Somatoform and Factitious Disorders


DSM-IV

DSM-5

Somatomorphic disorders

Somatization disorder

Undifferentiated somatoform disorder

Pain disorder

Hypochondriasis disorder

Somatic symptom and related disorders

Somatic symptom disorder

Illness anxiety disorder

Conversion disorder

Conversion disorder (functional neurological symptom disorder)

Body dysmorphic disorder
  
Psychological factors affecting other medical conditions

Factitious disorder

Factitious disorder



Factors that increase risks of suffering unexplainable somatic symptoms—with the exception of the hypochondriac disorder—include being a woman, young, different race from white, low cultural level, and low level of income [21].


33.3.1 Historical Evolution


The existence of patients, women in most of the cases, with multiple and recurrent physical complaints for which it is impossible to find an organic explanation, and are therefore interpreted as a mental illness, have a long history.

In 1859 Paul Briquet, in his work Traite Clinique et Therapeutique de L’Hystérie, described a psychopathological pattern suffered by young women, characterized by sexual complaints and pain symptoms. This syndrome was understood to be a type of hysteria that appeared at an early age and was stable throughout time [22]. There is a certain unanimity in the scientific literature in designating Steckel as the author who coined the term somatization [23, 24], who granted a similar meaning to Freud’s conversion concept. Steckel (1943) defined the term as “the process in which a psychological disorder can produce corporal disorders” [24].

In the 1960s more than 60 symptoms were listed, belonging to more than ten categories, of which at least 25 are needed to diagnose de Briquet syndrome [14, 25]. In the DSM-III, the term somatization disorder is used for the first time, substituting the de Briquet syndrome and the somatomorphic disorders category is included. Somatomorphic disorder is defined as a chronic disorder, although it is fluctuating, polysymptomatic, that begins before the age of 30 years, and occurs primarily in women.

The DSM-III R proposes seven symptoms that could be considered almost pathognomic [26]. These authors indicate that the presence of two or more symptoms of this group of seven (dysmenorrhea, feeling a lump in one’s throat, vomiting, breathing problems, rectal, mouth or genitalia burning, pain in the extremities, and amnesia) give an accurate diagnosis.

In the DSM-IV [1] for the somatization disorder the symptoms have to be specified, with at least four pain symptoms being necessary, two gastrointestinal, one sexual symptom, and one neurological symptom. Another highlight in the DSM-IV is the necessity of these symptoms to provoke an important deterioration in crucial activities the person does or that lead this person to search for medical care.

The somatization disorder is not included in the CIE until the last version. It does not specify the number of symptoms that the patient must suffer, but it does say that they must be multiple and variable, there must not exist a medical explanation that justifies the clinical and that the patient must show a persistent negative attitude to accepting medical explanations. This disorder provokes a deterioration of personal, professional, and social behavior.

The DSM-5 recently published proposes a change in the somatomorphic disorder diagnosis to somatic symptoms and related disorders. It defines them more as a somatic symptom, which generates distress and anxiety and/or ends up disturbing everyday life. This must be associated with thoughts, feelings or behaviors involving symptoms or health conditions. It becomes chronic after 6 months.

Somatization, hypochondria, pain, and somatomorphic undifferentiated disorders are deleted from the DSM-5. Somatization and somatomorphic undifferentiated disorders are combined to become somatic disorder symptoms, which does not need a specific number of somatic symptoms. In the DSM-5, people with chronic pain can be diagnosed as having a disorder of somatic symptoms with predominant pain or as psychological factors, which affect other medical conditions. Finally, it proposes the predominance of somatic symptoms, anxious or painful; hypochondria is renamed anxiety disorder owing to illness and conversion disorder becoming neurological function disorder.


33.3.2 Need for Change DSM IV–DSM 5


Next are listed some of the possible reasons why the somatomorphic disorders have been modified in the DSM-5 [27].



  • In the DSM IV the only common characteristic of the somatomorphic disorders is the presence of somatic symptoms, which are not referable to medical illness. There are multiple coincidences with psychiatric disorders that are defined equally because of the presence of somatic symptoms, such as depression and anxiety; thus, there is a clear disposition to errors of diagnosis.


  • Many of the somatomorphic disorders cannot be extrapolated to other cultures that conceive mind and body in a less dual way: for example, the Chinese classification excludes somatomorphic disorders.


  • The exclusion of medical illness as essential criteria to diagnose a somatomorphic disorder also leads to errors, because it is not made clear if the “somatic functional symptoms,” such as irritable bowel, chronic fatigue or fibromyalgia would also be excluded from the diagnosis.


  • In general, many of the diagnostic subcategories included within somatomorphic disorders lack validity as an independent disease and would be included with better criteria under other disorders. The clearest example is the dysmorphic body disorder, included under somatomorphic disorders, which would require relocation toward obsessive disorders.


  • The terminology is unacceptable for patients, as far as somatic symptoms with no medical explanation are considered, and “mental,” in other words products of the mind, are not “real.”


33.3.2.1 Disorders with a Predominance of Somatic Symptoms



Somatization Disorder

The term somatization has been used to refer to a wide variety of clinical phenomena. From a more traditional view it could be defined as the inability to express emotional distress, the somatic symptoms being a “distress idiom.” Another point of view would define somatization as somatic complaints in the presence of an anxiety disorder or an underlying depression. The third view presents somatization as the presence of somatic symptoms that do not have a clear medical explanation. Each of the three ways used to define somatization may identify different groups of patients. Several studies indicate varying prevalence rates, from 0.2 % to 2 % in women and less than 0.2 % in men. Individuals with somatization disorder are usually young women, who describe their symptoms in a striking and exaggerated way. They tell of multiple, relevant, somatic complaints that affect various systems. The majority of individuals with this disorder report the presence of nausea and bloating. The disease is diagnosed before the age of 25, and the first symptoms can start to occur during adolescence; in women menstrual irregularities constitute one of the signs that manifest it more promptly. Sexual symptoms are often associated with marital conflict. The reasons why these patients are often seen in mental health facilities are because of the presence of significant symptoms of anxiety and depression. There is a positive correlation between depression and somatic symptoms [28], constituting in certain studies up to 85 % [29]. From this close relationship the term “masked depression” arises, which explains the manifestation of a depressive disorder primarily by physical symptoms, which are more intense and severe than the psychic symptoms [30]. In the work of Kirmayer and Robins [31], only 21 % of the patients presenting an anxious or depressive disorder communicate mental symptoms to their general physician.

Disorders related to substance abuse are frequently associated with somatization disorder, as are histrionic personality, and limited and antisocial disorders. It is important to differentiate between somatization disorder and simulation and factitious disorders. In the latter, unlike with somatization, the patient exerts control of his symptoms either by faking them or by self-inducing them.


Pain Disorder

Pain is defined by the International Association for the study of Pain (IASP) as “an unpleasant sensation and emotional experience, associated with a present or potential damage in tissues,” and it is a subjective experience only recognized by the patient who can be believed or not by the treating physician. Pain disorder is defined in the CIE as “a persistent pain without a clear medical explanation”; it differs from the DSM definition, which believes that “psychological factors play an important role in the onset, severity, exacerbation or the persistence of pain.” It is more frequent in women with a ratio of 2 to 1.This disorder can appear at any age. Women seem to experience certain types of chronic pain, such as headaches and musculoskeletal pain, more frequently than men. The pain may seriously alter several aspects of daily life. Unemployment, disability, and family problems have been frequently observed among individuals who suffer from chronic forms of pain disorder.

Dependence or abuse of iatrogenic opiates and/or benzodiazepines may occur; therefore, the use of these drugs should be avoided. Individuals suffering from pain associated with severe depression or related to a terminal illness, primarily cancer, are at an increased risk of suicide. Patients with recurrent acute pain or chronic pain are convinced that somewhere there is a health professional who has the healing method for their pain. There is no voluntary control of the symptoms and it is often difficult to find a psychological factor in the psychogenesis of pain. Comorbidity with anxiety and depression as well as with conversion disorders is very common.


Conversion Disorder

It is historically referred to as hysterical neurosis of conversion. The essential characteristic of conversion disorder is the presence of symptoms or deficits that affect the motor or sensory functions and which suggest a neurological disorder or any other medical illness. Conversion symptoms are related to voluntary or sensory motor activity, and therefore are called “pseudo-neurological.” Typical motor symptoms are disturbances of coordination and balance, paralysis or localized muscle weakness, localized hoarseness, difficulty swallowing, sensation of a lump in the throat, and urinary retention. The sensory type symptoms tend to be loss of touch and painful sensitivity, diplopia, blindness, deafness, and hallucinations. Crisis or seizures may also occur. The less medical knowledge the patient has, the more implausible are his referring symptoms. Individuals with symptoms of conversion may manifest la belle indifference (a relative lack of concern about the nature or the implications of the symptoms) or present attitudes of a dramatic or histrionic type. Owing to the easy suggestibility of these individuals, their symptoms may be modified or may disappear according to external stimuli; however, it must be kept in mind that this is not specific to conversion disorder and that it can occur in different medical diseases. It is common for symptoms to appear after a situation of extreme psychosocial stress.


Other Clinical Pictures

Various specific somatic syndromes have been described that are defined by somatic symptoms; these are part of entities such as fibromyalgia, irritable bowel syndrome or chronic fatigue syndrome. Most of these syndromes occur more frequently in women than in men [32]. Primary care studies have found that several of these syndromes are associated with symptoms of anxiety and depression [33].


33.3.2.2 Disorders with Predominant Cognitive Symptoms



Hypochondria

The essential feature of hypochondriasis is worry and fear of suffering, or the conviction of having a serious illness, from the erroneous interpretation of one or more signs or somatic symptoms. It usually starts between the ages of 20 and 30, being somewhat more frequent in women and having a chronic evolution. The fact that it is more frequent in women may have to do with the high proportion of women being treated in the medical facilities.

The physical examinations and different tests that these patients undergo because of the etiology of their symptoms are negative. Despite these negative results, patients are persistent in their belief and are alarmed when there is any indicative sign of possible illness, constantly observing their bodies. Often, patients tend to present their clinical history in a very detailed and extensive manner. The presence of “medical pilgrimages” (doctor shopping) and the deterioration of the patient–physician relationship, with frustration and anger on both sides, are frequent. Sometimes these patients believe that they do not receive appropriate care and refuse to be sent to mental health centers. People suffering from this disorder may be alarmed when reading or hearing about diseases, with the news that someone has been ill or even by observing what is happening in their own body. Being concerned about the disease often becomes the individual’s central feature of self-perception, in a repeated conversation subject, and in response to a stressful situation. It is important to differentiate between hypochondriasis and apprehensive people. In hypochondriasis discomfort is significant, affecting employment, social life, or other important areas in the person’s life. Rates of psychiatric comorbidity of hypochondria are high, up to 80 %, including anxious disorders, depressive disorders, and personality disorders [34, 35]. In the latter case, many authors argue that hypochondria is really a pattern of dysfunctional personality with a tendency to interpret somatic sensations [36].

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

May 28, 2017 | Posted by in PSYCHOLOGY | Comments Off on Somatoform and Factitious Disorders

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access