The Psychotherapies
Dozens of different psychotherapies address innumerable different patient problems (1). With the possible exception of a few specific behavioral and cognitive-behavioral methods applied to several discrete problems, rigorous proof of psychotherapy’s effectiveness does not exist. However, much nonrigorous but very compelling experience indicates that various psychotherapies can help many patients—almost every therapist educates, gets patients to voice their concerns, encourages them to try out new behaviors, etc. Unfortunately, specific indications for specific therapies generally are not available. Some experts argue that many supposedly different psychotherapeutic methods are actually quite similar in practice (2). Other experts suggest that trained therapists using specific techniques may be less important for the patient’s improvement than the therapist’s personal characteristics of accurate empathy, nonpossessive warmth, and genuineness. Studies comparing the effectiveness of empathic trainees with that of experienced therapists have often found only modest differences in outcome (3).
Psychotherapy is a field without a high level of scientific objectivity. However, it is clear that some patients benefit from such care and that an essential ingredient to that care is a good patient-therapist relationship built on trust and genuine interest. Psychotherapy is an art, and a good therapist does make a difference. In general, one needs to find a therapy that is a “good fit” for the patient (i.e., the patient is comfortable with the therapist and the type of therapy). Patients resist psychotherapy unless they feel that it is both tolerable and likely to be of benefit; the dropout rate from therapy can be quite high. Individual treatment is the most common form of psychotherapy and comes in endless variations; group, family, and marital therapy are in widespread use as well (4).
INDIVIDUAL THERAPY
Supportive Therapy
Supportive therapy is probably the most common form of individual therapy (5). Therapists skilled in this method include
psychiatrists, clinical psychologists, and social workers, although some approximation of supportive therapy is used by just about anyone who tries to help a person in emotional distress. The goal is to evaluate the patient’s current life situation and his strengths and weaknesses and then to help him make whatever realistic changes will allow him to be more functional. Patients usually are seen weekly (or more often) for several weeks or months (although some patients are followed up infrequently for years). Also included is brief (1-3 session) crisis intervention.
psychiatrists, clinical psychologists, and social workers, although some approximation of supportive therapy is used by just about anyone who tries to help a person in emotional distress. The goal is to evaluate the patient’s current life situation and his strengths and weaknesses and then to help him make whatever realistic changes will allow him to be more functional. Patients usually are seen weekly (or more often) for several weeks or months (although some patients are followed up infrequently for years). Also included is brief (1-3 session) crisis intervention.
The therapist deals with the patient’s symptoms but works very little with the patient’s unconscious processes and does not attempt major personality change. Psychological defenses are reinforced; techniques used include reassurance, suggestion, ventilation, abreaction, and environmental manipulation. The therapist must be active, interested, empathic, and warm—listen to the patient, understand his concerns, and help him find direction. Medication may be used.
Patients who are failing to cope successfully with present stress are good candidates, whether or not they have underlying psychiatric problems. Patients with serious psychiatric illnesses (e.g., schizophrenia, major affective disorder) often benefit from concurrent use of biologic methods and supportive psychotherapy.
Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy
Psychoanalysis is the classic, long-term insight-oriented therapy. The goal is to make major personality changes by identifying and modifying (“working through”) unconscious conflicts by means of free association, analysis of transference and resistance, and dream interpretation. An “analysis” typically takes several hundred hours. “Neurotics” and those with personality disorders are the preferred patients. It is lengthy, expensive, and of uncertain effectiveness and so is infrequently used.
Psychoanalytic psychotherapy is similar to supportive therapy in that the goal is removal of symptoms, yet is similar to psychoanalysis in requiring a dynamic understanding of the patient’s unconscious conflicts (insight) and in using analysis of the transference and dream interpretation. It is briefer than psychoanalysis and is used much more often.
Recently, brief psychotherapy has been explored as a way to affect a patient’s problems while limiting both the number of therapy sessions (12 to 25+) and the number of issues addressed.
Usually a single conflict or interpersonal issue is chosen for therapy and explored in depth, most commonly from a psychodynamic perspective. Early results appear promising (6). Recognize that brief therapy can be approached from numerous different theoretical perspectives as well (e.g., using humanistic principles such as a belief that we all share an innate need for acceptance, love, and respect and that given proper support and help, we all have an innate drive toward psychological growth and health).
Usually a single conflict or interpersonal issue is chosen for therapy and explored in depth, most commonly from a psychodynamic perspective. Early results appear promising (6). Recognize that brief therapy can be approached from numerous different theoretical perspectives as well (e.g., using humanistic principles such as a belief that we all share an innate need for acceptance, love, and respect and that given proper support and help, we all have an innate drive toward psychological growth and health).
Interpersonal Therapy
A recent, reasonably well-controlled study (the New Haven-Boston Collaborative Depression Project) compared the effectiveness of various forms of psychotherapy with, and without, medication in the treatment of mild to moderate depression (7,8). Interpersonal therapy (ITP) was found effective. The combination of ITP and drugs improved most depressions, and maintenance medication or ITP or both seemed to prevent relapse.
ITP focuses on the patient’s interpersonal relationships, their nature and their failings, and on improving those relationships. The idea is that if a person has vigorous, healthy, rewarding relations with other people, the person is less likely to become, be, or stay depressed (or anxious, etc.), and more likely to be happy. Evidence suggests this to be true. Treatment consists of:

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

