on Mechanism and Therapeutic Implications of Spinal Cord Stimulation and Cerebral Hemodynamics: A Narrative Review


Author (year) references

Animal model

Observation method

Site of stimulation

Results

Garcia-March et al. (1987, 1989) [15, 16]

Dog and goat

Electromagnetic flowmetry; 131I antipyrine brain scintigraphy

Upper cervical (C2)

Increase of CBF at the common and internal carotid level of more than 60 % and an increase of CBF of more than 50 % increase in cerebral blood flow

Visocchi et al. (1994) [57]

Rabbit

Electromagnetic flowmetry; CW Doppler

Cervical

Reduction of sympathetic excitability

Isono et al. (1995) [23]

Cat

Hydrogen clearance method

Cervical

No CBF effects during SCS after lesion of dorsal column

Sagher and Huang (2000), Zhong (2006) [52, 76]

Rat

Laser Doppler flowmetry

Cervical

Changes in CBF were significantly attenuated after interruption of sympathetic or parasympathetic pathways

Patel et al. (2003) [44]

Rat

Laser Doppler flowmetry

Cervical

Sympathetic nervous system blockers (hexamethonium and prazosin) abolish the SCS-induced increase in CBF

Patel et al. 2004 [45]

Rat

14C-inosine monophosphate radiotracer studies

Cervical

Spinal transection strongly attenuated the effect of SCS on CBF, otherwise no similar effect in cases of superior cervical ganglion resection (effects of SCS involve central influences rather than cervical sympathetic outflow)

Zhong et al. (2004) [75]

Rat

Laser Doppler flowmetry

Cervical

Magnitude of the response varied in a dose-dependent fashion with the stimulation amplitude

Yang et al. (2008) [73]

Rat

Laser Doppler flowmetry

Cervical

TRPV1 agonists block CBF effects; cerebral but not spinal

TRPV1 is involved in cSCS-induced cerebral vasodilatation


SCS spinal cord stimulation, CBF cerebral blood flow, TRPV1 transient receptor potential vanilloid type 1, cSCS cervical spinal cord stimulation, CW cervical spinal cord stimulation, Doppler continuous-wave Doppler




Table 2
Clinical studies investigating the mechanisms involved in SCS effects on CBF












































Author (year) references

Observation method

Site of stimulation

Results

Hosobuchi (1985) [21]

SPECT (133Xe)

Cervical/thoracic

Indomethacin blocks CBF effects; atropine dose not affected CBF effects

Meglio et al. (1991) [39, 40]

TCD; SPECT (133Xe)

Cervical/thoracic

Decrease in cerebral vascular resistance and increase in flow velocity observed in 63 % cervical SCS and 29.4 % thoracic SCS

Visocchi et al. (1992) [58]

TCD; OBF system of Langhans

Cervical/thoracic

SCS changes CBF and OBF at the same time with the same sign (same autoregulatory mechanisms?)

Visocchi et al. (1996) [61]

TCD

Cervical

SCS and CO2 interact with mechanisms of regulation of CBF in a competitive way

Mazzone et al. (1995, 1996) [35, 36]

TCD; SPECT (133Xe)

Cervical/thoracic

Increase of CBF induced by SCS mainly in the anterior region

Robaina et al. (2004) [47]

TCD for middle cerebral artery velocity and color Doppler for common carotid artery blood flow

Cervical

Increase in flow velocity in middle cerebral artery and common carotid artery blood flow


CW Doppler Continuous-wave Doppler, NE norepinephrine, OBF ocular blood flow, SPECT Single Photon Emission Computed Tomography, TCD Trans-cranial doppler


From the first experimental observation concerning the role of SCS in the regulation of CBF, researchers soon started to think about the possible application of the same stimulation in pathological models that could resemble so-called low-perfusion syndromes. Thus, several experimental studies on animals came along, each one of which was designed to mimic a pathological status such as SAH and/or related vasospam [50], or cerebral ischemia and brain injury, searching in this particular condition for some possible blood flow changes after SCS application. A large number of papers about this matter have been published since the late 1980s (Table 3). The first to describe some evidence in this field was Matsui, in 1989 [34], who reported the effects of cervical SCS on an experimental stroke model. Matsui induced a middle cerebral artery occlusion (MCAO) in a group of 31 cats, dividing them into three subgroups, one of which underwent MCAO and subsequent cervical SCS. Data on infarct size were checked in the three group underwent middle cerebral artery occlusion; among them just one group underwnt spinal cord stimualtion after the occlusion, using a computer system model, and compared. The analysis showed a prolonged survival rate within 24 h after ischemia and prevention of infarct size progression in the SCS group, demonstrating that cervical SCS prevents the progression of brain infarction. In 1991 Gonzales-Darder [19] discovered the role of SCS in reducing brain edema in an experimental stroke model induced by bilateral carotid artery occlusion in rats. That study suggested that the stimulation could have the most relevant role just during the reperfusion period, because the hemodynamic effect was described only when SCS was applied 60 min before ischemia or at the beginning of the reperfusion period. The basilar mechanism mediating such an effect of SCS could be related to a global increase in CBF, protecting the brain against ischemia, or it could be related to the activation of vascular regulation systems. A similar experience was published by Broseta et al. [3] in 1994, in 45 rabbits with different stroke models (bilateral carotid ligation, unilateral microcoagulation of the middle cerebral artery [MCA], and microcoagulation of the vertebral artery). More recently, Sagher et al. [51] used an MCA occlusion model in rats and observed that SCS reduced stroke extension; they proposed SCS as feasible for the treatment and prevention of stroke. Visocchi et al. [63] carried on these studies, building an experimental model combining head trauma and ischemic injury in 20 rabbits. They reported some results indicating the ‘preventive’ effect of SCS on the secondary damage induced by trauma in an already established vascular insufficiency setting. Since 2001 various authors have carried out experimental studies on SCS in cerebral vasospasm and SAH models, focusing attention on this possible therapeutic subset. Goksel et al. [18] investigated the mechanism of the SCS-induced increase in CBF and its relation with physiological vasomotor mediators, using an NO synthase inhibitor in an animal model of SAH. They concluded that the effect of SCS on CBF could be attenuated but not completely suppressed by NG-nitro-L-arginine methyl ester (L-NAME). Gurelik et al. [20] were the only ones to propose a study in which the hemodynamic effect of SCS in a vasospasm model was measured indirectly, recording motor evoked potentials and changes occurring in the latency and amplitudes of the signal. The studies published by Karadag et al. [26] and Lee et al. [28] reported similar animal models (rabbits and rats) enhancing the remarkable effect of SCS on vasospasm in the anterior and posterior circulation. Visocchi et al. [60, 62, 65] pointed out the protective role of SCS in SAH regarding the prevention of ‘early’ vasospasm. TCD provides an easy and reliable indication of corresponding CBF modifications both in homeostatic conditions (CBF augmentation with increase in TCD velocities along with a reduction in the resistive index) and during vasospasm (decrease in CBF with increase in TCD velocities, as well as an increase in the resistive index). These pioneer observations were followed by Ebel et al. [12, 13], who evaluated the effect of cervical SCS on CBF in rats with SAH, demonstrating an enhancement of cerebral and cerebellar blood flow (Table 4).


Table 3
Experimental studies on animals checking the effect of cervical SCS on cerebral low-perfusion syndromes


















































































Author (year) references

Experimental model

Animal

Observation method

Results

Matsui and Hosobuchi (1989) [34]

Experimental stroke (middle cerebral artery occlusion)

Cat

TTC method; measurement by computer technique (PDP-11/23)

Reduction in death rate within 24 h after MCAO; prevention of progression of brain infarction

Gonzales-Darder and Canadas-Rodriguez (1991) [19]

Experimental stroke with bilateral carotid artery occlusion

Rat

Microgravimetric technique

Reduction in ischemic brain edema

Broseta et al. (1994) [3]

Experimental ischemic infarction in three models (middle cerebral artery microcoagulation; bilateral carotid artery occlusion; vertebral artery occlusion)

Rabbit

LDF

Improved CBF in right emisphere and posterior fossa (mean of 27 % and 32 %, respectively)

Visocchi et al. (2001) [63]

Experimental stroke and brain injury in conjunction (bilateral carotid artery occlusion plus “mechanical injury”over the dura mater after bone removal; right emispheric craniectomy)

Rabbit

MRI

No ischemic damage far from the “traumatic injury site”

Gőksel et al. (2001) [18]

Experimental SAH and cerebral vasospasm (intracisternal saline injection and administration of L-NAME)

Rabbit

TDU

SCS induced vasodilation in all SAH animals even after the administration of L-NAME

Sagher et al. (2003) [51]

Experimental stroke-middle cerebral artery occlusion

Rat

LDF;

radiotracer clearance

Reduction in stroke volume

Visocchi et al. (1996, 2001) [60, 62]

Experimental vasospam in SAH

Rabbit

Angiography; electromagnetic

flowmetry

Prevention of vasospasm

Ebel et al. (2001) [12, 13]

Experimental SAH

Rat

(99 m)Tc-HMPAO investigation

Improved cerebral and cerebellar blood flow

Gurelik et al. (2005) [20]

Experimental vasospasm

Rat

MEP evaluation

Improved changes in MEP latency and amplitude in “vasospasm group”

Karadag et al. (2005) [26]

Experimental vasospasm in SAH

Rabbit

LDF

Increasedcortical cerebral blood flow

Lee et al. (2008) [28]

Experimental vasospasm in SAH

Rat

Studies of the BA

diameter and LDF

Increase in the diameter of BA and increase in cortical blood flow


TTC triphenyltetrazolium chloride solution, SAH subarachnoid hemorrhage, MEP motor-evoked potential, LDF Laser Doppler flowmetry, TDU transcranial Doppler ultrasonography, L-NAME L-Nitro-L-arginine methyl ester, (99 m)Tc-HMPAO flow tracer, BA basilar artery, MRI magnetic resonance imaging, MCAO middle cerebral artery occlusion, PDP 11/23 Programmed Data Processor model 11



Table 4
Clinical studies on the effect of cervical SCS in cerebral ischemia, vasospasm, and tumor perfusion in humans
























































































Author (year) references

Clinical condition

No. of patients

Effect recording

Observation

Kanno et al. (1989) [25]

Impaired consciousness (persistent vegetative states)

23

SPECT

Increase in regional CBF; increase in the metabolism of catecholamines in CSF; improvement in EEG and clinical condition

Matsui and Hosobuchi (1989) [34]

Impaired consciousness (persistent vegetative states)

8

SPECT

Clinical improvement (no correlation of clinical outcome with SPECT CBF investigation)

Hosobuchi (1991) [22]

Cerebral ischemia

3

SPECT

Increase in CBF

Visocchi et al. (1994) [59]

Cerebral ischemia

1

NIRS; surface

polyelectromyography; TCD

Clinical-neurophysiological improvement

Broseta et al. (1994) [3]

Cerebral low-perfusion syndrome

10

SPECT

Clinical improvement, no MRI changes; increase in CBF

Takanashi and Shinonaga (2000) [53]

Cerebral vasospasm (SAH patients; Hunt Hess 2–3, Fisher 3)

10

xenon computed tomography

and cerebral angiography

Increase in CBF, clinical improvement

Visocchi et al. (2001) [64]

Ischemic/hemorrhagic brain damage

18

TCD; NIRS; SPECT

Clinical improvement, no absolute correlation increase, reduction, no changes in cerebral blood flow, or either increase/reduction of cerebral blood flow

Clavo et al. (2007, 2004, 2003, 2002) [47]

Brain tumor perfusion (advanced gliomas and head and neck tumors)

64

TCD, polarographic probes

Increased tumor blood flow and oxygenation

Robaina and Clavo (2007) [48]

Cerebral ischemia

49

SPECT; TCD; Color doppler, PET

Significant increases in velocity in middle cerebral artery flow and common carotid artery flow and glucose metabolism

De Andrés et al. (2007) [9]

Ischemic brain damage

1

Doppler, functional MRI

Clinical improvement, increase in CBF

Liu et al. (2008) [33]

Impaired consciousness (persistent vegetative states)

20

SPECT

Clinical improvement, increase in CBF; increase in DA and NE in CSF

Clavo et al. (2012) [8]

High-grade glioma

26

TCD, SPECT, Polarographic probes

Increase in locoregional blood flow, oxygenation, and glucose metabolism, improved chemotherapy delivery, oxygen effect during radiotherapy


CBF cerebral blood flow, CSF cerebrospinal fluid, EEG electroencephalogram, DA dopamine, MRI Magnetic Resonance Imaging, NE norepinephrine, NIRS Near Infrared Spectroscopy, PET Positron Emission Tomography, SPECT Single Photon Emission Computed Tomography, TCD trans cranial doppler

The fruitful research on the hemodynamic effects of cervical SCS has been applied in clinical studies since 1989, as the preliminary observations in experimental models of SCS in low-perfusion syndromes had led to great interest in their possible applications in humans. The clinical studies published in the literature deal with patients I a persistent vegetative-state, and those with cerebral ischemia, cerebral vasospasm within SAH [43, 55, 74], and brain tumors.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jun 24, 2017 | Posted by in NEUROSURGERY | Comments Off on on Mechanism and Therapeutic Implications of Spinal Cord Stimulation and Cerebral Hemodynamics: A Narrative Review

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access