Pilot and Preliminary Studies of Thrombolytic Therapy for Stroke


Author (ref.)

N

Thrombolytic agent

Ancillary

Outcome

Herndona [11, 12, 14]

27

Fibrinolysin over 3 d iv

Heparin, Dicoumarol

15 % involved, 33 % died, 4 systemic hemorrhages

Clarke [4]

10

Fibrinolysin up to 4 day
 
2 rapid complete recovery

Meyerb [7]

40 (randomized to thrombolytic or placebo)

Thrombolysin (iv plasmin)over 3 day

Anticoagulants

3 rapid improvement, 2 died, 45 % improved in each group 35 % died in each group

Meyerc [8, 14]

73 (randomized to thrombolytic or placebo, both administered heparin stroke-in-progression)

SK iv

Heparin

43 % SK treated improved, 35 % SK treated died

Fletcherd [15]

31

UK iv
 
No Improvement, SK iv Heparin, 4 with clinical ICH


aDuration symptoms: 2 h–1 month (3 treated <6 h).

bOnly 1/10 treated <6 h, duration of symptoms = 3 h–1 month

cAll treated <72 h after symptom onset

dAll treated <36 h after stroke onset (range 8–34 h)



The first attempt to treat ischemic stroke using a thrombolysis was reported in 1958 by Sussman and Fitch [9]. They treated three patients with plasmin (fibrinolysin); one patient had moderate clinical improvement with recanalization of the MCA. The other two patients did not improve clinically despite one case of large cerebral vessel recanalization. Clifton reported a 45-year-old woman with [10]. The clot was lysed after 15 min of plasmin therapy, but she died 48 h later (on Dicumarol and heparin) owing to a tracheal obstruction from a hematoma. Clifton also mentions that two cases of cerebral thrombosis were treated with plasmin (inadequate doses) without success. Two years later, Herndon et al. treated 13 patients within 3 days of presumed ischemic stroke onset (clear CSF) with bovine thrombolysin and anticoagulants [11]. Eight of 13 (62 %) patients improved. Five patients died; however, there was no evidence for hemorrhagic infarction or ICH found at postmortem examinations.

Herndon et al. then reported 27 cases given fibrinolytic therapy for cerebral artery occlusion (CSF with more than 3,000 red blood cells as a contraindication); diagnosis was confirmed by autopsy in six cases and by arteriography in 16 (Table 4.2) [12]. In addition, one case of retinal vein thrombosis and one case of bilateral cavernous sinus thrombosis were treated with fibrinolytic agents. Two of three patients treated died within 6 h (at 31 h and 3 days), both of whom had basilar artery thrombosis, whereas the third patient improved.


Table 4.2
Thrombolytic stroke trials incorporating neuroimaging: post-computed tomography series





















































Author

Year

n

Thrombolytic agent

Ancillary therapy

Outcome

Hossmann [37]

1983

15

Ancrod

LMW dextran, mannitol

Improvement in neurologic deficit, no ICH, 60 % 1-year survival (47 % in control group)

Fusjishima [22]

1988

143

iv UK for 1–7 days

62 also received DS

Moderate to marked improvement in 31 % UK treated, in 61% UK + DS treated hemorrhagic events in 3.2 % of UK + DS treated mortality 1.6 %/2.5 %

Del Zoppo [20]

1988

20

IA, UK, or SK up to 4 h

Heparin, hydroxyethyl starch in some patients

75 % complete recanalization, 20 % hemorrhagic transformation

Hacke [23]

1988

43

IA, UK, or SK up to 48 h

Heparin, hydroxyethyl Starch

44 % recanalized, 46 % persistent occlusion, 9.3 % hemorrhagic transformation

Mori [25]

1988

22

IA, UK

Variable: hypervolemic or 18% isovolemic hemodi-lution, 10 % iv glycerol, aspirin, heparin, or combination

45 % immediate recanalization, 18 % hemorrhagic infarction


UK urokinase, LMW low molecular weight, ICH intracranial hemorrhage, iv intravenous, DS dextran sulfate, IA intra-arterial, SK streptokinase

Ten patients with cerebrovascular thrombotic events treated with fibrinolytic agents (Table 4.2) were reported by Clark and Clifton [4]. Three patients treated by intra-arterial fibrinolysin all showed complete recanalization. One of these showed good clinical response but the other two died of local hematoma or a rebleeding aneurysm. Intravenous thrombolysis was performed in seven cases. Two (29 %) completely recovered, three improved, and two were unchanged.

Meyer et al. used intra-arterial human thrombolysin, intravenous bovine thrombolysin, and anticoagulants in 14 patients [13]. Four of seven patients with internal carotid artery distribution infarcts improved, two were unchanged, and one died. Of the five patients with vertebrobasilar disease, two improved (one then died of medical complications), and two were unchanged. Eleven of 14 patients underwent cerebral angiography; 3 showed clot dissolution, and 1 had presumed clot dissolution.

A pilot study was then reported by Meyer et al. who randomized 40 patients with occlusion of the carotid or MCA tree in a placebo-controlled trial using 200,000 U intravenous plasmin (thrombolysin) administered over 4 h daily for 3 days (Table 4.2) [7]. Thirty-four (85 %) had angiography before treatment and eight (20 %) had repeat arteriograms before hospital discharge. All cases were also treated with subcutaneous heparin followed by oral warfarin therapy. At 10 days there was no difference in outcome between placebo- and plasmin-treated groups when the subgroup with proven occlusive disease of the large vessels was analyzed. Of those eight patients with repeat angiography, six had no change, and two had partial recanalization (one in each treatment group). One patient who was administered plasmin and died 48 h after beginning treatment from a large hemorrhagic infarction had been given a loading dose of warfarin (30 mg) for 2 days in error.

Meyer et al. reported 73 patients with progressive stroke treated within 72 h of onset of symptoms with heparin (n = 36) or heparin plus streptokinase (SK) (n = 37) (6 h infusions, individually dosed after a dose-prediction test) in a randomized protocol (Table 4.2) [8, 14]. Patients had to have a clear CSF and systolic blood pressure less than 180 mm Hg before inclusion. Arteriography was obtained on admission (demonstrating an occluded vessel in 35 patients) and repeated at 10 days if an occluded vessel was found initially. Twenty-one (58 %) of 36 heparin-treated patients and (43 %) of 37 SK- and heparin-treated patients improved, whereas 4 (11 %) and 13 (35 %) of the two groups, respectively, died. Statistical analysis was not performed. Clot lysis was demonstrated by repeat angiography or at autopsy in ten patients (three heparin treated, seven treated with heparin plus SK). Autopsies on 13 of 17 who died (three controls, 10 in the SK group) showed 3 cerebral hemorrhages (all SK treated), 1 hemorrhagic infarction (SK treated), and 9 bland infarctions (all 3 controls and 6 SK treated).

Fletcher et al. reported results of a pilot study of intravenous urokinase (UK) in cerebral infarction involving 31 patients treated either with a single- or double- infusion period, each of 10–12 h (Table 4.2) [15]. Patients enrolled in the study had more severe neurological deficits than the average stroke patient observed at their institution. Angiography was performed before UK treatment in seven patients. One had no vascular lesion noted, and in two others the examination was unsatisfactory. Four patients had stenotic disease or occlusion of the MCA. One patient died from complication of a neck hematoma following traumatic carotid angiography. The investigators observed no instance of unequivocal clinical improvement attributable to treatment. Anecdotal pre-CT reports of thrombolytics for cerebrovascular disease continued as did a larger series with UK [16].

In summary, arterial recanalization was shown in 31–100 % of the patients in whom pre- and post-treatment angiography was performed. However, because of a discouraging number of ICH, enthusiasm for these agents dissipated.




Early Post-computed Tomography Studies


Advances in clinical and neuroimaging assessment of ischemic cerebrovascular disease combined with the expanding knowledge of the pathophysiology of human brain infarction led to a resurgence of enthusiasm for newer potentially safer thrombolytic agents and techniques in human ischemic stroke [17]. This renewed interest was greatly influenced by the animal studies outlined in Chap. 2. It was realized that earlier attempts initiated treatment too late (i.e., longer than 6–8 h and as long as beyond 2–3 days after the onset of symptoms). Beginning in the early 1980s, individual case reports documented clinical improvement from ischemic stroke following cerebral arterial recanalization with intra-arterial thrombolytic agents [1820].

Abe et al. studied stroke patients using UK (60,000 IU/days) for 7 days or placebo in a double-blind protocol. Improvement in two of three clinical outcome scales was noted in the UK-treated group [21]. Fujishima et al. reported on 143 patients with cerebral infarction treated with either UK (2.83 × 105 U iv over 6 h [n = 81] or a combination of UK-dextran sulfate [DS], 2.84 × 105 U plus 300 mg DS over 1 day [n = 62]) in a multicenter cooperative study [22]. Only 89 % of the cases had head CT performed for stroke diagnosis and 30 % had spinal taps. Overall, clinical improvement rate and safety was reported in 74 % of UK-treated patients and 84 % of the UK-dextran-treated patients.

From 1983 to May 1986, Hacke et al. treated 43 prospectively studied patients with intraarterial UK or SK for angiographically documented vertebrobasilar artery territory thrombosis [23]. Heparin, 300 U/h, was routinely administered simultaneously with the thrombolytic agents and then administered at 1,000 U/h intravenously with hydroxylethyl starch. All patients without recanalization died, whereas 14 (74 %) of 19 who recanalized survived (p = 0.000007), 10 with a favorable outcome. Thrombolysis was avoided if the initial head CT showed hypodense areas in the brain stem or cerebellum. Four of the 43 cases developed hemorrhagic transformation: two of the four died. Fibrinogen, activated partial thromboplastin time, and fibrin split product measurement in the patients with hemorrhagic events were not different from the patients without ICH. Two of four with hemorrhagic infarction did not show recanalization. This study strongly suggested that recanalization of vertebrobasilar occlusions could be accomplished, and was associated with clinical salvage. Their expanded experience with 66 patients was also reported [24].

Data on local intra-arterial UK or SK for acute carotid territory stroke was reported by Del Zoppo et al. from a prospective, angiographically based, two- center open-pilot study [20]. The longest time from symptom onset to treatment time with complete recanalization was 10 h. Seventy-five percent (15 of 20 patients) with acute stable symptoms (mean treatment onset interval 7.6 h) demonstrated complete recanalization (unblinded evaluation) with 10 of 15 exhibiting clinical improvement by the time of hospital discharge. Four patients with hemorrhagic transformation had complete recanalization and were treated 6–10 h after symptom onset (all were also treated with heparin and hydroxyethyl starch). Three of these four patients showed clinical improvement. Although these data are often cited to support a claim that patients should not receive thrombolytic therapy beyond 6 h following stroke onset, three of the four hemorrhage patients actually improved.

Mori et al. reported 22 patients who received intracarotid UK for evolving cerebral infarction resulting from angiographically documented thromboembolic occlusion of the MCA or its major branches [25]. Five of six with investigator- rated excellent outcome were in the recanalized group, and the volume of CT infarction was significantly less in the recanalized group (35.5 ± 55.4 mL) compared with the nonrecanalized group (172.8 ± 122.6 mL) (p < 0.01). Prognosis was also correlated with restoration of blood flow (r = 0.60, p = 0.003). There was no correlation between initial neurological state and recanalization. Neither interval from onset to infusion nor dose of UK correlated with prognosis.


Tissue Plasminogen Activator Preliminary Trials


Terashi et al. treated 364 stroke patients with either t-PA (n = 171) or UK in a double-blinded protocol [26]. Of the total, 36 % started treatment within 24 h and 70 % within 48 h. There were no statistically significant differences between the two groups at the 7-day clinical evaluation. Adverse effects were noted in approx 10 % of each group, and the incidence of hemorrhagic infarction was less than 5 % in each group.

Hennerici et al. reported the results of administering 70 mg alteplase intravenously over 90 min in 19 patients with ischemic stroke of less than 24-h duration [27]. Full-dose intravenous heparin was also administered. One patient was excluded after entry because his symptoms were later determined to be of greater than 24-h duration. Of the other 18 patients, one sustained a fatal ICH, and early arterial recanalization was achieved in only 25 %. Nine additional patients died of complications of their entry strokes. The onset times of many of the patients could not be determined with certainty, and the authors proposed that delayed treatment may have contributed to the poor outcomes. They also suggested that the dose of alteplase was too low.

Later, von Kummer and associates reported on 32 patients with severe hemispheric deficits treated with a 100 mg of alteplase administered over 90 min, combined with a 5000 U bolus of intravenous heparin followed by a continuous infusion at 1,000–1,500 U/h, aiming to double the activated partial thromboplastin time in each patient [28]. All patients were treated within 6 h (mean ± SD = 3.8 ± 1.1 h) of stroke onset, and all had pretreatment CT scanning and cerebral angiography. Partial or complete recanalization of the infarct-related artery was documented angiographically in 34 % immediately after the recombinant tissue plasminogen activator (rt-PA) infusion, and in an additional 19 % within 12–24 h by predominantly transcranial Doppler assessment. Hemorrhagic transformation was observed in 38 %, of which one-fourth (9 %) was associated with neurological deterioration and death. At 4 week, clinical outcome was classified as good (ambulatory, National Institutes of Health [NIH] Stroke Scale score <13) in 44 % and poor or dead in the remainder. Good outcomes were correlated with recanalization within 24 h. Reocclusion was reported in one patient despite the heparin treatment. The authors acknowledged that their results did not show a clear benefit of concomitant heparin therapy, but suggested that it did not appear to be substantially more dangerous than t-PA alone.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Apr 21, 2017 | Posted by in NEUROLOGY | Comments Off on Pilot and Preliminary Studies of Thrombolytic Therapy for Stroke

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access