Recognizing, Diagnosing, and Assessing PTSD




(1)
U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, National Center for PTSD, White River Junction, VT, USA

(2)
Departments of Psychiatry and Pharmacology & Toxicology, Geisel School of Medicine at Dartmouth, Hanover, NH, USA

 



Keywords
DSM-5PTSD diagnostic criteriaIntrusion symptomsAvoidance symptomsNegative alterations in cognitions and moodAlterations in arousal and reactivityDiagnostic assessmentClinical interviewAssessment instrumentsComorbid disorders




This Chapter Answers the Following Questions



  • What are the main characteristics of PTSD?


  • What are the DSM5 diagnostic criteria for PTSD?—This section includes a reprint of the DSM-5 criteria and a discussion of each major criterion.


  • How should clinicians approach initial patient interviews?—This section covers strategies for conducting the initial clinical interview as well as PTSD risk factors to identify early in the assessment process.


  • What tools are available for diagnosing PTSD?—This section presents strategies for conducting a clinical interview, identifying risk factors, and using standard measurements to assist in the PTSD diagnosis.


  • How do you differentiate PTSD from comorbid and other disorders?—This section reviews comorbid disorders and other posttraumatic outcomes as well as their prevalence. It also covers how to differentiate from PTSD both coexisting disorders and other conditions that manifest in a person who has experienced trauma.


What Are the Main Characteristics of PTSD?


As noted in Chap. 1, people at risk for PTSD have not only been exposed to a severely stressful event but must also exhibit a pattern of symptoms embedded within four symptom “clusters”: intrusion, avoidance, negative mood and cognitions, and arousal and reactivity—as well as meeting the duration and functional impairment criteria.

Before reviewing the DSM-5 symptoms of PTSD in depth, here is a brief introduction.

Figure 2.1 on page XX provides an overview of these symptom clusters.

A320755_6_En_2_Fig1_HTML.gif


Fig. 2.1
PTSD symptom clusters


Classification of PTSD in DSM-5


When first introduced in 1980 in the DSM-III [1] and later in the 1994 DSM-IV [2], PTSD was classified as an anxiety disorder for two reasons. First, altered arousal and reactivity symptoms such as insomnia, irritability, and difficulty concentrating (see below) are found in other anxiety disorders such as panic disorder and generalized anxiety disorder. Second, animal models, such as inescapable stress and fear conditioning, have long been understood within an anxiety context [3]. However, more recent research has shown that for many patients with PTSD, the fear-based anxiety symptoms are not the most prominent and are not the symptoms that require the most clinical attention. For example, for some PTSD patients, the major problem is the negative alteration in mood and cognitions (as also seen with depression), expressed as anhedonia or dysphoria. For others, hyperarousal and reactive behaviors such as angry outbursts or reckless/risk-taking behaviors predominate. Others exhibit dissociative symptoms that are very disruptive. And most exhibit mixed clinical pictures characterized by different combinations of the aforementioned phenotypes [4, 5]. For these reasons, PTSD was removed from the anxiety disorder cluster in DSM-5 and reclassified as a Trauma and StressorRelated Disorder. This category also includes acute stress disorder (ASD), adjustment disorders, and two child diagnoses, reactive attachment disorder and disinhibited social engagement disorder. All diagnoses in the trauma and stressor-related disorder clusters have in common (as a diagnostic criterion) that their onset was preceded by exposure to a very aversive event. In the case of PTSD and ASD, such events must have been traumatic. For the others, the event need not have been traumatic, but must have been aversive (such as rejection, failure, bankruptcy, or parental maltreatment).


What Are the DSM5 Diagnostic Criteria for PTSD?


To be diagnosed with PTSD, a person must have been exposed to trauma and experienced symptoms for at least a month after exposure. Figure 2.2, on page xx, presents the Diagnostic and Statistical Manuel, fifth edition: DSM-5 criteria for PTSD (pages 271–274).

A320755_6_En_2_Fig2a_HTML.gifA320755_6_En_2_Fig2b_HTML.gifA320755_6_En_2_Fig2c_HTML.gifA320755_6_En_2_Fig2d_HTML.gif


Fig. 2.2
DSM-5 diagnostic criteria for posttraumatic stress disorder [5]


The Traumatic Stress Criterion


People who meet the DSM-5 A criterion have been exposed to catastrophic events that involve actual or threatened death, serious injury (e.g., military combat, sexual assault, physical attack, torture, man-made/natural disasters, accidents, incarceration, or exposure to war zone/urban/domestic violence ), or sexual violence (criterion A1). Others meeting the A criterion include people not directly endangered but who witness such events (criterion A2) and people who witness the violent aftermath of a catastrophic event (such as dead body parts) but were never personally in danger (criterion A4). Finally, DSM5 includes people who have learned that a loved one was exposed to a life-threatening event or sexual violence but were never in any personal danger themselves (criterion A3). If a loved one died during such an event, the death must have been violent or accidental in order to meet criterion A3.

Mothers of the disappearedare women whose children were arrested by police during the statesponsored terrorism of theDirty Warin Argentina, when the military junta arrested, incarcerated, tortured, and often executed individuals whom they considered subversive. These mothers may or may not have witnessed any more than the arrest of their children. In all cases, however, their childrens continued disappearance was a very strong indication that they might have been executed. According to DSM-5, these mothers have all meet criterion A3, because of the strong likelihood that their children were tortured and killed violently.


Multiple Traumas


Although people may develop severe PTSD from one horrific event, as did Mary T (see below), it is not uncommon in clinical practice to see people who have been exposed to many extremely stressful A criterion experiences. Unfortunately, this is common in cases of childhood sexual or physical trauma, domestic violence, urban violence, forced migration, war, state terrorism (e.g., as torture), or state-sponsored genocide. If the events are sequential episodes of the same traumatic stress (as in child abuse, war, etc.), psychosocial treatment may be successful by focusing on the “worst” episode (see Chap. 4). If, however, two or more traumatic stressors are quite different in character (e.g., war trauma and childhood sexual abuse), each A criterion experience may have to be addressed separately during psychotherapy.


Introduction to Symptoms of PTSD



Intrusion Symptoms


Unique to PTSD, these symptoms reflect the persistence of thoughts, feelings, and behaviors specifically related to the traumatic event. Such intrusive recollections are not only unwanted but also powerful enough to override consideration of anything else. Daytime recollections and traumatic nightmares often evoke panic, terror, dread, grief, or despair. Traumatic memories can elicit symptoms of psychological distress (e.g., terror, despair) or abnormal physiological reactions (e.g., racing pulse, rapid breathing, or sweating).

Sometimes people with PTSD are exposed to reminders of the trauma (trauma-related stimuli) and are suddenly thrust into a psychological state—the PTSD flashback—in which they relive the traumatic experience, losing all connection with the present. This is referred to as an acute dissociative reaction which occurs on a continuum from a brief reaction to a complete loss of awareness in which they actually behave as if they must fight for their lives, as was the case during exposure to the initial trauma.

For example, a woman was raped at dusk by an assailant who sprang out of the shadows opening onto an urban thoroughfare. He dragged her into the recesses of a dark alley before beginning his sexual assault. It is now many months later. She is walking home from work. The setting sun produces shadows over every nook and cranny adjacent to the sidewalk. As she glances into a heavily shadowed alley, she actually “sees” an assailant poised and ready to grab her. In fact, no one is there. The similarity between the rape scene several months ago and those produced today by an urban sunset has produced a hallucination (a compelling perceptual experience of seeing, hearing or smelling something that is not present) that is, in effect, a PTSD flashback. As a result, she believes that she is again about to be raped and runs down the street, screaming in terror.


Avoidance Symptoms


These symptoms can be understood as behavioral or cognitive strategies to ward off the terror and distress caused by intrusion symptoms.

Avoidance symptoms include:



  • Cognitive efforts to avoid trauma-related thoughts, memories, and feelings (e.g., through distraction)


  • Behavioral efforts to avoid activities, places, and people related to the original traumatic event


Negative Alterations in Cognitions and Mood


Negative alterations in cognitions and mood that began or worsened after the traumatic event may be expressed in a variety of symptoms including dissociative amnesia, (the inability to remember emotionally charged events for psychological rather than neurological reasons) exaggerative negative expectations about the future, self-blame, persistent negative mood states, diminished interest or participation in previously enjoyed activities, or a persistent inability to feel positive emotions.


Dissociative (Psychogenic) Amnesia


The inability to remember emotionally charged events for psychological rather than neurological reasons

Dissociative amnesia for trauma-related memories (e.g., a 10-year-old refugee who witnessed the massacre of his father and brothers and the rape of his mother by armed paramilitary militia members only remembers that the troops came to the house, that he ran, hid, and eventually escaped; he cannot remember what happened in between)


Negative Cognitions






  • The belief that one’s self, one’s environment, and one’s future have been irretrievably changed as a result of the traumatic event (e.g., “I’m weak,” “No one can be trusted,” “The world is completely dangerous”)


  • Self-blame for the traumatic event or its consequences


Persistent Negative Mood State


Persistent fear, horror, sadness, anger, guilt, or shame that began or worsened after exposure to the traumatic event


Diminished Interest or Social Detachment






  • Loss of interest or pleasure from previously enjoyable activities


  • Feeling detached or estranged from other people resulting in social withdrawal


Inability to Feel Positive Emotions


The inability to experience love, happiness, joy, or satisfaction is often a major reason why intimate relationships, marriages, family life, and friendships cannot be sustained by people with PTSD.


Alterations in Arousal and Reactivity


This cluster of PTSD symptoms is characterized by a hyper-reactive psychophysiological state—a state in which emotions are heightened and aroused, and even minor events may produce a state in which the heart pounds rapidly, muscles are tense, and there is great overall agitation. Many of these symptoms, especially irritability, insomnia, and problems with concentration, most closely resemble symptoms seen in panic disorder and generalized anxiety disorder. It is one reason why PTSD was previously classified in DSM-III and DSM-IV as an anxiety disorder. (For information on distinguishing panic disorder and generalized anxiety disorder from PTSD, see pages xx–xx.)


Irritable Behavior or Angry Outbursts


DSM-5 differentiates between irritable/angry feelings and behavior. Irritable/angry feelings are considered a persistent negative mood and included along with fear, sadness, guilt, or shame. Irritable behavior and angry outbursts may be expressed as



  • A quick temper and which sometimes lead to unprovoked aggressive verbal and/or physical behavior are the focus of this symptom.


Reckless or Self-Destructive Behavior






  • Dangerous driving


  • Alcohol/drug abuse


  • Self-injurious and suicidal behavior


Hypervigilance






  • Preoccupied by watchful or protective behavior motivated by excessive fears for personal safety


Exaggerated Startle Reactions






  • “Jumpy” behavior manifested as a tendency to exhibit an exaggerated startle response to unexpected noises or movements by others


Problems with Concentration and Sleep






  • Due to the disorder’s hyper-reactive psychophysiological state, which makes it very difficult for people with PTSD to sleep or to concentrate or perform cognitive tasks. For example, a youth with PTSD might not be able to do schoolwork or focus on intellectual tasks.

Combatants in Iraq and Afghanistan spoke of “having your head on a swivel,” meaning that they must be on alert (e.g., hypervigilant) at all times and must constantly survey all 360° of the environment


Preschool Subtype


Children, especially those aged 6 years and younger, who lack an adult’s capacity for abstract thinking or linguistic expression, may express their PTSD symptoms behaviorally rather than verbally through developmentally appropriate, nonverbal indicators of psychological distress, such as disorganized or agitated behavior during play. Because a number of PTSD symptoms require introspective sensitivity and cognitive capabilities that are not present in younger children, the DSM-IV prevalence of PTSD among preschool children has been much lower than for older age groups [6]. As a result, a special preschool subtype has been included in DSM-5 that eliminates subjective symptoms and lowers the number of symptoms to meet the full PTSD criteria. As shown in Fig. 2.2, these changes primarily affect criteria C and D. Instead of needing to fulfill both C and D criteria, preschool children only need to exhibit 1 symptom from either criterion C or D. Furthermore, elimination of subjective symptoms has left only 4, rather than 7 (adult), symptoms in criterion D. Finally, adult criterion E2 has been eliminated since it is difficult to identify “reckless” behavior in children 6 years and younger. These changes are based on strong empirical evidence that PTSD symptoms and symptom thresholds are appropriate for this age group.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jun 22, 2017 | Posted by in PSYCHIATRY | Comments Off on Recognizing, Diagnosing, and Assessing PTSD

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access