Psychological Reactions



Psychological Reactions


Vicenzio Holder Perkins

Jeffrey S. Akman



Over the past two decades, the medical and psychosocial needs of people with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection have changed considerably. The introduction of highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) has had a profound effect on the epidemic and the prognosis of people affected by HIV. Numerous studies have shown that HAART extends life expectancy, reduces significantly the progression of HIV-related illness, decreases HIV viral loads, and increases CD4 counts. However, the verdict is still out on whether the experience of living longer with HIV disease and its related illnesses is significantly less stressful today than before the introduction of HAART. It is the extension of life for many individuals treated with HAART that has defined HIV infection as a chronic illness. Even though many may feel healthier and are living longer, HAART is not without its problems. Furthermore, these very complex antiretroviral regimens are a constant reminder of one’s HIV status. Thus, inherent in living with HIV infection as a chronic illness is the coexistence of emotional and psychological reactions.

Psychological stress, demoralization, and distress are ubiquitous with chronic illness. The uncertainty regarding one’s future state of health, potential shortening of one’s life trajectory, unpredictability of physical discomfort or ailments, and the impact on the individual’s partner, spouse, and family are common sources of psychological stress in individuals with chronic illness. Studies of individuals facing grave illness have identified the key themes for maintaining emotional equilibrium to be a search for meaning, attempts to gain mastery or control over illness, and attempts to enhance self-worth. For many, the meaning and experience of having HIV disease remains difficult and challenging.

The passage of time and modern advances of medicine have not diminished the complexity of social and psychological issues that confront those living with HIV disease. The immediate psychological impact of learning one’s HIV seropositivity is frequently one of acute distress expressed as depressed mood, anxiety, shock, and anger. Sexual avoidance is not an
uncommon phenomenon, because patients may perceive sex as an activity that is associated with illness and death. These symptoms often take the form of transient and situational adjustment disorders. Seropositive individuals wonder if they can continue with their activities of daily living and responsibilities, including jobs and social relationships. Persons with HIV can become preoccupied with becoming ill and dying, as do persons with any life-threatening disease. Some confront the failure of antiretroviral or protease inhibitors, whereas others live apprehensively, wondering how long they will escape an opportunistic infection. In these situations, hopelessness is a prominent theme. The social impact of HIV infection can also be distressing. People living with HIV-related illness have been stigmatized since the epidemic began. Fear of stigma has interfered with disclosure of seropositive status to sexual partners, family, and friends. The shame imposed by societal beliefs (“they deserve their illness”) may adversely affect care-seeking behaviors and adherence to HAART. Furthermore, HAART may be a double-edge sword. On the one hand, it decreases mortality and morbidity, and on the other it produces disturbing physical side effects, including neuropathy, chronic diarrhea, fatigue, and lipodystrophy syndrome. This new treatment adds to the “stressor chest” of HIV infection. The additional impact of physical anguish on mental health can be significant.

The psychological distress linked with the social and physical pressures of HIV infection manifest in the form of depressive symptomatology, including heightened anxiety, worries, tension, perceived stress, and avoidant, intrusive, and overwhelming thoughts. The prevalence of these reactive symptoms has not been determined. Although these symptoms are usually mild and self-limiting, they can be severe and disabling to the extent that they may meet criteria for an adjustment disorder or another Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV) Axis I diagnoses. HIV infection is also experiential because it is expressed emotionally as shame, guilt, grief, and numbness. An “emotional roller coaster” is often the core of one’s experience of living with HIV disease. These emotional responses may elicit maladaptive defense mechanisms, such as denial, regression, or isolation of affect.

Persons with HIV-related illness experience significant psychological and emotional vulnerabilities at each of the key milestones of its clinical course (HIV testing, notification of HIV seropositivity, development of HIV disease, diagnosis of acquired immunodeficiency syndrome [AIDS], development of cognitive dysfunction, progressive disability, and terminal deterioration). Even with the clear advantages of HAART treatment, current research does not, as of yet, support the notion that individuals transverse these clinical milestones with less psychological distress during the era of HAART.


Psychological Impact at Different Stages of HIV/AIDS


Psychological Reactions to Antibody Status Notification

HIV testing is a crucial step in the continuum of HIV disease care. Yet people undergo or avoid HIV antibody testing for many reasons. The decision to test for the presence of HIV antibody can be associated with considerable psychological distress. Fear and denial are the most common obstacles to HIV testing among those acknowledging that they have been at risk.1 Other reasons for avoiding testing include worries about confidentiality, and wishing to avoid anxiety while waiting for the results. The psychological consequences of choosing to know or not to know one’s HIV serostatus were examined in a group of 224 men who had been tested for HIV.2 Results indicate that men who avoided testing had AIDS-related preoccupations significantly higher than those who were aware of their serostatus, whether seronegative or seropositive. This led to the suggestion that learning what might appear as threatening information may be more psychologically beneficial than avoiding it.


Although it may seem intuitive that a positive HIV antibody test result is an extremely emotional distressing experience, the research findings however, are reflecting a changing picture. Kelly and Murphy3 observed that studies conducted before 1988 generally report high and pervasive levels of distress following positive HIV serostatus notification, whereas later studies generally indicate relatively lower levels of distress. This observable change may be explained by different conceptual and methodological approaches utilized by the investigator(s) in studying the psychological impact of notification of HIV serostatus over time. Other possible explanations may be related to the level of satisfaction with the communication of test results by the provider or an awareness of the widespread combined use of viral load monitoring and combination therapy (HAART) that has led to a dramatic decrease in morbidity and mortality.

Most studies examining the psychological impact of notification of HIV serostatus before 1988 were restricted to cohorts of gay/bisexual men, hemophiliacs, and intravenous drug users, regardless of gender. Several of these studies found that notification of a positive HIV serostatus was associated with persistent psychological distress manifested in the form of depression, anxiety, suicidal ideations, suicide attempts, and other somatic and psychological symptoms of distress.4,5 Cleary et al.5 studied the psychological effects of HIV antibody testing of 173 seropositive individuals (135 men and 38 women) at the completion of a notification session in which antibody test results were provided. They reported higher depression scores on the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) in seropositive individuals than in community samples postnotification.5

In contrast to these earlier studies, others did not find strong associations between initial positive HIV serostatus notification and persistent psychological distress. Perry et al.6 found that those most distressed after notification of HIV seropositivity were also most distressed before it. This observation reflects a limitation in retrospective studies of whether certain HIV seropositive individuals are particularly vulnerable for psychiatric symptoms, and whether their psychiatric risk factor profile differs from that found in HIV-seronegative samples. This methodological limitation was not present in some prospective studies performed in later years of the epidemic, such as seen in the Perry et al.6 investigational study. They were interested in studying the psychological reactions of HIV testing in adults. They followed 328 homosexual and heterosexual men at perceived risk for HIV infection but without AIDS. Over a 1-year period, they found a decline in severity of symptoms on both clinician and self-rated scales, but no difference between HIV-positive and HI-negative participants on any occasion. These investigators concluded that regardless of serostatus, a notable percentage of at-risk adults had sustained levels of psychiatric symptoms.7 A similar conclusion was echoed by Dew et al.8 in a multivariate analyses of 113 HIV-positive and 57 HIV-negative men. They reported that persons at risk for HIV infection (regardless of serostatus) had higher rates of some psychiatric disorders than the general population.

Early in the epidemic, relatively few women were included in clinical trials and psychological research. As a result, there is a relative lack of information on the psychological well-being related to HIV testing in women. A literature review by Nakajima and Rubin9 showed 31 studies examining the psychosocial aspects of HIV infection in 2,438 patients.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Aug 28, 2016 | Posted by in PSYCHIATRY | Comments Off on Psychological Reactions

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access