Algorithm 1
Algorithm 2
Initial imaging usually consists of plain radiography. This is not very sensitive mainly because of the poor two-dimensional tissue separation due to the complex three-dimensional anatomy of the spine. The sensitivity to specify a vertebral lesion on an X-ray is difficult as well. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is the imaging modality of choice when it comes to detecting and characterizing tumours of the osseous spine. MRI has the advantage of superior soft tissue characterization, the possibility of multiplanar imaging and the ability of evaluating present neurological compromise. Computed tomography (CT) is superior in detecting calcifications or cortical bone lesions. Since this technique offers multiplanar imaging too, it is very well suited to evaluate the complex anatomy of the posterior vertebral elements and assess some typical lesions in this anatomical region. Furthermore CT plays an important role in biopsy guidance or therapeutic ablation of certain tumours.
1.1.2 Age and Clinical History
The patient’s age is a very important piece of information when it comes to differentiating a vertebral tumour (Algorithm 2). For example, osteoid osteoma, aneurysmal bone cyst (ABC) and Ewing sarcoma are predominantly found in young people, giant cell tumour (GCT) in the middle-aged and chordoma in the elderly.
The value of a thorough clinical history and examination should not be underestimated. Multiple vertebral body lesions in a patient with a known primary tumour will most likely be metastases. Depending on the extent and location of the tumour, clinical symptoms may arise. Osteoid osteoma, aggressive haemangioma and malignancies are typically symptomatic.
1.1.3 Number of Lesions
Determining the multiplicity of vertebral bone pathology offers a valuable clue to narrow down the differential diagnosis. Solitary vertebral lesions are less common than lesions in multiple locations. Pathology with multiple vertebral lesions will most frequently be metastases from breast and lung tumours in woman and prostate and lung tumours in men (Fig. 1.1). A medical history of a primary tumour supports this diagnosis even more. Multiple lesions are seen in 30% of vertebral metastases [1]. Multiple primary vertebral lesions are most commonly lymphoproliferative disorders such as lymphoma or multiple myeloma (Fig. 1.2). Other multifocal lesions include eosinophilic granuloma in children, fibrous dysplasia and haemangioma (Fig. 1.3). MRI and bone scintigraphy or single positron emission computed tomography (SPECT) are most sensitive in the detection of multiple lesions. Radiologists should, however, be aware that MRI is normal in as much as 20% of cases of multiple myeloma [1].
Fig. 1.1
Sagittal T1-WI in a patient with a known primary neoplasm showing multiple hypointense vertebral metastases
Fig. 1.2
Sagittal T2-WI in a patient with lymphoma showing multiple lesions
Fig. 1.3
(a, b) Coronal CT reconstruction showing an aggressive vertebral haemangioma extending over multiple vertebral levels (a). Multilevel involvement in a patient with fibrous dysplasia, illustrated on a sagittal T1-weighted MRI image (b)
Solitary vertebral tumours are less common. The differential diagnosis is much broader than for multiple lesions. This stresses the importance of a thorough analysis of the imaging features in order to come to the correct diagnosis or narrow down the differential diagnosis.
1.1.4 Location
The location of the tumour(s) in the spine is another helpful tool in the assessment of the nature of the lesion. The cervical spine is favoured by osteoblastoma, osteochondroma and eosinophilic granuloma. The thoracic spine is a predilection site for haemangioma, enostosis and chondrosarcoma [1–3]. ABC is frequently found in the thoracic spine but even more in the lumbosacral spine. Enostosis and osteoid osteoma are most commonly found in the lumbar spine [4]. The sacrum is often affected by chordoma and plasmacytoma (Fig. 1.4). Giant cell tumours (GCT) are the most common benign sacral tumours [5, 6]. Rarely Ewing sarcoma occurs in the sacrum [7].
Fig. 1.4
(a, b) Sagittal T1-WI demonstrating the typical sacral localization of plasmacytoma (a) and GCT (b). These tumours can be difficult to distinguish from each other on imaging alone, often stressing the need for a correlation with age and symptoms. In the case insufficient biopsy, this might be needed to make a diagnosis
The next feature to look for is the site of the lesion within the vertebra. Haemangioma, enostosis and GCT have a strong predilection for the vertebral body. Only 10% of haemangiomas are found in the posterior elements. Chordomas and Ewing sarcomas have a predilection for the vertebral body too, usually eccentrically. GCT tends to lie more centrally. Benign lesions of the posterior vertebral elements comprise osteoblastoma, osteoid osteoma, ABC and osteochondroma (Figs. 1.5, 1.6 and 1.7). Some lesions affect the vertebral body as well as the posterior elements. ABC prefers the pedicles but sometimes extends into the vertebral body (Fig. 1.8). On the other hand, plasmacytoma and multiple myeloma mainly affect the vertebral body but tend to spread to the posterior elements.
Fig. 1.5
Axial CT image in a patient with an osteoblastoma in the cervical spine. The tumour has a calcified or ossified matrix and is typically located in the posterior elements, in this case the right pedicle and lamina
Fig. 1.6
Axial CT image in a patient with an osteoid osteoma in the left lamina of a cervical vertebra. The characteristic morphology with a lucent central nidus surrounded by dense sclerotic bone can easily be depicted
Fig. 1.7
Osteochondroma localized both in the posterior elements and body of a vertebra, showing typical continuity of marrow and cortex with the underlying native bone
Fig. 1.8
Aneurysmal bone cyst. A well-defined, geographic, expansive, osteolytic lesion is found on CT. The tumour is located in the vertebral body as well as in the posterior elements
1.1.5 Morphology
1.1.5.1 Border
The border of a lesion is a good indicator of its biological activity. Benign lesions like haemangioma, enostosis, osteoid osteoma, osteoblastoma and ABC have a clear demarcation, known as geographic appearance (Fig. 1.8). In contrast, aggressive benign lesions like aggressive haemangioma and malignant lesions such as osteosarcoma, Ewing sarcoma and metastases have a large transition zone. Cortical destruction is also a sign of aggressiveness.
1.1.5.2 Matrix
The structure or matrix of a tumour can help the radiologist in diagnosing tumours arising from the bone or cartilage.
Osteoblastic tumours contain amorphous ossifications on plain radiography or CT. The matrix lacks an organized trabecular pattern and is usually less dense than normal bone. Dense osteoblastic lesions display a low T1–T2 signal intensity pattern on MR imaging. Enostosis is characterized by solid, dense, cortical bone within the spongy bone of the vertebral body. A typical feature of osteoid osteoma is calcification within a lucent nidus with surrounding reactive sclerosis (Fig. 1.6). Osteoblastoma is histologically similar to osteoid osteoma, with areas of calcification in the matrix, but is larger and more expansive (Fig. 1.5).
Cartilage-forming tumours typically show punctate, arc or ring calcifications at radiography and CT. These calcifications appear as low-signal-intensity foci at MR imaging. Chondroid tissues with ring- and arc-type calcifications are typical for osteochondroma and chondrosarcoma. This pattern may, however, also occur in osteoblastoma and chondroid types of chordoma (Fig. 1.5).
1.1.5.3 Expansion
ABC, osteoblastoma and to a lesser extent aggressive haemangioma can have an expansive nature (Figs. 1.5 and 1.8). Malignant lesions such as Ewing sarcoma and chondrosarcoma demonstrate expansion in combination with soft tissue extension, a feature that may, sometimes, be found in benign lesions like osteoblastoma and GCT as well.
1.1.5.4 Soft Tissue Component
A soft tissue component can be seen in malignant lesions like Ewing sarcoma but also in benign lesions like osteoblastoma. Aggressive haemangiomas can also be accompanied by a large soft tissue component. These lesions are frequently symptomatic.
1.1.6 Imaging Features
1.1.6.1 CT/X-ray Imaging Features
Distinction between lesions can be made based on their osteoblastic or osteolytic nature (Table 1.1). The amount and degree of matrix mineralization in osteoblastic lesions is widely variable; thus the appearance on plain radiography or CT may range from densely blastic to nearly completely lytic. The differential diagnosis of osteoblastic tumours includes osteoblastic metastasis, bone island, lymphoma and osteosarcoma. Osteoid osteoma and osteoblastoma are essentially no bone-forming tumours but display a high density due to adjacent reactive bone sclerosis.
Table 1.1
List of vertebral lesions that are predominantly osteolytic and those that are predominantly osteoblastic
Osteolytic vertebral lesions | Osteoblastic vertebral lesions |
---|---|
ABC | Osteoid osteoma (reactive sclerosis) |
Chordoma | Osteoblastoma (reactive sclerosis) |
Giant cell tumour | Enostosis |
Lymphoma | Lymphoma |
Metastasis | Hemangioma |
Plasmacytoma/multiple myeloma | Metastasis (breast, prostate) |
Sarcoma (osteo-, chondro-, Ewing) | Osteosarcoma |
As in osteoblastic lesions, a gradient in osteolytic lesions exists. A very lytic appearance is usually associated with a more aggressive behaviour. Less lytic lesions tend to be less aggressive. The differential diagnosis of a lytic vertebral lesion, ranked from moderately lytic to extremely lytic, includes ABC, chordoma, GCT, lymphoma, metastasis, plasmacytoma/multiple myeloma and sarcoma.
A SPECT study is very sensitive to osteoblastic activity. Osteoblastic and less aggressive osteolytic lesions with partial osteoblastic activity will be detected using this technique. Purely osteolytic tumours might escape detection (Table 1.2).
Table 1.2
Vertebral lesions that are purely osteolytic in nature and therefore might escape detection on SPECT examination
Bone lesions that can be negative on SPECT |
---|
Multiple myeloma |
Aggressive metastasis |
Chordoma |
In some cases the density of a lesion on CT facilitates further characterization. A low density (−50 to −100 HU) can be found in fatty lesions like lipomas and haemangiomas. By measuring the density, fat-containing lesions can be differentiated from air (−800 to −1000 HU), occasionally seen in degenerative disc disease. A very dense tumour in the spongy vertebral bone with a density similar to cortical bone will most likely be a bone island, also known as enostosis (Fig. 1.9).
Fig. 1.9
Axial CT image showing an enostosis in the right pedicle of L1, which appears very dense, similar in density to cortical bone
1.1.6.2 MR Imaging Features
The behaviour of a lesion on T1-weighted and T2-weighted MRI sequences is another important parameter. The majority of pathological lesions have low signal intensity on T1-WI and high signal intensity on T2-WI (Fig. 1.10). However, a few exceptions exist (Table 1.3). Haemangioma and eosinophilic granuloma contain fat and will be bright on T1-WI (Figs. 1.11 and 1.12). Another exception is the dark appearance of a GCT on T2-WI due to the high cellularity and collagen and haemosiderin content [8]. Bone islands are dark on both T1-WI and T2-WI since they are histologically identical to cortical bone.
Fig. 1.10
(a–c) Ewing sarcoma in the body of C3, demonstrating a low signal on T1-WI (a), a high signal on T2-WI (c) and a moderate enhancement after gadolinium administration (b)
Table 1.3
Vertebral lesions that do not follow the general rule of low signal intensity on T1-WI and high signal intensity on T2-WI
Lesions with high signal intensity on T1-WI | Lesions with low signal intensity on T2-WI |
---|---|
Haemangioma | Giant cell tumour |
Eosinophilic granuloma | Enostosis |
Fig. 1.11
(a, b) Multiple vertebral haemangiomas. These lesions typically have a high signal on T2-WI (a) but also on T1-WI (b), due to fatty contents
Fig. 1.12
(a–c) Eosinophilic granuloma. A well-demarcated lytic lesion is noted eccentrically in the body of a thoracic vertebra. A high signal intensity on T2-WI as well as T1-WI is typical
The enhancement pattern after the administration of a gadolinium chelate can be very suggestive in some cases, like a ring and arc pattern in chondroid tumours (Fig. 1.13).
Fig. 1.13
Sagittal contrast-enhanced T1-WI image in a patient with a vertebral chordoma. The tumour extends across multiple cervical segments and has a large dumbbell-shaped soft tissue component. Heterogeneous enhancement with ring and arc pattern of the chondroid matrix is noted
1.1.6.3 Specific Patterns
Some morphological patterns can offer, if present, a very specific diagnosis or differential diagnosis. It is, however, important to interpret these findings with caution and correlate them with all other features. Vertebra plana is characteristic for EG but can also be seen in rare cases of other tumours like GCT. A polka-dot pattern on axial CT images is very typical for a haemangioma (Fig. 1.14b). Osteoid osteoma displays a specific morphology that can be detected on radiography, CT and MRI: prominent reactive sclerosis surrounding a lucent central nidus (with variable central calcification) (Fig. 1.6). Paget’s disease and lymphoma may result in an expanded vertebra with marked sclerosis, known as an ivory vertebra. Although typically linked to ABC fluid–fluid levels, a result of sedimentation of blood degradation products can sometimes be found in osteoblastoma, chondroblastoma, telangiectatic osteosarcoma and rarely in GCT and fibrous dysplasia (Fig. 1.15) [9]. On axial MR images, a plasmacytoma may resemble the morphology of the brain, called mini-brain appearance [10]. Chordomas may be shaped as a dumbbell or mushroom, preserving the disc space (Fig. 1.13). The spider pattern can be observed in plasmacytoma but also in haemangioma (Fig. 1.16).
Fig. 1.14
(a–c) Thickening of bone trabeculae in a classic, nonaggressive haemangioma resulting in a “jail bar” or “honey-combing” appearance on plain radiography (a) and corresponding “polka-dot” sign on axial CT images (b). Sagittal T1-WI image (c) also showing the “jail bar” appearance, as well as a high signal intensity due to the fatty component of the lesion
Fig. 1.15
Aneurysmal bone cyst (ABC) in the right lateral parts of C6. T2-weighted MRI shows a large, expansive tumour with cystic components showing fluid–fluid levels. This is a typical finding for ABC but may also occur in other tumours
Fig. 1.16
(a, b) Axial CT image of a vertebra containing an osteolytic lesion with central dense bone and extending dense spider-leg appearance. This pattern is frequently observed in plasmacytoma (a) but also in haemangioma (b)
1.2 Primary Vertebral Lesions
1.2.1 Vertebral Haemangioma
1.2.1.1 General
Haemangioma is the most common benign vertebral tumour. Its incidence increases with age, with a peak around 40–60 years of age. The majority of haemangiomas are asymptomatic and discovered incidentally. In rare cases an aggressive behaviour is noted with a soft tissue mass that can cause neurological compromise. This lesion primarily affects the thoracic spine (>50%), a smaller portion is found in the lumbar spine (30%), and the cervical spine and sacrum are involved in the remainder. There is a strong affection for the vertebral body, but in 10% of the cases, spread to the posterior elements occurs. One third are multiple.