Perioperative Strategy for Prevention of Chronic Postsurgical Pain: General Foundations



Gérard Mick and Virginie Guastella (eds.)Chronic Postsurgical Pain201410.1007/978-3-319-04322-7_9
© Springer International Publishing Switzerland 2014


9. Perioperative Strategy for Prevention of Chronic Postsurgical Pain: General Foundations



F. Bonnet1, 2, 3  , J. Berger1, 2, 3 and Y. Ynineb1, 2, 3


(1)
Anaesthesiology and intensive care department, 75020 Paris, France

(2)
Assistance publique – Hôpitaux de Paris, Pierre et Marie Curie University, 75020 Paris, France

(3)
Tenon hospital, 4, rue de la Chine, 75020 Paris, France

 



 

F. Bonnet



Abstract

Opiates have a role in causing postoperative hyperalgesia. Postoperative hyperalgesia is probably involved in the causation of chronic postsurgical pain. Antihyperalgesic agents could reduce the incidence of chronic postsurgical pain. The antihyperalgesic agents that have been the subject of clinical trials on the prevention of hyperalgesia are ketamine (NMDA receptor antagonists), calcium channel alpha2-delta subunit agonists (gabapentin, pregabalin), nefopam and local anaesthetics.


Key points



  • Opiates have a role in causing postoperative hyperalgesia.


  • Postoperative hyperalgesia is probably involved in the causation of chronic postsurgical pain.


  • Anti-hyperalgesic agents could reduce the incidence of chronic postsurgical pain.


  • The anti-hyperalgesic agents that have been the subject of clinical trials on the prevention of hyperalgesia are ketamine (NMDA receptor antagonists), calcium channel alpha2-delta subunit agonists (gabapentin, pregabalin), nefopam and local anaesthetics.


Introduction


Chronic postsurgical pain (CPSP) is a phenomenon which is now recognised and whose reality and importance have been demonstrated by a large number of epidemiological studies. There are a number of risk factors for the persistence of pain after surgery, some of which are related to the patients themselves and others to the type of operation carried out. The role of anaesthesia is to prevent the occurrence of adverse phenomena associated with surgery. This is done while the operation is taking place. When considering the problem of CPSP, however, it seems possible that anaesthesia plays a preventative role but in some circumstances also facilitates the development of the phenomenon. Alteration of the physiological response to pain through the development of the phenomena of hyperalgesia and allodynia, resulting in an exacerbation of the experience of pain, is in fact one of the mechanisms that may facilitate the establishment of CPSP [1]. There seems to be a relationship between the area of immediate postoperative mechanical periwound allodynia and the incidence of CPSP: the larger the area, the higher the risk of chronic pain [2]. The ultimate aim of reducing or preventing these processes of allodynia and hyperalgesia could therefore be to prevent CPSP. Although these hypersensitisation processes are a direct consequence of the tissue injuries caused by surgery and the release of pro-inflammatory mediators at the surgical site, they are also dependent on the administration of opiates for analgesic purposes [3]. The way in which opiates are administered during the perioperative period may therefore play a role in the long-term consequences of anaesthesia and analgesia in causing CPSP.


Hyperalgesia and Opiate Administration


The exacerbation of pain when stopping treatment with opiates is a phenomenon that has been recognised for some time, and it was long thought to be linked to chronic opiate administration. It has been known for several years now that this is not the case and that the same phenomenon can be observed after the administration of opiates for a short period corresponding to the time of the operation itself. It appears that opiates have a dual role, at once inhibiting and facilitating nociceptive transmission, the latter effect continuing for longer than the former one [3, 4]. In animals, hypersensitivity to pain caused by a surgical lesion or inflammation is potentiated by the administration of an opioid and this occurs in a dose-dependent way [57]. Increasing the dose of the opioid also increases not only the amplitude of the hyperalgesic type response but also its duration. This process of hypersensitisation to pain causes activation of NMDA type post-synaptic receptors, while concomitant administration of an agent that blocks NMDA receptors, such as ketamine, attenuates the occurrence of the phenomenon [57]. Opioids inhibit nociception by stimulating mainly μ-type opioid receptors. They also activate facilitatory systems which are triggered by NMDA receptors. Passage of calcium into the cell via NMDA receptors activates a protein kinase Cγ which, by phosphorylating the NMDA receptors themselves, triggers the activation of more of these receptors. The administration of opiates can therefore be considered to induce a vulnerability to pain which seems not only to persist during the days following a mechanical trauma (such as an operation in man), but may also extend beyond that period. To prevent this, two strategies may be used: reducing the quantity of opiates administered due to a sparing effect resulting from the use of other analgesic agents, and concomitant administration of agents capable of blocking the hyperalgesia by blocking the NMDA receptors.


Prevention of Hyperalgesia Caused by Opioids and Surgery



Reducing the Dose of Opioids Administered


It has been shown that reducing the quantity of opiates administered during the course of anaesthesia makes it possible to reduce postoperative opiate use. This is more of an indirect demonstration of the development of postoperative hyperalgesia, which takes the form of increased opioid use in those groups of patients who receive the largest quantities of opioids perioperatively [8]. Extrapolating from this, one might imagine that during anaesthesia, every factor that might contribute towards reducing opioid use indirectly reduces the risk of developing hyperalgesia. This is true when it comes to the concomitant use of a technique of loco-regional anaesthesia.


Use of NMDA Receptor Antagonists


Ketamine in low doses is a non-competitive NMDA receptor antagonist. Ketamine is therefore used at low doses (intravenous bolus of 0.15 to 0.30 mg/kg followed by continuous infusion at around 2 mg/hr for a 70 kg patient) concomitantly with opiates during the perioperative period. A number of meta-analyses evaluating the peri- and postoperative administration of ketamine have shown that it had an opioid-sparing effect and reduced the intensity of postoperative pain [9, 10]. Ketamine also prevents the processes that cause perioperative opioid tolerance and the resulting postoperative opioid overuse [11]. Finally, it causes a significant and prolonged reduction in periwound hyperalgesia [12]. It should also be remembered that at the doses mentioned, ketamine only rarely causes the dysphoric effects that have been seen at anaesthetic doses. The data in relation to CPSP are less convincing. Two studies have shown that a perioperative infusion over a short period may reduce the incidence of chronic pain after thoracotomy or general surgery [13, 14]. A study in patients undergoing hip operations showed that administering ketamine (bolus of 0.5 mg/kg and continuous infusion of 2 μg/kg/min over 24 h) resulted in a 21 % (ketamine group) versus 8 % (placebo group) reduction in the number of patients complaining of pain at rest on the side of the operation [15], while in other studies, ketamine (bolus of 0.5 mg/kg followed by a continuous infusion of 0.25 mg/kg/hr) was unable to prevent the occurrence of post-mastectomy syndrome [16] or did not reduce the number of patients presenting with CPSP after thoracotomy [17].


Gabapentinoids as Calcium Channel Modulators


Gabapentin and pregabalin are ligands of the calcium channel alpha2-delta subunit, which attach to presynaptic membrane channels of nociceptive afferents in the superficial layers of the spinal cord and consequently reduce the release of excitatory neuropeptides and amino acids. Gabapentinoids have an antihyperalgesic effect [18] and are known to be indicated for the treatment of neuropathic pain. A number of clinical studies have shown a reduction in opiate use by 30 to 60 %, and a reduction in postoperative pain intensity scores when doses of 600 mg to 1200 mg of gabapentin are administered as a premedication [19, 20]. A few studies have proposed that gabapentin may have a role in the prevention of CPSP, but these results should be considered as preliminary and still require confirmation. On the one hand they involved small groups of patients and on the other, gabapentin is often associated with other therapeutic interventions. Finally, two of the three studies on this subject were carried out by a single team (Fassoulaki et al.) [21, 22]. Clarke et al. also showed that administering 600 mg of gabapentin as a premedication did not permit a reduction in postoperative morphine use after a hip operation, nor did it reduce the incidence of CPSP at 6 months, which affects approximately one-third of patients [24]. A recent study, however, compared ketamine (0.3 mg/kg as a bolus, followed by 0.05 mg/kg/hr as a continuous infusion during surgery) with gabapentin (1200 mg as a premedication) and showed that the intensity of residual pain after hysterectomy by laparotomy was lower in the patients who had received gabapentin than in those who had received placebo or ketamine [25]. Nevertheless, it should be pointed out that in the three groups in this study, the average scores for pain at 3 months were lower than 3 on a score from 0 to 10.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Mar 25, 2017 | Posted by in NEUROSURGERY | Comments Off on Perioperative Strategy for Prevention of Chronic Postsurgical Pain: General Foundations

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access