstration of low zinc levels in the CSF of affected patients raised the possibility of an acute zinc deficiency syndrome, but the origin of the zinc deficiency and confirmation thereof have not been defined. The possibility that some cases of benign nonfamilial neonatal convulsions are related to de novo mutations of KCNQ2, the K + channel most commonly affected in benign familial neonatal seizures (described earlier), is suggested by a description of four infants.
Early Myoclonic Encephalopathy and Early Infantile Epileptic Encephalopathy (Ohtahara Syndrome).
Early myoclonic encephalopathy (EME) and EIEE or Ohtahara syndrome, characteristically present clinically in the first weeks of life ( Tables 12.22 and 12.23 ). However, in some patients, these may not present until several weeks or rarely even several months of life. Intrauterine onset has been documented. These disorders are characterized by severe recurrent seizures, principally myoclonic and clonic at the onset in EME and tonic spasms at the onset in EIEE, and a striking suppression-burst EEG pattern. Patients with EME tend to have myoclonic seizures involving any part of the body but may also experience focal motor seizures and tonic spasms. Patients with EIEE tend to have frequent clusters of tonic spasms but may also have focal motor seizures. However, the characteristics of the suppression-burst EEG pattern differ (see Table 12.22 ); in EME, the burst-suppression feature is enhanced by sleep and tends to involve high amplitude bursts followed by brief periods of suppression, whereas in EIEE the pattern is not altered by sleep or waking and is a more typical burst-suppression pattern. Further, the evolution of the EEG pattern differs ; in EME the burst-suppression pattern persists, whereas in EIEE the pattern evolves to hypsarrhythmia and West syndrome. The primary etiologies also differ ; in EME the causes are primarily metabolic (especially nonketotic hyperglycinemia but also other amino acid and organic acid disorders), whereas in EIEE the causes are primarily structural (primarily dysgenetic, i.e., migrational defects, microencephaly or hemimegalencephaly, but also encephaloclastic, i.e., hypoxic-ischemic, disorders). Definition of an etiological mechanism is possible in most cases of EIEE, whereas as many as 50% of cases of EME are cryptogenic. Of the structural bases for EIEE, the rare lesion, dentato-olivary dysplasia, is the most difficult to identify in vivo. In addition, while structural malformations are the most common causes of EIEE, many genetic mutations have been reported to cause EIEE (see Table 12.22 ). The predominant genetic defect in EIEE is STXBP1, found in 20% to 30% of patients. STXBP1 promotes the formation of functional vesicle fusion complexes via interaction with two N-terminal domains of syntaxin 1a, and a loss of function mutation impairs this interaction. Patients with STXBP1 encephalopathy present in the neonatal period with severe epilepsy and a suppression-burst pattern on EEG. While refractory seizures are typical, the core of the phenotypic spectrum is the encephalopathy, which is present in the neonatal period.
CLINICAL FEATURES | EME | EIEE (OHTAHARA SYNDROME) |
---|---|---|
Major clinical seizure types at onset | Myoclonic (also focal motor clonic and tonic) | Tonic spasms (also focal motor clonic) |
Electroencephalographic interictal pattern | Suppression burst | Suppression burst |
Relation to sleep | Enhanced by sleep | Same asleep and awake |
Evolution | Persistent suppression burst | Transition to hypsarrhythmia |
Etiology | Metabolic (rarely structural or genetic) | Bilateral structural cerebral lesions (rarely metabolic or genetic) |
Outcome | Unfavorable | Unfavorable |
Genes | ERBB4, PIGA, SETBP1, SIK1, SLC25A22 | STX BP1 in ~30%; KCNQ2 in ~20%; SCN2A in ~10%; AARS, ARX, BRAT1, CACNA2D2, GNAO1, KCNT1, NECAP1, PIGA, PIGQ, SCN8A, SIK1, SLC25A22 |
GENE | TYPE/INHERITANCE | CLINICAL MANIFESTATION | PROTEIN FUNCTION |
---|---|---|---|
ARX | EEIE1/XLR | Ohtahara syndrome | Transcriptional repressor and activator |
SLC25A22 | EIEE3/X homozygous | Ohtahara syndrome | Glutamate transport into mitochondrion |
STXBP | EEIE4/AD | Ohtahara syndrome | Modulator of synaptic vesicle release |
SCN1A | EEIE6/X de novo | Dravet syndrome | Subunit of voltage-gated sodium channel |
PNKP | EEIE10/AR | Microcephaly, seizures, and developmental delay | Enzyme involved in DNA repair |
PLCB1 | EIEE12/AR homozygous | Malignant migrating partial seizures in infancy | Phospholipase-C role in intracellular transduction of extracellular signals |
KCNT1 | EEIE14/sporadic | Malignant migrating partial seizures in infancy | Sodium-activated potassium channel subunit |
The second most common genetic defect in EIEE involves KCNQ2 and accounts for 10% of cases. The phenotype is characterized by profound neonatal encephalopathy with severe, frequent, intractable seizures that have been termed KCNQ2 encephalopathy. In contrast to BFNE related to KCNQ2 defect (see earlier), the interictal EEG before anticonvulsant administration is multifocal, and there is hypotonia, paucity of spontaneous movements, no visual fixation, and altered reactivity. Whereas mutations that lead to BFNE result in mild reductions in potassium current, the de novo mutations responsible for KCNQ2 encephalopathy represent more profound alterations, in some cases through a dominant negative effect or even via gain of function. The best success to date for the management of seizures in KCNQ2 encephalopathy has been with sodium channel blockers and with carbamazepine in particular. Indeed, carbamazepine is emerging as an old drug with a new indication in treating early-onset genetic epilepsies, as relative success has also been reported in treating early epilepsy associated with SCN2A and SCN8A, sodium channel gene defects.
Malignant Migrating Partial Seizures of Infancy.
This rare neonatal epilepsy syndrome is striking. Although the usual time of onset of the seizure disorder is at 1 to 3 months, onset in the first days of life has been reported, and approximately one-half of cases have had onset in the first month of life. The seizures are focal clonic at the onset, and over the ensuing weeks become multifocal, extremely frequent, and intractable to antiseizure medications. One report describes a good therapeutic response to levetiracetam. EEG findings show striking multifocal epileptic activity. Detailed metabolic studies and neuroimaging have been reported to be negative for any abnormality. Neuropathological study has shown no abnormality in the neocortex but pronounced hippocampal neuronal loss. Later neurodevelopmental outcome is poor with death or moderate to severe mental retardation in most infants. However, a report of six cases showed mild deficits in two infants. Genetic defects include de novo mutations involving SCN1A (sodium channel) and KCNT1 (potassium channel) and homozygous mutations involving SLC25A22 (glutamate transport into the mitochondrion) and PLC1 (phospholipase C). Recent case reports indicating that KCNQ2 mutations are associated with this epilepsy syndrome suggest benefit from quinidine therapy.
Diagnosis
Appropriate diagnostic procedures in the newborn infant with seizures can be surmised from the discussion of causes. However, the diagnostic evaluation often is made unnecessarily complicated, and many diagnoses can be strongly suspected by such uncomplicated maneuvers as obtaining a complete prenatal and natal history and performing a careful physical examination. The first laboratory tests to be performed are directed against the two disorders that are dangerous but readily treated when recognized promptly: hypoglycemia and bacterial meningitis. Thus, blood glucose determination and lumbar puncture should be performed as soon as clinically feasible. In addition, blood should be drawn for determinations of Na + , K + , calcium, phosphorus, and magnesium levels. Other imaging and laboratory studies should be directed by specific clinical features. Focal seizures should lead to neuroimaging because of the frequency of focal ischemic cerebral lesions, and MRI is preferred because many focal lesions may not be detected by cranial ultrasound evaluation. As noted earlier, the most common etiologies of neonatal seizures are hypoxic–ischemic encephalopathy, intracranial hemorrhage, and perinatal arterial ischemic stroke. In one study of 354 patients with MRI and ultrasound performed, the diagnosis of important brain lesions would be frequently missed by ultrasound alone. In addition, MRI contributed information beyond ultrasound to the diagnosis in about 40%. Similarly, in a large cohort registry study by the Vermont Oxford Network, the deficiencies of cranial ultrasound and computed tomography scanning compared to MRI for clinically relevant lesions of deep nuclear gray matter injury and focal cortical and white matter injury were highlighted.
Warning signs for inborn errors of metabolism as a cause of neonatal seizures include: (1) seizures beginning in the antepartum period; (2) seizures refractory to anticonvulsant medications; (3) progressive worsening of clinical and EEG abnormalities; (4) EEG showing burst suppression; (5) MRI showing prominent brain atrophy; or (6) findings of hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy without any obvious hypoxic-ischemic event identified. When laboratory testing is performed, the presence of low CSF glucose (but normal blood glucose) should suggest glucose transporter defect; the presence of elevated CSF glycine despite normal blood amino acids should suggest transient or true nonketotic hyperglycinemia; and the presence of elevated CSF lactate should suggest a mitochondrial disorder. Other CSF abnormalities of diagnostic value in this context are discussed in Chapter 29 .
Electroencephalogram and Electroencephalographic Monitoring
EEG provides important diagnostic and prognostic information. Moreover, increasingly, continuous EEG monitoring is performed in neonatal intensive care facilities for several important reasons. EEG data can assist in the determination of whether clinical events are correlated with electrical seizures requiring anticonvulsant medication or with nonepileptic events in which anticonvulsant medication administration can be avoided. As discussed earlier, some seizures have readily identifiable clinical manifestations (i.e., clonic or tonic components), while many seizures have more subtle manifestations (i.e., orolingual, ocular, or autonomic). Thus, clinical diagnosis of seizures may be difficult and unreliable. As described earlier, when compared to the gold standard of EEG data, observers only classify clinical events correctly as seizures about half of the time, and there is poor interobserver agreement. As a result, many nonictal events are classified as seizures, potentially leading to unnecessary exposure to anticonvulsant medications. Second , many newborns experience clinically silent seizures, which can only be identified with EEG. In many clinical settings the majority of electrographic seizures are not accompanied by clinically evident seizures, and the majority of time spent having electrographic seizures is not accompanied by clinically evident seizure activity. Third, in newborns with clinically evident seizures and administration of anticonvulsant medications, EEG-only seizures may persist (electromechanical uncoupling or dissociation). Thus, even if management is initiated based on identification of clinically evident seizures, EEG monitoring may be required to fully assess the impact of management on seizure cessation. Fourth, assessment of the EEG background may provide important prognostic information (discussed later).
As a result of these data, there is increasing emphasis on continuous EEG monitoring to aid in management of seizures in newborns . Many neonatal intensive care units report using EEG monitoring, with conventional EEG or aEEG, to identify and manage neonatal seizures. In addition, recent guidelines and consensus statements have advocated for EEG monitoring. This recommendation has included the need for confirmation of seizures by EEG in specialized settings before therapy and the need for continuous electrophysiological monitoring in the setting of therapeutic hypothermia.
The most comprehensive guideline on continuous EEG monitoring in the newborn was produced in 2011 by the American Clinical Neurophysiology Society. The guideline was created to standardize care and define best neuromonitoring practices in the neonatal population, while recognizing that not all recommendations would be feasible or applicable across institutions. The guideline recommendations included that (1) electrodes be placed using the International 10 to 20 system with additional electrocardiogram, respiratory, eye, and electromyography leads; (2) at least 1 hour of recording be assessed to adequately assess cycling through wakefulness and sleep; (3) high-risk newborns be monitored for at least 24 hours to screen for the presence of electrographic seizures; and (4) in newborns with seizures, monitoring occur during seizure management and for an additional 24 hours after the last electrographic seizure. Video EEG recording was recommended for 24 hours rather than a briefer EEG recording because many newborns will not have seizures in the first hour of recording but will experience electrographic seizures within the first day. Studies in high-risk newborns indicate that the majority of acute seizures occur within 48 hours of the brain insult.
Accurate delineation of seizure phenomena by EEG in the newborn requires experienced electroencephalographers with training in the normal developmental features of EEG in the newborn and skilled EEG technologists for the application of the EEG. A recent report on Standardized EEG Terminology and Categorization for the Description of Continuous EEG Monitoring in Newborns was developed by the American Clinical Neurophysiology Society summarizing the many reports of the EEG accompaniments of neonatal seizures. As summarized earlier (see Table 12.9 ), an electrographic seizure is defined as “a sudden, abnormal electroencephalogram (EEG) event defined by a repetitive and evolving pattern with a minimum 2 microvolt voltage and duration of at least 10 seconds.” The major EEG correlates of neonatal seizures thus consist of focal or multifocal spikes or sharp waves or both and focal rhythmic discharges, occurring as a distinct change from background. These discharges may spread to adjacent cortical regions or to homotypic areas of the contralateral hemisphere. Such discharges are distinguished from normal sharp “transients,” which are random rather than localized, are not rhythmic, do not spread, and are not followed by voltage suppression. Two general points concerning identification of electrical seizure activity in the newborn should be emphasized. First, neonatal seizures tend to be brief, usually lasting less than 2 minutes ( Fig. 12.14 ). Second, electrographic seizures tend to be focal and well localized, arising most commonly from temporal and central regions, less commonly from occipital regions, and least commonly from frontal regions.