Penitentiary Mental Health Care in Belgium



Norbert Konrad, Birgit Völlm and David N. Weisstub (eds.)International Library of Ethics, Law, and the New MedicineEthical Issues in Prison Psychiatry201310.1007/978-94-007-0086-4_7
© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2013


7. Penitentiary Mental Health Care in Belgium



Paul Cosyns  and Kris Goethals2


(1)
University Forensic Centre, Antwerp University Hospital, Wilrijkstraat 10, 2650 Edegem, Belgium

(2)
Collaborative Antwerp Psychiatric Research Institute (CAPRI), University of Antwerp, Campus Drie Eiken, R3.27, Universiteitsplein 1, 2610 Wilrijk, Belgium

 



 

Paul Cosyns



Abstract

The new century has ushered new innovations in mental health care in Belgian jails and prisons, following a century of inaction and neglect. Despite repeated pleas by several leading Belgian forensic psychiatrists, the political authorities did not see through the necessary reforms in order to bridge the severe gap between regular psychiatric care and penitentiary forensic psychiatric care. The primary reason for this situation is that, despite an extensive public health system, Belgium has not extended equitable care to prisoners. It remains the responsibility of the Justice Department to organize health care within jails and prisons but it never assumed this duty at an acceptable level; consequently, there is no quality control of the somatic or psychiatric care in jails and prisons.



7.1 Introduction


The new century has ushered new innovations in mental health care in Belgian jails and prisons, following a century of inaction and neglect. Despite repeated pleas by several leading Belgian forensic psychiatrists, the political authorities did not see through the necessary reforms in order to bridge the severe gap between regular psychiatric care and penitentiary forensic psychiatric care. The primary reason for this situation is that, despite an extensive public health system, Belgium has not extended equitable care to prisoners. It remains the responsibility of the Justice Department to organize health care within jails and prisons but it never assumed this duty at an acceptable level; consequently, there is no quality control of the somatic or psychiatric care in jails and prisons.

A second reason for the comparatively low level of medical care in the Belgian penitentiaries is chronic overcrowding. Additionally, most prisons and jails were constructed in the nineteenth century. Modernization of the outdated infrastructure is too slow and insufficient. The European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhumane or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CPT) of the Council of Europe has repeatedly condemned Belgium for the confinement conditions of prisoners and the lack of quality of medical care inside jails and prisons (CPT-report on Belgium 2010). The Belgian government decided in 2009 to build several new prisons and a brand new penitentiary medical facility but it will take at least a decade to complete.

Following the arrest in the mid-nineties of a highly publicized case of a serial murderer and rapist, the Belgian public was shocked. This rather exceptional criminal case (Marc Dutroux) did initiate several new laws and developments in the organization of Belgian forensic care. The aims were: harsher punishment of sexual offenders, better protection of victims, and – last but not least – to develop a forensic pathway to control and treat sexual as well as mentally disturbed offenders. Concrete examples of the new trend are: the creation of specialized community treatment units for the treatment of released sex offenders (Agreement of cooperation between the federal state and the regional communities regarding the treatment of sexual abusers was approved by the federal laws of May 4, 1999, and March 12, 2000) and the building of two high security forensic hospitals in Belgium (Ghent and Antwerp). However, another important law of January 2005 is of note confirming the legal right of detainees to health care of the same quality as health care in the community (Belgisch Staatsblad 2005). This Law on Prisons and Prisoners’ Rights (LPPR) is widely recognized as a milestone in Belgian penitentiary history (Verbruggen et al. 2008).


7.2 The Prevalence of Mental Disorders Among Prisoners in Belgium


Belgium (10.4 million inhabitants) has more than 30 prisons scattered throughout the country, even one in Tilburg, the Netherlands. The reason for this latter location is overcrowding in Belgian prisons. Indeed, the daily population is more than 10,000 prisoners for 9,000 places of whom 5,500 are convicted, 3,500 on remand, 1,000 are ‘interned’ (meaning not guilty because of insanity or severe mental disorder) and 50 are juvenile incarcerated delinquents. The incarceration rate is 100 per 100,000, considerably lower than the US with 753, and England and Wales with 154, but somewhat higher than France with 96 and Sweden with 74 (all per 100,000 people). During the last 10 years the penitentiary population increased by 21 %; 44 % of the prisoners are foreigners. Deficient language skills of therapist or prisoner is a major problem for psychiatric treatment. Moreover, there is an annual yearly turnover of 15.000.

Belgium has no official records of the prevalence of somatic or psychiatric disorders in this population, but the Prison Health Care Service (PHCS) notes an excess of the following pathologies as compared with the general society: tuberculosis (×16), HIV (×5), hepatitis C (×7), psychosis (×5), suicide (×6), alcohol and substance abuse (×7) (van Mol 2009). Prison doctors report an increase of psychiatric pathology among prisoners and this is a source of concern because the prison context is not suited for their treatment at all.


7.3 Organization and Supervision of Penitentiary Mental Health Care


Belgium is a complex federal state with three regions (Flanders with 6 million inhabitants; Wallonia, 3.4 million; Brussels, 1 million) and three communities (Dutch, French- and German-speaking): Belgians are Dutch-speaking in Flanders, French-speaking in Wallonia and bilingual in Brussels. The small German-speaking community (71,000 inhabitants) is located in Wallonia. The Justice Department is an exclusive federal matter and all the prisons are governed by the federal state. On the other hand, community treatment after release from a penal institution is mainly a matter of the local regions.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Dec 3, 2016 | Posted by in PSYCHOLOGY | Comments Off on Penitentiary Mental Health Care in Belgium

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access