Radiation Therapy in Atypical Teratoid/Rhabdoid Tumors




© Springer International Publishing Switzerland 2015
M. Memet Özek, Giuseppe Cinalli, Wirginia Maixner and Christian Sainte-Rose (eds.)Posterior Fossa Tumors in Children10.1007/978-3-319-11274-9_43


43. Radiation Therapy in Atypical Teratoid/Rhabdoid Tumors



Hale Basak Caglar 


(1)
Department of Radiation Oncology, Medipol University, Istanbul, Turkey

 



 

Hale Basak Caglar




43.1 Introduction


The first description of primary malignant rhabdoid tumor was made by Beckwith and Palmer in 1978 as a highly malignant pediatric tumor of the kidney [1]. Since then, this neoplasm appeared in many other parts of the body, including the central nervous system (CNS). The CNS variant of this tumor was recognized as the atypical teratoid rhabdoid tumor (AT/RT) when added as a separate entity to the World Health Organization (WHO) in 1993 [2]. AT/RT is a malignant embryonal tumor of the CNS that is composed of rhabdoid cells, with or without fields resembling classical primitive neuroectodermal tumor [3]. Although the morphological pattern resembles other embryonal tumors of the CNS (medulloblastoma, PNET), it is shown to exhibit different serum marker expression and immunohistochemical (IHC) staining patterns from them and proved significantly more aggressive [4]. To date, approximately 300 cases of AT/RT have been described in the literature. It is likely that the incidence of AT/RT has been underestimated given the clinical and histological similarities to medulloblastoma and the previous unavailability of IHC for routine diagnosis. Prior to recognition of AT/RT as a unique entity, many cases of AT/RT may have been misdiagnosed as medulloblastoma. Since the rise in accessibility of IHC testing in the late 1990s, the recognition of AT/RT has increased. Results from a pathologic review of a Children’s Cancer Group study of children with malignant brain tumors suggest that although AT/RT is a relatively rare disease, accounting for less than 5 % of all pediatric CNS tumors, up to 20 % of malignant CNS tumors diagnosed before the patient is 3 years old are AT/RTs [46].

In addition to the histological similarities, AT/RT has many common radiological and clinical characteristics with medulloblastoma. It commonly affects infants and young children. It can be located both infratentorial and supratentorial although posterior fossa is more common.

Looking at the clinical and pathological similarities between these two entities, it is important to realize that the clinical outcomes of these tumors are somehow different. Over the past 30 years, the overall survival of medulloblastoma has increased from 25 to 65 % [7], while the numbers are still the same for AT/RT with a median survival of almost a year especially when metastases were found at the time of diagnosis, an entity seen in 20 % of the patients [6]. The patients with AT/RT tend to be refractory to standardized therapies, especially chemotherapy for medulloblastoma. A significant portion dies of local recurrence.

Majority of the patients with AT/RT present at an age of less than 3 years, radiation therapy has usually been withheld as a standard treatment option right away from surgery. However, the most recent evidence suggests that long-term survival can be obtained with the use of more intensive and aggressive chemotherapy with adjuvant radiation therapy still presents a particular dilemma as young patients with this disease may experience serious late effects of therapy if with longer follow-up.

The first and the most important step of treating this tumor is achieving the correct diagnosis for directing the patient to the most proper therapy. As approximately two-thirds of the patients with AT/RT have pathologic samples that contain cells resembling medulloblastoma [7]. IHC is the most objective and reliable way to make a differentiation.

The earliest publication for the association of AT/RT with chromosomal abnormalities especially chromosome 22 was from Rorke et al. in 1995 [8]. Through subsequent years, specific gene mutations were identified on a specific locus of the chromosome. The identification of hSNF5/INI1 gene mutation is now used for the definition of the disease.


43.2 Treatment Strategies


Much of the management of AT/RT has evolved from medulloblastoma because of the similarities. The central pathologic review of the data collected from protocols for medulloblastoma and PNET have shown that a number of these patients are actually AT/RT. By this, a retrospective analysis of these tumors was performed to evaluate response for standard treatment strategies.

A multi-institutional registry of patients with AT/RT with complete information on surgery, chemotherapy, and radiotherapy was published by Hilden et al. in 2006 [6]. Complete information was observed for 42 patients. Primary therapy included chemotherapy in all patients, radiotherapy in 13 patients (31 %), stem-cell rescue in 13 patients (31 %), and intrathecal chemotherapy in 16 patients (38 %).

Achieving a complete resection appears to be a significant prognostic factor for overall survival (OS) [6, 9]. Among the three strategies, chemotherapy has been the most studied one. As most of the children present at an early age of less than 3 years, chemotherapy is usually started after surgery as a way of postponing radiation. The initial response to medulloblastoma/PNET protocols is very poor, so more aggressive chemotherapy combinations with intrathecal applications are recommended.

The role of radiation therapy is much less studied than chemotherapy in the management of AT/RT. The most recent evidences support the use of early and effective radiotherapy for making long-term survival possible in this group of patients. The rationale of radiation is to prevent local recurrences as in many other tumor sites. In the early report of the registry, the majority of the recurrences were in the primary tumor site. Another role for radiation could be the prevention of leptomeningeal disease especially when performed as a full axis irradiation. Although long-term detrimental effects of radiation in patients aged less than 3 years old has been clearly identified, the disadvantages of radiation should be weighed given the dismal prognosis of the disease especially in the presence of new technological advances of the treatment [10].


43.3 The Necessity of Adjuvant Radiation Therapy for AT/RT


Immediate initial radiation therapy for AT/RT is a controversial issue as most of the patients are under the age of 3 years. Postponing radiotherapy until after 3 years because of the highlighted side effects such as endocrine dysfunction, cognitive disturbances, and mental retardation has been the trend for various neoplasms in this age group. Duffner et al. reported the effects of delaying radiotherapy in children that have neoplasms under 3 years old with chemotherapy in a POG study in 1993 [11]. The progression-free survival (PFS) at 1 and 2 years were reported to be 41 and 39 %, respectively. Although the results of this study confirmed the safety of deferring radiation until 3 years as a standard management strategy for patients diagnosed as having a medulloblastoma and PNET under 3 years old, there still might be some high-risk patients leading to poorer outcomes with this delay [12]. Additionally it has to be emphasized that these are the evidence for medulloblastoma and PNET, which is known to have better outcomes with less aggressive therapies from AT/RT. As the number of the patients with AT/RT is much less than other histologies, currently there is not any prospective data for the postponement of radiation. Looking at the retrospective evidence with small number of patients, AT/RT is less sensitive to traditional chemotherapy regimens used for medulloblastoma and has a high rate of relapse within the first year [13].

In the AT/RT registry report, a total of 42 patients were included where 28 of them experienced progression and recurrence. Eight of the 13 children who were clinically without evidence of disease at least 19 months after diagnosis had received radiation therapy as part of their initial treatment regimen [6].

The initial report of 37 cases of AT/RT diagnosed at St. Jude’s Children’s Research Hospital over a 19-year interval was published in 2005 by Tekautz et al. They reported 22 patients who were less than 3 years old at the time of diagnosis, and of these patients, there were only two long-term survivors. Both long-term survivors received initial radiation therapy as part of their treatment protocol. The majority of patients who were older than 3 years old at diagnosis received craniospinal irradiation as part of their primary treatment. The only significant prognostic factor for event-free survival (EFS) and OS was the age at diagnosis [5]. The same group updated their data in 2012 according to radiotherapy sequencing as a prognostic factor [14]. Thirty-one patients at a median age of 2.3 years at diagnosis were enrolled into protocols that included risk- and age-stratified radiotherapy. Radiation was delayed more than 1 month in 24; seven patients received immediate postoperative irradiation (majorly craniospinal irradiation) preceding high-dose alkylator-based chemotherapy. At a median follow-up of 48 months, children receiving delayed RT were more likely to experience local failure.

A retrospective review from Taiwan reported 17 patients with AT/RT. All patients were treated with primary surgery and then radiation therapy. All but one patient in this series were 3 years or older at the time of radiation therapy. There were five patients in the series that were disease-free for a period of 25 months or longer, of which three remain disease-free. Median overall survival and failure-free survival were 17 and 11 months, respectively. The three longest surviving patients were older, underwent gross tumor removal, and completed both craniospinal and focal boost irradiation. Multivariate analysis revealed a significant relationship between performance status, total irradiation dose, time interval between surgery and radiotherapy initiation, and time interval between surgery and radiotherapy end point [15].

A Surveillance Epidemiology and End Results (SEER) database was used to identify 144 patients with ATRT from 1973 to 2008. The median age at diagnosis was 1 year, gross total resection of the primary tumor was achieved in 39 % of patients, and 33 % of patients received RT. From 1992 to 2008, RT use increased 2.4-fold in patients aged less than 3 years. The median OS for was 10 months. In multivariate analyses, metastatic disease and radiation treatment were identified as independent predictors of survival [16].

Another SEER study from 2012 confirmed similar results in infant brain tumors which included mixed histologies including ATRT [17]. For infants with medulloblastoma and ATRTs, improved survival was observed in patients treated with both surgery and early radiation compared with those treated with surgery alone.

The fact that long-term survivors of AT/RT were more likely to have had initial radiation provides an argument for the use of initial radiation therapy as part of a treatment regimen for AT/RT. The dismal salvage rate for AT/RT also suggests that the best opportunity to cure this disease is prior to relapse or disease progression. The only prospective data included radiation as a primary adjuvant treatment in all age groups [18]. Based on the current available evidence, the NCI AT/ RT workshop in 2001 recommended that involved field radiation therapy be included in the developing COG protocol for CNS AT/RT [19].

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jun 22, 2017 | Posted by in NEUROSURGERY | Comments Off on Radiation Therapy in Atypical Teratoid/Rhabdoid Tumors

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access