Febrile Convulsions



Febrile Convulsions





Febrile seizures are the prototype of occasional epileptic seizures (see Chapter 1). That young children have a high susceptibility to convulsions in a setting of acute fever has long been known. This vulnerability to seizures with fever is common, and it appears to cluster in families. The relationship of seizures induced by fever to epilepsy has been hotly debated (Addy, 1986; Hauser, 1981; Millichap, 1968). Undoubtedly, however, the natural history of febrile convulsions (FCs) is quite different from that of the epilepsies, and the population affected by FCs differs considerably from that affected by epilepsy, especially with regard to age and family history.

FCs can be defined as occasional seizures that occur in association with fever but without evidence of intracranial infection or other definable cause. Seizures with fever in children who have suffered a previous nonfebrile seizure are excluded. FCs must be distinguished from epilepsy, which is characterized by recurrent nonfebrile seizures (Consensus Development Panel, 1980).

This definition is rather imprecise. Not all paroxysmal events occurring with fever are FCs. The term applies only to those attacks that are of “epileptic” mechanism. The presence of a typical ictal electroencephalographic (EEG) discharge has been demonstrated in a few cases (Gastaut et al., 1962), and it is thought to be present in all cases of true FC, whereas it is not found in anoxic or syncopal attacks induced by fever (Stephenson, 1983; Gastaut, 1974), which may be difficult to separate clinically from FC.

FCs occur in childhood, and, although the age limits are not clearly defined, an upper limit of 5 years for a first seizure is often accepted. The degree of fever sufficient for a diagnosis of FC is not specified. In addition, the height of fever at the time of a convulsion is often unknown. Likewise, the absence of intracranial infection or of a recognized acute neurologic illness remains an unproved assumption in at least some children. Differentiation of an acute febrile encephalopathy from a severe FC (febrile status epilepticus) may be difficult if no specific signs are present and the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) analysis is normal (Aicardi and Chevrie, 1970, 1983; Chevrie and Aicardi, 1975).

If all cases of prolonged FCs are considered to be due to some unrecognized causal disease, no case of febrile seizures will have sequelae. On the contrary, if all are regarded as FCs, an artificial increase in the frequency of sequelae due to FCs will result. Pneumonia (Nelson and Ellenberg, 1976), salmonellosis, or shigellosis (Lahat et al., 1990) can produce brain damage without an abnormal CSF analysis, though these are not true febrile seizures. For practical purposes, however, febrile status epilepticus, even if it is followed by permanent neurologic damage, should be included in the FC syndrome, as long as no cause or specific mechanism of brain insult is demonstrable.

Difficulties in precisely defining FCs are likely due to the variable mechanisms of seizures associated with fever, which clearly constitute a heterogeneous group of convulsive disorders. Three subgroups can be recognized. The first and largest subgroup consists of those children who have seizures in response to fever as a result of individual susceptibility, which usually is of genetic basis. In the second subgroup, which probably is small, the seizures are due to a brain insult that has resulted from the febrile illness. The third subgroup includes children with a previous latent epilepsy in whom fever acts merely as a trigger of the seizure. This heterogeneity would explain the different outcomes of some cases. The overwhelming majority of FC cases have an excellent outcome. The rare cases that do not could, however, belong to subsyndromes with a more severe outcome. Recent work has shown that such subsyndromes may feature abnormal prolongation of the FCs beyond the age of 5 or even 10 years or the occurrence of afebrile seizures of different types and severity following the onset of febrile seizures (Wallace et al., 1998; Scheffer and Berkovic, 1997). However, clinical recognition of such subsyndromes is difficult because the clinical features and durations of the seizures are not good predictors of outcome. Future progress in the study of FCs will probably permit reliable diagnostic criteria to be established and will determine more precisely the prognosis.


INCIDENCE OF FEBRILE SEIZURES

FCs are the single most common problem in pediatric neurology. Although the definitions and methods of case ascertainment have varied, that 2% to 5% of all children will experience at least one convulsion
with febrile illness before 5 years of age is widely accepted (Fukuyama, 1991; Forsgren et al., 1990b; Annegers et al., 1987; Verity et al., 1985a; Leviton and Cowan, 1982; Lennox-Buchtal, 1973). Higher rates have been reported in some nonoccidental countries, including rates of 7% in Japan and of up to 14% in the Marianna Islands (Tsuboi, 1984, 1986; Mathai et al., 1968). These high rates may be explained by several factors. In developing countries, some common infections of childhood (e.g., measles) may occur earlier, on an average, than in industrialized countries, thus taking place during the period of maximum susceptibility to FCs; the number and/or severity of febrile diseases may therefore be greater.

Living conditions (e.g., the whole family living in a single room) may result in improved case identification. Other unknown factors, whether genetic or environmental, also may play a role. FCs are more common in males (Hauser, 1981; Lennox-Buchtal, 1973; Millichap, 1968), with the sex ratio varying between 1.4 to 1 and 1.2 to 1. This male excess may be the result of an excess of one-sex (male) sibships (Ounsted et al., 1966).


RISK FACTORS FOR FEBRILE CONVULSIONS

The main risk factors for FCs include age, fever, and genetic predisposition. Other factors of lesser importance may be a history of abnormal prenatal and perinatal events that may facilitate the occurrence of FCs or influence their clinical expression and outcome (Forsgren et al., 1991; Wallace, 1976a, 1976b Chevrie and Aicardi, 1975). In one study, heavy smoking during pregnancy was associated with a higher rate of febrile seizures in offspring (Nelson and Ellenberg, 1982, 1990) and was perhaps related to the increased frequency of respiratory illness in young children exposed to passive smoking, but this relationship was not found in another study (Forsgren et al., 1990b).

The initial development of the child has a definite impact on the expression and the outcome of febrile seizures. Wallace (1972, 1976b) considered FCs a possible indication of lifelong developmental defects of prenatal or perinatal origin.

The studies of Wallace (1972, 1976b) and those of Nelson and Ellenberg (1982, 1990) have found that previous developmental abnormalities were associated with complex febrile seizures and that these had a less favorable outlook. Nelson and Ellenberg (1981b) found an extraordinarily high incidence of suspect or abnormal development before the occurrence of FCs on at least one examination in the large National Collaborative Perinatal Project (NCPP). In this study, 22% of their patients had such a history. However, the rate of abnormal development in nonconvulsive children is not stated, although that it was also quite high, possibly on the order of 12%, has been indicated by Nelson and Ellenberg (1976). Thus, the population of children with FCs likely was somewhat biased by the presence of children considered worrisome or abnormal on early examination when compared with a normal population, but the precision of the measurement limits the value of such evaluations.


Fever

Fever responsible for the occurrence of FCs is most often caused by upper respiratory tract infections, otitis media, pneumonia, influenza-like diseases, gastroenteritis, and urinary tract infections. Such infections are the cause of most febrile disorders of childhood. FCs usually supervene during the earliest hours of acute infectious illnesses and, in a vast majority, during the first 24 hours of fever. The term initial convulsions reflects this time distribution (Lennox-Buchtal, 1973) and emphasizes the fact that convulsions occurring later in the course of infectious disease, especially in exanthemas, are apt to be the expression of encephalitic complications. The seizure was the initial symptom of the illness recognized by the parents in 25% of the patients studied by Wolf et al. (1977). Further convulsions are uncommon even when temperature remains high. However, the seizures do not always occur at the time of highest fever, and they may even supervene at the time of defervescence (Lennox-Buchtal, 1973; Herlitz, 1941). Likewise, for a child who has had an FC to tolerate a higher fever later without a fit is not unusual (Nelson and Ellenberg, 1978).

The degree of temperature observed with FCs is variable. In one large series, 75% of children had a temperature of 39°C or higher at the time of the fit, and 25% had a temperature higher than 40°C (Herlitz, 1941). Children who convulse with relatively low levels of fever may have a greater risk of repeated seizures, and these should be observed with care (Offringa et al., 1992; Tsuboi et al., 1991; Tsuboi, 1986). The diagnosis of FCs should be regarded as tentative in such patients, especially when they are younger than 10 months of age (Dravet et al., 1982). The rate of increase in fever is deemed important in the causation of FCs by some workers (Millichap, 1968), but no definite evidence of its importance has been found (Michon and Wallace, 1984; Gastaut et al., 1962). Whether the cause of the fever has a role in the occurrence of FCs that is independent of the degree of fever remains debatable. The predominance of viral
infections probably reflects their frequency rather than representing a specific factor (Lewis et al., 1979; Stokes et al., 1977). However, long focal convulsions may be more common with demonstrated viral diseases than with those in which no evidence of viral infection is found (Wallace and Zealley, 1970).

Seizures occurring with exanthem subitum (roseola infantum) or with febrile disorders with neutropenia have received special attention. Lennox-Buchtal (1973) thought that such diseases were associated with FCs in 14% to 20% of patients. Data (Nelson and Ellenberg, 1981b) have suggested that the risk of recurrence in cases of roseola infantum is no higher than that with other causes of fever. However, herpesviruses 6 and 7 may be responsible for encephalitic complications, in addition to triggering febrile seizures (Asano et al., 1992, 1994). Rotavirus infections have also been associated with encephalopathic manifestations (Keidan et al., 1992).

Bacterial infections less commonly cause FCs. However, the presence of occult bacteremia (McIntyre et al., 1983) and other bacterial disorders should always be considered. Specific infections have been reported to be associated with a higher than average rate of FCs or with unusually severe FCs. The high rate of seizures with shigellosis (Lahat et al., 1990) and salmonellosis may be related to a toxemic effect (Fischler, 1962). Lahat et al. (1990) found the incidence of febrile seizures with shigellosis to be 19.7%. However, only 2 of their 66 patients followed for an average of 9.7 years had recurrent FCs. This suggests that febrile seizures with shigellosis differ from the usual FCs.

Fever resulting from immunizations can provoke febrile seizures. Children who had fits after immunizations were almost always febrile, and, in one large study (Hirtz et al., 1983), more than half of the children who had seizures after immunization procedures had a personal history of other febrile seizures or a family history of FCs in a sibling or parent. The prognosis of such seizures seems favorable in most cases. Cases with severe convulsive encephalopathies probably result from a mechanism different from that of FCs. Seizures following immunizations are seen mainly with the pertussis (Hirtz et al., 1983; Fenichel, 1982) and measles vaccines. However, immunization against measles can produce FCs in 1.9% of recipients, compared with a rate of 7.7% in wild disease (Landrigan and Witte, 1973).


Age Dependence

FCs are strongly age dependent. In all series, the shape of the distribution curve by age is similar. Few infants have FCs before the age of 5 or 6 months; 80% have had their first seizure by the age of 4 years and 90% by the age of 5 years. The median age varies between 17 and 23 months, depending on gender and type of seizure. Unilateral and severe FCs occur earlier than those that are bilateral and brief (16 months versus 21 months). Occasional first FCs are seen late, with onset after 5 years up to 7 or 8 years of age. Persistence of FCs beyond the age of 5 or 6 years is not very rare (see “Course and Outcome”). Convulsions before 5 or 6 months are much more common with infections of the central nervous system (CNS) than they are with FCs. Purulent meningitis should be strongly suspected in this age group.


Genetic Factors

FCs occur with increased frequency among the family members of patients with FCs (Hauser and Anderson, 1986; Hauser et al., 1985; Annegers et al., 1982a, 1982b; Fukuyama et al., 1979; Tsuboi, 1977a; Van den Berg, 1974; Schiottz-Christensen, 1972). The estimates of this frequency vary. Annegers et al. (1976) found a level of risk to siblings that was two to three times higher than that expected in the local population. Tsuboi (1977a) found an incidence of FCs of 17% for parents and 22% for siblings of FC probands. Aicardi and Chevrie (1976) found an incidence of 31% in first-degree relatives. Verity et al. (1985a) reported a 26% incidence of a positive family history. The low figure of 7.3% of first-degree relatives found in the series by Nelson and Ellenberg (1978) may be explained by the difficulties inherent in a large-scale population study. Familial clustering of FCs suggests that genetic factors play an etiologic role. The frequent transmission from parent to offspring and the risk to siblings of less than 25% in most studies tend to rule out a recessive mode of inheritance. Most studies suggest a dominant mode of inheritance with reduced penetrance and variable expression (Degen et al., 1991; Fukuyama et al., 1979; Lennox-Buchtal, 1973; Frantzen et al., 1970) or a polygenic mode; the latter is currently preferred (Hauser and Anderson, 1986).

Anderson et al. (1990) and Rich et al. (1987) have proposed that a different mode of inheritance may apply to cases in which the proband has had three or more FCs. In such cases, dominant transmission seems likely, whereas a multifactorial model better fits the observed rates in patients who have had fewer than three seizures. Doose et al. (1983), Doose and Baier (1987), and Gundel and Doose (1986) have suggested that the risk of a child having FCs and/or another form of epilepsy is associated with the presence
of one or several EEG characteristics that are inherited independently. The EEGs of children with FCs commonly show a monomorphous parietal theta rhythm in the awake state. In this concept, each inherited EEG characteristic could depend on a single gene, and the various combinations could account for the diverse types of genetic epilepsy of polygenic inheritance.

Several different loci on chromosome 8q (FEB1); 2q23-24 (FEB2); 19p (FEB2); and 5q14-15 (FEB4) have been mapped in multiple families with dominant inheritance of FCs. A possible third gene on chromosome 2q23-24 has been reported by Peiffer et al. (1999). However, this gene could be one of the genes for the syndrome of generalized epilepsy with febrile seizures plus (GEFS+), a syndrome that is related to but probably distinct from classic FCs (Scheffer and Berkovic, 1997), as discussed below (also see Chapter 20).

The more frequent involvement in boys may also be considered a genetic factor. However, it could also be due to the increased susceptibility of boys to febrile illnesses rather than being specifically due to FCs (Berg et al. 1995).

The empirical risk for a further offspring in a family with one affected child is approximately 10%. This risk is higher if one of the parents has had FCs, and it rises to almost 50% if one parent and one offspring have had febrile seizures. Some studies have reported a higher than expected rate of nonfebrile seizures among relatives of FC probands (Verity et al., 1985a; Van den Berg, 1974), whereas others have found no increased rate over the expectancy in the general population (Annegers et al., 1982a, 1982b; Frantzen et al., 1970).


CLINICAL MANIFESTATIONS OF FEBRILE SEIZURES

All febrile seizures are either tonic-clonic or possibly hypotonic (Gastaut et al., 1962). They never manifest as myoclonic seizures, spasms, or nonconvulsive attacks. The great majority are bilateral clonic or tonic-clonic attacks of short duration (less than 15 minutes). These are termed simple FCs. These seizures are followed by very brief postictal manifestations but no others; their virtual absence is of great diagnostic significance. Complex febrile seizures are those of long duration (15 minutes or more), those with focal features (most commonly unilateral), or those that recur two or more times within a single illness episode. Up to one-third of febrile seizures may have one or more of these complex features. Seizures of long duration were noted in 18% of the children in the Gentofte series (Frantzen et al., 1968), in 16% in an old series by Herlitz (1941), and in 35% in studies by Wallace (1974, 1976a, 1988). In the large population study of Nelson and Ellenberg (1978), 4.3% of the FC attacks lasted longer than 30 minutes and 7.6% longer than 15 minutes; 4% had a focal onset. Some of the unilateral seizures may be followed by a Todd hemiplegia that usually lasts a few hours but that may persist for up to several days. The incidence of Todd hemiplegia is probably in the range of 0.4% of all cases of FC (Nelson and Ellenberg, 1978). Seizures lasting 30 minutes or more qualify as status epilepticus. Rarely, they can constitute the initial stage of the hemiconvulsion-hemiplegia syndrome or acquired postconvulsive hemiplegia (see Chapter 10). However, the outcome is favorable in most cases of febrile status (Shinnar et al., 1992; Maytal and Shinnar, 1990). Such patients need emergency treatment. Most long-lasting convulsions (approximately 75%) are the initial seizure (Nelson and Ellenberg, 1978; Aicardi and Chevrie, 1970, 1975), an important finding that indicates the impossibility of prevention.

The occurrence of more than one seizure in 24 hours during the same febrile episode is not uncommon; it amounted to 16% of the cases in the Collaborative Childhood Perinatal Project series (Nelson and Ellenberg, 1976). Repeated seizures are also seen in the initial attacks in 6% of cases. They are usually brief convulsions, and they generally occur within 2 to 4 hours after the onset of fever.

Complex seizures more commonly occur in children with previously abnormal development or neurologic findings than do simple seizures. Aicardi and Chevrie (1983) showed that children with unilateral FCs, most of which were also of long duration, had a lower incidence of a positive family history of FCs than did those with brief bilateral seizures (18% versus 35%) and a higher incidence of abnormal and perinatal antecedents, thus suggesting the possible role of acquired, possibly lesional factors in their determination. Their prognosis, however, is favorable, although they may carry a slightly increased risk of febrile recurrences (Offringa et al., 1994).


ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHIC FINDINGS WITH FEBRILE CONVULSIONS

Paroxysmal EEG abnormalities were found in 35% to 45% of patients for whom serial EEGs were obtained before the age of 5 years (Doose et al., 1983; Lennox-Buchtal, 1973). Sofijanov et al. (1992) found that the initial EEG of 676 children with FCs contained
paroxysmal abnormalities in 22%. In all series, spike-waves at 3 Hz or more were most common, with focal spikes being second in frequency (about 10% of cases) (Lennox-Buchtal, 1973).

Generalized spike-waves should be distinguished from the so-called hypnagogic bursts that are a normal finding in children in the age bracket of FCs and that therefore are often found in these patients (Alvarez et al., 1983). The presence of paroxysmal EEG abnormalities is correlated with age. Paroxysmal anomalies are rare before the age of 1 year, but they are found in 51% of patients who had an initial EEG recording after 4 years of age (Sofijanov et al., 1992). Paroxysms are also significantly more common in children who had complex febrile seizures lasting more than 15 minutes, but they are related neither to the birthweight, gender, the nature of the febrile illness, the family history of convulsions, or epilepsy nor to the occurrence of multiple seizures in the same 24-hour episode. The number of previous febrile seizures is strongly related to the occurrence of EEG anomalies. These were found in 18% of children who had a single seizure and in 63% of those who had four or more seizures (Sofijanov et al., 1992). In the same study, EEG paroxysms were also more common in children with abnormal neurologic signs antecedent to the convulsions and with focal seizures, but the association was not as close as that of age and number of previous convulsions.

Most prospective studies have found no correlation between the presence of EEG paroxysms and the later emergence of nonfebrile seizures (Lennox-Buchtal, 1973; Frantzen et al., 1968). Millichap and Colliver (1991) did, however, find the incidence of paroxysmal EEG abnormalities to be five times greater in children who developed epilepsy than in those who did not. Even so, the EEG is of little, if any, practical value for the prediction of recurrences or epilepsy in the individual patient; paroxysms are found in a high proportion of the older patients who are least likely to develop severe or recurrent seizures of epilepsy, whereas they never appear on the EEGs of the young infants who are at maximum risk for recurrences, status epilepticus, and epilepsy. Biparietal theta rhythms were present during wakefulness in 54% of their patients, spike-wave activity in the resting record in 49%, and photosensitivity in 42%. The last two patterns were strongly age dependent.


DIAGNOSIS

The diagnosis of FCs is not always easy. Clearly, seizures associated with CNS infections, a topic discussed later in this chapter (see “Investigations in Children with Febrile Convulsions”), must not be diagnosed as FCs. Convulsions associated with fever may also be observed with toxic exposure, septic embolization, hemolytic-uremic syndrome, and other acute encephalopathies (Nelson and Ellenberg, 1983). Biotinidase deficiency may be responsible for both seizures and repeated infections (Aicardi, 1992a), and this condition is important to recognize because it is lethal condition if left untreated. Malaria and other parasitic diseases are important in many parts of the world, and these require specific therapy (Newton and Warrell, 1998). Severe FCs may raise the problem of the acute encephalopathies of obscure origin. Lyon et al. (1961) has suggested that some of the cases of acute encephalopathy in childhood are nothing more than severe and complicated cases of FCs. Whether such cases should be separated from FCs remains uncertain, as discussed in the introduction to this chapter.

Gastaut (1974) and Stephenson (1983, 1976, 1990) emphasized the fact that seizures occurring with fever were not necessarily of an epileptic nature. Syncopes, or reflex anoxic seizures, also can be triggered by fever, and the distinction between anoxic and epileptic seizures may be difficult (see Chapter 21). Stephenson (1976) divided 100 children who had fits with fever into the following three subgroups on the basis of the clinical description of attacks; 14 children were considered without doubt to have anoxic seizures, 35 had epileptic seizures, and the remaining 51 children could not be definitely classified. An exaggerated oculocardiac reflex was rare in the epileptic group, it was extremely common in the anoxic group, and it occurred with intermediate frequency in the undetermined group. However, an excessive oculocardiac reflex may be found in a child with authentic epileptic seizures, and the findings of Stephenson (1976) are difficult to interpret, even though they certainly suggest that febrile anoxic seizures may be common.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Aug 1, 2016 | Posted by in NEUROLOGY | Comments Off on Febrile Convulsions

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access