Personality disorders

15 Personality disorders



Introduction


‘Personality’ can be defined as the lifelong persistent and enduring characteristics and attitudes of an individual, including that person’s ways of thinking (cognition), feeling (affectivity) and behaving (impulse control and ways of relating to others and handling interpersonal situations). For instance, we may recognize individuals as being characteristically lifelong worriers or oversensitive, or having a temper under stress.


Personality is a theoretical concept and a basis for prediction, in that it is considered to remain relatively uniform over time. Personality development occurs in one’s early years and remains modifiable up to adolescence and early adulthood. Thereafter, although defined as enduring, it is not true to say that personality characteristics (traits) never change after about the age of 30. Change after such an age may be much more limited, but an analogy has been made to the way an adult body changes in shape and weight with age. Everyday life demonstrates that personality traits can become more prominent in the elderly. For instance, previously ‘prickly’ personalities may become more so in old age, whereas those previously described as ‘nice’ may become even nicer.


Normal personality may be used to refer to:





Normal personality has been considered to have five major dimensions: extroversion, emotional stability (in contrast to ‘neuroticism’), agreeableness, conscientiousness and intellectual open-mindedness.


Personality disorder can be defined as an extreme persistent variation from the normal (statistical) range of one or more personality attributes (traits), causing the individual and/or family and/or society to suffer.


It is unlikely that a diagnosis of personality disorder would be appropriate before the age of 16 or 17, as personality remains very malleable until then. Critics of the concept of personality disorder see it as representing a social rather than a medical diagnosis, i.e. a way of designating, for instance, those who behave antisocially as ‘sick’ and in need of medical treatment and control. There may also be no clear cut-off point between personality disorder and normal personality. For example, there may be a continuum among individuals from those whose personality can be described as empathic and sensitive to those who are oversensitive, to those who have a paranoid (suspicious) personality. Mild personality difficulties or personality accentuation may become apparent only under stress or, for instance, after the removal of support through the death of parents or a spouse.



Personality disorder and mental illness


It is important to distinguish personality disorder from mental illness, as they may coexist in clinical practice and both can result in an abnormal mental state and abnormal behaviour. However, personality traits are continuous, whereas in mental illness (which itself implies previous health) the symptoms or mental state are discontinuous, presenting with the onset of illness and receding with remission. One should therefore either avoid, or take great care in, making a diagnosis of personality disorder during an episode of another psychiatric disorder, when symptoms and behaviour may be due to the illness. A depressed patient, for example, may perceive the past negatively; such patients may describe themselves as having always been depressed and wicked.


Particular personality traits, difficulties or disorders may make individuals more vulnerable to a particular mental illness or to drug or alcohol abuse (i.e. personality traits can be pathogenic). Alternatively, they may colour the clinical presentation of an episode of mental illness (i.e. can be pathoplastic). For instance, obsessional symptoms may be more marked in a depressed individual with a premorbid obsessional personality. Some personality traits even guard against the development of mental illness. For instance, fantasy counters depression.


Most individuals referred to as ‘neurotic’ by the general public are, in fact, handicapped by lifelong personality difficulties rather than suffering from neurosis, which is a mental illness and an abnormal psychogenic reaction (often in a vulnerable personality) to stress. The term character neurosis, which stems from psychoanalysis, stresses the failure to develop a normal character, and refers to those with a personality disorder, not to those suffering from a neurotic mental illness. Character more generally refers to the moral and ethical aspects of a personality. Personality consists of character, those aspects acquired over time, and temperament, those aspects of personality that are hereditary or congenital.





Clinical features


Personality disorders have been classified by:





Research demonstrates considerable reliability between psychiatrists on an individual’s trait descriptions. However, there is much less reliability on an overall actual diagnostic category of personality disorder for an individual. In the UK, ICD-10 is used for official data collection. The types of personality disorders described, with their prominent traits, are shown in Table 15.1. Not all the features described for each personality disorder will necessarily be present; three are required as a minimum for diagnosis. In clinical practice there is often an overlap between diagnostic categories, but personality disorders do tend to cluster into three or four groups, as shown in Figure 15.1. These are:





Table 15.1 ICD-10 classification of personality disorders













































Personality disorder Main characteristics
Paranoid Oversensitivity, tendency to bear grudges, suspiciousness, misconstrues neutral or friendly actions of others as hostile or contemptuous
Schizoid Emotional coldness, preference for fantasy, introspective reserve, little interest in having sexual experiences with others, lack of close, confiding relationships
Anxious (avoidant) Pervasive tension and apprehension, self-consciousness, hypersensitivity to rejection, enters into relationships only if guaranteed uncritical acceptance
  Exaggerates potential dangers and risks in everyday situations and avoids certain activities, leading to restricted lifestyle
Dependent Encourages or allows others to assume responsibility for major areas of individual’s life; subordinate to, compliant with and unwilling to make demands on those on whom they depend
  Perceives self as helpless, fears being abandoned and alone, devastated when close relationships end
Anankastic (obsessive–compulsive) Indecisiveness, perfectionism, excessive conscientiousness, pedantry and conventionality, rigidity and stubbornness, plans all activities far ahead in immutable detail
Histrionic Tendency to theatricality, overemotional, suggestible, shallow and labile affectivity, craves attention, manipulative
Emotionally unstable  
Impulsive type Emotionally unstable, lack of impulse control, outbursts of violence or threatening behaviour common
Borderline type Unclear or disturbed self-image, intense and unstable relationships, which may lead to repeated emotional crises that may be associated with a series of suicidal threats or acts of self-harm
Dissocial Irresponsibility, cannot maintain relationships, low tolerance of frustration and low threshold for discharge of aggression, including violence
  Incapacity to experience guilt and to profit from experience (including punishment), blames others or offers plausible rationalizations for antisocial behaviour


The differences in the onset and course of these three clusters are illustrated in Figure 15.2.



Individuals with personality disorders may or may not regard their personalities as desirable (i.e. respectively egosyntonic or egodystonic). However, most are dissatisfied with the resulting difficulties they experience in everyday life and in sustaining interpersonal relationships. This frequently results in depression or anxiety, which may be the main complaint that leads an individual to seek psychiatric contact.



Withdrawn personality






Dependent personality





Passive–aggressive personality disorder


This is a related condition, characterized by passive resistance to demands for adequate social and occupational performance, procrastination, childish obstruction and sulkiness. Such individuals tend to work slowly on tasks that they do not wish to perform, and often believe they are doing a better job than others think.



Case history: dependent personality disorder


Mrs A.B. was a 40-year-old woman who was often separated from her parents during her childhood. Her father was frequently away at sea and her mother in and out of hospital. Mrs A.B. herself was an anxious child, fearful of the dark and of going to school. She lacked self-confidence. After school she began working as a typist, which went well as long as she was not expected to work independently. She married during her adolescence. In the marriage she assumed the passive role, allowing her spouse to decide where they should live, where she should work and with whom they should be friendly. She would generally only take everyday decisions following advice from her husband and would easily feel hurt by his criticisms. She had no close friends outside her marriage. When her husband left her for another woman, she found it very difficult to adjust and became increasingly depressed and began drinking excessive amounts of alcohol. Feeling ‘stupid’ and unable to cope with the demands of everyday life, she took an overdose of paracetamol tablets. The severity of Mrs A.B.’s dependent personality disorder had thus been revealed by her separation from her husband. She was admitted to a general hospital, where she was assessed by a psychiatrist as being dependent on alcohol. She was transferred to a psychiatric hospital for alcohol withdrawal and subsequently followed up as an outpatient by a psychiatrist, on whom she became very dependent. Using supportive psychotherapy, the psychiatrist encouraged her to become more independent. She was also given a course of a tricyclic antidepressant for depression which had persisted following her withdrawal from alcohol, on which she made a fair response. She was able to return to work and increasingly took over making day-to-day decisions in her life that others had previously made for her.



Inhibited personality



Anankastic (obsessive–compulsive) personality disorder


The term anankastic is derived from the Greek for compulsion. This personality disorder is characterized by perfectionism and inflexibility. Obsessional personalities, although insecure, may be conscientious and hardworking professionals. They may make good subordinates and have bureaucratic capacities. Alternatively, they may be obsessional ditherers. They may wish others would be as efficient as they see themselves, and may become angry when their rigid views are challenged. Unlike those suffering from obsessive–compulsive neurosis, they show no resistance to their obsessional behaviour and may become bogged down in details rather than take a broad view. This personality disorder corresponds to the Freudian anal personality, i.e. fixated at the anal stage of development, with their obsessionality reflecting the symbolic collection of faeces. Such individuals lack fantasy. It is more common and more frequently diagnosed in males. In general, medical practice obsessional personalities may circumstantially describe their symptoms at great length in an effort not to miss out any detail. They may pick up at an early stage any body changes, for instance in bowel function, and they react poorly to any doubt as to diagnosis. They are more prone to develop depression, obsessive–compulsive disorder or neurosis, hypochondriasis, anorexia nervosa, migraine and duodenal ulcer. Anankastic personality disorder is more common among first-degree biological relatives of those who suffer from it.


Two related conditions include hypochondriacal personality disorder (health conscious, disease fearing) and depressive (dysthymic) personality disorder, characterized by longitudinal depressed mood, pessimism and low self-esteem.




Antisocial personality



Histrionic personality disorder


Histrionic personality disorder is characterized by excessive emotionality, attention seeking and overdramatic behaviour. It corresponds to the Freudian phallic personality, fixated at the Oedipal stage (the five-year-old child being seductive towards the parent of the opposite sex). Insecurity results in such individuals attempting to become the focus of attention, for instance everyday events are described as ‘just fantastic’ and greetings to others are ‘over the top’. Such individuals may act out the role of victim or superstar, but can nevertheless be entertaining and the centre of the party. They are often empathic and sexually flirtatious, although sometimes frigid. Histrionic personality traits may be useful in acting and may explain the stereotype descriptions of actresses. Interpersonal relationships are often stormy and ungratifying for such individuals: they may select spouses who are ‘doormats’. It is diagnosed more commonly in females than in males, which may, in part, reflect sexual stereotyping, as males with identical case histories may be diagnosed as suffering from antisocial personality disorder instead. Previously, histrionic personality disorder was generally referred to as hysterical personality disorder. However, the behaviour is conscious in histrionic personality disorder and should be distinguished from hysterical dissociative or conversion disorder (neurosis), where symptoms are unconsciously produced, and also from mass hysteria. Those with histrionic personality disorders are more liable to take overdoses of medication under stress and to develop conversion and somatization disorders.

< div class='tao-gold-member'>

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jul 12, 2016 | Posted by in PSYCHIATRY | Comments Off on Personality disorders

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access