Animal model
MES
PTZ
Kindling
DBA/2 mice
GAERS rats
Human seizure/epilepsy type
Generalized tonic-clonic seizures
Generalized absence seizures
Partial seizures (limbic)
Generalized tonic-clonic, reflex seizures, SUDEP
Generalized absence seizures
Animal model | 6-Hz psychomotor seizure model in mice | MAM seizure model | Post-status epilepticus model in rats |
---|---|---|---|
Human seizure/epilepsy type | Pharmacoresistant limbic seizures | Pharmacoresistant seizures, cortical dysplasia | Chronic focal epilepsy |
One animal model that is predictive of efficacy against partial (focal) seizures is the kindling model. In this model, repeated electrical stimuli are applied to the amygdala or hippocampus of rats, resulting in permanent lowering of the seizure threshold, so that stimuli that initially produced only subclinical after discharges eventually result in full-fledged generalized tonic-clonic seizures [10]. Though laborious, this model has been increasingly used in the preclinical testing of candidate drugs. However, this model has also been criticized for the absence of spontaneous seizures that are typical of human epilepsy.
True animal models of epilepsy should have spontaneously recurrent seizures. Such models may have genetic or acquired epilepsy. Commonly used genetic models are DBA/2 mice with audiogenic seizures and the genetic absence epilepsy rats from Strasbourg (GAERS) [22, 23]. Efficacy in DBA/2 mice with audiogenic seizures helps predict efficacy against human generalized tonic-clonic seizures, while efficacy on GAERS helps predict efficacy against human generalized absence seizures. Animal models of acquired chronic epilepsy include post-status epilepticus models, in which chemically or electrically induced status epilepticus is followed by spontaneously recurring seizures.
Because newly introduced AEDs have had limited impact on the proportion of patients with drug-resistant epilepsy, it is now recognized that there is a need for animal models of epilepsy that are drug-resistant [21]. One such model is the 6-Hz psychomotor seizure model in mice. In this model, 6-Hz pulses of 0.2-ms duration are delivered through the cornea for 3 s, resulting in a seizure that resembles limbic seizures in humans. At an intensity of 44 mA (twice that necessary to produce seizures in 97% of mice), many AEDs become ineffective [21]. The methylazoxymethanol acetate (MAM) rat model of cortical dysplasia can also serve as a model of pharmacoresistant epilepsy. In this model, MAM in utero exposure to results in a cortical dysplasia-like lesion, and seizures induced in these rats by kainate are resistant to several AEDs. Pharmacoresistant epilepsy can also be produced by exposure to low doses of lamotrigine during kindling or by selection of subgroups of rats that are resistant to specific AEDs from a large group of epileptic rats.
All the currently marketed AEDs are used as symptomatic treatment to suppress seizures. There is no clear evidence that any current AED is effective in the prevention of epilepsy. There is increasing interest in the identification of disease modifying treatments that could prevent the development of epilepsy after an insult or prevent the progression of epileptogenesis. Chronic animal models of epilepsy can be used to study potential anti-epileptogenic treatments. The most commonly used models in this setting are the kindling model and the post-status epilepticus model [21].
Hormonal and Immunological Treatment
Hormonal therapy may be considered in women with catamenial epilepsy, in whom seizures seem to follow a cyclical pattern related to the menstrual cycle [13, 15]. Three patterns of catamenial epilepsy have been described: C1 pattern where seizures increase in frequency just before and during menses, C2 pattern where seizures increase around the time of ovulation, and C3 pattern where seizures occur with anovulatory cycles. Catamenial epilepsy is thought to be related to progesterone and estrogen fluctuations. Estrogen appears to be proconvulsant, and progesterone appears to be anticonvulsant. In catamenial epilepsy, seizures are more likely to occur when the ratio of progesterone to estrogen decreases, as seen around the time of menstruation and the time of ovulation. The C1 pattern of catamenial epilepsy responds to progesterone 200 mg tid administered on days 14–28 of the cycle [14]. Synthetic progestins and clomiphene citrate have also been reported beneficial as treatments for catamenial epilepsy in small studies.
Ganaxolone is a derivative of allopregnanolone that lacks hormonal activity. It has been tested in a number of clinical trials. There was a suggestion that women with catamenial epilepsy were a subgroup that benefited in particular [30]. Ganaxolone was also tested in infantile spasms and found helpful in some patients [19]. It is not known if this compound will eventually be available for clinical use.
ACTH and steroids are first-line short-term treatments for infantile spasms/West syndrome. They help control seizures and improve behavior and EEG. They are most effective in the idiopathic syndrome. A high dose seems to be more effective. When it comes to ACTH, one approach is to begin with 40 IU per day for 1–2 weeks and increase to 60 or 80 IU per day thereafter if the response is incomplete. If it is effective, it is then tapered over 1–4 months. ACTH and steroids are less commonly used to treat Lennox–Gastaut syndrome and Landau–Kleffner syndrome.
Steroids and IVIG may be considered in the treatment of Rasmussen’s syndrome and other epilepsies suspected to be of immune origin, to treat the underlying cause of epilepsy. Limbic encephalitis, usually autoimmune, is increasingly recognized as a cause of chronic epilepsy. An immune basis of epilepsy should be considered when there is no other clear etiology, the onset was acute or subacute, and there is a prior history of autoimmunity (or autoimmunity is present in a first-degree relative), in the presence of a neoplasm, when there is CSF or imaging evidence of inflammation, and when neuronal autoantibodies are detected [36]. Faciobrachial dystonic seizures are brief seizures that predominantly affect the arm and ipsilateral face. They are an early sign in anti-LGI1 encephalitis that should prompt investigation for immune etiology and early immune therapy [17, 18]. The autoantibodies most commonly associated with immune epilepsy are anti-LGI1 antibodies (anti-voltage-gated potassium channel complex antibodies), anti-GAD antibodies, and anti-thyroid antibodies [25, 26]. Anti-NMDA antibodies are associated with a distinctive limbic encephalitis syndrome that usually includes seizures, but is unlikely to be a cause of pure chronic epilepsy [6]. When an immune origin is confirmed, first-line immunotherapies include oral or IV steroids (IV methylprednisolone 1000 mg daily for 3–5 days, then weekly for 4–6 weeks), IVIG (0.4 g/kg/day for 3–5 days then weekly for 4–6 weeks), or plasmapheresis [36]. If there has been incomplete benefit and there is strong evidence of autoimmune etiology, chronic immunosuppression could be considered with mycophenolate mofetil, azathioprine, or rituximab [36].
References
1.
2.
Anonymous. Topiramate extended-release (Trokendi XR) for epilepsy. Med Lett Drugs Ther. 2013;55: 87–88.
3.
Biton V, Shneker BF, Naritoku D, et al. Long-term tolerability and safety of lamotrigine extended-release: pooled analysis of three clinical trials. Clin Drug Investig. 2013;33:359–64.CrossRefPubMed