Conclusion

and Penney Upton2



(1)
Faculty of Health, University of Canberra, Canberra, Aust Capital Terr, Australia

(2)
Institute of Health and Society, University of Worcester, Worcester, UK

 




Box 9.1: Key Points





  • The economic costs of wound care can be extensive and account for a significant proportion of health service costs;


  • Despite the significant financial costs, the psychological consequences can be just as important and costly;


  • Pain, stress, mood disorders, well-being, concordance, social support are all fundamental psychological issues that the practicing clinician should consider to develop their wound care practice;


  • Patient well-being should be at the centre of all clinical practice;


  • It is imperative that the clinician incorporates psychological knowledge and skills into their everyday practice for the benefit of all their patients.


Summary


Psychological stress, pain, negative emotions, malodour, high exudate levels, social isolation, sleep and mobility problems are just some of the negative consequences of living with a wound. The subsequent psychological effects can have a severe impact on an individual’s quality of life and their well-being. The evidence suggests that these psychological factors not only influence the occurrence of further wounds, but they also exacerbate the severity of a wound and affect its ability to heal, resulting in the individual having to endure further psychological problems as a consequence- a vicious circle that clinicians must be aware of when treating patients with wounds. This chapter explores some of the negative consequences of a wound and how some psychological resources can help both the clinician and, more importantly, the patient and their family. Summarizing the material presented elsewhere in this book and highlighting the clinical relevance, this chapter demonstrates the importance of psychology in both the experience of living with a wound and effective wound care.


Introduction


Chronic wounds have been described as: “a silent epidemic that affects a large fraction of the world population and poses a major and gathering threat to the public health and economy” (Sen et al. 2009, p. 763). It has been estimated that there are over 200,000 patients with chronic wounds in the UK (Posnett and Franks 2007) although this figure, despite being frequently cited, is probably a significant under-estimate. With an aging population and increasing incidence of concomitant factors, such as obesity and diabetes, it is possible that this figure has increased considerably since their report and will continue to do so.

The cost in the UK to the NHS of these chronic wounds has been estimated at £2–3 billion: approximately 3 % of NHS budget (Posnett and Franks 2007). The health care costs of chronic wounds in the European population accounted for 2 % of the European health budget (Bottrich 2014). In the Scandinavian countries, the costs of chronic wounds comprised 2–4 % of the total health care expenditure (Gottrup et al. 2001). Graves and Zheng (2014) suggest that in Australia the direct health care costs reach approximately US$2.85 billion.

Whatever country, continent or service, wounds are a significant cost to the respective health economies. The elements included in these estimates tend to focus on the medical costs alone. Hence, these have been included: costs of dressing materials, average hospitalisation rates, average time to healing, and complication rates have all been considered. However, an aspect that is often overlooked is the cost of the psychological consequences of the wounds: both to the patient and the health service (see Box 9.1). The psychological consequences of living with a chronic wound can include many negative emotions, such as stress, anxiety, concern about physical symptoms, lack of self-worth and feelings of despair. These can vary in severity, from minor negative emotions to suicidal thoughts, depending on each individual case (Upton and South 2011; Upton et al. 2012a, b, c). Upton and Hender (2012) explored the economic costs of the additional psychosocial problems with wound care and suggested that in the UK these additional cost of treating chronic wound patients for mood disorder could be as much as £85.5 million per annum as a lower estimate.

At the outset of this book we highlighted the growing research interest in psychological issues in health care and wound care in particular. It would appear that this interest can have a financial reality as well. For many years, health care professionals may have overlooked some of the important psychosocial aspects of an individual’s care but this situation is changing and we hope that this book has gone someway to strengthening the time and energy afforded these variables. In this way not only the economic factors can be addressed but also, more importantly, the needs of the patient.

When constantly dealing with many wound patients in a time and resourced pressed environment, it may be difficult for practitioners to fully appreciate the impact a chronic wound can have upon an individuals’ life. The focus can often be directed towards treating the wound rather than the associated sequelea (Briggs and Flemming 2007). We hope that this book has highlighted how some of the research evidence may be of particular relevance to the health care professional in their day-to-day practice.

Studies have also shown that patients living with long-term wounds often have poor psychological wellbeing and a reduced quality of life as a consequence of the impact of the wound and wound care. The impact on the patient and their caregiver’s social life can be extensive and all encompassing. The presence of these factors, along with immobility, social isolation, pain, mood disorders and other psychosocial factors not only exacerbates their severity and jeopardises their ability to heal but also could lead to further wounds occurrence. Of course, there are some protective factors and these can include not only positive and appropriate clinical wound care but also psychosocial factors.

Each of these factors, whether positive or negative, has been described, evidenced and reported in this book. This final chapter will emphasise the clinical relevance of the material presented and provide some simple implications for professional practice (see Table 9.1).


Table 9.1
Psychological factors and relevance to care





















































































Factor

Element

Some implications for the clinician

Psychosocial

Lack of energy

Education

Work limitations

Support

Leisure activity restrictions

Cognitive therapy

Low self-esteem

Acknowledgement of difficulties

Daily routine alterations

Development of coping strategies

Sleep disturbance

Social support development

Body image distortion

Fatigue

Restricted mobility,

Odour and social isolation

Depression

Anxiety

Mood disorders

Pain

Pain from wound

Cognitive behaviour therapy

Pain from treatment

Distraction techniques

Background pain

Imagery

Pain from anticipation of treatment

Relaxation

Altering significance of the pain

P.A.I.N model

Appropriate clinical techniques

Acknowledgement of pain

Stress

Stress from pain

Pain management techniques

Stress from treatment

Calm and relaxed treatment environment

Stress from psychosocial issues

Cognitive behaviour therapy

Stress delayed healing

Education and appropriate control

Self-management

Appropriate dressings

Pre-information for novel treatments


Psychosocial Issues of Wounds


As we have seen in Chap.​ 1, most researchers, clinicians and patients agree there are a host of psychosocial factors that can affect the individual patient of which the health care professional should be aware. These can include: lack of energy, limitations in work and leisure activities, worries and frustrations, a lack of self-esteem, frequency and regularity of dressing changes, which affect a patient’s daily routine, feeling of continued fatigue due to lack of adequate sleep, restricted mobility, persistent pain, exudate, odour and social isolation (Upton and South 2011). Mobility restrictions may effect every aspect of the patients life, limiting their availability to work or perform household tasks. Even attending to personal hygiene may become difficult, as previously independent patients become reliant on others and report loss of self-worth and role reversal within families. Social isolation may be exacerbated by the impact on self-esteem of the physical consequences of the wound- the odour, any strike-through or required dressing changes. These may increase anxiety and depression, embarrassment, negative body image and social isolation, which can all impact negatively on quality of life (Hareendran et al. 2005; Herber et al. 2007).

All of these factors may contribute to the psychological distress experienced by both the patient and their carer. Furthermore, some individuals may try different methods of coping with the physical manifestation of the wound. Such actions are often ineffective and, in some cases, can worsen the condition of the wound. For example, Lo et al. (2008) reported the experiences of cancer patients living with a malignant fungating wound. Findings suggest that some patients would attempt to cover wounds to avoid leakage, would drink less fluid in the hope of reducing the amount of exudate produced and would remove bandages to help exudate disperse. Patients often feel embarrassed about exudate leakage and malodour and have difficulty maintaining dignity and outward appearances (Walshe 1995; Hyde et al. 1999).

It is therefore essential that the clinician recognises and responds to these psychosocial issues: dealing with any self-esteem issues, any psychological distress or social isolation and importantly providing accurate information and education for the patient to reduce any misunderstanding or inappropriate coping mechanisms. In this way it should be possible to promote a positive approach to the patient’s situation and their treatment. This may involve information on self-management, self-care, and social integration (see Table 9.1).


Pain


In a systematic review of studies on the impact of leg ulcers on daily life Persoon et al. (2004) listed pain as the first and most dominant factor and this has been fully explored in Chap.​ 2. Jones et al. (2006) found prolonged pain (along with malodour) was the specific symptom associated with anxiety and depression. Given the numerous negative effects of pain, it is not surprising that healthcare practitioners unanimously believed that reducing chronic wound pain could improve patients’ psychological state significantly (Upton et al. 2012a, b, c). However, in an interactive wound care survey of 246 wound conference delegates only 35 % of NHS community staff and 44 % of NHS hospital staff considered that wound pain was being addressed sufficiently (Lloyd Jones et al. 2010). Given the over-riding significance of pain, the reported poor support provided and the potential impact that pain may have on treatment concordance, stress levels and ultimately wound healing it is the key issue that clinicians have to address in wound care through careful assessment and management. Along with the underlying wound aetiologies and local trauma that is exacerbated at dressing change (Woo and Sibbald 2008), a constellation of patient factors including emotions, personality structure and stress are integral to the comprehensive assessment and management of wound related pain. These can all be encapsulated under the P.A.I.N. (Preparation, Assessment, Intervention and Normalisation) model previously described (see Chap.​ 2).

There are many psychological therapies that can help the patient deal with their pain. For example, cognitive therapy that aims to modify attitudes, beliefs, and expectations has been shown to be successful in the management of both stress and pain. Furthermore, distraction techniques, imagery, relaxation or altering the significance of the pain to an individual can also be successful in reducing pain. Patients can also learn relaxation exercises to help reduce anxiety related tension in the muscle that contributes to pain. These techniques can be employed by the clinician, or referred on for more specialist interventions and can help not only pain but stress and other psychological disorders. Finally, support from others, whether those with a similar condition or from the family can help and should be actively encouraged by the clinician (see Table 9.1).


Stress


A systematic review and meta-analysis (Walburn et al. 2009) explored the relationship between stress on a variety of wound types in different contexts (for example, different types of acute and chronic wounds and experimentally created wounds such as punch biopsies). The findings demonstrated that the relationship between stress and wound healing is clinically relevant (Kiecolt-Glaser et al. 1995; Cole-King and Harding 2001). For example, in a study of 72 patients with burns, it was found that the greater the level of distress a person was under, the slower the wound healing process can be (Wilson et al. 2011). This study, along with many others and other clinically relevant reviews (e.g. Solowiej et al. 2010a, b; Solowiej et al. 2010; Solowiej and Upton 2010a, b; Upton and Solowiej 2011) presented in detail in Chap.​ 3 demonstrates the importance of minimising the stress of both living with a wound and the wound management regime.

Wound-related pain at dressing changes has also been shown to correlate positively with stress and anxiety (Solowiej et al. 2009, 2010a, b). The relationship between pain and anxiety could be due to the patient being more sensitive to pain due to increased anxiety and fear, particularly if this is based on a past experience (Mudge et al. 2008; Woo 2010). Alternatively, patients suffering higher pain levels are more likely to become stressed and anxious. This may, in turn, impact on their healing rate. Considerable evidence now exists demonstrating the link between stress and delayed healing and controlling pain more effectively can affect stress and should also impact upon healing rates (Cole-King and Harding 2001; Soon and Acton 2006; Woo 2010; Gouin and Kiecolt-Glaser 2011; Solowiej and Upton 2010a, b). Consequently this has considerable implications for practice. It may be that the continued stress of wound care change leads to chronic stress. In this way, stress has a cumulative impact- the “minor hassle” or relatively low levels of pain experienced at any one dressing change have a significant impact over time (see Fig. 9.1).

A320414_1_En_9_Fig1_HTML.gif


Figure 9.1
A potential relationship between acute pain and stress occurring at dressing change and increased chronic stress levels

Practitioners have to appreciate this cumulative impact and minimise stress and pain at all wound changes. This may be related to dressing choice, relaxed and calm environments, effective communication with the patient, provision of appropriate support, or demonstrated psychological or physical therapies (see Table 9.1).


Quality of Life and Well-Being


Although there have been a wealth of studies exploring the quality of life (QoL) of patients with wounds, many tend to focus on ‘health-related quality of life’ (HRQoL) or ‘health status’. Such measures are useful as outcome measures of treatment, yet they do not always tell us about important psychological factors and the impact of wounds on well-being; consequently, these issues are often overlooked (Upton et al. 2013a, b). Throughout this book we have attempted to address these psychological factors and put well-being at the centre of the discussions (see Fig. 9.2).
May 28, 2017 | Posted by in PSYCHOLOGY | Comments Off on Conclusion

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access