Literature (author; year)
PTSD (trauma; gender; N)
Control (trauma; gender; N)
Measure
Brain structures
Hippocampus (HC)
Amygdala
Prefrontal and cingulate cortices
Other brain regions
Abe et al. (2006)
Attack; mixed; 9
Trauma exposed; mixed; 16
DTI
FA increase in the left ACC
Baldacara et al. (2011)
Violence; mixed; 42
Trauma exposed; mixed; 42
Volume
Smaller left cerebellum and vermis
Bing et al. (2013)
MVA, mixed, 20
Healthy; mixed; 20
Thickness
Thinner in left mPFC, inferior frontal, ACC
Thinner in right superior temporal cortex
Bonne et al. (2001)
Unclear; mixed; 10
Trauma exposed; mixed; 27
Volume
No group difference and over time change
No group and overtime change
Bremner et al. (1995)
Combat; mixed; 26
Trauma-free; mixed; 22
Volume
Smaller right HC
Bremner et al. (1997)
Childhood abuse; mixed; 17
Trauma-free; mixed; 17
Volume
Smaller left HC
No difference
No difference in temporal lobe
Bremner et al. (2003)
Childhood abuse; F; 10
Childhood abuse; F; 12; trauma-free; F; 11
Volume
Smaller right and left HC in PTSD vs two control groups
Cardenas et al. (2011)
Veteran; M; 25
Trauma exposed; M; 22
Volume (DBM)
PTSD: non-PTSD: no difference
PTSD: non-PTSD: no difference
worsen PTSD: non-PTSD: decrease in dlPFC, ACC
worsen PTSD: non-PTSD: decrease in insula, anterior temporal lobe
Chao et al. (2012)
Combat; M; 21
Combat; M; 20
VBM
Lower density in left precentral, occipital, and right angular cortices
Chao et al. (2013)
Combat; mixed; current PTSD; 39, remitted PTSD; 34
Combat; mixed; 43, nonexposed; mixed; 75;
Volume
Smaller HC in current PTSD
No difference
Smaller caudal ACC in current PTSD
Smaller insula, corpus callosum, total brain volume in current PTSD
Chen et al. (2009)
Disaster; mixed; 12
Trauma exposed; mixed; 12
VBM
Lower density in left medial frontal gyrus
Lower density in bilateral insula
Chen et al. (2012)
Disaster; M; 10
Trauma exposed; M; 10, trauma-free; M; 20;
VBM
Lower density in left ACC in PTSD vs trauma-free control
Corbo et al. (2005)
Mixed trauma; mixed; 14
Trauma-free; mixed; 14
VBM
Lower density in right cingulate gyrus
Lower density in left insula
Depue et al. (2014)
Combat with PTSD+TBI; mixed; 16
Combat; mixed; 21
VBM volume
Decreased density and volume
Eckart et al. (2011)
Mixed civilian traumas; M; 20
Trauma exposed; M; 19
Volume, VBM
Smaller volume in left rostral middle frontal in PTSD and isthmus cingulate cortices in PTSD and trauma-exposed control
Smaller right volume in right inferior parietal cortex in PTSD and trauma-exposed control
Trauma-free; M; 13
Lower density in bilateral ACC, left isthmus cingulate cortices in PTSD and trauma-exposed control
Lower density in right inferior parietal cortex in PTSD and trauma-exposed control
Emdad et al. (2006)
Mixed; M; 23
Trauma-free; M; 17
VBM
Smaller bilateral HC
Volume
Lower density in right HC
Fani et al. (2012)
Interpersonal trauma; F; 25
Trauma exposed; F; 26
DTI
Lower FA in bilateral posterior cingulum
Lower FA in left superior longitudinal fasciculus, high FA in right lateral occipital cortex, uncorrected
Felmingham et al. (2009)
Civilian trauma; mixed; 21
Trauma exposed; mixed; 17
VBM
Lower density in bilateral HC
Lower density in bilateral rostral ACC, bilateral superior medial frontal cortex, left orbitofrontal gyrus
Lower density in left middle temporal gyrus and left supramarginal gyrus
Fennema-Notestine et al. (2002)
Intimate partner violence; F; 11
Trauma exposed; F; 11
Volume
No difference
No difference
Trauma-free; F; 17
Geuze et al. (2008)
Veteran; M; 25
Trauma exposed; M; 25
Cortical thickness
Thinner in bilateral superior, middle frontal, and left inferior frontal gyri
Thinner in left superior, temporal gyrus
Gilbertson et al. (2002)
Combat; monozygotic twins; M; 17
Trauma exposed; monozygotic twins; M; 23
Volume
Smaller HC in PTSD twin pairs than control twin pairs
No difference
Golier et al. (2005)
Holocaust; mixed; 14
Trauma-free; mixed; 20
Volume
No difference
Larger left lateral temporal lobe and bilateral superior temporal gyrus in two holocaust groups
Trauma-exposed; mixed; 13
Gurvits et al. (1996)
Combat; M; 7
Trauma exposed; M; 7
Volume
Smaller in bilateral HC in PTSD
No difference
CSF volume increased in PTSD and trauma-exposed groups
Trauma-free; M; 8
Hakamata et al. (2007)
Cancer; F; 14
Cancer; F; 100; healthy; F; 70
VBM
Smaller gray matter density in right orbitofrontal cortex
Hara et al. (2008)
Cancer; F; 15
Cancer; F; 15
Volume
No difference
No difference
Healthy; F; 15
Hedges et al. (2007)
Combat; M; 6
Trauma exposed; M; 5
Volume
No difference
Smaller right superior, middle, inferior temporal volume, fusiform and parahippocampus volume
Herringa et al. (2012)
Combat; mixed; 13;
Combat; mixed; 15;
VBM
Lower density in subgenual ACC and right middle frontal gyrus
Lower density in caudate, hypothalamus, left insula, middle temporal gyrus
Irle et al. (2009)
Childhood abuse; F; 10
Trauma-free; F; 25
Volume
Smaller bilateral HC
Smaller bilateral amygdala
Jatzko et al. (2006)
Disaster; mixed; 15
Trauma-free; mixed; 15
Volume
No difference
No difference in total brain volume, gray and white matter volume, and density
VBM
Kasai et al. (2008)
Combat; monozygotic twins; M; 18
Trauma exposed; monozygotic twins; M; 23
VBM
Lower density in right HC in PTSD
Lower density in pregenual ACC in PTSD
Lower density in bilateral insula in PTSD
Kim et al. (2006)
Disaster; mixed; 21
Trauma-free; mixed; 21
DTI
Lower FA in the left rostral, subgenual, dorsal ACC
Kitayama et al. (2006)
Abuse; mixed; 8
Trauma-free; mixed; 13
Volume
Smaller volume in right ACC
Kitayama et al. (2007)
Abuse; F; 9
Trauma-free; F; 9
Volume
Smaller posterior mid-body/total CC area ratio
Kuo et al. (2012)
Combat; mixed; 42
Trauma exposed; mixed; 45
Volume
Larger volume
Bossini et al. (2008)
Mixed trauma; mixed; 34
Trauma-free; mixed; 34
Volume
Smaller bilateral HC
Smaller brain gray matter volume, larger brain white matter volume, no difference in brain volume and CSF volume
Levitt et al. (2006)
Combat; monozygotic twins; M; 20
Trauma exposed; monozygotic twins; M; 23
Volume
No differences in vermis volume
Levy-Gigi et al. (2013)
Mixed trauma; mixed; 39
Traumatized; mixed; 31
Volume
Smaller bilateral HC; increased after CBT
No difference
Smaller volume in medial orbitofrontal cortex
No difference in total brain volume
Li et al. (2006)
Fire disaster; mixed; 12
Trauma exposed; mixed; 12
VBM
Lower density in left HC
Lindauer et al. (2005)
Mixed trauma; mixed 18
Trauma exposed; mixed; 14
Volume
Smaller HC, no change after treatment
No difference
Larger total and left parahippocampal gyrus
Lindauer et al. (2004)
Traumatized police officers; mixed; 14
Trauma exposed; mixed; 14
Volume
Smaller HC
No difference
No difference in parahippocampal gyrus, gray matter, white matter and CSF
Lindauer et al. (2006)
Traumatized police officers; mixed; 12
Trauma exposed; mixed; 12
Volume
Smaller bilateral HC
Lindemer et al. (2013)
Combat; mixed; 65
Combat; mixed; 39
Cortical thickness
Vertex based: thinner in bilateral postcentral and middle temporal; left fusiform; right precuneus, and inferior temporal
ROI based: thinner in right postcentral and left insula
Liu et al. (2012)
Disaster; M; 10
Trauma exposed; M; 10
Cortical thickness
Thinner in right inferior frontal cortex
Thinner in left precuneus and right parahippocampus
Lyoo et al. (2011)
Disaster; mixed; 30
Trauma-free; mixed; 36
Cortical thickness
Thicker in right dlPFC, left superior and inferior frontal cortices 1 year later
No difference 5 years later
May et al. (2004)
Combat; monozygotic twins; M; 20
Trauma exposed; monozygotic twins; M; 23
Volume
Greater cavum septum pellucidum in PTSD twins
Morey et al. (2012)
Military; mixed; 99
Trauma exposed; mixed; 101
Volume
Smaller left HC
Smaller bilateral amygdala
Nardo et al. (2010)
Occupational trauma; mixed; 21,
Trauma exposed; mixed; 22
VBM
Lower density in no treatment response PTSD (5 NR) than response PTSD (10 R)
Lower density in left PCC in PTSD than non-PTSD
Lower density in left precuneus, lingual, and posterior parahippocampal gyrus in PTSD than non-PTSD
Lower density in bilateral PCC and left middle and medial frontal gyri in NR than R
Lower density in left precentral, right anterior insula, and anterior parahippocampal gyrus in NR than R
Nardo et al. (2013)
Accident/assault mixed; 15
Trauma exposed; mixed; 17
VBM
Low density in right PFC, including superior, middle, and inferior frontal and rACC
Niedtfeld et al. (2013)
Abuse; F; 21
Trauma-free; F; 31
VBM
No difference
No difference
Greater density in dlPFC in borderline with PTSD
Greater density in left superior temporal gyrus in borderline with PTSD
Pavic et al. (2007)
Combat; mixed; 15
Trauma-free; mixed; 15
Volume
Smaller right HC in PTSD than control, smaller right HC than left HC in PTSD
Pitman et al. (2006)
Combat; monozygotic twins; M; 20
Trauma exposed; monozygotic twins; M; 24
Smaller HC in PTSD twin pairs
Rauch et al. (2003)
Combat; F; 9
Trauma exposed; F; 9
Volume
Smaller pregenual ACC, subcallosal cortex
Rocha-Rego et al. (2012)
Assault; mixed; 16
Trauma exposed; mixed; 16
VBM
No difference
No difference
Low density in pregenual ACC, premotor cortex
Rogers et al. (2009)
Attack; mixed; 9
Trauma exposed; mixed; 16
Volume
No difference
Smaller bilateral amygdala
VBM
Saar-Ashkenazy et al. (2014)
Civilian trauma; mixed; 20
Trauma-free; mixed; 17
Volume
Smaller corpus callosum, no difference in white matter and gray matter volume
Schuff et al. (2011)
Veterans; M; 17
Trauma exposed; M; 15
ASL, DTI
Lower FA in PFC, ACC and PCC
Higher rCBF in right parietal, superior temporal gyri
Starcevic et al. (2014)
Unclear; M; 49
Trauma exposed; M; 30
Volume
No difference
Smaller volume
No difference in PFC
Stein et al. (1997)
Childhood abuse; F; 21
Trauma-free; F; 21
Volume
Smaller left HC
Sui et al. (2010)
Sexual assault; F; 11
Trauma-free; F; 12
VBM
Lower density in right HC
Lower density in right amygdala
Higher density in right PCC
Higher density in left insula, cerebellum, including pyramis, uvula, declive, and nodule
Sui et al. (2010)
Sexual assault; F; 11
Trauma exposed; F; 8
VBM
Lower density in bilateral medial frontal and left middle frontal cortices, higher density in right PCC in PTSD
Lower density in left middle temporal and fusiform cortices in PTSD;
Trauma-free; F; 12
Higher density in right postcentral, bilateral precentral, and inferior parietal cortices in PTSD
Tan et al. (2013)
Mine disaster; M; 12
Symptom improved; M; 7
VBM
Lower gray matter density in right lingual gyrus in chronic PTSD vs symptom-improved group
Trauma exposed; M; 14
Right superior frontal and left superior parietal lobe in PTSD vs trauma control
Tavanti et al. (2012)
Mixed trauma; mixed; 25
Trauma-free; mixed; 25
Volume
Smaller bilateral frontal lobes
Smaller bilateral occipital lobes
VBM
Lower density in left frontal lobe
Lower density in right inferior temporal gyrus
Villarreal et al. (2002)
Mixed trauma; mixed; 12
Trauma-free; mixed; 10
Volume
Smaller bilateral HC
Volume reduction in white matter
Villarreal et al. (2004)
Mixed trauma; mixed; 12
Trauma-free; mixed; 10
Volume
Smaller corpus callosum total volume, and genu, mid-body, and isthmus subregional volume
Vythilingam et al. (2005)
Combat; mixed; 14
Trauma exposed; mixed; 23
Volume
Smaller bilateral head of HC in PTSD than civilians, smaller right HC in trauma-exposed veterans than civilians
Trauma-free; mixed; 22
Trauma-free civilians; mixed; 29
Wang et al. (2010)
Combat; M; 17
Trauma exposed; M; 19
Volume
Smaller HC and CA3/dentate gyrus subfield volumes
Weniger et al. (2008)
Childhood abuse; F; 10
Trauma-free; F; 25
Volume
Smaller HC in PTSD
Smaller amygdala in PTSD
Trauma exposed; F; 13
Wignall et al. (2004)
Accident; mixed; 15
Trauma-free; mixed; 11
Volume
Smaller right HC
No difference
Smaller brain volume
Woodward et al. (2009)
Combat; mixed; 50
Trauma exposed; mixed; 47
Volume, cortical thickness
Smaller volume in lateral OFC and pars orbitalis
Smaller volume in parahippocampus, superior temporal region
Thinner thickness in rostral and caudal ACC
Thinner thickness in superior temporal cortex
Woodward et al. (2006)
Combat; mixed; 51
Trauma exposed; mixed; 48
Volume
Smaller ACC volume
Woodward et al. (2007)
Combat; mixed; 51
Trauma exposed; mixed; 48
Volume
Smaller cranial and CSF volume
Yamasue et al. (2003)
Attack; mixed; 9
Trauma exposed; mixed; 16
VBM
Lower density in the left ACC
Yehuda et al. (2007)
Combat; M; 17
Trauma exposed; M; 16
Volume
No difference
Zhang et al. (2011)
Disaster; M; 17
Trauma-free; M; 28;
DTI
Decreased FA in ACC in PTSD vs GAD
Generalized anxiety disorder (GAD); M; 20
Increased FA in left superior frontal gyrus in PTSD vs trauma-free controls
Zhang et al. (2011)
Disaster; M; 10
Trauma exposed; M; 10
Volume, VBM
Smaller volume and lower density in left HC
Smaller volume and lower density in bilateral calcarine and left parahippocampus
Zandieh et al. (2016)
Torture; mixed; 9
Violent-free; mixed; 10
Volume
Smaller volume in left HC
Fani et al. (2016)
Mixed trauma; F: 13
Trauma exposed; F; 41
DTI
Decreased FA in ACC in PTSD
Luo et al. (2016)
Bereavement; mixed; 57
Trauma- xposed; mixed; 11
Volume
Left HC atrophy in PTSD and trauma-exposed group
No difference
trauma-free; mixed; 39
Li et al. (2016)
Earthquake; mixed; 67
Trauma exposed; mixed; 78
Cortical thickness, volume
Greater thickness in the right superior temporal gyrus, inferior parietal lobule, and left precuneus; reduced volume in the posterior corpus callosum
Helpman et al. (2016)
Mixed trauma; mixed; 25 (11 remitters; 14 non-remitters)
Trauma exposed; mixed; 25
Cortical thickness, volume
Left rACC thinning and reduced volume from pre- to posttreatment in remitters
Mueller et al. (2015)
Combat; M; 40
Trauma exposed; M; 45
Cortical thickness, volume
Cortical thinning in rACC
Cortical thinning in insula
Sun et al. (2015)
Traffic accidents; mixed; 15
Trauma exposed; mixed; 14
DTI
Decreased FA in commissural tracts connecting bilateral superior/middle frontal gyrus
Bierer et al. (2015)
Combat; M; 12
Trauma exposed; M; 8
DTI
Lower MD in the right cingulum bundle
Chalavi et al. (2015)
Interpersonal trauma; F; 33
Trauma exposed; F; 28
Volume
Smaller bilateral HC, especially bilateral subfield CA2-3, right CA4-DG, and left presubiculum
Table 12.2
Summary of structural MRI studies on pediatric PTSD
Literature | PTSD (trauma; gender; N) | Control (trauma; gender; N) | Measure | Brain structures | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Hippocampus | Amygdala | Prefrontal and cingulate cortices | Other brain regions | ||||
Carrion et al. (2001) | Mixed trauma; mixed; 24 | Trauma-free; mixed; 24 | Volume | No difference | No differences | Smaller total brain and cerebral gray matter volumes | |
Carrion et al. (2009) | Interpersonal trauma; mixed; 24; | Trauma-free; mixed; 24 | Volume | Larger volume in bilateral superior and inferior PFC | Smaller volume in the pons | ||
VBM | Greater density in bilateral ventral PFC | ||||||
De Bellis et al. (1999) | Maltreatment; mixed; 44 | Trauma-free; mixed; 61 | Volume | No difference | No difference | No difference | Smaller volume in cerebral, intracranial, and corpus callosum, larger volume in bilateral lateral ventricles and CSF |
De Bellis et al. (2001) | Maltreatment; mixed; 9 | Trauma-free; mixed; 9 | Volume | No difference | No difference | No difference in temporal lobe | |
De Bellis et al. (2002) | Maltreatment; mixed; 28; | Trauma-free; mixed; 66; | Volume | No difference | No difference | Smaller total and white matter volume in PFC | Smaller cerebral and intracranial volume; right temporal, and corpus callosum volume; larger frontal lobe CSF and lateral ventricular volume |
De Bellis et al. (2002) | Maltreatment; mixed; 43; | Trauma-free; mixed; 61 | Volume | Larger cerebral volume and unadjusted gray matter volume in superior temporal gyrus (STG), smaller STG white matter volume | |||
De Bellis et al. (2003) | Maltreatment; mixed; 61; | Trauma-free; mixed; 122 | Volume | Larger prefrontal CSF volumes and smaller midsagittal corpus callosum in both boys and girls with PTSD; smaller cerebral, rostrum, and isthmus corpus callosum volumes; and greater lateral ventricular volume in boys with PTSD | |||
De Bellis et al. (2006) | Maltreatment; mixed; 58 | Trauma exposed with GAD; mixed; 13 | Volume | Smaller brain stem volume and bilateral cerebellum volume in PTSD, larger cerebellar volume in PTSD boys | |||
Trauma-free; mixed; 98 | |||||||
De Bellis et al. (2010) | Maltreatment; mixed; 49 | Maltreatment; mixed; 49 | Volume | No difference | |||
Trauma-free; mixed; 118 | |||||||
Jackowski et al. (2008) | Maltreatment; mixed; 17 | Trauma-free; mixed; 15 | DTI | Lower FA in anterior and posterior mid-body corpus callosum regions | |||
Richert et al. (2006) | Mixed trauma; mixed; 23 | Trauma-free; mixed; 24 | Volume | Larger gray matter volume in the middle and inferior ventral PFC | |||
Tupler et al. (2006) | Maltreatment; mixed; 61 | Trauma-free; mixed; 122 | Volume | Larger bilateral HC | |||
Ahmed et al. (2012) | Mixed trauma; mixed; 21 | Trauma exposed; mixed; 32 | VBM | Low density in right ACC | Low density in left insula, right precuneus | ||
Thickness | Thinner thickness in insula | ||||||
De Bellis et al. (2015) | Maltreatment; mixed; 38 | Trauma exposed; mixed; 35 | Volume | smaller cerebral and cerebellar total volume and gray matter volumes, smaller superior posterior brain regional gray matter volumes, larger white matter and CSF volumes in bilateral superior frontal-parietal region | |||
Trauma-free; mixed; 59 | DTI | lower AF in occipital region to corpus callosum | |||||
Morey et al. (2016) | Maltreatment; mixed; 32 | Trauma exposed; mixed; 31 | Volume | Large right HC in non-PTSD group vs PTSD and non-trauma control groups | Large left amygdala in non-PTSD group vs PTSD and non-trauma control groups | Smaller right vmPFC in PTSD group | |
Trauma-free; mixed; 57 | |||||||
Keding et al. (2015) | Mixed trauma; mixed; 27 | Trauma-free; mixed; 27 | VBM | No difference | Smaller gray matter volume in right anterior vmPFC | Reduced gray matter volume in bilateral fusiform gyrus and left occipital cortex |
Hippocampus
Hippocampus is a temporal lobe structure implicated in learning and memory processing as well as in emotion processing, contextual processing, stress regulation, and more [11, 42, 119, 147]. PTSD symptoms had been also associated with deficits in memory function and negative emotion processing [11], implicating hippocampus in PTSD-related pathophysiology. Accordingly, abnormal activation of the hippocampus had been suggested by functional MRI studies of PTSD patients, as compared to trauma-exposed and healthy control subjects (reviewed by [80, 112]). Multiple structural MRI studies thus examined the hippocampal volume and VBM in diverse cohorts of adult PTSD patients including survivors of combat, physical/sexual abuse, disasters, and childhood maltreatment. The majority of volumetric studies reported smaller left, right, or bilateral hippocampal volumes in PTSD patients [7–10, 15, 17, 36, 47, 50, 57, 76, 82–84, 88, 109, 111, 120, 127, 139, 140, 144, 146, 149, 157]. In contrast, a smaller but meaningful number of studies failed to find difference in hippocampal volume in PTSD [6, 40, 48, 52, 53, 59, 117, 126, 156]. The meta-analyses published to date in general confirm smaller hippocampal volume in PTSD patients [61, 78, 107, 125], and the most recent largest meta-analysis examining neuroimaging and clinical data from 1868 subjects across 16 cohorts confirmed the presence of smaller hippocampus in PTSD [87]. Studies of the size of the subdivisions of hippocampus suggest that the dentate gyrus and adjacent anterior hippocampus specifically might be smaller in PTSD patients [140, 143]. Furthermore, some studies had found that hippocampal volume is smaller in veterans with current PTSD as compared to veterans with remitted PTSD, potentially suggesting that the hippocampal volume may be associated with the presence of active PTSD symptoms [17]. In concert, VBM-based studies also reported decreased gray matter density in hippocampal regions in PTSD patients [36, 39, 62, 77, 129, 130].
These structural findings were met with substantial interest because the convergence of functional and structural MRI findings suggests that the hippocampus may play a role in PTSD development. With respect to the functional significance of the volumetric findings, several studies reported relationships between hippocampal volume and the severity of PTSD symptoms, especially reexperiencing or dissociative symptoms [8, 39, 47, 82, 83, 127, 134, 139, 140, 144]. Furthermore, it has been also reported that in PTSD veterans, a smaller right hippocampal volume was positively correlated with deficits in short-term verbal memory, suggesting that alterations of hippocampal structure may be related to the memory functions of PTSD patients [8]. Interestingly, more recent data suggested that these findings might be at least to some degree reversible, as some interventions may be able to alter the hippocampal volume of PTSD patients. For example, a SSRI treatment that increases hippocampal volume of PTSD patients also reduces PTSD symptoms and significantly improved verbal memory [137]. Similarly, cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), which had been demonstrated as effective treatment for PTSD, also increased hippocampal and medial orbital frontal volume associated with the clinical symptom improvement in PTSD patient [76]. However, these relationships between reduction of hippocampal volume and memory function or PTSD symptoms have not been detected in other studies [40, 117, 143, 150]. Thus, existing findings linking the abnormalities of hippocampal structure to symptom levels in PTSD patients are yet to be firmly established, and additional work clarifying these relationships is needed. Further examination of these relationships carries promise to further advance current understanding of PTSD pathophysiology.

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

