Occupational Therapy with Mood Disorders

24
Occupational Therapy with Mood Disorders


Madeleine Duncan1 Claire Prowse1,2


1 Division of Occupational Therapy, Department of Health and Rehabilitation Sciences, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa


2 Occupational Therapy private practitioner, Cape Town, South Africa


Introduction


Mood disorders refer to a group of psychiatric conditions that share the essential features of a disturbance in mood that is not due to any other mental or physical disorder, medication or substance abuse. ‘Mood’ refers to the internal and sustained emotional state of an individual and ‘affect’ to the external expression of emotional content. The American Psychiatric Association (APA 2013) addresses mood disorders in two sections: depressive disorders and bipolar and related disorders. Nowadays, depression and mania are household terms, perhaps because most people have some idea of what it feels like to be ‘down in the dumps’ and ‘blue’ or ‘hyper’, ‘speedy’ and ‘in a frenzy’. However, there is a distinct difference between these symptoms being a sign of normal human emotion and being a sign of a mood disorder. The distinction lies in the type, intensity and duration of the symptoms; the amount of distress they cause to the person and those around them; and the extent to which the symptoms affect functioning and participation in everyday life.


While a focus on the medical aspects of mental illness is necessary, given the significant role that hospitalisation, medication and treatment play in recovery, care should be taken not to reduce occupational therapy to a procedural process aimed at ‘fixing’ the performance component impairments (i.e. symptoms) associated with mood disorders. The term ‘person’ rather than ‘patient’ or ‘client’ is therefore used in this chapter. The person’s behaviour and functioning is best understood, assessed and addressed in occupational therapy by taking into consideration the participation demands of his/her environment. What people are able to do every day and how they go about performing their various life tasks and activities depend as much on their mental and physical state as it does on the environments in which they live, work, play and socialise. For example, poverty, poor living conditions, violence and unemployment require particular forms of coping and adaptation. The occupational therapy proposed must therefore be adjusted with due consideration of the setting within which the service is rendered.


Depressive disorders


By 2020, depressive disorders are expected to be the second biggest cause of disease burden worldwide (Reddy 2010). Given its prevalence, depression has been called the common cold of mental health problems. The term can apply to a transient mood, a sustained change in affect, a symptom, a syndrome or a psychiatric disorder (Checkly 1998). While the causes of depressive disorders are unknown, the complex interaction of multiple factors such as genetic transmission, biochemical imbalance, temperament, emotional trauma and adverse socio-environmental conditions are considered to play a role. Females are more vulnerable to develop depression than males due to hormonal differences, as well as childbirth and social conditions related to women’s roles and stressors (Sadock et al. 2009). One in five women are likely to experience a depressive episode at some point in their lives, with 1 in 10 men being affected (Harkness et al. 2010). Although depression is three times more common in relatives, many professionals do not follow the ‘genetic’ school of thought. They believe that the intergenerational presence of depression within families is the result of ‘a learnt pattern of behaviour’ in which unhealthy coping mechanisms are used to resolve life stressors. Irrespective of its causes, a depressive disorder can be a debilitating mental illness that causes considerable distress and impairment in all areas of functioning. Affected persons report a deep sense of despair and hopelessness beyond their normal emotional experience. These feelings may lead some depressed people to become withdrawn and passive, while others may become irritable and agitated. While some forms of depression may lead to delusional or suicidal thoughts, the cognitions of depressed individuals are usually marked by distortions in ways of explaining things, self-evaluations and information processing. The depressed person’s thoughts are dominated by a view of self as worthless, the world as bleak and the future as hopeless. Through this negative view of the world, they distort experiences and display information processing errors such as overgeneralising and making predictions of poor outcomes. They exaggerate the implications of minor life events, blaming themselves when things go wrong. No matter how bright the day is, how many goals are accomplished or how many compliments are received, the individual tends to find a flaw or a reason for self-criticism. Depressive thinking has a self-sustaining, self-defeating quality that curtails role functioning and occupational performance.


Clinical presentation of depressive disorders and general treatment approaches


Adjustment disorder with depressed mood


The person who is unable to adapt to or resolve a stressful life event may develop a reactive depression. The life event may be unexpected such as physical and/or psychological trauma, retrenchment, death or divorce that creates stressors with which the person is unable to cope. Expected life events such as moving house, getting married or starting a job may also cause significant changes to which the person is unable to adjust. A combination of medicine and psychotherapy including trauma and/or grief counselling is usually effective in resolving the depressed mood and promoting rapid return to premorbid functioning. Intervention aims to support the person in coming to terms with the precipitating problem or to change the perception of the trigger events so that they can adapt to the challenges facing him/her. Occupational therapy may provide psycho-education, life skills training such as strategies to manage stress, anxiety and depression and coaching in the selection of occupations for a mental health-promoting lifestyle.


Dysthymia


As a low-grade, neurotic type of depression, dysthymia is situated in the temperament of individuals who struggle to cope with relatively minor life events. Temperament refers to a person’s disposition and outlook on life. Dysthymic individuals are easily demoralised and have fragile levels of self-worth and agency. Intervention is aimed at the development of emotional and functional resilience through psychotherapeutic methods such as transactional analysis, cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) and assertiveness training. Life coaching including strategies for mental health promotion through occupation is likely to strengthen the individual’s capacity for productive participation in life roles.


Major depression


This is a serious mood disturbance with significant performance component impairments (insomnia, anhedonia, loss of libido) and occupational performance dysfunction (decreased productivity at work, inability to socialise and restricted participation in valued activities). A combination of medicine, psychotherapy and social intervention is indicated. Anti-depressive medication, prescribed by a medical practitioner, includes tricyclic and selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs). Monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs) or electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) may be used for those who do not respond to anti-depressive medication. Psychotherapy may focus on behavioural and cognitive behavioural change, adjusting the person’s self-concept and increasing his/her emotional insight into the maladaptive use of defence mechanisms. Social interventions may address family and other significant relationships as well as ameliorate housing, economic, legal, environmental, educational and other social stressors. Occupational therapy focuses on reducing the person’s vulnerability to depression through psycho-education, life skills training and occupation-centred changes to his/her lifestyle.


Major depression with melancholia


Usually requiring hospitalisation and carefully monitored pharmacological intervention, melancholia is a deep depression in which the person may present in a vegetative state. If the person does not respond to medication and a supportive psychotherapeutic environment, ECT may be indicated especially if the person is a serious suicide risk. Occupational therapy, in the early stages of admission, focuses on activation through sensory integrative therapy followed, in the later stages, by the same methods that apply to a major depression.


Major depression with psychosis


The key features of this type of depression are the simultaneous presence of deep mood disturbances and loss of contact with reality such as nihilistic delusions and catatonia. A dopamine blocker is usually prescribed together with an antidepressant and/or ECT. Occupational therapy will be particularly concerned with the reintegration of the individual into his or her life roles after discharge and aims to prevent a relapse through community-based psychosocial rehabilitation. Promoting participation in a range of meaningful occupations with appropriate support will prevent relapse and facilitate recovery.


Masked depression


Adults with masked depression may engage in uncharacteristic behaviours such as petty theft and excessive alcohol use, while children may exhibit anxiety or behavioural problems. Adolescents may deal with depression through somatisation (headaches, abdominal or other pain) or ‘acting out’ (truancy, substance abuse or multiple accidents) (National Institute of Mental Health 2011). Treatment involves medication and, once the mood lifts, involvement in a supportive, therapeutic environment with a focus on CBT and emotional insight. Occupational therapy will guide the person towards occupations that affirm self-esteem and enable emotions to be expressed in ways that promote a positive sense of identity, purpose and belonging.


Signs, symptoms and functional consequences of depression


The functional consequences of depression can be considered from two angles, firstly, how the mood disturbance affects functioning and, secondly, what functioning is required by the person in his/her various life contexts. Table 24.1 summarises some of the most prominent specifiers (signs and symptoms) and functional consequences of mild and severe depression.


Table 24.1 Signs, symptoms and functional consequences of depression (Duncan in Crouch and Alers 2005).












Mild/moderate depression Functional consequences Severe depression
Lowered drive

Apathy
Indecisiveness
Worrying
Poor attention and concentration
Negative statements about self
Sadness and pessimism

Irritability

Low self-esteem
Loss of spontaneity
Inability to have fun
Withdrawn
Somatisation, for example, headaches

Loss of energy
Chronic fatigue
Insomnia or sleeps a lot

Weight loss or gain
Loss of libido
Uncharacteristic behaviour such as temper outbursts and accident proneness
Insufficient drive, low self-esteem and negative self-talk may lead to poor self-care, an unkempt appearance and a disorganised, untidy or dirty environment at home and at work

The ‘sick role’ may be used for secondary gain. Avoidance of responsibilities may place strain on interpersonal relationships

Apathy may lead to poor productivity that in turn may reinforce a low self-esteem, setting up a vicious cycle of poor occupational performance

The lack of motivation or a lack of pleasure when engaging in the activitiesmay lead to occupational imbalance ordeprivation, for example, avoiding social situations
Masked depression may present as occupational imbalance, for example‘Workaholic’ behaviour
Psychomotor retardation or agitation

Vigorous self-denunciation

Delusions of guilt or nihilism
Excessive rumination about some wrongdoing

Deep sense of despair or rage
Extreme feelings of unworthiness, hopelessness and helplessness

Socially withdrawn and isolated

Excessive psychomotor agitation or psychomotor retardation
Suicide risk

Marked weight loss

Severe sleep problems
Psychotic behaviour such as bizarre motor tics, catatonic posturing or foetal positioningwith loss of contact with reality

The following examples depend on personal circumstances and are presented on a continuum to combine in different ways in different people.


Bipolar disorder


Persons with a bipolar disorder experience both depressive and manic episodes. The manic episode is characterised by an abnormal and persistently elevated, expansive or irritable mood. Swinging from one affective state to the other will vary from person to person in terms of the duration, timing, depth and type of mood change that is experienced. Although there is a significant genetic component to bipolar disorder, some kind of stress usually triggers the onset of a discernible mood change. During an extreme state of excitation, the manic person is clearly psychotic and does not appreciate the consequences of his/her expansive behaviour. In the early and milder stages of mania (called hypomania), family and friends might experience the person as ‘fun’, their happy mood is likely to be infectious, and they may be more creative and productive than usual. The person with hypomania experiences a sense of well-being and increased productivity that may mask more serious aspects of the illness such as irritability, argumentativeness, insomnia, poor judgement and engaging in high-risk behaviours such as casual sexual encounters or making irrational business decisions. Hypomanic symptoms can adversely affect the person’s social life, family life and employment if the illness is not medically managed. Jamison (1995, p. 212), a psychiatrist who has experienced bipolar mood disorder first hand, states, ‘I am too frightened that I will again become morbidly depressed or virulently manic – either of which would, in turn, rip apart every aspect of my life, relationships and work that I find most meaningful – to seriously consider any change in my medical treatment’.


Although medication is the most effective approach for attaining a stable mood and restoring functioning, it may produce unpleasant side effects. Persons with a bipolar disorder have a high relapse rate, that is, 50% in the first 5 months and 80–90% within the 18 months, because of a lack of compliance with medication. Psycho-education for both the individual and the family is likely to promote compliance with medication and encourage consistent use of self-help methods. Psycho-education may include information on the physiology of the disorder, identification of relapse risk factors and strategies for coping with the side effects of medication and lifestyle adjustments to manage stressors. Holistic management of the disorder also includes exercise, support groups, vocational guidance, counselling, leisure enhancement, stress management and creative pursuits. Although relaxation therapy and mentalisation (mind-mindedness) techniques are useful, these self-help techniques can only be used once the manic episode subsides.


Signs, symptoms and functional consequences of mania


As with depressive disorders, the main concerns of occupational therapy are, firstly, to help individuals overcome the functional problems associated with bipolar disorder through occupation-centred interventions and, secondly, to mobilise for the social inclusion of persons with mental health concerns by addressing the attitudinal and structural environments within which they participate. Table 24.2 summarises some signs, symptoms and functional consequences of mania, all of which will vary in intensity, from mild, moderate to severe episodes.


Table 24.2 Signs, symptoms and functional consequences of mania (Duncan in Crouch and Alers 2005).


































Hypomania/mania Functional consequences
Hyperactivity, restlessness, distractibility and psychomotor agitation Too busy and preoccupied to care about taking a bath, washing hair or eating
Increased sexual activity and lack of inhibition Grooming is overdone, makeup is thickly applied, flamboyant clothing (bright colours, lots of jewellery)
Increased creativity and productivity Increased creativity during hypomanic period. High quantity of productivity, sometimes poor quality – starts many projects but seldom completes any due to flight of ideas and poor concentration
Loss of sleep Starts projects or makes promises impulsively with little foresight into feasibility or long-term implications
Racing and pressurised thoughts and speech, flight of ideas, tangential or circumstantial thinking. Jokes and punning are common with rude or vulgar connotations Unable to identify and respond to social cues. Expansive and intrusive interpersonal relationships create tension in social contexts. Overfamiliar with strangers
Ideas of grandeur, unrealistic ideas and grand schemes, religiosity and the indiscriminate spending of money Impulsivity leading to occupational overload and imbalance, for example, shopping sprees, excessive drinking, reckless driving, indiscriminate sexual encounters
Elevated mood, euphoria
Irritability, poor frustration tolerance, argumentative
Expansive behaviour: flamboyant and ‘larger than life’, takes things to the extreme, high risk taking

Assessment


The aims of assessment are to identify the type and severity of performance component impairments, determine the impact of the illness process on occupational performance and identify the barriers and facilitators for participation in the person’s lived environments. Objective information provides both the occupational therapist and the person concerned with a baseline from which to identify recovery goals and ways of addressing the practical challenges of ‘doing’ daily life.


Interview


The psychiatric interview is one way through which a mental state examination is done. It provides information about performance component impairments and activity limitations that the person may be finding difficult. Standardised tests such as the Beck Depression Inventory (Beck 1978) and the Hamilton Depression Inventory (Reynolds & Kobak 1995) can be used to augment the mental state examination. The occupational therapy interview differs from the psychiatric interview by focusing on the person as an occupational being. The term ‘occupational being’ refers to a person who is actively engaged in ‘doing life’ through participation in and performance of various occupations. Besides personal particulars and pertinent background history such as education, work and social circumstances, the occupational therapy interview focuses on the person’s occupational history, occupational environments and current occupational performance. Interviewing also assists in negotiating the person’s recovery goals and in the development of a therapeutic relationship. While interview guidelines such as the Occupational Performance History Interview (OPHI-2), (Kielhofner et al. 2004), the Canadian Occupational Performance Measure (COPM) (Law et al. 2005) and the Occupational Self-Assessment (Baron et al. 2002) provide structure to the information gathering process, they must be adapted to match the socio-economic and cultural context of the interviewee.


Observation


Observation is a skill that involves the discernment and interpretation of information about a person’s mental state and capabilities gathered through the therapist’s five senses. It is used throughout occupational therapy to obtain information about the intrinsic performance components that support occupational performance and about the illness behaviour and its impact on role competence and social inclusion. Observation during activity participation is useful in assessing the impact of a mood disorder on a person’s functioning as there is no room for him/her to filter the information shared with the therapist. Observation during participation in unstructured and structured activities eliminate this dynamic, creating opportunity for realistic self-appraisal and collaborative goal setting. The Assessment of Motor Process Skills (AMPS) (Fisher & Bray Jones 2010) is a useful tool for documenting observations in a community mental health rehabilitation setting. While it provides an extensive evidence base about the quality of performance in activities of daily living for persons residing in resourced environments, the AMPS does not adequately reflect the socio-economic realities of people living in poorly resourced contexts.


Collateral sources


These are valuable sources of information that are used to corroborate or augment the information provided by the person seeking help. Members of the professional mental health team, family members, friends and work colleagues can be approached to gain further factual information and understanding about the impact of the mood disorder on the person’s functioning. As an example, the manic person may feel very positive about his/her ‘happy’ self and be unaware of the negative impact his/her illness is having on relationships and role performance as parent, spouse, worker or friend. Collateral sources may only be approached with informed consent from the person or legal guardian.


Social and occupational mapping


Besides collaborating with the individual in identifying mental health concerns, the occupational therapist also maps the opportunities for personal development and recovery, which are available in the living, socialising, learning and working environments of the person. A map is a visual representation of the person’s social network and sites, offering him or her access to personally meaningful and purposeful occupations. Crane and Mooney (2005) provide an example of a community resource mapping toolkit, which occupational therapists may find useful when adopting a developmental and occupation-centred approach to practice. Hitch et al. (2007) provide an overview of occupational therapy outcome measures in a community mental health setting.


Intervention


Occupational therapy approaches


Person centred


By seeking help, individuals acknowledge that they have a problem with which they cannot cope. Some mood-disordered persons may have an involuntary admission if they are assessed as mentally incompetent and are posing a risk to themselves or others. Involuntary admissions have to follow due legal process in accordance with mental health care acts of the country that protect the rights of persons with mental illness. Being person centred involves working with understanding, empathy and validating the individual’s unique circumstances. It is demonstrated by being ethical, reality focused and solution orientated.


Ethical

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jun 10, 2016 | Posted by in PSYCHIATRY | Comments Off on Occupational Therapy with Mood Disorders

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access