Psychiatric Treatment of Children and Adolescents
Children and adolescents are the most accurate informants of their own thoughts, feelings, moods, and perceptual experiences. External behavior problems are often identified by others, yet children’s internal experiences may be largely unknown. Children often can describe their feelings in a particular situation but cannot execute therapeutic changes without an advocate’s help. Thus, child psychotherapists function as advocates for their child patients in interactions with schools, legal agencies, and community organizations. Child psychotherapists may be called on to make recommendations that affect various aspects of children’s lives.
Treatment reflects an understanding of children’s developmental levels and shows cultural sensitivity toward families and environments in which children live. Most children do not seek psychiatric treatment; rather, they are taken to psychotherapists because of a disturbance noted by a family member, a schoolteacher, or a pediatrician. Children often believe that they are being taken for treatment because of their misbehavior or as a punishment for wrongdoing.
Group formats have been demonstrated to be useful in randomized clinical trials using cognitive behavioral techniques to treat childhood anxiety disorders. Groups have been used for a wide range of clinical situations, including anger management for aggressive adolescents, social skills improvement, survivors of childhood sexual abuse and other traumatic events such as the trauma of the September 11, 2001, World Trade Center tragedy, adolescents with social phobia and obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), children with psychotic disorders, interventions for adolescents with substance abuse, and children and adolescents with learning disorders. Group therapy can be done with children of all ages using developmentally appropriate formats. Group therapy can be structured to address a variety of communication skills, including issues of interpersonal competence, peer relationships, and social skill. Group psychotherapy can be modified to suit groups of children of various ages and can focus on behavioral, educational, and social skills and psychodynamic issues. The mode in which the group functions depends on children’s developmental levels, intelligence, and problems to be addressed. In behaviorally and cognitive behavioral groups, the group leader is a directive, active participant who facilitates prosocial interactions and desired behaviors.
Students should study the questions and answers below for a useful review of these treatments.
Helpful Hints
These terms should be known and defined by students.
acting out
action-oriented defenses
ADHD
atypical puberty
behavioral contracting
bell-and-pad conditioning
child guidance clinics
child psychoanalysis
classical and operant conditioning
cognitive therapy
combined therapy
compliance
confidentiality
conflict resolution skills
developmental lines
dietary manipulation
ECT
family systems theory
filial therapy
group living
group therapy
hospital treatment
learning-behavioral theories
liver to body weight ratio
masked depression
milieu therapy
modeling theory
mood disorders
obsessive-compulsive disorder
parental attitudes
play group therapy
psychoanalytic theories
puberty and adolescence (differentiation)
regression
relationship therapy
remedial and educational psychotherapy
sequential psychosocial capacities
supportive therapy
sympathomimetics
therapeutic interventions
therapeutic playroom
violence
Questions
Directions
Each of the questions or incomplete statements below is followed by five suggested responses or completions. Select the one that is best in each case.
53.1 The systems approach to family therapy
A. places more emphasis on the meaning of a child’s symptoms for the larger family than on the child’s specific symptoms
B. maintains that all things are interdependent and nothing changes without everything else changing
C. sees symptoms as serving a purpose for the family system
D. views each family member as acting in a way that opposes symptomatic improvement in the presenting patient
E. all of the above
View Answer
53.1 The answer is E (all)
The systems approach, a departure from so-called “linear theories,” uses cybernetics and general systems theory. Whereas cybernetics holds that systems maintain an equilibrium, general systems theory describes all living systems as existing in tension between homeostasis and change. All components of a family are interdependent, and nothing changes without everything else changing accordingly. In this approach to family problems, symptoms are seen not as residing within the child but rather as serving a purpose for the entire family system. These symptoms provide systemic survival and maintain homeostasis. Each family member is presumed to act in a way that opposes symptomatic improvement in the presenting patient. Family-systems theorists attempt to counteract this hypothetical process in treatment; they believe that one must destabilize the family system to promote change. The formulation for a family-systems therapist emphasizes the meaning that symptoms have for the family. Problem-maintaining patterns are observed, and these patterns are interrupted.
53.2 With regard to adverse effects of medications in children and adolescents,
A. tardive dyskinesia has not been observed in this age group
B. withdrawal dyskinesias do occur in this age group
C. anticholinergic and cardiovascular side effects are rarely seen in this age group
D. there is less risk for adverse effects in this age group compared with adults
E. none of the above
View Answer
53.2 The answer is B
Even though they may metabolize medications more rapidly than adults, children are at no less risk than adults for adverse effects of medications and in some cases are at increased risk. Clinicians must therefore know the adverse-effect profiles of all medications being prescribed, as well as how to manage adverse effects should they arise. Many of the adverse effects of antipsychotic, antidepressant, and mood-stabilizing medications seen in adults are also seen in children and adolescents. Of particular concern are the anticholinergic and cardiovascular effects of the tricyclic medications and the extrapyramidal effects of the antipsychotics. Withdrawal dyskinesias are more common than tardive dyskinesia among children and adolescents, although both have been observed in this age group.
The best policy is usually to start with low dosage and titrate slowly upward to therapeutic effect. Use of the lowest possible maintenance doses in the therapeutic range can minimize adverse effects. Monotherapy is preferable. Targeted combined pharmacotherapy may be necessary in children with multiple disorders but should be used with caution to minimize adverse effects. Table 53.1 lists common adverse effects of medications.
53.3 Which theorist described a series of “developmental pathways,” for example, a pathway that connects a child’s capacity to play to the adult’s capacity to work?
A. Sigmund Freud
B. Anna Freud
C. Donald Winnicott
D. Melanie Klein
E. Margaret Mahler
View Answer
53.3 The answer is B
Child psychotherapy began with Sigmund Freud’s case of Little Hans, a 5-year old boy with phobia. Published in 1909, the case was the first description of the psychotherapeutic treatment of a child. The therapy in the case was actually rendered by Hans’s father, who reported to Freud and received guidance from him. Significant interest in the mental and emotional lives of children was generated by Freud’s theory of psychosexual development, which posited that symptoms in adulthood could be traced to conflicts arising at earlier stages of development.
Decades later, Anna Freud and Melanie Klein developed the field of child psychoanalysis. Klein understood play to be the childhood equivalent of free association in adults. She explored early object relations; the role of primitive defenses such as projection, projective identification, and omnipotent control; the process of early identifications; and the role of envy and guilt in these early relationships. Anna Freud looked at play from a psychoanalytic perspective and learned about the child from the play but did not view play as a substitute for free association. Her work concerned the development of the ego, the evolution of defenses, and the developmental pathway of various ego functions. In one example of a developmental pathway, she described a continuity from the child’s capacity to play to the adult’s capacity to work.
There were several other major early contributors to the field. Donald Winnicott emphasized the importance of the mother-infant relationship. His understanding of the transitional object, for instance, as playing a role in the child’s ability to separate from the maternal figure instilled a new appreciation of the meaning of commonly observed childhood behaviors. Margaret Mahler observed mother-toddler interactions in a systemized way and described the evolution of early object relations from the perspective of separation and individuation. August Aichorn first extended psychoanalytic work to delinquent adolescents. Jean Piaget focused on children’s cognitive development.
53.4 Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is useful in the treatment of which of the following disorders or situations?
A. Conduct disorder
B. Adolescent depression in a group setting
C. Obsessive-compulsive disorder
D. Socially rejected children
E. All of the above
View Answer
53.4 The answer is E (all)
Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is the most extensively, thoroughly researched therapy in use today for the treatment of psychological problems in children and adolescents. CBT can be used in both individual and group settings.
Children with conduct disorder may be impulsive, oppositional, defiant, moody, and angry. During assessment, the therapist gauges the child’s thought processes in addressing a variety of situations. The child is then taught a step-by-step approach to solving problems. In this training, the child is guided to develop skills in appraising situations and making appropriate decisions for action. This technique may be adapted to accommodate children ages 4 years through young adulthood. The treatment uses structured tasks such as games, academic activities, and other age-appropriate tools. The therapist plays an active role in the treatment, encouraging modeling via practice and role playing. Punishment or withdrawal of privileges is used when necessary.
Individual CBT has been demonstrated to be an effective treatment for depression in adolescents. Additionally, Peter Lewinsohn and colleagues developed the “Adolescents Coping with Depression Course,” which consists of 16 2-hour sessions conducted over an 8-week period for groups of up to 10 adolescents. The program includes a psychoeducational component that aims to destigmatize depression, emphasize skills training to promote control over one’s mood, and enhance adolescents’ abilities to cope with problematic situations. The group activities include role playing. Social skills training occurs throughout the treatment to facilitate and enhance communication and includes teaching conversational techniques, planning social activities, and developing strategies for making friends. Sessions are designed to increase participation in pleasant activities based on the assumption that depressed adolescents have few positively reinforcing activities in their lives. Relaxation training is provided to enhance comfort in social settings and to offset anxiety. Focus on changing depressogenic cognitions is provided by identifying, challenging, and changing negative thoughts and irrational beliefs. The teens are also taught negotiating and problem-solving techniques.
Table 53.1 Adverse Effects and Their Management in Children and Adolescents | ||
---|---|---|
|