of Positional Therapy: Transition from Tennis Balls to New Devices



Fig. 1
Patents in positional therapy



In 1900, L.E. Wilson, from Nebraska, filed a patent for a “Shoulder brace and antisnoring attachment” [26]. The device consisted of a metal “prodding device”, kept in place by adjustable, washable and ventilated straps. Not only did the device block the patient from adopting the supine position, the device also forced the patient to roll over to a lateral position. The first patent for a device for medical application was filed by T. Thomas in 1907: “A belt and shield to be worn at night to give support to the wearer, prevent his sleeping on his back, to prevent dreaming and snoring…” [27].

In 1908, two patents were filed, both titled “Antisnoring device” by C.F. Rohwer and L.F. Liebhardt. These devices aimed to “provide a simple and easily applied device, which will effectively prevent snoring, sleep talking, bad dreams and other disagreeable features with which many persons contend when sleeping on their backs”, by securing a hollow ball composed of compressible material, such as rubber on the wearer’s back [28, 29].

E.R. Boots invented a new sleeping garment, for which a patent was filed in 1941 [30]. This garment consisted of a pocket sewn onto the back panel of a nightshirt or pyjama, sized to retain a so-called “anti-snore medium such as a sponge rubber ball”. This ball served as an obstacle for the wearer to sleep in supine position.

Under a decade later, the journal CHEST published a letter written by a patient’s wife [31]. She had cured her husband’s sleep apnea snoring problem by “having sewn a pocket into the back of a T-shirt and having inserted a hollow, lightweight plastic ball, to prevent her husband sleeping on his back”. To our best knowledge, this is the first publication of “positional therapy” in medical literature.

It was not until the mid-1980s that the first scientific studies on positional therapy were published.

Kavey published the results of two patients who had been instructed to attach a ball in a sock to the back of their nightshirt in such a way as to make the supine position uncomfortable [32]. Henceforth, variations of the tennis ball techniques have been described in the literature varying from vests, “shark fins” or special pillows, as shown in Table 1. After running a thorough search strategy in the MEDLINE and Embase databases, 24 relevant articles were found. Seven studies were excluded from the overview. Two studies did not provide information on the effect of PT on OSA parameters and were omitted from the overview. Five studies evaluated the effect on OSA of an array of devices resulting in an elevated posture and head extension. As these devices did not prevent the patient from assuming the supine position, the studies were not included in the overview. All studies report positive effect of positional therapy on the AHI [2433, 40, 43, 44, 48, 49, 55, 56, 58].


Table 1
Overview literature on positional therapy





















































































































































































































































































































 
Year

Design

LoE

No.

BMI (kg/m2)

PT method

Mean AHI without PT

Mean AHI with PT

Mean TST in supine position without PT (%)

Mean TST in supine position with PT (%)

AHI in supine position without PT

AHI in supine position with PT

AHI in non-supine position without PT

AHI in non-supine position with PT

Sleep efficiency without PT (%)

Sleep efficiency with PT (%)

Follow-up

Cartwright [48]

1985

Case series

4

10

30.6

Positional alarm

54.7

21.4

51.4

2.1

72.0

11.0

19.3

21.6

ND

ND


Kavey [32]

1985

Case series

4

2/4

24.5

Ball in sock on back

9.2b,c

3.8b,c

40.4c

8.8c

13.7b,c

5.1b,c

ND

ND

ND

ND

4–12 months

Kavey [32]

1985

Case series

4

2/4

26.5

Verbal instructions

40.8b,c

2.8b,c

92.1c

11.2c

42.4b,c

6.9b,c

ND

ND

ND

ND

3–4 months

Cartwright [49]

1991

Case series

4

15/60

ND

Positional alarm

33.3

20.8

141.1f

3.4f

62.5

32.9

9.7

21.7

ND

ND

8 weeks

Cartwright [49]

1991

Case series

4

15/60

ND

Verbal instructions

26.7

7.7

101.3f

16.5f

87.3

26.8

7.7

4.6

ND

ND

8 weeks

Braver [33]

1994

Randomized crossover trial

2b

20

36

Foam wedges

17.5

14.1

68

ND

ND

ND

ND

ND

ND

ND


Jokic [43]

1999

RCT

2b

13

30

Backpack with softball inside

17.9

9.5

25.6

1.

63.8

ND

4.9

ND

ND

82


Maurer [34]

2003

Case series

4

12

26.5

Vest with semirigid foam on dorsal part

26.7

7.6

300f

63f

39.3

ND

5.5

ND

81

83


Zuberi [35]

2004

Case series

4

22

23–48a

Triangular pillow

23.5

11.1

ND

ND

ND

ND

ND

ND

ND

ND


Oksenberg [36]

2006

Case series

4

28825

28.1

Tennis ball technique

46.5

17.5

79

12.3

57.0

44.4

11.6

13.8

80.9

78.9

2 months

Wenzel [37]

2007

Case series

4

12

28.1

Vest with semirigid foam on dorsal part

31.3

13.8

72.2

2.1

ND

ND

ND

ND

86.3

78.9


Loord [38]

2007

Case series

4

18/23

ND

Soft vest attached to a board with pillow

21.8

14.3

ND

ND

50.4

ND

ND

ND

ND

ND

3 months

Skinner [44]

2009

Randomized crossover trial

2b

20

30.7

Thoracic anti-supine band (TASB)

22.7

12.0

34.4

6.3

59.6

37.8

4.7

10.3

ND

ND

1 month

Permut [60]

2010

Randomized crossover trial

2b

38

31

Vest with semirigid foam on dorsal part

11d

2d

40d

0d

31d

ND

2d

ND

89d

88d


Choi [39]

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Oct 17, 2016 | Posted by in PSYCHIATRY | Comments Off on of Positional Therapy: Transition from Tennis Balls to New Devices

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access